Goulash (Gulyás): Hungary's Paprika and Beef Soup

Hungarian goulash in an earthenware pot: chunks of beef in a red paprika broth, garnished with parsley and paprika
Prep
20 min
Cook
2 hr
Total
2 hr 20 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Hungarian

A complete recipe for gulyás, Hungary's national dish. How to use paprika, the heat trick that keeps it from scorching, how to cook the onions down, and how to make csipetke dumplings, all with ingredients you can find in an ordinary grocery store.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Cook the onions

15 min

Step 1: cooking the chopped onions in lard in a heavy pot
Melt 2 tbsp lard over medium heat, add the 3 chopped onions, and cook over medium-low heat for 15 minutes until golden

Melt 2 tbsp lard (or vegetable oil) in a heavy pot over medium heat and add the 3 finely chopped onions. Cook slowly over medium-low heat for 15 minutes, until golden.

The basis of Hungarian cooking is "don't be stingy with the onions." The amount of onion sets the backbone of the flavor, as in the oil-free dry sauté of zigni (in Japanese), though less intensely. The onions melt into the sauce and give it body and sweetness.

STEP22 / 7

Add the paprika

30 sec

Onions and beef being cooked with paprika in a pot
Take the pot off the heat, add the paprika, stir it in with the residual heat, then add the beef

Take the pot off the heat, add 3 tbsp paprika and, with a wooden spoon, turn it quickly from the bottom for just 30 seconds. Stop when the surface of the onions is an even red-orange and no dry, powdery patches are left.

Why the paprika goes in off the heat

Paprika scorches easily, and scorched paprika turns bitter. This is the number one cause of failed goulash. Just 30 seconds of stirring in the residual heat of the pot is enough to pass the color and aroma of the paprika to the onions. Never add paprika while the pot is still over high heat.

STEP33 / 7

Brown the beef

3–4 min

Step 3: browning the beef with the paprika onions
Return to medium heat and add the beef. Cook 3–4 minutes until browned on all sides and coated in paprika

Return the pot to medium heat and add the beef, cut into 1 inches (3 cm) cubes. Cook for 3–4 minutes, until browned all over. The beef becomes coated in paprika and turns a vivid orange.

STEP44 / 7

Add the aromatics

30 sec

Step 4: adding minced garlic and crushed caraway seeds
Add the garlic and crushed caraway and cook 30 seconds; the caraway adds depth to the goulash

Lower the heat to medium-low and add the minced garlic and the lightly crushed caraway seeds. Cook for 30 seconds. When the garlic turns whitish and the fresh aroma of the caraway rises, move on. If you can't find caraway, look in import food shops, specialty spice shops or online. If you substitute cumin, use the same amount.

STEP55 / 7

Add the water and simmer

60–90 min

Step 5: simmering the goulash with water and tomato
Add 1.2 L water and the tomato, boil once, skim, then cover and simmer on low for 60–90 minutes

Add the 1.25 quarts (1.2 L) water and the tomato, bring to a boil once, skim off the scum and reduce to low heat. Keep it at a gentle simmer, one small bubble rising every second or two, and cover and simmer for 60–90 minutes. Stir once from the bottom every 30 minutes. You can move on when the onions and paprika have melted into the soup, a fork slides easily into the beef, the soup is clear and red, and a thin ring of oil floats on the surface.

Goulash is a dish you can leave alone and peek at only now and then. Stir once every 30 minutes, and add water only if it has reduced too much. When the beef falls apart easily with a fork, move on.

STEP66 / 7

Simmer the vegetables

20–30 min

Step 6: adding potatoes, carrot and bell peppers and simmering with the lid on
Add the potatoes, carrot and bell peppers and simmer covered for 20–30 minutes until a skewer slides into the potatoes

Add the potatoes, carrot and bell peppers, cover and keep it on low heat for 20–30 minutes. It's done when a bamboo skewer slides easily into the potatoes and the corners of the carrot have softened slightly. Wait until the vegetables have settled into the soup, and shake the pot once, gently, to keep the potatoes from breaking up.

STEP77 / 7

Adjust the seasoning

5 min

Step 7: seasoning and adjusting the consistency
Season with salt and pepper. Add water if too strong; if too thin, simmer uncovered for 5 minutes

Season with salt and black pepper. The finished dish should be a soup. If it's too strong, add water; if it's too thin, remove the lid and simmer over low heat for 5 minutes, until the surface bubbles and the broth regains a little body.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Main ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Beef (shank, or cubed stewing beef) 500 g Cut into 3 cm (about 1 in) cubes. Shank is best (about 1 lb)
Onions 3 large, finely chopped The foundation of goulash. Don't skimp
Potatoes 2 medium (2 cm cubes) A waxy variety holds its shape best (2 cm is about 3/4 in)
Carrot 1 (1 cm cubes) 1 cm is about 1/2 in
Bell peppers (red and yellow) 1 each (2 cm cubes) Green bell pepper can substitute
Tomato 1 medium, roughly chopped Or 100 g canned tomatoes
Garlic 3 cloves, minced —
Water 1.2 L Beef bone stock is even better (about 5 cups)
Salt 2 tsp Adjust to taste
0 / 0

Bundles of red paprika hang in bright strings from the ceiling of Budapest's Central Market, and beneath them an older woman stirs a pot brimming with something red. The rich smell of paprika drifts across the vast two-story hall, and passing tourists stop in their tracks. That pot is gulyás (goulash), the dish you can't talk about Hungarian cooking without. Beef, onions and potatoes simmer in Hungarian paprika until the broth turns deep red, sweet from the onions and warm with spice.

What Hungarian gulyás is

Outside Hungary, goulash is often described as "beef stew," but the real thing is a soup: beef, onions and potatoes in a paprika broth, with the quality and quantity of the paprika deciding the flavor. The Hungarian word gulyás means "herdsman," and the dish began as a plain pot cooked at camp by cattle herders on the great plain (the puszta). Hungarians have their own names for the close relatives. A stew-like version with little liquid is pörkölt, and one finished with sour cream is paprikás.

Germany's Gulasch, Austria's Wiener Gulasch and the Czech guláš all derive from Hungarian gulyás, but they are different dishes. Much as borscht (in Japanese) differs between Ukraine and Russia, goulash looks completely different in Hungary and in its neighboring countries.

History of goulash

The story goes back to the nomadic life of the Magyars on the puszta in the 9th century. The herdsmen stewed dried meat and onions in a pot and carried it as portable food, and that original goulash contained no paprika at all.

Paprika came to Hungary in the 16th century, during Ottoman rule. At first it was grown as an ornamental plant, and it only found its way into cooking in the late 18th century. When large-scale cultivation began around Szeged in the 19th century, goulash became the red soup we know today. It later spread across Central Europe, and while other countries turned it into a stew, Hungary kept eating it as a soup.

Production still centers on two cities, Szeged and Kalocsa. Every autumn, bundles of paprika are hung up to dry all over town, an iconic seasonal sight in Hungary. At home, cooks often make goulash in a big pot for the weekend table.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Paprika and spices

Spice Amount Notes
Hungarian sweet paprika 3 tbsp Don't skimp. It is the star
Caraway seeds 1 tsp Lightly crush in a mortar. Cumin can substitute
Black pepper A little —
Lard (or vegetable oil) 2 tbsp Lard is traditional. Butter also works
Choosing paprika makes or breaks the dish

In goulash, paprika matters more than curry powder does in curry. 3 tbsp is the minimum.

Ordinary supermarket paprika powder will work, but Hungarian édes (sweet) paprika is on another level for aroma and color. Look for it at import food shops or online.

Various kinds of paprika: sweet paprika powder and dried paprika in wooden bowls
Paprika is the life of goulash. Use sweet (édes) as the base and blend in a little hot (erős) for depth

Choosing beef and paprika for goulash

You don't need special equipment. If you get two things right, beef shank and Hungarian paprika, an ordinary pot can get you quite close to the real flavor.

Hungarian paprika is graded into eight levels, from sweet (édes) to hot (erős), and each grade has its uses. For goulash, the usual approach is to use sweet (édes) as the base and add a little hot (erős).



How to make csipetke (pinched dumplings)

Authentic goulash is traditionally served with small pinched dumplings called csipetke. They are nearly the same as Japanese suiton, and they add body and substance to the soup.

Ingredients

  • 100 g cake flour or all-purpose flour
  • 1 egg
  • A pinch of salt

Method

  • Put the flour, egg and salt in a bowl and knead for about 3 minutes into a dough firmer than an earlobe.
  • Rest the dough for 5 minutes.
  • Ten minutes before the goulash is done, pinch the dough with your fingertips into 0.5 inches (1 cm) pieces and drop them into the gently bubbling pot.
  • Simmer on low heat for 4–5 minutes, until the csipetke float and no floury taste remains at the center.
Csipetke substitutes

If dumplings feel like too much work, you can substitute:

  • Dried pasta (penne or fusilli): add it at the end of the simmering and boil it in the pot
  • Extra potatoes: more potatoes give a similar satisfying feel
  • Bread: serve Hungarian white bread alongside and dip it in the soup
Goulash in a soup bowl: beef, paprika and parsley floating in the red soup, with bread on the side
Real goulash is a soup. Eating it with bread is the classic Hungarian style

Goulash mistakes and fixes

Top 4 common mistakes

Because the steps are simple, how you handle the paprika changes the flavor enormously.

The paprika scorches and turns bitter

This is the most fatal mistake. Scorched paprika tastes bitter, the color goes dark, and there's no fixing it afterward. So this is the one rule to follow without exception: always add the paprika off the heat.

The flavor is flat

The usual cause is too little paprika. 3 tbsp is the minimum, and going up to 4 tbsp is fine if you like it stronger. Without enough salt the sweetness of the paprika doesn't come forward either, so taste as you season.

The soup is cloudy

Broken-down potatoes are the culprit. Use a waxy variety and add them for the last 20 minutes of simmering. A hard boil also clouds the soup, so keep it at a slow, gentle simmer on low heat.

The beef is tough

It simply wasn't simmered long enough. Shank needs at least 90 minutes, or use a pressure cooker (see the FAQ). As with tagine (in Japanese), low heat and patience win.

Close-up of goulash: tender beef and the texture of the paprika sauce
Finished goulash. The beef is tender enough to fall apart with a fork, and the red of the paprika is beautiful

Serving and storing goulash

Serve goulash in deep soup bowls with chopped parsley scattered on top, and set out a few things alongside:

  • Bread: Hungarian white bread (fehér kenyér) is the standard. A baguette can substitute
  • Sour cream: put it on the table and let everyone add as much as they like. The tang sets off the sweetness of the paprika
  • Pickled hot green peppers: an essential accompaniment in Hungarian cooking. Any tangy pickled pepper gives a similar feel
The whole goulash spread: red stew in a soup bowl, with a small dish of paprika powder and bread alongside
Goulash at the table, with paprika powder, bread and chile alongside. Everyone adds their own sour cream

For lunch the next day or as a side, Rakott krumpli (in Japanese), a baked dish of layered potato, egg and sour cream, is another Hungarian home-style dish that fits right in. And if you want to keep cooking in this direction, Carbonnade (in Japanese), Waterzooi (in Japanese) and Pašticada (in Japanese) share many of the same ingredients and aromas. After a stew, Kūčiukai (in Japanese), a light baked sweet, shows you another side of an Eastern European winter table.

Storing goulash

Like zigni (in Japanese), goulash tastes better the next day. The paprika spreads through the whole pot, and the potatoes soak up the sauce.

Storage How long Tips
Refrigerator 2–3 days Cool a little, store airtight. Reheat in a pot until it boils all the way through
Freezer About 1 month Deal with the potatoes first (see tip below)
Make-ahead uses — Pasta sauce, risotto stock or pie filling
Freezing tip

Potatoes tend to turn spongy when frozen. Either mash them with a masher and melt them into the sauce before freezing, or freeze the goulash without potatoes and add fresh ones when you reheat it.


Goulash variations

Paprikás csirke (chicken paprikash)

Use bone-in chicken thighs instead of beef and finish by stirring sour cream into the sauce. In Hungary "paprikás" usually means this chicken version, classically paired with small egg dumplings called nokedli. It's creamier than goulash and popular with children.

Pörkölt

In Hungarian, the soup in this recipe is called gulyásleves, "goulash soup." For something different, cut back the potatoes and water, use more onion and simmer until little liquid is left and you get something close to pörkölt. Serve it with nokedli or boiled potatoes.

Székely goulash (with sauerkraut)

This Transylvanian variation simmers pork with sauerkraut, and the sour cabbage plays against the sweetness of the paprika. Like burek (in Japanese), it shows how much Balkan and Central European dishes shift from region to region.

Goulash pasta

Reduce the sauce until thick and toss it with fusilli or penne, then pile on plenty of cheese for an Italian-Hungarian crossover. You can also chop the pasta and stir-fry it in goulash sauce, like kottu.

Goulash served with pasta: red sauce and beef with fusilli on a white plate
Goulash sauce also goes well with pasta. Fusilli or penne makes a rich paprika pasta sauce

Japanese-style goulash (nikujaga-style)

"Paprika nikujaga" is seasoned with 2 tbsp paprika powder, 1 tbsp mirin and 1 tbsp soy sauce. Use more potatoes and carrots and cook off most of the liquid, and it sits naturally on a Japanese table.


Goulash nutrition (per serving, from the 4-serving recipe)

Nutrient Amount
Energy About 440 kcal
Protein About 1 oz (29 g)
Fat About 14 g
Carbohydrate About 1.5 oz (41 g)
Fiber About 6 g
Salt equivalent About 3.0 g

One bowl gives you the protein and iron of beef and the potassium of potatoes and vegetables. The figures are estimates, and the salt equivalent depends on how much salt you use.


Frequently asked questions

Q1. What is the difference between goulash and beef stew?

Beef stew is thickened with roux or demi-glace. Goulash is a soup with paprika as the star, and Hungarian goulash contains no ketchup, flour or wine. Paprika, onions, meat and water: that simplicity is the whole point.

Q2. Which paprika powder should I buy?

Ideally Hungarian édes (sweet) paprika, from an import food shop or online. Ordinary supermarket paprika works too, but the color and aroma are weaker.

Q3. Can I leave out the caraway seeds?

You can, but you lose a lot of the characteristic Hungarian flavor. If you can't find them, substitute 1 tsp cumin seeds.

Q4. Is sour cream required?

It doesn't go into the goulash itself; in Hungary each person spoons some on at the table. Plain yogurt can substitute. As with moussaka (in Japanese), a little dairy lifts the finished dish.

Q5. Can I save time with a pressure cooker?

Yes. Do the onion and paprika steps as usual, then add the meat and water and cook for 25 minutes under pressure followed by a natural release. Release the pressure before adding the potatoes and vegetables, and simmer them without the lid for 20 minutes. It's ready in about 1 hour in total.

Q6. Can I serve it with pierogi (in Japanese)?

Pierogi are Polish, so it's not a standard pairing in Hungary. Still, potato-and-cheese pierogi on the side make a filling menu that doubles as the starch.


Sources