Bagna Cauda: Piedmont's Warm Anchovy-Garlic Dip for Winter Vegetables

A winter table with a bowl of Piedmont-style bagna cauda and raw and cooked vegetables laid out around it
Prep
35 min
Cook
30 min
Total
1 hr 5 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Italian, Piedmontese

A bagna cauda recipe from Piedmont's winter table, made without scorching the anchovy and garlic. Covers combining raw and cooked vegetables, substitutes for cardoon and Jerusalem artichoke, keeping the sauce warm without a fujot, storing leftovers, and where to draw the line when making it at home.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Prepare the garlic and anchovy

15 min

Prep: removing the garlic centers and rinsing the surface of salt-cured anchovy
Remove the garlic centers, rinse the salt from the anchovy, and wipe dry

Slice 6 cloves of garlic and remove the green center. Rinse the surface salt from 5.5 oz (150 g) salt-cured anchovy with water or red wine, take out the bones, and wipe dry with paper towel. Only when you want a milder garlic aroma, soak it in milk for 2 hours, take it out, and wipe it completely dry. Do not put the used milk into the sauce. Water from the anchovy entering the oil will splatter, so dry it well after rinsing.

STEP22 / 7

Soften the garlic without coloring it

10–15 min

A pot softening garlic over low heat in butter and oil without coloring it
Do not scorch the garlic; soften it with the edges still white

In a heavy small pot or earthenware pot, put 1 oz (30 g) butter, ¼ cup (60 ml) olive oil, and the garlic, and set over very low heat. Move it slowly with a wooden spoon and wait until the edges of the garlic are still white and it is soft enough to crush with a finger. Do not let the garlic turn brown. If brown color, strong bubbles, or a fried smell appear, the heat is too high. Take the pot off the heat to lower the temperature, and then resume.

STEP33 / 7

Melt the anchovy into the oil

20–30 min

The pot of bagna cauda, with the anchovy loosened by a wooden spoon and melting into the oil
Do not sear the anchovy; melt it slowly in the oil into a brown-tan sauce

Add the anchovy, then the remaining ¾ cup (180 ml) olive oil and 1 tbsp (15 ml) walnut oil. Keep stirring slowly with a wooden spoon over very low heat, and continue over very low heat until the anchovy pieces disappear. The sauce should flow, be brown-tan, and not boil hard. Do not color the garlic or fry the sauce. If smoke comes up, a burnt smell appears, or large bubbles rise in the oil, take the pot off the heat at once. Once garlic burns, its bitterness cannot be fully removed.

Tip

Even without a thermometer, if small bubbles rise from the bottom of the pot one at a time, you can keep heating as it is. Move on when the garlic crushes under the wooden spoon and the anchovy is no longer in strands. If you raise the heat to hurry, the fish and garlic fry and bitterness comes out.

STEP44 / 7

Separate the vegetables for serving raw from those to boil

20–25 min

Prep of cutting cardoon, Jerusalem artichoke, potatoes, and cauliflower to boil
Separate the vegetables that soak in acidulated water from those that are boiled until soft

Cut the cardoon and Jerusalem artichoke to an easy size. Soak them in water with lemon juice as you cut, to prevent discoloration. Boil each in water over medium heat: about 20 minutes for the cardoon and about 7 minutes for the Jerusalem artichoke. Take them out when a bamboo skewer goes through the center but they do not fall apart. Take the boiled vegetables out before they collapse. Heat the potatoes and cauliflower in separate pots until soft, drain, and let the surface dry. Wash and cut the celery, carrot, cabbage, and endive, and serve them raw. Use the bell pepper raw, or roast it in the next step. Thicker pieces take longer, so test with a skewer.

STEP55 / 7

Cook the onion and bell pepper

20 min

Roasting halved onion and red bell pepper and peeling them for bagna cauda
Roast the onion and bell pepper to bring out sweetness and separate the texture from the raw vegetables

Cut the onion in half lengthwise and roast it cut side down in a 400°F (200°C) oven for about 20 minutes. If you roast the bell pepper, take it out when the skin has color and the flesh has softened. Peel it after it has cooled a little. Slice the precooked beet, and drain the cauliflower and potatoes. Do not add the juices from the roasted vegetables to the sauce, so each vegetable keeps its own sweetness and moisture.

STEP66 / 7

Keep the sauce warm and arrange the vegetables

5 min

Bagna cauda kept warm in a small pot, with raw and cooked vegetables arranged separately on the table
Keep the sauce warm without boiling it, and arrange the vegetables separately as raw and cooked

Taste the sauce for saltiness. If the anchovy is too salty, add more vegetables or thin it with a little warmed olive oil. Move the sauce to a small pot or a dedicated fujot. Keep it over low heat, just below the point where the surface bubbles. Do not boil the oil. At the table, set the pot where it cannot tip. Arrange raw and warm vegetables on separate plates, and let each person dip one clean piece at a time. In the traditional way of eating, a bitten vegetable is not returned to the pot, and bread is not used to soak up the sauce.

Caution

Do not set an ordinary small dish or a non-heatproof vessel over a candle. If you use a fujot, follow the instructions for the dedicated item, and do not leave your seat while the flame is lit. Do not leave the sauce and vegetables at room temperature for long; bring to the table only what you will eat.

STEP77 / 7

Set an egg in the leftover sauce

5 min

Adding egg to the leftover bagna cauda and cooking it through in the bottom of the pot
Add egg to the leftover sauce, set it with no half-raw part, and finish it all

Add 2 beaten eggs to the sauce left at the end of the meal. Stir with a wooden spoon over medium-low heat until the egg is set throughout and no liquid remains. In Piedmont, the sauce left at the bottom of the pot, called "spesso della bagna," is finished this way. Eat every last spoonful with egg. Heat until the whole thing is set; do not leave it half-raw. Do not store it; eat it on the spot. For sauce you will keep, move it to a shallow clean container and refrigerate within 2 hours of cooking. Do not store garlic oil at room temperature.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Salt-cured anchovy (fillets) 5.5 oz (150 g) Remove the bones and rinse off the surface salt. If using oil-packed, drain the oil and add no extra salt
Garlic 6 cloves Remove the center if it is green. To soften the aroma, soak in milk for 2 hours and wipe dry
Extra virgin olive oil 1 cup (240 ml) ¼ cup (60 ml) first, then ¾ cup (180 ml) after adding the anchovy. Choose one with a mild aroma
Unsalted butter 1 oz (30 g) Rounds out the finish. Replace with olive oil if avoiding dairy
Walnut oil 1 tbsp (15 ml) Optional. Adds fragrance
2 / 3

Vegetables for dipping

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Cardoon 10.5 oz (300 g) If unavailable, combine thick celery stalks and cabbage cores
Jerusalem artichoke (topinambur) 9 oz (250 g) Can be replaced with burdock or lotus root, but the earthy scent and texture change
Potatoes 10.5 oz (300 g) Peeled, in bite-size pieces. Boil before use
Red beets 5.5 oz (150 g) Precooked is easier to handle. If you have none, red turnip can make up the color
Red bell pepper 1 (about 5.5 oz/150 g) Raw, or roasted and peeled
Celery 2 stalks (about 4 oz/120 g) Remove the strings and cut to an easy length
Carrots 2 (about 6.5 oz/180 g) Served raw. If hard, cut into thin sticks
Cabbage 9 oz (250 g) Raw leaves or briefly boiled
Endive or escarole 5.5 oz (150 g) Chicory or outer lettuce leaves can substitute
Cauliflower 9 oz (250 g) Divide into small florets and boil
Lemon 1/2 For the acidulated water to soak the cardoon and Jerusalem artichoke
3 / 3

For the table

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Eggs 2 Cooked in the last of the sauce. Even if of raw-eating quality, avoid undercooking
Red wine ¼ cup (60 ml) Optional if you use it to rinse the anchovy. Water also works
Polenta or bread not prepared In the traditional way of eating, bread is not the main dipper; if needed, put out a little on a separate plate
0 / 0

A low dish sits on a winter table in Piedmont, a pale brown sauce warming slowly over a small flame. Around it are red bell peppers, raw celery, boiled potatoes, and cardoon. Whoever reaches out takes a piece of vegetable and dips it into the sauce. Nothing gets poured over anything; you dip each piece of vegetable into the hot sauce. Bagna cauda is built on garlic, anchovy, and olive oil, sometimes with butter. It is salty and mellow, and the vegetables do as much of the work as the sauce.

Bagna cauda in Piedmont

The name, written in Italian as Bagna càuda or Bagna caoda, means "hot sauce" or "hot bath." It is an autumn and winter dish, eaten with a mix of raw and cooked vegetables. The sauce stays warm while everyone gathers around it and works through the vegetables bit by bit. At home, the two hard parts are balancing the saltiness of the anchovy and softening the garlic without coloring it. Let the sweetness of the vegetables meet the saltiness of the anchovy, and be generous with the vegetables.

Anchovies in a landlocked region

Piedmont has no coast, yet anchovy is a key ingredient. A trade route carried salt from Provence across the Alps, and anchovies traveled the same way. They were caught in the Gulf of Lion (Golfo del Leone) and packed in barrels with salt. Fish from the sea traveled the salt road to the mountain kitchen, and a dish pairing strongly salted fish with local vegetables and oil grew out of that.

Garlic was a crop that medieval statutes and rural proclamations required farmers to grow. Olive oil, by contrast, was not produced in large amounts in the region and also had to come from outside.

Good to know

The "ancioè," mountain people of Val Maira, went from house to house selling anchovies in the cold season. Even a small amount could be bought at the door, which spread the fish to every household.

A dish for the end of the harvest

Bagna cauda has no single inventor. It is a country dish, made to celebrate bottling the new wine in late autumn, and some trace it to Provençal anchoïade. Whatever the origin, the picture is the same: 19th-century farmers gathered around a pot on long winter nights. A communal winter dish from the end of the harvest, it still lives on in home cooking today. Villanova d'Asti also makes a cold summer version, called "bagna fèrgia."

The vegetables and regional differences

The traditional raw vegetables are cardoon, Jerusalem artichoke (topinambur), cabbage, endive or escarole, celery, carrot, and peppers. Cooked ones include potatoes, onions, beets, cauliflower, and roasted peppers. Names and growing areas differ from town to town, like the "cardi gobbi" of Nizza Monferrato and the cardoon of Chieri, so every table is a little different. Put raw crunch and the sweetness of cooked vegetables on one plate, and the same sauce tastes different with every bite. Really, it helps to think of it as a sauce for eating winter vegetables.

How it is eaten

In Piedmont, each person gets a terracotta fujot (fojòt) of sauce, kept warm by a flame underneath. A few manners apply: never dip a vegetable again after you have bitten it, do not scoop only the thick part from the bottom, and do not make bread the main dipper.

At home, you can keep it warm in a small pot without a dedicated fujot. Use a heavy small pot over low heat and move small amounts into a hot dish. Never set a candle or open flame under an ordinary dish, and even with a real fujot, check that it sits stably and never leave the flame unattended.

A scene of a Piedmont winter table gathered around vegetables and bagna cauda
A Piedmont winter table gathered around raw and cooked vegetables with a warm sauce at the center

Ingredients (serves 4)

This recipe serves 4 and is scaled to fit a home pot: 6 cloves garlic, 5.5 oz (150 g) salt-cured anchovy, 1 cup (240 ml) olive oil, and 1 oz (30 g) butter. Walnut oil is optional. Prepare plenty of vegetables and finish the sauce at the table.

Salt-cured anchovy, garlic, olive oil, butter, and winter vegetables laid out as bagna cauda ingredients
Prepare raw and cooked vegetables around the anchovy and garlic
Caution

Anchovy contains fish and butter contains dairy, so do not serve it to anyone with those allergies. Wash vegetables to be eaten raw under running water. If you use the same cutting board for cooked vegetables, cut the raw ones first and wash the board between uses. A sauce of garlic mixed with oil is not a dish to bottle and keep at room temperature. Warm only what you will eat at the table, cool the rest quickly, and refrigerate.

Choosing anchovies, vegetables, and substitutes

Garlic, olive oil, potatoes, celery, bell pepper, and cabbage are easy to find, and they make up the base of the dish. The anchovy is what sets it apart, so start by looking for fillets. Salt-cured fillets are the easiest to break up and dissolve into the oil. With oil-packed fillets, add no salt and taste as you go.

Tip

Check the label to see whether the anchovy is described as "fillet," "salt-cured," or "oil-packed." Rinse salt-cured fillets in water or red wine to remove surface salt before use.

A fujot warms one person's sauce, and at home a heavy small pot on a low tabletop burner does the same job. At the table, the goal is to keep the sauce warm, not to heat it; a candle will not bring the oil to a simmer. More than a dedicated vessel, what matters is keeping it warm without scorching.

Cardoon and Jerusalem artichoke are hard to find, and choosing substitutes by role works better than hunting for the same name. Cardoon brings bitterness and fiber, which celery and cabbage cores can stand in for. Jerusalem artichoke has the crumbly texture of a root vegetable, and lotus root or burdock give that texture and earthy scent in another form. Red beet is mainly there for color and earthy sweetness; red turnip makes both milder. Replace vegetables by texture, not by name. The anchovy, garlic, and oil are another matter: swap any of them and it becomes a different dish.

Local ingredient Candidate that is easy to get What changes
Cardoon Thick celery, cabbage cores Bitterness and fibrous quality weaken. Do not overboil, to keep the bite
Jerusalem artichoke (topinambur) Lotus root, burdock Lotus root is crisp, burdock has a strong aroma, and neither has the sweetness of Jerusalem artichoke
Red beet Cooked red turnip Color is paler and the earthy sweetness is lighter
Endive, escarole Chicory, outer lettuce leaves The strength of bitterness changes. The sauce is strong, so choose tender leaves
Fujot Heavy small pot, tabletop burner Heat retention for one person drops, so move small amounts to keep the temperature

How to make it

Bagna cauda is not an emulsified sauce. Garlic and fish melt slowly into oil over low heat. A good result is garlic that has not colored and is soft, anchovy with no pieces left, and a flowing brown sauce. Dissolve, do not fry. Watch the sound at the bottom of the pot and the color of the garlic, not only the heat. Mix raw and cooked vegetables to keep a difference in texture.

Fixing scorched, salty, or watery bagna cauda

Scorched garlic is the one mistake you cannot undo. Once it turns brown, the bitterness stays, so take out the scorched parts, and if it is still bitter, make a new batch of garlic in a separate pot over low heat. Since scorching cannot be undone, lowering the heat is the best prevention. If pieces of anchovy remain, resist turning up the heat; crush them with a wooden spoon and keep going over low heat.

Separated oil is normal, since bagna cauda is a flowing sauce, so just stir gently before serving. If the flavor is too strong, add warmed olive oil a little at a time. If it is too salty, add no salt and serve more vegetables.

A comparison of browned burnt garlic and a smoothly melted bagna cauda without scorching
Compare the color of the garlic and the fluidity of the sauce, and finish without scorching
Condition What is happening How to fix
Garlic is brown and bitter Heat is too high and it fried in the oil Remove the brown parts. If bitterness remains, make new garlic in a separate pot, and do not mix in the scorched sauce
Anchovy pieces remain Heating was short, or the pieces were large Do not raise the heat; crush with a wooden spoon and heat in 5-minute steps
Oil looks like it is floating The sauce has cooled, or the ingredients have little moisture Warm it over low heat before serving and stir slowly. Do not thin it with a lot of water
Too salty Anchovy was not desalted enough, or salt was added Add no salt; add a little unsalted vegetables and olive oil
Garlic is too sharp Preparation was short, finished before it softened If it is not scorched, soften it over very low heat. Next time use the milk soak
Vegetables release water Boiled vegetables were stacked into the hot sauce Drain the vegetables well and let them cool before putting them on the plate. Do not return water to the sauce
Cardoon is hard Strings remained, or cooking time was short Remove the strings again and boil more. Do not make people chew the fibers
Tip

In the finished sauce, the garlic crushes under a wooden spoon, no pieces of anchovy can be seen, and it flows slowly when you tilt the spoon. A burnt smell, smoke, or boiling bubbles are not signs of completion. When you dip a vegetable, the sauce should cling thinly to the surface and still drip a little onto the plate.

Serving bagna cauda, leftovers, and variations

The crunch of raw celery, carrot, cabbage, and endive, then the sweetness of boiled potato, cardoon, and cauliflower: going back and forth, you end up comparing the seasons of vegetables with one sauce. Young red wine suits this table, especially young Barbera. Don't pile all the vegetables for 4 onto the plate at once; add only as much as the sauce can take without cooling down.

A winter table of four people sharing raw and cooked vegetables around bagna cauda
A table where raw and warm vegetables are dipped in bagna cauda by turns

Leftover sauce can go into spaghetti, polenta, or a fully cooked egg. Wiping the pot with bread is not a traditional finish, so finish the leftovers with egg or polenta. For rice that soaks up a sauce, see risotto, and for another Italian dish built on raw vegetables, try Tuscan panzanella.

Good to know

In Piedmont, the thick sauce left at the bottom of the pot is gathered up with egg, so nothing is wasted. At home, cook the egg until fully set and eat it on the spot.

The basic sauce is complete as it is, but a few variations change its character. Cream and walnut oil soften or deepen it, while pasta and polenta turn it into a different kind of meal.

Variation What changes Taste and when to use
Add walnut oil Replace 1 tbsp (15 ml) of the olive oil Adds toastiness. A small amount is enough at first
Soak garlic in milk Soak peeled garlic for 2 hours and dry it Milder sharpness. Do not put the milk in the sauce
Add a little cream Add 1 to 2 tbsp at the finish Rounder flavor, but the outline of oil and anchovy also weakens
Make it bagna fèrgia Cool the sauce and combine with raw vegetables Nearly a separate dish, as the summer version of Villanova d'Asti
Use with pasta Toss a little with boiled spaghetti and thin with pasta water A plate for days when it is hard to serve vegetables. Taste before adding salt
Serve with polenta Put fried polenta on a separate plate Soaks up the sauce less than bread, and becomes the staple of the table
Finish with egg Add egg at the end of the meal and set it completely Does not waste the sauce at the bottom of the pot. Do not store it

Frequently asked questions

Can I substitute anchovy paste?

You can, and it is convenient because it has no pieces. Saltiness and acidity differ greatly between products, though, so do not use it in the same amount as 5.5 oz (150 g) of fillets. Add it in teaspoon amounts, adding oil little by little, and adjust by tasting. For melting at low temperature, salt-cured or oil-packed fillets are still the closest match.

Can I make the garlic smell milder?

Soaking it in milk for 2 hours and wiping it dry reduces the sharpness. Using less garlic also works, but the sauce becomes lighter in body. Do not make up for that by adding more anchovy.

Can I serve all the vegetables raw?

You can. Mixing in cooked vegetables such as potato, cardoon, onion, beet, and cauliflower gives the table more range. Drain boiled vegetables well so their moisture does not get into the sauce, and slice hard vegetables thin or cook them before serving.

Can I eat leftover sauce the next day?

Warm only what you will eat, and move the rest into a shallow clean container. Refrigerate it within 2 hours of cooking. Do not store it at room temperature, either bottled or with garlic left submerged in oil. Reheat it thoroughly before eating, and do not eat it if the smell or appearance is off. Wash the ingredients well before use.

Is it wrong to serve bread?

Traditionally, bread is avoided as a dipper because it soaks up too much sauce; the vegetables are the center of the meal. A little bread on a separate plate is fine. Just don't use so much that it drinks up everyone's sauce.

Sources