Sauerbraten: Cologne's Sweet-and-Sour Beef, Marinated 3 Days in Vinegar

Thinly sliced sauerbraten with a brown raisin sauce, served with potato dumplings and applesauce
Prep
20 min
Cook
3 hr 10 min
Total
76 hr 30 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
German, Rhineland

A recipe for Sauerbraten, the home dish of the Rhineland in Germany (Soorbrode in Cologne), made with 1 kg of beef. The beef sits 3 days in a marinade of red wine vinegar, cloves, and juniper berries, then is finished in a sweet-and-sour sauce with raisins and gingerbread. Covers the horse-meat tradition, regional differences, substitutes, hygiene during marinating, and sides.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Boil the marinade and cool it

Boiling the vinegar marinade with onions, carrots, and spices in a pot
Turn off the heat when the vinegar aroma rises and the onions turn a little translucent

Put 2 cups (500 ml) water, 1 cups (250 ml) red wine vinegar, 1 tsp salt, 3 onions' worth of wedges, the carrot rounds, and all the spices and herbs from the cloves through the rosemary into a pot and set over medium heat. When it boils, lower the heat, boil gently for about 5 minutes, and turn off the heat. Leave at room temperature for about 1 hour until it has cooled to the point where it feels no warmth when you touch it. Pouring it hot over the meat cooks only the surface.

STEP22 / 7

Marinate the beef in the refrigerator for 3 days

Hands turning a piece of beef submerged in marinade in a storage container
Turn the meat once or twice a day while it marinates in the refrigerator

Put 2.25 lb (1 kg) beef in an acid-resistant container or heavy storage bag and pour in the cooled marinade, vegetables and all. Keep the meat almost submerged and marinate in the refrigerator for 72 hours. Turn the meat over once or twice a day. When it is done, the surface of the meat will be a grayish brown with the red gone. It is fine if the color has not changed all the way through.

STEP33 / 7

Wipe dry and brown the surface

about 10 min

Searing the surface of a piece of beef in a heavy pot to a deep brown
Turn the meat as you go until every side is a rich brown

Take the meat out and strain the marinade through a sieve, keeping only the liquid. Do not use the strained vegetables and spices. Wipe the surface of the meat thoroughly with paper towels. Heat 2 tbsp vegetable oil in a heavy pot over medium-high heat and brown each side of the meat for 2–3 minutes, about 10 minutes in total. If it goes in wet, the oil spatters and the meat browns poorly, so dry it carefully.

STEP44 / 7

Add the raisins and onions and cook

about 15 min

A pot with raisins and chopped onions cooking around the browned beef
When the onions are soft and the raisins have plumped, go to the next stage

With the meat still in the pot, add 7 oz (200 g) raisins, 1.75 oz (50 g) currants, and 2 finely chopped onions around it. Cook over medium to medium-low heat for about 15 minutes, scraping the bottom of the pot from time to time. When the onions are soft and lightly colored and the raisins have plumped, move on. If the bottom of the pot looks about to scorch, first add about 2 tbsp of the strained marinade.

STEP55 / 7

Pour in the marinade and braise

about 2 h 30 min

Beef cooking quietly in marinade and raisins in a pot with the lid slightly ajar
Keep the heat where the surface bubbles gently, and turn the meat from time to time

Pour the strained marinade into the pot and bring it to a boil once over medium heat. Because the marinade has touched raw meat, bring it to a full boil here before lowering the heat. Cover and cook for about 2 hours 30 minutes at a heat where the surface bubbles gently. Turn the meat every 30 minutes, and if the liquid drops below half the height of the meat, add ½ cup (100 ml) water at a time. It is done when a fork goes in without resistance and the meat falls off when lifted.

STEP66 / 7

Finish the sauce

about 10 min

A pot of brown liquid with crushed gingerbread cookies added to thicken it
Dissolve the cookies a little at a time and decide the amount by the thickness

Take out the meat, wrap it in foil, and let it rest somewhere warm. Stir 1 tbsp apple jam into the liquid in the pot, and over medium-low heat add 1.5 oz (40 g) crushed gingerbread cookies a little at a time to dissolve. Do not add it all at once; stop when it is thick enough that the trail made by a wooden spoon across the bottom slowly closes. Adjust with salt and black pepper, and after turning off the heat stir in 3 tbsp sour cream. Do not let it boil after the sour cream goes in, and it finishes smooth without separating.

STEP77 / 7

Slice the meat and serve

Hands slicing the cooked beef to 1 cm thick on a cutting board
Cutting across the grain keeps the shape even of tender meat

Cut the meat across the grain, about 0.5 inches (1 cm) thick. Cooked meat crumbles easily, so use a well-sharpened knife and draw it back and forth in long strokes rather than pressing. Arrange the meat on plates and spoon on plenty of sauce, raisins and all.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Beef and marinade

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Beef (shoulder or round, in one piece) 2.25 lb (1 kg) Lean meat suited to braising. A neat single piece is best
Water 2 cups (500 ml)
Red wine vinegar 1 cups (250 ml) If you cannot get it, half rice vinegar and half red wine. The quality of the sourness changes
Salt 1 tsp
Onions 3 Cut into wedges
Carrot 1 Cut into 0.5 inches (1 cm) rounds
Cloves (whole) 5
Juniper berries 10 A spice available at import food stores or online. If you cannot get them, leave them out, and the aroma will be more restrained
Black peppercorns 10
Mustard seeds 1/2 tsp
Bay leaves 2
Ground coriander 1/4 tsp A pinch
Marjoram (dried) 1/4 tsp A pinch. Omit if you do not have it
Rosemary (dried) 1 tsp
2 / 2

Browning and sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp Instead of 3.5 oz (100 g) beef fat or sunflower oil. Reduced for home cooking
Raisins 7 oz (200 g) Half works if you want it less sweet
Currants (small dried grapes) 1.75 oz (50 g) If you have none, add 1.75 oz (50 g) more raisins
Onions (for the sauce) 2 Finely chopped
Gingerbread cookies or Lebkuchen 1.5 oz (40 g) A substitute for 1–2 Printen. Crush before using
Apple jam 1 tbsp A substitute for Apfelkraut (apple syrup)
Sour cream 3 tbsp For finishing. Without it, the sourness comes a bit more to the front
Salt and black pepper A little of each Taste at the end and adjust
0 / 0

In Cologne's old town, a short walk from the cathedral, brewhouses (Brauhäuser) line the streets and pour Kölsch into slender glasses. The plate that keeps arriving at their wooden tables is thinly sliced beef under a dark brown sauce. This is Sauerbraten, or Soorbrode in the Cologne dialect. The name means "sour roast," and the meat is left in a vinegar marinade for days before it ever sees the pot. In the Rhineland, the sauce comes out sour and sweet at the same time.

Sauerbraten and Kölsch on a wooden table reminiscent of a Cologne brewhouse

Rhineland Sauerbraten and where it comes from

Sauerbraten is made all over Germany and is often called the country's national dish. Raw meat goes into a marinade of vinegar or wine with pepper, juniper berries, cloves and other spices, and is then braised. The cuts are tough ones, because that is the whole point: a long soak, tenderizing tough meat with acid.

The sweet Rhineland style

The finish changes from region to region, and the Rhineland version is clearly sweet. Cooks add raisins and a syrup boiled down from apples or sugar beets (Apfelkraut, Rübenkraut), then crush hard spice cookies from Aachen called Printen and melt them into the sauce to thicken it. A sauce where sour and sweet arrive at the same time is what sets Rhineland Sauerbraten apart.

Good to know

Germany even has ingredients named Sauerbraten-Printen (Printen for Sauerbraten) and Saucenlebkuchen (gingerbread for sauces). Melting a sweet into a stew sounds odd, but a hard baked treat with honey and spices thickens the sauce and adds sweet aroma at once.

Horse meat and beef

Horse meat was traditionally part of Rhineland Sauerbraten, and some Rhineland restaurants still use it. Cologne brewhouses usually serve beef, though, since many guests avoid horse meat, and beef is the mainstream in homes and restaurants today.

Origin stories

One story says Charlemagne devised the dish to use up leftover roast; another says Julius Caesar had wine-marinated beef sent to Cologne. Most of these tales lack supporting evidence. It makes more sense to see Sauerbraten as a kitchen method from before refrigerators, when vinegar both kept the meat and made tough cuts easier to eat.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Beef roast, red wine vinegar, onions, carrots, raisins, cloves, bay leaves, and juniper berries used for sauerbraten

This is a home version for 2.25 lb (1 kg) of beef, with some ingredients swapped so they are easier to find.

The marinade has a lot of vinegar, so do the soaking in an acid-resistant container, such as glass, enamel, or a heavy storage bag. Avoid aluminum or iron containers. Juniper berries are the conifer berries used to flavor gin, and they bring a resinous, pine-like aroma to the marinade. Printen are hard to find outside Germany, so use a firm cookie spiced with cinnamon and ginger. A sweet butter cookie lacks both the spice aroma and the thickening.

Tip

Most of the spices (cloves, juniper berries, peppercorns) are used whole, so the liquid does not turn cloudy after straining. If you substitute powders you have at home, halve the amount and use a fine-mesh sieve when you strain the marinade.

Warning

Some gingerbread cookies and Lebkuchen contain wheat, egg, dairy, and nuts. Sour cream is a dairy product. If you have an allergy, check the ingredient label before choosing.

Choosing beef, spices and thickeners for Sauerbraten

Pick a lean piece suited to braising, such as shoulder or round; rump is often used too. Fatty cuts tend to make the sauce heavy over the long braise.

Juniper berries are worth tracking down. You can make the dish without them, but their conifer-like aroma disappears and the flavor leans toward cloves and pepper. Even a small amount brings the taste much closer to the real thing.

If you can't find Printen, you have options. Across Germany there is no single thickener: gingerbread, Lebkuchen, ginger snaps, flour, sour cream, brown sugar and roux all turn up. Some recipes finish the sauce with pumpernickel (dark rye bread) and raisins in place of Printen.

Good to know

One marinade is made with 1 liter of red wine and red wine vinegar, with allspice added. Another is based mostly on water and red wine vinegar. Even within the same Rhineland style, the base of the marinade differs from house to house.


How to make sauerbraten

Marinating takes 3 days (72 hours), so work backward from the day you plan to eat. Prep takes about 20 minutes, cooling the marinade about 1 hour, marinating 72 hours, and cooking about 3 hours 10 minutes (5 minutes to boil the marinade, 10 to brown, 15 to simmer the raisins and onions, 2 hours 30 minutes to braise, 10 to finish the sauce). In total, it is about 76 hours 30 minutes.

Warning

Always marinate raw meat in the refrigerator, not at room temperature. Boil any marinade that has touched raw meat or poultry before reusing it. That is why the marinade is brought to a full boil in step 5.

Tip

If you find the sourness too strong, add apple jam 1 tsp at a time. If it is too sweet, set aside some of the strained marinade, boil it, and add it 1 tbsp at a time. Always taste the sauce at the end and decide the balance of sweet and sour.

Tip

Meat is much easier to slice after cooling overnight. It is also a good method to do everything through step 5 the day before and chill the meat in the liquid, then slice it thin on the day and rewarm it in the sauce.

Serving Sauerbraten the Cologne way

Sauerbraten with potato dumplings, applesauce, and braised red cabbage

In the Rhineland, Sauerbraten comes with potato dumplings (Kartoffelklöße) or Reibekuchen, grated-potato pancakes, and Apfelmus (applesauce) is always on the side. Boiled potatoes sometimes appear too, and braised red cabbage (Rotkohl) suits it well.

At home, mashed or boiled potatoes plus store-bought applesauce or stewed apples make a convincing plate. Let the potatoes soak up the sweet-and-sour sauce as you eat.

Frequently asked questions

A storage bag of beef marinating in the refrigerator, set on a tray

Can I marinate for less than 3 days?

Some recipes marinate for 2 days in the refrigerator, while Cologne recipes call for at least 3. The shorter the time, the more restrained the sourness and the tenderness.

Can I eat it with children?

The recipe contains no alcohol, but the vinegar's sourness is quite pronounced. A little more apple jam in the sauce finish and a spoonful of sour cream will round it out. Watch for allergens in the cookies and sour cream.

Sources