Custard Powder Ice Cream: A Three-Ingredient Vanilla Freezer Recipe

Vanilla custard powder ice cream served in a plain bowl
Cuisine
Indian

How to make custard powder ice cream with just vanilla custard powder, sugar and milk, following Suguna Vinodh's Kannamma Cooks recipe. The powder is mixed into milk reserved from the same liter, cooked with the rest of the milk and the sugar until it boils and thickens, cooled completely, frozen to half-set, whisked once for 2 minutes, then frozen overnight.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 10

Make the custard powder slurry

Mixing custard powder into reserved milk to make a slurry
Mix the custard powder with the 1/4 cup of milk reserved from the liter

From the 1 liter of milk, measure out 1/4 cup. In a small bowl, mix it with the 1/4 cup of vanilla custard powder to make a slurry, then set it aside.

This happens before anything goes on the heat. Only the reserved milk goes into this bowl, not the whole liter.

STEP22 / 10

Warm the remaining milk

Warming the remaining milk in a saucepan
Heat the milk that remains after reserving the slurry portion

Pour the rest of the milk into a saucepan and heat it. This is the 1 liter minus the 1/4 cup you set aside for the slurry.

STEP33 / 10

Add the sugar

Adding sugar to the warmed milk
Sugar goes into the warmed milk while the slurry waits in its own bowl

Add the 3/4 cup of sugar to the warmed milk. Keep the slurry separate for now; it goes in next.

STEP44 / 10

Add the slurry

Pouring the custard powder slurry into the pan of milk
Add the prepared slurry to the milk and sugar

Pour the custard powder slurry you made in step 1 into the saucepan of milk and sugar.

STEP55 / 10

Cook until it boils and thickens

The custard base boiling and thickening in the pan
Cook over medium heat until the base boils and thickens well

Cook over medium heat for 3–4 minutes, until the mixture comes to a boil and is well thickened. Then take it off the heat.

STEP66 / 10

Cool completely

The custard base cooling off the heat
Let the base cool completely before it goes into the freezer

Leave the cooked base off the heat until it has cooled completely. Do not move on to freezing until it has.

STEP77 / 10

Freeze until half-set

The custard base after the first freeze, about half set
After 3–4 hours the base is only half set: an in-between stage, not the finish

Freeze the cooled base for 3–4 hours, until it is about half set.

It is not finished at this point. This soft, partly frozen stage is when you whisk.

STEP88 / 10

Whisk for 2 minutes

Whisking the half-set base by hand
Whisk the half-set base once, by hand, for 2 minutes

Take the half-set base out and whisk it by hand for 2 minutes. Do this once.

STEP99 / 10

Transfer to a bowl

Transferring the whisked base into a freezer bowl
Once whisked, move the base into its bowl for the final freeze

Move the whisked base into a bowl for the freezer.

STEP1010 / 10

Freeze overnight

Custard powder ice cream finished in the freezer
After freezing overnight the ice cream reaches its finished state

Put the bowl in the freezer and freeze it overnight. This is the finished state: plain vanilla custard powder ice cream.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Vanilla-flavored custard powder 1/4 cup Thickens and flavors the base. Mixed first with reserved milk to make a slurry
Sugar 3/4 cup Sweetens the base
Milk 1 liter (4 cups) The whole quantity. 1/4 cup of it is reserved for the slurry, and the rest is heated
0 / 0

A pan of pale, thickened milk sits off the heat, cooling completely before it goes anywhere near the freezer. Hours later it comes back out only half-set, and that's when the whisk comes in for two minutes before the base goes into a bowl and back into the freezer overnight. This is custard powder ice cream, made with vanilla-flavored custard powder, sugar and milk and nothing else. That one short whisking breaks up the large ice crystals, which is what makes the finished ice cream smooth.

About Custard Powder Ice Cream

This is a homemade ice cream from Indian home cooking. It is different from kulfi, which is a separate dish, so this milk-and-custard-powder ice cream shouldn't go by that name. For more Indian food on this site, see India.

You'll find other custard powder ice creams online, and each has its own formula and method. Some use the same vanilla custard powder, sugar and milk but add cream, freeze the base for about an hour, then whip it again and again with a mixer. Others add vanilla essence and cream, give the base a longer first freeze, blend it with the cream and refreeze it. The version here sticks to three ingredients and a single pass with a hand whisk, so keep the steps from other recipes out of this one.

Ingredients: Three Foods, One Liter of Milk

Milk, custard powder and sugar for custard powder ice cream
Only three foods go into this ice cream: milk, vanilla custard powder and sugar

The 1/4 cup of milk for the slurry is part of the 1 liter, not added on top of it. Measure it out of the full quantity before you start, and heat only what remains.

Equipment

  • Measuring cup
  • Small bowl and a spoon, for the slurry
  • Saucepan
  • Balloon whisk
  • Bowl for the freezer
  • Freezer

Choosing the Custard Powder, Sugar and Milk

Use plain vanilla custard powder and milk. The recipe doesn't name a brand of powder or a fat content for the milk. Keep it to the three ingredients, with no cream, condensed milk, egg, vanilla extract, gelatin, fruit, nuts or mint.

The milk does two jobs. Custard powder won't blend well if you tip it straight into the whole quantity of milk, so 1/4 cup is set aside first and stirred with the powder into a slurry. That 1/4 cup comes out of the liter, not on top of it.

Dietary and allergy information

Custard powder products differ in composition. If you need egg-free, vegan or allergen-free ice cream, or you are cooking for someone with allergies or dietary restrictions, check the label on the product you buy before you serve it.

Method: Slurry, Simmer, Cool, Freeze, Whisk, Freeze Again

The shape of the method
  1. Make a slurry with reserved milk.
  2. Heat the remaining milk, then add the sugar and then the slurry.
  3. Cook over medium heat until it boils and thickens.
  4. Cool completely.
  5. Freeze for 3–4 hours until half-set.
  6. Whisk once for 2 minutes.
  7. Move the base to a bowl and freeze it overnight.

The half-set stage is a midpoint. The ice cream is finished only after the overnight freeze.

Custard Powder Ice Cream Troubleshooting

Most problems with this recipe come from the order of the steps, so check that first.

What you notice Likely reason What to do
The powder won't blend into the milk It went straight into the whole quantity of milk Make a slurry with 1/4 cup of reserved milk first, then add it to the pan
The base seems thinner than expected Extra milk was added for the slurry Use 1 liter in total, slurry milk included
The base hasn't thickened on the stove It hasn't cooked long enough yet Cook over medium heat until it boils and is well thickened, about 3–4 minutes
The ice cream is still soft after the first freeze This is the half-set stage Half-set is the point to whisk, not the finish. Whisk for 2 minutes, then freeze overnight
You aren't sure when to start freezing The base is still warm Let the base cool completely before the first freeze

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it make?

About 1 1/4 liter.

Can I convert the cups to grams?

Measure the custard powder and sugar in cups, as written. For the milk, 1 liter is 4 cups, so each cup is 250 mL.

Sources

  • Suguna Vinodh, "Custard Powder Ice Cream Recipe," Kannamma Cooks, September 2017. The sole basis for this recipe: the author attribution, the three ingredients and their source amounts (1/4 cup custard powder, 3/4 cup sugar, 1 liter milk (4 cups)), reserving 1/4 cup of the milk for the slurry, the order of heating, medium heat for 3–4 minutes until boiling and thickened, complete cooling, the 3–4 hour freeze to half-set, the 2-minute whisk, transfer to a bowl, the overnight freeze, the author's explanations of the slurry and whisking, the card's yield, and the page's "Indian" cuisine label. https://www.kannammacooks.com/custard-powder-ice-cream-recipe/
  • Raks Kitchen, "Custard powder ice cream recipe | Homemade ice cream." Used for comparison only: a separate formula with cream, a first freeze of about an hour and repeated mixer whipping. The post body describes a guest post by Jeyashri; the recipe card credits Raks Anand. https://rakskitchen.net/custard-powder-ice-cream-recipe/
  • Aarthi, "Eggless Custard Powder Ice Cream Recipe," Yummy Tummy Aarthi. Used for comparison only: a separate formula with vanilla essence and cream, a longer first freeze, blending and refreezing. Its title does not describe the powder used in this recipe. https://www.yummytummyaarthi.com/eggless-custard-powder-ice-cream-recipe/