Skyr: Iceland's Strained Fresh Dairy and How to Make It at Home

A bowl of plain white Icelandic skyr with cream and dark wild bilberries
Cuisine
Icelandic

What skyr is, how it differs from yogurt, and how it is eaten in Iceland, plus a home recipe using skimmed milk, a spoonful of skyr and rennet. Covers heating to 86–90°C, cooling to 39°C, the knife test for the curd, and slow straining in the refrigerator.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Heat the milk to 194°F (90°C)

Skimmed milk warming in a pot with a thermometer in the milk
Bring the milk to 86–90°C, checking with the thermometer

Pour 2 quarts (2 L) skimmed milk into a heavy pot and heat it, watching the thermometer, until the milk reaches 194°F (90°C).

STEP22 / 7

Cool slowly to 102°F (39°C)

A pot of heated milk off the heat with a thermometer checking the temperature as it cools
Let the milk cool slowly and confirm 39°C before adding the starter

Take the pot off the heat and let the milk cool slowly to 102°F (39°C). This takes several hours. Check with the thermometer. Do not add the starter while the milk is still hot.

STEP33 / 7

Add the skyr and rennet

A spoonful of plain skyr going into the warm milk, with a small rennet dropper beside the pot
Add the skyr and rennet to the cooled milk and mix well

At 102°F (39°C), add 1 tbsp plain skyr and 2 drops rennet (or the amount on your rennet's label for 2 quarts / 2 L of milk). Mix well.

STEP44 / 7

Keep warm and let it set for about 5 hours

A lidded pot wrapped in a plain cotton towel on the counter
Cover and wrap the pot to keep it warm while the curd sets

Put the lid on the pot and wrap it in a towel to hold the warmth. Leave it for about 5 hours. If you use a yogurt maker, hold the temperature steady.

STEP55 / 7

Test the curd with a knife

A long knife cutting into set white curd, the cut staying open
When the cut stays open, the curd is ready to strain

Cut into the curd with a long knife. If the cut stays open and does not close up right away, move on. If it closes, give it a little more time and test again.

STEP66 / 7

Move the curd into a cloth-lined sieve

Soft white curd being spooned from the pot into a cheesecloth-lined sieve over a bowl
Keep the curd layer no deeper than 7–9 cm so it drains evenly

Line a sieve with clean cloth and set it over a bowl. Ladle the curd in, keeping the layer no deeper than 3.5 inches (9 cm).

STEP77 / 7

Drain in the refrigerator for 12–24 hours

A cheesecloth-lined sieve over a glass bowl on a refrigerator shelf, pale whey collecting below
Drain in the refrigerator until the skyr looks firm and dry

Put the sieve and bowl in the refrigerator and let the whey drain slowly for 12–24 hours. The skyr is done when it looks firm and dry. Serve it plain, or with a little sugar, milk or cream. Store it in a clean, covered container in the refrigerator and serve it with clean utensils.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Skimmed milk 2 quarts (2 L) The base of the curd
Plain fresh skyr (skyr) 1 tbsp Starter. Use an unsweetened, plain skyr with live cultures
Rennet (rennet) 2 drops Sets the milk into a firm curd. Check your product's label for the amount for 2 quarts (2 L) of milk

Sugar, milk, cream and berries are for serving only. Do not add them to the milk.

0 / 0

Thick, ivory and eaten with a spoon, skyr looks like a very thick yogurt, and most people treat it that way: plain or sweetened, at breakfast or as a snack. Traditional Icelandic skyr, though, is an acid-set fresh cow's-milk cheese. Milk is set into a curd, and the curd is strained through cloth until the whey runs off. That draining, not stirring, is what gives skyr its dense, spoonable body. At home, 2 litres of skimmed milk gives you about 1 litre of skyr and about 1 litre of whey.

Skyr in Iceland

Skyr has been an Icelandic specialty since the time of settlement. The milk is usually skimmed and set with bacterial cultures and rennet. Skyr was relatively cheap to make compared with cheese, which is a likely reason Icelandic cheesemaking traditions faded.

In traditional artisanal making, the starter is carried over from a previous batch of skyr, and calf rennet goes in if the milk sets weakly. Skyr is made in many ways today, and the home method here is one simple version.

Skyr's place in Icelandic life has also shifted, from everyday food to national food heritage. Branding and global markets have shaped that heritage story, so modern marketing is a poor guide to what the old tradition actually was. For more Icelandic dishes, see the Iceland country page.

Ingredients: Skimmed Milk, a Spoonful of Skyr and Rennet

Skimmed milk, plain skyr, rennet, a thermometer and cheesecloth laid out with a pot and sieve
Three ingredients, plus the tools that let you measure temperature and strain the curd

Equipment

  • Heavy pot with a lid
  • Thermometer that reads at least 194°F (90°C) and 102°F (39°C)
  • Towel for wrapping the pot
  • Long knife
  • Sieve or colander
  • Clean cheesecloth or similar cloth
  • Bowl to catch the whey, sized to hold the sieve

Choosing the Starter, Rennet and Milk for Skyr

Starter. Traditionally, the starter is skyr from a previous batch. For your first batch, use a plain store-bought skyr with live cultures. Plain yogurt, sour cream or buttermilk will work in a pinch, but they change the flavor, and what you get is a skyr-style strained dairy rather than skyr started the traditional way.

Rennet. Rennet comes in different strengths and forms, so 2 drops will not suit every product. Go by the label for your rennet and your milk volume; converting a powder or tablet into drops is guesswork.

Check your rennet

Rennet strength differs between products. Read your rennet's label before you start.

Milk. Use skimmed milk, as Icelandic makers usually do.

Method: From Hot Milk to Firm, Drained Skyr

Judge by temperature and curd

Two checks decide the batch: the milk at 102°F (39°C), and a knife cut that stays open. Check the actual state before moving on.

Common Skyr Problems and Fixes

Temperature, curd and clock

Measure the temperatures and check the curd with a knife. Treat the clock as a guide.

What you see Where to look What to do
The knife cut closes up The curd has not set firmly enough yet Give it a little more time, keeping it warm, then test again
The milk barely sets Temperature when the starter went in; rennet amount; whether the starter had live cultures Check that the milk was at 102°F (39°C), the rennet matched the label, and the skyr was plain with live cultures. Traditional makers add calf rennet if the milk sets weakly
Still soft and wet after draining Drainage time and layer depth Keep draining in the refrigerator within the 12–24 hours, with the curd spread no deeper than 3.5 inches (9 cm)
Flavor is different from skyr you have bought Starter Yogurt, sour cream or buttermilk starters change the flavor. Next time, use plain fresh skyr

Serving Skyr

Plain skyr in a bowl with cream in a small pitcher and dark bilberries in a separate dish
Serve the skyr plain and let each person add cream and berries to taste

At the table, skyr is eaten plain, with a little sugar, or loosened with cream or milk. In Iceland, try it the classic way, with wild bilberries and cream. Outside Iceland, cultivated blueberries can stand in for the bilberries; it's still lovely, just a different berry flavor.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does the rennet do?

It helps the milk set into a curd firm enough to hold a knife cut, working alongside the bacterial cultures.

How long does homemade skyr keep?

Store it in a clean, covered container in the refrigerator and use clean utensils. It keeps for 4–5 days.

Sources