Ingredients and steps on one page. Print it, or choose “Save as PDF” in the print dialog.
Sekai Gohan
Sup Ekor: Malaysian Clear Oxtail Soup with Whole Spices

Ingredients
| Ingredient | Amount | Role |
|---|---|---|
| Oxtail, cut into ½–¾-inch (1–2 cm) rounds | 1⅔ lb (750 g) | Meat, gelatin and the body of the broth |
| Vegetable oil | 2 tbsp | For searing the oxtail |
| Onion, cut into small pieces | 3½ oz (100 g) | Sweetness and depth in the broth |
| Ginger, sliced | scant 1 oz (25 g) | Warmth; cuts the gamey edge of the meat |
| Garlic, sliced | 1 oz (30 g) | Aromatic base |
| Ground cumin | 3 tsp | The main scent of the soup |
| Water | 6¼ cups (1.5 L), or enough to cover | The soup itself |
| Bird's eye chilies (cili padi), halved | 5 | Sharp heat |
| Coriander leaves (cilantro), with stems | 1 stalk | Stems for the pot, leaves for the garnish |
| Coriander seeds | 1½ tsp | Citrusy lift, in the spice bundle |
| Cloves | 7 | Sweet, deep note, in the spice bundle |
| Green cardamom pods | 6 | Resinous perfume, in the spice bundle |
| Star anise | 1 (about 10 points) | Rich anise note, in the spice bundle |
| Cinnamon stick | 1 | Warmth; goes into the pot loose |
| Tomato, cut into large pieces | 3½ oz (100 g) | Freshness and light acidity |
| Potato, cut into large pieces | 3½ oz (100 g) | Body and substance |
| Carrot, cut into thick slices | 3½ oz (100 g) | Sweetness and color |
| Salt | 4 tsp | Seasoning, added at the end |
| Sugar | 1 tsp | Rounds off the salt |
| Black pepper | ¼ tsp | Finishing aroma |
| Lime | as needed | Squeezed at the table |
| Fried shallots or fried onions (bawang goreng) | as needed | Crunch and sweetness on top |
| Steamed white rice | as needed | To serve |
Steps
1Sear the oxtail
Heat the 2 tbsp oil in a wide skillet over medium-high heat. Lay the oxtail rounds in a single layer with space between them; if they crowd the pan, sear them in two rounds. Turn each piece once so both cut faces touch the hot oil. Move on when both sides are light golden brown and a thin brown film has formed on the pan.
Searing builds the flavorBrowning gives the broth a roasted depth. Do not skip this step to save time. The brown film left in the pan goes into the soup with the aromatics in the next step.
2Soften the aromatics and fill the pot
Set the oxtail aside on a plate and add the onion, ginger and garlic to the same skillet. Stir for 1 minute, scraping up the brown bits as the onion releases moisture. Scrape everything into the deep pot, add the oxtail and pour in water until the meat is covered. A wide pot needs more water to cover than a tall, narrow one, and a strong flame evaporates more over the simmer. The aromatics are done when the onion is glossy and just turning translucent, with the garlic smelling sweet rather than browned.
3Toast and tie the spice bundle
Warm the coriander seeds, cloves, cardamom pods and star anise in a dry pan over low heat, shaking the pan, until they smell fragrant. Tip them onto a square of muslin, gather the corners and tie the bundle tightly with string. Keep the cinnamon stick out of the bundle, because it goes into the pot loose. The bundle keeps the broth clear and lets you lift every seed out at once. It is ready when the knot holds and nothing slips out when you shake it.
4Add the spices and bring to a boil
Pull the stems and a few sprigs off the coriander for the pot, and keep the leaves for the garnish. Add the coriander stems, ground cumin, cinnamon stick, spice bundle and halved chilies to the pot. Push the bundle under the water so the cloth soaks through. Bring the pot to a boil over high heat. It is ready to turn down when the surface rolls and the first grey foam rises.
5Simmer and skim until the meat leaves the bone
Lower the heat to medium so the broth bubbles steadily without churning. Skim off the grey scum and the floating fat often, especially in the first half hour. Simmer for 2 to 2½ hours, topping up with a little water if the meat starts to show above the surface. The oxtail is done when a fork pulls the meat away from the bone with no resistance.
Skim for a clear brothA clear broth defines sup ekor, and skimming is how you get it. Remove the scum, impurities and fat every time they gather. Fat left in the pot clouds the broth and turns the flavor heavy.
6Add the vegetables
Add the tomato, potato and carrot once the meat is tender, after the long simmer. Adding them late keeps the potato from breaking down and keeps the carrot sweet. Simmer for 20 minutes. They are done when a knife slides through the potato and carrot while the pieces still hold their shape, and the tomato has softened.
7Season and lift out the spices
Lift out the spice bundle and the cinnamon stick. Stir in the salt, sugar and black pepper, and let the pot bubble for a moment. Season only now that the broth has reduced to its final strength, so you judge the salt against the finished soup. Taste a spoonful. The broth should taste rounded and meaty, with the cumin and cardamom clear behind the salt.
8Finish with lime and shallots
Ladle the oxtail, vegetables and broth into deep bowls. Squeeze lime over each bowl just before eating. Lime cooked in the pot loses its fresh aroma. Scatter fried shallots and the reserved coriander leaves on top, and serve with steamed white rice. Add the shallots last so they stay crisp.