← Back to the recipe

Ingredients and steps on one page. Print it, or choose “Save as PDF” in the print dialog.

Sekai Gohan

Plokkfiskur: Iceland's Comforting Cod and Potato Fish Stew

Servings 4 servingsPrep 15 minCook 35 minTotal 50 min

Plokkfiskur, Iceland's beloved everyday dish: a white stew of cod and potatoes broken up together, with melting butter and rye bread on the side
Steps with photos

Ingredients

Main ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Cod fillets (fresh) 400 g Lightly salted cod also works; if using it, cut back on the salt (about 14 oz)
Potatoes (floury, such as russet) 500 g (about 3–4) Floury varieties that break up easily work best. Waxy potatoes hold their shape more (about 1 lb 2 oz)
Onion 1 (medium) Finely chopped
Butter (salted) 40 g Unsalted butter plus a pinch of salt also works (about 3 tbsp)
Milk 200 ml Whole milk recommended (about 3/4 cup + 1 tbsp)
Choosing your cod

In Iceland, plokkfiskur is often made from leftover boiled cod or haddock, and some households use salt cod (saltfiskur) that has been soaked to remove the salt. Lightly salted cod fillets are a handy option, since they need no soaking and can be used as is. If you use fresh cod, add 1 tsp salt. In Iceland, recipes using fresh cod or haddock are common, so fresh cod turns out plenty delicious.

Ingredients for plokkfiskur: cod fillets, potatoes, onion, butter and milk
The ingredients. Plokkfiskur's charm is that it needs only simple ingredients; the freshness of the white cod makes all the difference

Seasonings

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Salt 1 tsp Reduce to 1/2 tsp if using lightly salted cod
White pepper 1/2 tsp White is more traditional than black
Nutmeg a pinch (about 1/8 tsp) Adds a lot of flavor if you have it
All-purpose flour 2 tbsp For thickening
Salt (for boiling the potatoes) a pinch Add to the potato cooking water
Water (for the cod) 500 ml For poaching the cod (about 2 cups)
Butter (for finishing) 10 g Cut into a 1 cm (1/2 in) cube and set on top

Steps

  1. 1Boil the potatoes

    20 min

    Peel the potatoes and cut them into 1 inch (3 cm) cubes. Put the potatoes in a pot with just enough water to cover and add a pinch of salt. Bring to a boil over high heat, then reduce to medium and cook for about 15 minutes, until a fork slides in easily. Reserve ¾ cup (200 ml) of the cooking water. Drain off the rest, return the potatoes to the pot and set over low heat for 30 seconds to drive off excess moisture.

  2. 2Poach the cod

    10 min

    In another pot, bring 2 cups (500 ml) water to a boil and add the cod fillets. Cook over low heat for 8–10 minutes. When the fish is opaque white all the way to the center and flakes easily with a fork, turn off the heat. Transfer to a tray and, once cool enough to handle, flake it by hand into fairly large pieces. Carefully remove any bones and skin.

    The secret to poaching cod

    High heat is the enemy when cooking cod. Drop it into rapidly boiling water and the flesh tends to shrink and dry out, so cook it in quiet water with only small bubbles rising from the bottom of the pot. Gentle heat keeps the cod moist.

  3. 3Sauté the onion and make the roux

    5 min

    Melt 1.5 oz (40 g) butter in a skillet over medium heat. Add the chopped onion and cook for about 3 minutes, until translucent. Don't let it brown. Sprinkle in 2 tbsp flour and stir with a wooden spoon for 1 minute. Once the raw flour taste is gone, gradually add ¾ cup (200 ml) milk, stirring. To avoid lumps, pour in a little at a time and stir, repeating until it's all in.

  4. 4Combine the potatoes and cod

    5 min

    Add the boiled potatoes and flaked cod to the skillet with the roux. Mix with a wooden spoon, roughly breaking up the potatoes as you go. True to the name "picked fish," you want the ingredients left roughly flaked and broken up. The key is not to mash it completely. Stop when potato chunks of 0.5–1 inches (1–2 cm) and cod flakes of 1 inch (2–3 cm) remain. You're aiming for everything to be bound by the white sauce, thick enough to fall in heavy dollops from the spoon. Leaving it humble and coarse is the Icelandic way.

    If it's too stiff, loosen it with 2–3 tbsp of the reserved cooking water. If it's watery, simmer over low heat for 2 minutes. Add the white pepper and nutmeg, and season with salt.

    Why white pepper?

    Traditional Icelandic cooking uses white pepper rather than black. There are two reasons. One is looks: it avoids black specks in a white stew. The other is flavor: white pepper is milder than black and doesn't overwhelm the delicate taste of the fish. If you only have black pepper, use just a little and it will look and taste balanced.

  5. 5Plate it

    3 min

    Spoon plenty of plokkfiskur into deep bowls. Mound it slightly higher in the center so that potato chunks and white flakes of cod show on the surface. Top with a piece of butter about 0.5 inches (1 cm) square, and when its edges start to melt from the residual heat, add a light sprinkle of white pepper. In Iceland it's classically served with a sweet dark rye bread called rúgbrauð, spread with butter. Pumpernickel or other rye bread makes a good stand-in.