Hochzeitssuppe: North German Wedding Soup with Meatballs and White Asparagus

North German Hochzeitssuppe: a clear beef and chicken broth with small meatballs, set egg custard and white asparagus
Prep
45 min
Cook
2 hr
Total
2 hr 45 min
Serves
6 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
German (Lower Saxony)

A North German wedding soup, Hochzeitssuppe, for a home kitchen: a clear broth of beef shank and chicken wings, small meatballs, Eierstich egg custard, how to cook white asparagus, regional variations, substitutes and storage.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Brown the beef shank and onion

10 min

Browning the beef shank and the cut side of the onion in a heavy pot
Without moving the meat and onion, build a light brown fond on the bottom of the pot

Heat: Preheat on medium heat for 2 minutes, then cook 3 minutes per side over medium to medium-high heat.

Wipe the surface of 1 lb (500 g) beef shank with paper towels. Put 1 tbsp rice bran oil in a heavy pot and warm over medium heat for 2 minutes, then place the meat so the pieces don't overlap. Put the onion, halved crosswise with the skin left on, cut side down on the bottom of the pot. Cook the meat 3 minutes per side, and leave the onion unmoved about 5 minutes until the cut side is a deep golden brown. Browned bits form on the bottom of the pot; stop before they burn black. This browning gives the clear broth a faint amber color.

STEP22 / 7

Gently simmer the chicken wings and aromatics

100 min

Simmering beef shank, chicken wings and root vegetables in small bubbles and skimming
Don't let the center boil; draw the broth at a heat where only small bubbles continue at the edge

Heat: Over medium heat for about 15 minutes until just before boiling, then keep 185–194°F (85–90°C) on low heat for 85 minutes.

Pour 3.25 quarts (3 L) water into the pot and lightly loosen the browned bits on the bottom with a wooden spoon. Add 12.5 oz (350 g) chicken wings, 5.5 oz (150 g) carrot, 5.5 oz (150 g) celeriac, 4 oz (120 g) leek, 10 g parsley stems and 10 peppercorns. Warm over medium heat, and when gray foam begins to rise, gather it in one direction with a skimmer and remove it. Drop to low heat before the whole surface rolls, set the lid 1 inch (2 cm) ajar and cook 85 minutes. Keep small bubbles going at the edge of the pot while the center stays quiet. If the water level drops by 1 inch (3 cm) or more, add ¾ cup (200 ml) hot water.

STEP33 / 7

Strain the broth and set the flavor base

12 min

Straining the simmered broth through a fine colander lined with cloth
Catching only the broth that falls without pressing the solids keeps a transparent gold

Heat: Turn off the heat, and after straining warm on low heat for only 5 minutes.

Line a large colander with a clean cloth wrung firmly from water, or heavy paper towels, and set it over another pot. Ladle the solids over first, and pour the broth in last, gently. Pressing the meat or vegetables lets fine fibers fall and cloud it, so wait 3 minutes until it drains naturally. Return the strained broth to low heat, check that it is clear enough to see the bottom of the pot, then skim only 1 to 2 tbsp of fat from the surface. Removing it completely makes it thin, so leave a few small golden droplets. Don't throw away the beef shank and chicken; cool them slightly and use them for sandwiches or the next day's stew.

STEP44 / 7

Set the Eierstich in a water bath

25 min

Setting the egg mixture in heatproof cups in a water bath and cutting it into cubes
If the water doesn't boil, large holes are less likely to form in the cross-section of the Eierstich

Heat: Bring the water to 80–85°C over medium heat and hold it on low heat for 20 minutes.

Put 2 eggs, 1 egg yolk, 120 ml milk, 2 g salt and 0.2 g nutmeg in a bowl. Keeping the whisk against the bottom, mix for 1 minute without letting in air. It is enough when the streaks of egg white are gone and the color is uniform. Strain once through a tea strainer and divide between 2 heatproof cups thinly greased with 3 g butter, covering loosely with aluminum foil. Lay a cloth on the bottom of a pot and pour hot water halfway up the cups. Don't boil the water; cook 20 minutes. Take them out when a bamboo skewer put into the center comes out with clear liquid and the center temperature reaches 71°C. Cool for 10 minutes and cut into 1.5 cm cubes.

STEP55 / 7

Roll the small meatballs

15 min

Meat mixture with nutmeg and small meatballs 1.5 cm across
Put priority on making them the same size rather than perfect spheres

Heat: No heat is used. Mix the ingredients cold.

Put 10.5 oz (300 g) ground beef and pork, 1 egg, 25 g breadcrumbs, 2 tbsp (30 ml) cold water, 4 g salt, 0.5 g black pepper and 0.2 g nutmeg in a bowl. Spread your fingertips like a rake and mix for only 1 minute. Stop when the mixture comes together as one mass and no liquid remains at the bottom of the bowl. Kneading until it is white and sticky makes the meatballs tough. With wet hands, roll them 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) across, about 8 g each, for about 38 meatballs. At this size they are easy to roll and easy to check with a thermometer.

STEP66 / 7

Gently poach the meatballs

10 min

Gently simmering small meatballs in clear broth and measuring the center temperature
After the meatballs float, confirm 71°C in the center of the largest one

Heat: Warm the broth over medium-low heat to 185°F (85°C), then hold on low heat for 8 minutes after adding.

Take 2½ cups (600 ml) of the strained broth into a small pot and warm over medium-low heat to 185°F (85°C). Add the meatballs one at a time, and only in the first 30 seconds gently free any that stick to the bottom with a wooden spoon. Cook on low heat for 8 minutes until the meatballs float and the red on the surface is gone. Insert a thermometer sideways into the largest one and confirm 160°F (71°C) in the center. If it hasn't reached it, extend by 2 minutes at the same heat. Boiling hard scatters fat into the broth and tightens the meatballs.

STEP77 / 7

Combine the asparagus, carrot and egg at the end

12 min

Combining meatballs, white asparagus and carrot in the clear broth, with the egg waiting until last
Warm the meatballs and vegetables first and add the fragile Eierstich last

Heat: Keep 167–185°F (75–85°C) on medium-low heat and do not boil.

Return the rest of the broth to a large pot, add 4 oz (120 g) carrot cut into 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick diamonds and simmer over medium-low heat for 6 minutes. Peel 9 oz (250 g) fresh white asparagus, cut it into 1.5 inches (4 cm) lengths and add it here for another 6 minutes. If jarred, add it only for the last 2 minutes. When a bamboo skewer goes into the carrot with a little resistance and the center of the asparagus breaks apart softly and white, return the meatballs and Eierstich. Warm for 2 minutes up to 167°F (75°C) or above, and set the seasoning by adding 2 g salt at a time. Pour into bowls, then scatter with parsley. Once the egg is in, don't stir with the ladle; only shake the pot gently.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 4

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bone-in beef shank 1 lb (500 g) Without bone, use 14 oz (400 g) beef shank plus 3.5 oz (100 g) more chicken wings
Chicken wings 12.5 oz (350 g) 14 oz (400 g) drumettes also work
Water 3.25 quarts (3 L) Planned for about 2.25 quarts (2.1 L) finished
Onion 1 (about 7 oz (200 g)) Wash the skin and cut in half crosswise
Carrot 1 (about 5.5 oz (150 g)) For the broth. Wash the skin well
Celeriac 5.5 oz (150 g) Substitute 1 celery stalk and 3.5 oz (100 g) small turnip
Leek 1/2 (about 4 oz (120 g)) Substitute the white part of 1 long green onion
Parsley stems 10 g Save the leaves for the finish
Black peppercorns 10 1/3 tsp coarse-ground pepper also works
Rice bran oil 1 tbsp For searing the meat and onion
Salt 8 g Add 2 g at a time at the end to adjust
2 / 4

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Eggs 2 (about 100 g) Medium
Egg yolk 1 (about 18 g) Omitting it lightens the color and richness
Milk 120 ml Unsweetened soy milk changes the flavor
Salt 2 g 1/3 tsp
Nutmeg 0.2 g About 2 shakes. Don't overdo it
Butter 3 g Thinly greased on the cups
3 / 4

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Ground beef and pork 10.5 oz (300 g) Ground beef alone also works
Egg 1 (about 1.75 oz (50 g)) Binder
Breadcrumbs 25 g Fine crumbs hold together more easily
Cold water 2 tbsp (30 ml) Keeps the meat mixture from getting too firm
Salt 4 g About 1.3% of the meat weight
Black pepper 0.5 g A little under 1/4 tsp
Nutmeg 0.2 g About 2 shakes
4 / 4

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
White asparagus 9 oz (250 g) Drain if jarred. If green, shorten the cooking
Carrot 4 oz (120 g) Cut into 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick diamonds
Parsley leaves 12 g Finely chopped
Salt 0 g to 4 g Decide by tasting when using jarred asparagus
0 / 0

Lift the lid of a big white soup tureen and the first thing to rise is a round aroma of beef and chicken, quietly simmered. Each time the ladle reaches the bottom, small meatballs, pale yellow egg and white asparagus come up together.

Ladling clear soup and meatballs into a bowl for Hochzeitssuppe
Even in the spring substitute made with green asparagus, not letting the broth boil is what decides whether it comes out clear

Hochzeitssuppe, German for "wedding soup," is the modest first bowl that settles the table for a long day of celebration. Every version is a clear meat broth with festive additions: meatballs, a set egg custard, seasonal vegetables, noodles or rice. It takes effort, but none of the steps is hard on its own. You finish the broth, meatballs, egg and vegetables separately and combine them in one pot just before eating, which keeps the soup clear and every piece intact.

Hochzeitssuppe and the North German wedding table

Local name and pronunciation

Hochzeit means "wedding" and Suppe means "soup." The regional name Wendländische Hochzeitssuppe means "wedding soup of the Wendland region."

The Wendland version

This recipe is the Wendland version from Lower Saxony. A broth of beef shank and chicken wings is combined with small meatballs called Fleischklößchen, an egg custard called Eierstich, and white asparagus. Eierstich may look like Japanese chawanmushi, but here it plays a supporting role, cut into yellow cubes and floated in the clear soup. Slowly drawing a beef broth in a home pot also connects this soup to the Gaisburger Marsch of Swabia.

A table around a large soup tureen at a simple North German wedding hall
A dish dished out from a big pot, the same bowl for everyone, serves as the first plate of a reception and links the guests

The amounts are for a pot to welcome guests, not a family dinner, and no single expensive ingredient dominates. Broth, meatballs, egg and asparagus, each prepared differently, all fit into one ladle. One person can roll the meatballs while another cuts the Eierstich and a third trims the asparagus, so the work splits easily even in a banquet kitchen. That practical abundance suits a festive day.

Whether the bride or the groom takes the first spoonful is a small piece of table lore that has lasted. After the ceremony, everyone sits in front of the same steam. At home you can skip the decoration: serve the clear soup from a large bowl and you'll see where the name comes from.

Regional versions of wedding soup

Three bowls comparing the wedding soups of Wendland, Hadeln and the Sorbian region
White asparagus and egg, rice and cauliflower, noodles and root vegetables. The regional differences show up in the clear broth

The name spreads from northern to southern Germany and on to the region where the Sorbs live, but what goes in the pot changes. The wedding comes first, and the local meat, vegetables, noodles and rice gather around it. Even the meatball differs: in the Sorbian region, liver dumplings are also used traditionally.

Region or name Main ingredients Character at the table
Wendland, Lower Saxony Beef and chicken broth, meatballs, Eierstich, white asparagus For large feasts. Parts made separately and combined in a big pot
Land Hadeln, Hadler Hochzeitssuppe Beef broth, meatballs, rice, cauliflower, white asparagus With rice, a slightly more filling bowl
Sorbian region, kwasna poliwka Beef and vegetable broth, meatballs or liver dumplings, noodles, root vegetables, Eierstich Served from a large tureen, home-style
Southern German versions Flädle, Grießnockerl, Brätspätzle and so on More starchy ingredients, putting local noodle culture forward

Land Hadeln lies between the Elbe and Weser rivers, and white asparagus turns up there just as it does in Wendland. That ties both soups to the northern German calendar: in Lower Saxony, white asparagus season runs from April to the end of June, so at a spring or early summer wedding the fields go straight into the celebration pot.

Compared with France's garbure, where ingredients and beans pile up into a one-dish main course, or Finland's lohikeitto, finished white with salmon and dairy, wedding soup is a clear entrance. Even with many ingredients, it makes room for the next plate.

Ingredients: building a pot for six

Ingredients: beef shank, chicken wings, ground meat, eggs, white asparagus and root vegetables
Preparing the meat for the broth separately from the meat for the meatballs you eat keeps the work from getting tangled

The finished amount is about 2.25 quarts (2.1 L). As a starter it serves 6, as a light lunch about 4. White asparagus can be used fresh or from a jar. If you use jarred, it is salty, so go easy on the broth's salt until the end.

Clear broth

Eierstich (egg custard)

Fleischklößchen (small meatballs)

Finishing ingredients

Allergies and cooking temperature

This uses beef, chicken, pork, eggs, dairy and wheat. Also check the allergen labeling on each product. Cook the meatballs and the Eierstich until the center of each reaches 160°F (71°C); for the meatballs, check the largest one. Ground meat and egg dishes both need 160°F (71°C). Don't judge doneness by color or by whether they float; check with a thermometer.

Choosing ingredients and substitutes for Hochzeitssuppe

A guide to shopping: a heavy pot, a pressure cooker and an instant-read thermometer
What's worth looking for are tools that help keep the broth clear and cook the meatballs safely

Beef shank, chicken wings, ground meat, eggs and root vegetables are all ordinary supermarket buys. What makes the difference is equipment: a heavy pot that keeps 2 quarts (2 L) or more of broth quiet, a thermometer to check the center of the meatballs, and, if you want to shorten the long broth-making, a pressure cooker. A pot of 4.25 quarts (4 L) or more with a thick bottom keeps the surface calm; in a thin pot, even on low heat, the bottom boils hard and scatters scum through the soup.

The usual obstacles at the market are beef bones, celeriac and white asparagus. Keep the core of the dish, a layered beef and chicken broth, meatballs and Eierstich, each finished separately, and the soup will still taste close to the original.

Ingredient or step that gives pause Why keep it Realistic answer
Bone-in beef shank Beef aroma and gelatin Use 14 oz (400 g) boneless beef shank and 1 lb (450 g) chicken wings
Celeriac Sweetness and earthy aroma of root vegetables Combine 1 celery stalk and 3.5 oz (100 g) small turnip
White asparagus A spring ingredient of northern Germany Drain jarred asparagus and warm it at the end
Green asparagus Stronger color and green aroma If substituting, cut into 1.5 inches (4 cm) lengths and simmer only the last 3 minutes
Eierstich Yellow cubes and a soft mouthfeel Set with milk and eggs only, no dashi as for chawanmushi
Clear broth The lightness of a celebration's first plate Keep it below a boil, and strain without pressing the solids

Fresh white asparagus can be expensive, so buy it only when it is in season and reasonably priced. The rest of the year, jarred asparagus keeps the white color and lets you make the same dish.

Method: finish the parts separately and bring them together at the end

Not boiling the broth too hard, and finishing the meatballs, egg and asparagus separately: these two points change the look a great deal. Cooking everything in one pot looks quicker, but the corners of the egg break down, the fat of the meatballs floats and the asparagus gets too soft.

Common problems with Hochzeitssuppe

A comparison of a gently simmered clear broth and a hard-boiled cloudy one
With the same ingredients, gently simmered broth lets you see the bottom, while broth kept boiling turns white and cloudy

A cloudy broth is still perfectly good to eat. Clarifying it with egg white adds work and often thins the flavor at home, so strain it once through a cloth and put your effort into the salt and meat aroma instead. Next time, remember "stop the boil" before "skim the foam."

The meatballs floating is the sign that they have started to cook. Simmered quietly in a heavy pot, they hold their surface better and the soup stays clearer. If you make this often in the cold season, warm a small amount of broth in a saucepan to adjust the seasoning separately, so you can finish without breaking up the ingredients in the big pot.

Serving, storage and variations

A table around a large soup tureen serving Hochzeitssuppe as the first plate
Even with meatballs and egg, about 300 ml per person as a starter makes it easier to move on to the next plate

Serving Hochzeitssuppe

To serve it like a wedding menu, pour 1 cup (250 ml) to 1¼ cups (300 ml) per person into a deep plate, with 5 to 6 meatballs and about 4 pieces of Eierstich. Get greedy and it starts to look like a stew. From a large tureen, each serving comes out a little different, one plate with more meatballs, another with more asparagus, and that variety is part of cooking in one big pot.

Keep what follows light. For a German table, serve sweet-and-sour Bavarian-style red cabbage on the side and a small portion of Käsespätzle in place of a main. After a meat soup, acidity or starch makes the meal easier to finish than another large meat dish.

Storing and reheating

Store the broth, meatballs, Eierstich and asparagus separately. Move them to shallow containers, cover once the steam settles, and refrigerate quickly. Cooked leftovers keep 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator; for the best texture, eat the broth and meatballs within 3 days and the Eierstich and asparagus within 2 days. To reheat, warm the broth and meatballs first to 165°F (74°C), and add the Eierstich and asparagus only for the last 2 minutes.

Only the broth and meatballs freeze well, separately, for 1 month. Eierstich turns watery and pocked, and asparagus goes soft in the fibers. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator, or warm the frozen broth directly in a pot over low heat without letting it boil; once it has completely melted, add the meatballs and reheat everything to 165°F (74°C).

Variations

For a pressure cooker version, put in the seared beef shank, chicken wings, aromatics and 2.75 quarts (2.5 L) water, cook at high pressure 25 minutes and release the pressure naturally for 20 minutes. After straining, move to an ordinary pot and finish the meatballs, Eierstich and asparagus separately as usual. The pressure cooker is for speed; anything that must keep its shape belongs in the ordinary pot.

The Wendland version is the easiest place to start, since without rice or noodles you can concentrate on a clear broth and the four main ingredients. The second time, try adding 20 g of cooked rice per person in the Hadeln style, or a small amount of thin egg noodles in the Sorbian style. And for another dish that refuses to rush the heat, try Sweden's tjälknöl, frozen meat cooked in a low oven. It looks nothing like this soup, but the patience is the same.

Frequently asked questions

Chilling the broth, meatballs, Eierstich and white asparagus in separate containers
When preparing the day before, keep the parts separate and return them to one pot just before eating

How far ahead can I make it the day before?

You can make the broth, meatballs and Eierstich, chilled in separate shallow containers in the refrigerator. On the day, warm the broth and meatballs first, cook the asparagus and carrot, and return the Eierstich last. If you combine everything the day before, the egg breaks down from the corners and the asparagus goes soft.

What if I can't find white asparagus?

Jarred is easiest and keeps the white look. Drain it, cut it into 1.5 inches (4 cm) lengths and warm it only for the last 2 minutes. Green asparagus works too, though its aroma is stronger and the color changes the look of the bowl; keep it from getting too soft.

My Eierstich has holes. Can I fix it?

They do no harm to the eating. Large holes tend to come from whipping the egg mixture or boiling the water bath, so next time strain the mixture through a tea strainer and set it in 80–85°C water. For this batch, cut it a little smaller than 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) and the holes will be less noticeable.

Will it have flavor if I can't get beef bones?

Yes. Use boneless beef shank and chicken wings and simmer quietly for the same time; the bones and skin of the wings make up the gelatin. Commercial bouillon added at the start makes the salt and aroma too strong, so use up to 1/2 tsp only if the flavor is weak after straining.

Can I make the meatballs with beef only?

Yes. Switch to 10.5 oz (300 g) ground beef and increase the cold water to 2.5 tbsp (40 ml). Without the pork the fat drops and they firm up a little, so keep the mixing to within 1 minute and the cooking on low heat. The center still needs to reach 160°F (71°C).

Finally, shake the pot gently, and turn off the heat when the corners of the egg haven't broken and golden broth shows between the meatballs. Carry the large bowl to the table and ladle meatballs and egg up together. Handing out that bowl is the finish of Hochzeitssuppe.

Sources consulted