Hokey Pokey Ice Cream: New Zealand's Honeycomb Toffee Flavor, Made at Home

Milk ice cream mixed with crushed amber pieces of hokey pokey toffee
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
New Zealand

How to make hokey pokey ice cream, New Zealand's flavor of creamy ice cream studded with crunchy honeycomb toffee. Covers making the golden-syrup hokey pokey, a milk-based ice cream base for the Cuisinart ICE-FD10XA dedicated cup, freezing, churning, adding the toffee with the Mix-in function, choosing dairy and golden syrup, fixing common problems, and the flavor's background in New Zealand.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 8

Grease the tin and get the equipment ready

STEP 1

Thinly butter the base and sides of the 8 × 8 inches (20 × 20 cm) tin. Have the heavy saucepan, the heatproof spatula and the baking soda ready beside the stove before you start, because once the soda goes in there is no time to look for anything.

STEP22 / 8

Melt the sugar and golden syrup, then boil gently for 2 minutes

Sugar and golden syrup melting together in a saucepan
Melt the sugar fully before bringing the syrup to the boil

Put 5 Tbsp sugar and 2 Tbsp golden syrup into the saucepan. Stir over medium-low heat until the sugar has dissolved. Once dissolved, bring the mixture to the boil, then let it boil gently for 2 minutes. Don't let it scorch.

STEP33 / 8

Take it off the heat and stir in the baking soda quickly

Hokey pokey foaming up strongly in the saucepan after the baking soda is added
The foam rises the moment the soda is stirred in; work at arm's length

Take the saucepan off the heat and set it on a stable, heatproof surface. Add 1 tsp baking soda and stir it in quickly. The mixture foams up suddenly and a lot, so keep your face and hands away.

STEP44 / 8

Pour into the tin right away, cool completely, then break

Cooled, set hokey pokey being broken into pieces
Break the set toffee, and crush part of it to 5 mm or smaller for the ice cream

Pour the foaming toffee immediately into the prepared tin. Be careful not to burn yourself as you pour from the pan. Leave it until it has cooled completely and set, then break it into pieces. Crush a portion to pieces 0.25 inch (5 mm) or smaller; this is what goes into the ice cream.

STEP55 / 8

Make the ice cream base

Milk and sugar being whisked, with cream waiting to be added
Dissolve the sugar in the milk first, then add the cream

Whisk ½ cup (100 ml) milk and 1 oz (30 g) caster sugar together until the sugar has dissolved. Then add ½ cup (100 ml) cream and mix.

STEP66 / 8

Pour into the dedicated cup and freeze level

Ice cream base in its lidded cup placed level in the freezer
Leave headroom below the MAX line and keep the cup level in the freezer

Pour the base into the ICE-FD10XA dedicated 240 ml cup, staying below the MAX fill line. You are not meant to fill the cup to the brim. Put on the lid and freeze on a level surface at -18°C or colder for at least 24 hours. No toffee goes in at this stage.

STEP77 / 8

Rest briefly, then process on the Ice Cream function

The ice cream maker assembled with its dedicated cup before processing the frozen base
Assemble the cup, mixing assembly and power handle as the instruction booklet shows

Take the cup out of the freezer and leave it at room temperature for 5–10 minutes. Assemble the machine and process on the Ice Cream function. Follow the machine's instruction booklet for assembly and operation.

STEP88 / 8

Add the crushed hokey pokey and use the Mix-in function

Finely crushed hokey pokey being added to the dedicated cup after churning
Tip the fine pieces straight into the same cup, then run Mix-in

Add 1 Tbsp of hokey pokey crushed to 0.5 cm or smaller directly to the churned ice cream in the cup, and mix using the Mix-in function. If you want a few pieces on top when serving, take them from this same tablespoon rather than adding more.

The toffee absorbs moisture easily and its texture changes, so eat the ice cream soon after mixing.

A spoonful of hokey pokey ice cream showing the crushed toffee pieces
Eat it soon after mixing, while the toffee pieces are still crisp
0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Full cream milk ½ cup (100 ml) Ice cream base. The sugar is dissolved into it first
Thickened cream ½ cup (100 ml) Ice cream base. Adds richness; added after the sugar has dissolved
Caster sugar 1 oz (30 g) Ice cream base. Sweetness
White sugar or caster sugar 5 Tbsp Hokey pokey. The body of the toffee
Golden syrup 2 Tbsp Hokey pokey. Melted with the sugar for the toffee's color and flavor
Baking soda 1 tsp Hokey pokey. Makes the syrup foam into the honeycomb texture
Butter As needed For thinly greasing the base and sides of the tin only. Not added to the toffee
Crushed hokey pokey, pieces 0.25 inch (5 mm) or smaller 1 Tbsp Mix-in, taken from the toffee made above
0 / 0

Hokey pokey ice cream is pale and creamy, with small amber fragments of airy toffee scattered all through it. Each spoonful brings smooth, cold ice cream and then a crisp little crunch of honeycomb. The flavor is a New Zealand favorite, and it's simple at heart: vanilla ice cream studded with chunks of sugar-and-golden-syrup toffee.

What Hokey Pokey Ice Cream Is

In New Zealand, "hokey pokey" is first the name of the honeycomb candy itself, a slab of sugar and golden syrup puffed up with baking soda. The same name covers the ice cream made by folding broken pieces of that candy into a vanilla base. Similar honeycomb toffee is common in Australia and elsewhere, but only in New Zealand does one word stand for both the candy and the ice cream. Its popularity there is distinctive enough that it shows up among New Zealand's favourite foods.

The history is less settled. A Dunedin confectioner, William Hatton, applied for a patent on hokey pokey confectionery in 1896, and some accounts say Newjoy put broken pieces of hokey pokey into ice cream in 1953. Several competing stories exist about who came up with it. Since the 1896 patent covers the candy rather than the ice cream, neither date is a confirmed birth year for hokey pokey ice cream.

For more dishes from the same country, see the New Zealand page.

This is a milk-based version

The typical hokey pokey flavor is vanilla ice cream with honeycomb toffee. The Cuisinart base here has no vanilla or other flavoring, so this is a milk-based version made for one specific appliance, not a vanilla recipe.

Ingredients: Two Parts, Ice Cream Base and Hokey Pokey

Milk, cream and sugar for the ice cream, with sugar, golden syrup and baking soda for the toffee
The ice cream base and the toffee use separate sugar; the butter is only for greasing the tin

The ice cream amounts are for one Cuisinart ICE-FD10XA dedicated 240 ml cup. 240 ml is the capacity of the cup, not the amount of finished ice cream. The toffee amounts are for the full batch; only 1 Tbsp of crushed toffee goes into the ice cream.

1 Tbsp is 15 ml and 1 tsp is 5 ml. Measure the sugar and golden syrup by spoon rather than converting them to grams.

Equipment

  • A 20 × 20 cm shallow tin
  • A heavy saucepan deep enough for the toffee to foam up well
  • A heatproof spatula or spoon for stirring the syrup and the baking soda
  • A heatproof surface or trivet to set the saucepan on off the heat
  • A bowl and whisk for the ice cream base
  • Cuisinart ICE-FD10XA ice cream maker with its dedicated 240 ml dessert cup and lid
  • A freezer that holds -18°C or colder, with a level shelf

Choosing the Dairy, Sugar and Golden Syrup

Thickened cream is a high-fat cream sold in Australia and New Zealand. If you can't find it, use fresh cream with 35% fat or more. Fat content and thickeners vary between products, so it won't be an exact match.

Caster sugar is a fine-grained white sugar. Granulated sugar works in its place for the ice cream base.

Golden syrup is worth tracking down, since it shapes the toffee's flavor and other syrups differ in both flavor and sugar makeup. Look for it at import grocers or online.

Hokey pokey contains no honey. "Honeycomb" describes the porous texture the baking soda creates. The toffee is just sugar, golden syrup and baking soda, with no butter, vanilla essence or chocolate coating.

Hot sugar and dairy safety

The sugar syrup gets very hot, and it foams up suddenly and strongly when the baking soda goes in. Keep your face and hands away from the pan, and take care when holding the saucepan and pouring. Use commercial pasteurized milk and cream and keep them chilled as their labels direct. Freezing is not a way to make dairy safe.

Method: Toffee First, Then the Base, the Freeze and the Churn

Order of work

Make the hokey pokey first so it has time to cool and set. The ice cream base needs at least 24 hours in the freezer before churning, so plan ahead.

Fixing Common Problems with Hokey Pokey Ice Cream

Problem Likely cause What to do
The foam rises fast and nearly reaches the rim The toffee foams up strongly once the soda goes in Use a deep, heavy saucepan from the start. Take it off the heat before adding the soda, and keep your face and hands back
The toffee tastes burnt or bitter The syrup scorched while boiling Melt the sugar over medium-low heat, and boil gently for only 2 minutes. Don't push the heat to hurry it
The foam sinks before it reaches the tin Too slow between adding the soda and pouring Have the greased tin beside the stove, stir the soda in quickly and pour immediately
The toffee won't break cleanly It hasn't cooled completely Leave it until it has fully cooled and set before breaking
Large lumps in the ice cream Pieces bigger than 0.25 inch (0.5 cm) Crush the mix-in portion to 0.25 inch (0.5 cm) or smaller before adding it
The toffee pieces turn soft or sticky The toffee has absorbed moisture Add the toffee only at the end with Mix-in, and eat the ice cream soon after
Base overflowing or not processing as expected Filled above the MAX line, or not frozen long or level enough Stay below MAX, freeze level at -18°C or colder for at least 24 hours, and follow the instruction booklet

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this without an ice cream maker?

Not with this recipe. The base, freezing and churning are written for the Cuisinart ICE-FD10XA and its dedicated cup, and freezing the base in an ordinary container while stirring it repeatedly won't give the same result. If you have a different machine, make its manufacturer's basic vanilla recipe and add crushed hokey pokey at the end, following that machine's amounts and timings.

Does one cup make 240 ml of ice cream?

No. 240 ml is the capacity of the dedicated cup, and the base must stay below the MAX line.

What do I do with the leftover toffee?

The full toffee recipe makes far more than the 1 Tbsp the ice cream uses, about 20 servings depending on how large you break the pieces. The toffee absorbs moisture and its texture changes, so use it up soon.

Sources