← Back to the recipe

Ingredients and steps on one page. Print it, or choose “Save as PDF” in the print dialog.

Sekai Gohan

Cayman-Style Beef: Slow-Cooked Shredded Beef in Its Own Fat

A plate of Cayman-style beef on its own, shredded after the whole pepper was removed
Steps with photos

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Beef, pieces of mixed cuts including fatty portions 2.5 lb (about 1.13 kg) The whole dish. Full batch: 10 lb. The fat is cut away and melted to cook the beef
Onion 1/8 lb (about 56.7 g), finely chopped Aroma and moisture. Full batch: 1/2 lb
Garlic 1 clove, finely chopped Aroma. Full batch: 4 cloves
Black pepper 1/4 tbsp (3/4 tsp) Seasoning. Full batch: 1 tbsp. Freshly ground or pre-ground
Salt 3/8 tbsp (1 1/8 tsp) Seasoning. Full batch: 1 1/2 tbsp
Seasoning pepper To taste, seeded and chopped Aroma, mixed into the seasoning. Full batch: to taste
Scotch bonnet pepper 1, whole Heat, cooked whole on top of the meat and removed at the end. Full 10 lb batch: 2, to taste

Steps

  1. 1Cut away the fat and set it aside

    Cut the thicker portions of fat away from the beef and put them in a small dish. They become the cooking fat for the pot. Don't trim the beef down to lean meat only. This dish is built on cuts that include fat, and on melting that fat.

  2. 2Season the beef

    In a bowl, toss the beef with the salt, black pepper, chopped garlic and chopped onion. Add seeded, chopped seasoning pepper to taste. Season and cook straight away. No long marinade is needed, and no liquid goes in. Keep the Scotch bonnet whole and outside the bowl for now. Don't taste the seasoned raw beef.

  3. 3Melt the fat in the heavy pot

    Put the reserved fat into a large heavy pot and heat it until the fat melts out. Don't add any oil. No need to crisp or brown the pieces of fat. Their job is to provide the fat the meat will cook in.

  4. 4Add the beef and the whole pepper, cover tightly and cook low

    Add the seasoned beef to the melted fat and turn the heat to low. Don't add water or more oil.

    Place the whole Scotch bonnet on top of the meat. Don't cut it, pierce it or press it into the beef.

    A whole, uncut Scotch bonnet placed on top of the seasoned beef in the pot
    One intact pepper, set on top before the lid goes on

    Close the lid tightly and cook over low heat. A full 10 lb batch takes 4–6 hours. Keep it at a gentle low simmer, not a hard boil. With no liquid added, check the pot often. Don't leave it alone if you smell scorching or the bottom seems to be running dry.

    A heavy pot with its lid closed, cooking gently on low heat
    The long, covered, low-heat stage
  5. 5Check tenderness, lift out the pepper and shred

    Use a clean food thermometer to confirm that the center reaches 167°F (75°C) and stays at or above that temperature for at least 1 minute. Separately, check whether the beef is tender to your liking with a fork. The full batch takes 4–6 hours. If it is still firm, keep cooking over low heat and check again. When it is tender, lift out the Scotch bonnet carefully with a spoon so it doesn't burst. Then stir the beef in the pot until the meat breaks into strands.

  6. 6Serve

    Serve the shredded beef. Rice and beans and "stemmed vegetables" are traditional sides. Both are optional, and the beef can stand on its own.