Caponata: Sicilian Sweet-and-Sour Eggplant with Fried Eggplant and Agrodolce

Caponata of fried eggplant, celery, green olives, and capers in a sweet-and-sour tomato sauce
Prep
20 min
Cook
40 min
Total
2 hr
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Italian, Sicilian

A Sicilian caponata for 4, made with separately fried eggplant and a sweet-and-sour finish. Covers the roles of celery, olives, and capers, regional differences in vegetables and nuts, the several theories behind the name, how to get the result with ordinary eggplant and vinegar, fixes for greasiness and sharpness, refrigerated storage, and serving with bread, with step photos.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Cut the vegetables and drain the packing liquid

Prep with 2.5 cm cubes of eggplant, sliced onion, and sliced celery and tomato set apart
Wipe the moisture from the eggplant surface and keep the cubes the same size

The work is about 15 minutes. Cut the eggplant with skin on into 1 inch (2.5 cm) cubes, the onion in 0.25 inch (5 mm) slices. Remove the strings from the celery and cut it 0.25 inch (5 mm) wide, and cut the tomatoes in 1 inch (2 cm) cubes. Halve the olives and drain the capers. If using salt-packed capers, finish desalting first as the label directs. Wipe the surface of the eggplant dry with paper towel. Do not soak the cut eggplant in water. Weigh after removing stems and strings. If the eggplant cubes are too small, they break down easily at the finish.

STEP22 / 6

Fry the eggplant in small batches

Frying a small batch of cubed eggplant in a small pot of oil, the surface beginning to turn light golden brown
Do not add too much at once; fry until soft to the center

Put about 1¼ cups (300 ml) frying oil in a small deep pot, about 1 inch (2 cm) deep and no more than half the pot. Heat over medium heat to an oil temperature of 170–180°C. Fry the eggplant in about 3 batches, about 4 to 5 minutes per batch, turning from time to time. Do not put in the whole amount at once. It is done when the surface is a light golden brown, the corners are slightly rounded, and it is soft to the center when pressed lightly with chopsticks. Do not decide by color alone; check the softness inside. Spread on a rack or paper towel to drain. When the oil temperature drops, bring it back up before adding the next batch. Avoid leaving it at high heat unattended.

STEP33 / 6

Sauté the onion and celery

Sautéing translucent onion and chopped celery in a skillet
Onion until translucent, celery with a little bite left

Put 1 oz (30 g) olive oil in a separate skillet and sauté the onion over medium-low heat for 5 minutes, until translucent and glossy with the edges lightly colored. Add the celery and sauté over medium-low heat for 3 minutes, until it begins to soften but still keeps its bite. If the browning suddenly deepens, lower the heat. Do not dissolve blackened parts in water and mix them through. Do not add the eggplant yet. Stirring fried eggplant for a long time makes it lose shape.

STEP44 / 6

Simmer the tomato and jarred ingredients

Simmering tomato, celery, onion, green olives, and capers into a red sauce
Simmer the vegetables to a thickness where no water collects at the bottom

Add 7 oz (200 g) tomato, 2.75 oz (80 g) olives, 20 g capers, and 2 tbsp (30 ml) water. When it begins to bubble over medium heat, lower to low, cover, and simmer 12 to 15 minutes, stirring once or twice. Cook until the tomato has broken down and the celery is soft enough to bite. If there is a lot of liquid, take off the lid and simmer 2 to 3 minutes more over medium-low heat. If it looks about to scorch, add 1 tbsp (15 ml) water. Aim for a thickness where, when you stroke the bottom with a spatula, the bottom shows for a moment and water does not rush back in right away.

STEP55 / 6

Add the sweet-and-sour and combine with the eggplant

Adding the fried eggplant to the reduced sweet-and-sour sauce and turning with a spatula to keep its shape
Do not simmer long; coat the fried eggplant with the sauce

Mix 2 tbsp (30 ml) white wine vinegar, 20 g sugar, and 15 g tomato paste in a small bowl and add to the sauce. If using distilled white or rice vinegar, begin with 1.5 tbsp (20 ml). Heat uncovered over medium heat for 2 to 3 minutes, until it bubbles, the sugar dissolves, and the sharp stinging smell of the vinegar softens. You are not driving off all the acidity. Add the eggplant after turning off the heat. Put in the fried eggplant and 3 g basil and turn from underneath with a spatula 2 to 3 times so the sauce coats it. Do not crush the eggplant. It is done when the sauce coats the surface. Take a little, let it cool, and taste, then add salt within 0–1 g. Add more sweetness or acidity only after tasting. Never add vinegar or sugar in bulk right after it comes off the heat.

STEP66 / 6

Move to shallow containers and refrigerate

Dividing finished caponata thinly between two clean shallow heatproof containers, ready for cooling
Do not leave it in a big pot; divide it shallowly and refrigerate promptly

The finishing work is about 5 minutes. Divide thinly between 2 clean, shallow heatproof containers and move to the refrigerator promptly. Do not leave it in the big pot at room temperature until it cools completely. Keep the refrigerator at 39°F (4°C) or below. Refrigerate within a total of 2 hours at room temperature after cooking, or within 1 hour when the air temperature is above 90°F (32°C). Refrigerate about 60 minutes to blend the flavors, and keep refrigerating until the center is fully cold. Take out only what you will eat with a clean spoon. If you garnish with basil, use some set aside from the 3 g in the ingredients, and return the rest to the refrigerator.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Vegetables and aromatics

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Eggplant 1 lb (500 g) Weight after removing the stem. The same weight of long eggplant, round eggplant, or American globe eggplant
Celery 5.5 oz (150 g) The stalk portion. Remove the strings. Do not replace with leaves only
Onion 5.5 oz (150 g) Sliced about 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick
Ripe tomatoes 7 oz (200 g) 1 inch (2 cm) cubes. 7 oz (200 g) of unsalted canned diced tomatoes also works; adjust the reduction
Green olives (pitted) 2.75 oz (80 g) Drain and weigh. Brine-packed and unstuffed as the basic
Capers 20g Drain vinegar-packed ones. For salt-packed, desalt as the label directs and then weigh
Basil 3g Tear by hand if the leaves are large. For finishing
2 / 2

Sweet-and-sour and oil

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
White wine vinegar 2 tbsp (30 ml) Check the acidity on the label. With distilled white or rice vinegar start at 1.5 tbsp (20 ml) and keep the other 2 tsp (10 ml) for adjusting
Sugar 20g Plain white sugar or similar. The basic amount for the agrodolce
Tomato paste 15g Unsalted type. If you have none, leave it out and increase the tomatoes to 9 oz (250 g) and reduce
Olive oil 1 oz (30 g) For the sauce. Weigh separately from the frying oil
Frying oil about 1¼ cups (300 ml) About 1 inch (2 cm) deep in a small deep pot, no more than half the depth of the pot. You do not eat all the oil
Salt 0–1g Check the saltiness of the capers and olives and add at the end. You do not need to use it up
Water 2 tbsp (30 ml) To prevent the sauce from scorching. Corrections are 1 tbsp (15 ml) at a time
0 / 0

Fried eggplant comes out of the oil with its edges still sharp. Over the pot of red tomato and green olives, the steam carries the bite of vinegar. This is caponata, Sicily's sweet-and-sour vegetable dish: eggplant, celery, onion, tomato, olives, and capers brought together in one pot. Unlike a dish where tomato simply simmers, it gets its flavor from sweet-and-sour, and the eggplant is softened in oil first and added later. The meeting of fried eggplant and agrodolce is the high point. Frying the eggplant separately is the heart of the dish, and ordinary eggplant and jarred capers will do.

Caponata on the Sicilian Table

Caponata is loved on Sicilian summer tables, the deep purple of eggplant, the red of tomato, and the green of olives all on one plate. It is a sweet-and-sour vegetable appetizer, traditionally eaten cold and served in small amounts on small plates, with bread, or beside grilled meat or fish. The basic mix contains no meat, fish, or dairy.

The eggplant and celery don't end up equally soft, and that's the point. The eggplant is fried on its own and then folded into the sauce, so it softens but keeps its corners. The celery cooks in the onion-and-tomato sauce and keeps more bite. This contrast of soft eggplant and crisp celery keeps it from getting tiresome as you eat.

Where the name comes from

One theory involves fish: the name comes from capone, meaning mahi-mahi (dolphinfish) in parts of Sicily. Common people replaced a sweet-and-sour fish dish eaten by nobles with eggplant.

Good to know

Besides the capone theory, another links the name to the Latin caupona, meaning a tavern. There are several theories for the name.

Caponata across Sicily

Move to another town on the island and what's on the plate changes, and even within one town, homes differ. Palermo has a simple form, while Catania uses red and yellow bell peppers, and some versions add garlic and potatoes. In Trapani, peppers are combined with toasted almonds.

Region Ingredient differences How to try it at home
Palermo A simple mix of vegetables Make the basic eggplant, celery, and sweet-and-sour first
Catania Red and yellow bell peppers. In some, garlic and potatoes For color, sauté bell pepper separately
Trapani Bell peppers, vinegar, toasted almonds Adding nuts just before eating keeps their crunch
Agrigento Roasted peppers, honey, garlic, chili, nuts, raisins, and others When you increase sweet ingredients, reduce the sugar

The basic recipe here has no nuts, raisins, or peppers. Get to know the eggplant and celery, the salt of the capers, and the vinegar-and-sugar balance first, then add one ingredient at a time. Honey or raisins push the sweetness up; nuts add crunch.

Good to know

Agrodolce means "sweet and sour." In cooking, it refers to a seasoning that combines vinegar and sugar. In caponata, the vinegar goes in at the final sauce stage so the eggplant is not simmered for long.


Ingredients (serves 4)

These amounts suit a home kitchen. The eggplant is 1 lb (500 g) edible portion, weighed after removing the stems. The celery, 5.5 oz (150 g), is also weighed after removing the strings. Always weigh the vegetables; do not go by the number of eggplants or stalks of celery. Leave the eggplant skin on. For frying, use a pot about 8 inches (20 cm) across with some depth, and for the sauce a skillet of about 10 inches (26 cm). An ordinary pot and skillet will do.

Eggplant, celery, onion, tomato, green olives, capers, vinegar, sugar, and oil laid out as ingredients
Handle the eggplant and celery separately, and combine the sweet-and-sour at the end

Tell vinegar-packed and salt-packed capers apart. Drain vinegar-packed ones; desalt salt-packed ones as the label directs and then weigh. Do not put the packing liquid into the sauce. If you measure the liquid from vinegar-packed capers in place of the 2 tbsp (30 ml) for the sweet-and-sour, the amounts of vinegar and salt change.

Tip

When substituting distilled white or rice vinegar, start with 1.5 tbsp (20 ml). After finishing the sauce, add 1 tsp (5 ml) at a time, up to about 2 tbsp (30 ml) at most. Vinegar varies in aroma and acidity by product, and distilled white or rice vinegar does not give the same fragrance as white wine vinegar. Topping up little by little after reducing is less likely to fail than adding it all at the start.

Caution

Wash the vegetables and basil under running water before cutting. Use clean tools, and keep them apart from the cutting board used for raw meat and fish. The basic mix contains no dairy, egg, wheat, or nuts, but check the allergen labels of jarred ingredients and seasonings. Serving with bread adds wheat and other allergens, and the nut variations add nuts. Choose ingredients to suit the food allergens you personally need to avoid.

Choosing Ingredients for Caponata

Let the olives and capers do the salting, and keep the finishing salt to 0–1 g. Balance the sweetness against the vinegar rather than pushing it with sugar alone.

Capers belong in the basic mix, and using them the first time shows you how the dish should taste. If you can't get them, leave them out and increase the olives from 2.75 oz (80 g) to 3.5 oz (100 g) as a home adaptation, though their distinctive fragrance is lost. Chopped pickles in the same amount bring a different aroma and acidity, so the flavor changes. Either way, decide any added salt by tasting at the end.

How to make it

The work has two parts: frying the eggplant and making the sauce. Prep takes 20 minutes and all the heating 40 minutes, though these rise or fall with your equipment and how much you fry at once. The key is to reduce the sauce first. In a soupy pot the eggplant will break down. Refrigerating for 60 minutes in step 6 blends the flavors.

Tip

If greasiness bothers you, first review temperature and quantity. Fry the eggplant in small batches and bring the oil back to temperature before adding the next. Do not keep topping up the oil so the eggplant soaks it up. If oil is floating on the surface of the sauce, skim off a small amount from the surface before combining with the eggplant. Do not fix wateriness by adding oil.

Tip

To keep the soft corners of the eggplant, set the eggplant aside while you reduce the sauce, and combine after turning off the heat. Once it is in, turn it from the bottom with the spatula rather than stirring in small motions. Eggplant that has broken down will not regain its corners however long you cook it.

Caution

Take great care with the frying oil. Add wiped-dry eggplant in small amounts, and never put wet tools or water into hot oil. Do not step away from the pot while frying. If the oil smokes, turn off the heat at once. Handle the oil after cooking only once it has cooled. Also, even with the sweet-and-sour, this is not a food that can be kept at room temperature. Observe the refrigeration conditions after cooking.

Fixing Sourness, Greasiness, and Broken Eggplant

The sweet-and-sour smells much stronger in a hot pot, so taste after letting it cool a little. If the acidity is too strong, stir 2 g sugar at a time into the sauce before adding the eggplant and dissolve it over medium heat for 30–60 seconds, up to 6 g in total. Once the eggplant is in, soften the sharpness at serving time instead, for example with a little cooked tomato. A long simmer to drive off acidity only breaks the eggplant down.

Problem Likely cause How to fix, or what to do next time
Sauce is watery Tomato has a lot of water, finished with the lid on Before adding the eggplant, take off the lid and reduce 2–3 minutes at a time over medium-low heat
Eggplant is greasy Fried too much at once, oil temperature dropped, not drained enough Spread on a rack to drain. Next time fry in small batches and bring the oil back to temperature
Too salty Saltiness of olives and capers and added salt stacked up Stop adding salt. Combine with unsalted cooked vegetables or bread
Vinegar is too sharp Sauce was heated too briefly, vinegar was increased all at once Before the eggplant goes in, heat 30–60 seconds more over medium heat and taste
Eggplant breaks down Cut too small, kept cooking after adding It will not return to its shape. Eat it on bread, and next time cut 1 inch (2.5 cm) cubes and combine at the end

Extra vinegar or sugar won't cover too much salt. Simmer some plain vegetables separately and combine them, or eat it little by little with bread or an unsalted main dish, and next time add salt last, in small amounts. Greasiness is a draining problem, so fix that rather than reaching for vinegar, which throws off the sweet-and-sour. If a scorched smell has spread through the pot, seasoning won't hide it; leave the scorched parts out.

Serving Caponata and Variations

A small dish of caponata beside sliced country bread on a Sicilian-style table
Take what you will eat from the refrigerator and enjoy it in small amounts with bread

Caponata is best in small helpings: a little on a small dish with bread, or beside grilled fish or meat. Cold caponata on warm bread is a lovely contrast in texture, so try it a little at a time on bread. Serving it with rice is a home adaptation, not a traditional Sicilian way to eat it.

Once you know the basic flavor, go ahead and add to it. The table gives amounts for the basic 4 servings. Cook bell peppers separately, don't scorch nuts and check their allergen labels, and reduce the sugar when you add sweet ingredients. Change one thing at a time so you can taste the difference from the basic sweet-and-sour.

Variation Change from basic 4 servings Change in texture and flavor
With bell pepper Cut 3.5 oz (100 g) red or yellow bell pepper into 1 inch (2 cm) cubes, take 5 g from the sauce oil, sauté over medium heat 5–6 minutes, then go to step 4 Adds color and the sweetness of the vegetable
With almonds Coarsely chop 15 g unsalted almonds, toast over low heat 2–3 minutes, and add just before eating Toastiness and crunch. Do not scorch
With raisins Soak 15 g raisins in 2 tbsp (30 ml) water for 10 minutes, drain, and go to step 4. Reduce the sugar to 10 g Adds the sweetness of fruit
A little heat Remove the seeds from 1/4 red chili, sauté with the onion in step 3, and take it out at the finish A touch of heat in the aftertaste. Omit for children
Roast the eggplant in the oven Skip the frying oil, toss 1 lb (500 g) eggplant with an extra 1 oz (30 g) olive oil, and roast at a preheated 425°F (220°C) for 25–30 minutes, turning once A home adaptation with a stronger roasted taste than separate frying. Also check softness at the center

For another Italian vegetable dish, try panzanella, a Tuscan dish that tosses tomato and vinegar with bread without any cooking, all bread and raw-vegetable texture. Bagna cauda, vegetables dipped in a warm sauce, takes you to a Piedmontese table quite unlike a cold appetizer.

Storage and frequently asked questions

Caponata's flavors blend in the refrigerator, but how good it is the next day depends on cooling it safely. Divide it into shallow containers, refrigerate promptly, and finish it within 2 days. Keep the refrigerator at 39°F (4°C) or below, and take out only what you'll eat with clean utensils. A strong sweet-and-sour doesn't make it keep any longer.

Caution

Avoid anything that has been at room temperature for more than 2 hours in total, or more than 1 hour in an environment above 90°F (32°C). Do not eat food that has fallen outside safe storage conditions. Do not judge safety by smell or appearance alone. Do not bring it to room temperature for a long time before eating. Take out only what you will eat.

Can I eat it cold?

Yes, straight from the refrigerator, and the bread can be warm. If you like it closer to room temperature, take out just what you'll eat at one sitting and bring it to the table at once. Don't leave a large platter out for hours.

Can I freeze it?

If you freeze it at home, do it on the day of cooking: cool it safely, portion it, seal it, and put it in a freezer at -18°C or below. Eat it within 2 weeks for the best quality. Thaw it in the refrigerator, never at room temperature, and finish it early. The eggplant and celery soften and release water, so freeze only a small amount the first time.

Should I salt the eggplant before frying?

Some versions salt the eggplant and leave it for 1 hour; others fry it as soon as it's cut. For this recipe, cut, wipe dry, and fry right away. If you do salt it, wash off the salt and dry it thoroughly, because wet, rinsed eggplant must never go into the oil.

How far can the nutrition numbers be relied on?

They are approximations for the full 4 servings, calculated with 2.5 oz (70 g) of oil consumed: 1 oz (30 g) sautéing oil plus 1.5 oz (40 g) absorbed by the fried eggplant, not the full 1¼ cups (300 ml) of frying oil. Olives are calculated as stuffed olives, and small amounts of capers, vinegar, and basil, as well as bread and the variations, are excluded. One serving comes to about 260 kcal, about 2.5 g protein, about 21 g fat, and about 20 g carbohydrate. It varies with how much frying oil is absorbed and with the products used, so don't rely on it for precise nutrition management.

Sources