Csirke Paprikás: Hungarian Paprika Chicken with Sour Cream

Chicken stewed in a red paprika sauce with a spoonful of sour cream, served with small nokedli dumplings
Prep
15 min
Cook
55 min
Total
1 hr 10 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Hungarian

A recipe for Hungarian csirke paprikás (paprikás csirke) made with bone-in chicken, onions, sweet paprika, and sour cream. It covers keeping the paprika from scorching, finishing the cream without splitting it, making the nokedli dumplings, and checking that the chicken is cooked through.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Sweat the onions in lard

about 10 min

Sweating finely chopped onions in a heavy pot until translucent
Sweat over low heat without browning, until translucent and glossy

Melt 2 tbsp lard in a heavy pot over low heat, add the finely chopped onions, and sprinkle with 3/4 tsp salt. Cover and cook for about 10 minutes, stirring occasionally. When the onions turn translucent and glossy and have reduced to about half their volume, they are ready. Do not brown them. If the edges start to turn brown, lower the heat further and add 1 tbsp water to cool the pot.

STEP22 / 6

Take the pot off the heat and melt in the paprika

about 3 min

Stirring paprika into the onions off the heat, then adding tomato and water
Always add the paprika off the heat and add liquid right away

Take the pot off the heat, add 2 tbsp paprika, and stir for about 10 seconds, until the red color has spread through the onions and the oil and paprika are smoothly combined. Immediately add the tomato and ½ cup (120 ml) water. Paprika scorches the moment it hits hot oil directly, and the sauce turns bitter. Add it off the heat, and add liquid right away. Once the liquid is in, return the pot to low heat and warm it for 2–3 minutes until it begins to bubble.

STEP33 / 6

Add the chicken, cover, and simmer

about 30 min

Simmering bone-in chicken in red paprika sauce, covered, over low heat
Keep the heat low enough that the sauce barely trembles, and check the bottom of the pot from time to time

Place the chicken in the pot skin side down and sprinkle with the remaining 3/4 tsp salt. Cover and simmer over low heat for about 30 minutes. Every few minutes, lift the lid and check the bottom of the pot; if the sauce has reduced and looks about to stick, add 2 tbsp water at a time. Keep enough liquid to come about halfway up the meat, and cook at a heat where the surface barely trembles, so the meat does not toughen. Turn the pieces over once partway through.

STEP44 / 6

Add the green pepper and finish simmering

about 10 min

Adding pepper rings to the chicken stew whose sauce has reduced slightly
Remove the lid to reduce the sauce a little, and check the chicken's internal temperature

Remove the lid, add the pepper rings, and simmer about 10 minutes more. With the lid off, excess liquid evaporates and the sauce begins to thicken. It is done when the pepper is soft and the meat around the bones pulls apart with chopsticks or a fork. Insert a thermometer into the thickest part and confirm that the center has been held at 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute.

STEP55 / 6

Boil the nokedli

about 10 min

Dropping nokedli batter into boiling water and lifting out the dumplings that float
Lift out 30 seconds after they float and toss with butter

Make the nokedli while the chicken simmers. In a bowl, mix 5 oz (140 g) bread flour and 1/4 tsp salt, add the 2 eggs and 2 tbsp sour cream, and mix. Add the milk 1 tbsp at a time until no dry flour remains and the batter is smooth and sticky. A good guide is a batter that falls from a spatula in a slow ribbon. If you have time, rest it for 30 minutes for a softer bite. Bring plenty of salted water to a boil over high heat, and keeping it at a rolling boil, push the batter a little at a time through a spätzle maker or a large-holed grater. Once the dumplings float, cook them about 30 seconds more, lift them out with a skimmer, and toss with 10 g butter.

STEP66 / 6

Bind the sauce with sour cream

about 2 min

Adding the sour cream and flour mixture to the sauce and binding it over low heat
Thin the cream with hot sauce before returning it, and thicken without boiling

Take out the chicken and set it on a plate. In a small bowl, whisk 2 tbsp sour cream, 1 tbsp flour, and 2 tbsp heavy cream until smooth, then thin it with about half a ladle of the hot sauce from the pot. Pour this back into the pot and warm over low heat for 1–2 minutes, stirring, until the sauce thickens. Do not let it boil. Spoon the sauce over the chicken and, if you like, add sour cream for serving and a little paprika on top.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Stew

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bone-in chicken thighs (skin on) 2.25 lb (1 kg) Cut into pieces. You can mix in drumsticks. With boneless thighs, use 1.75 lb (800 g)
Onions 2 large Finely chopped
Lard 2 tbsp Neutral oil works
Paprika (sweet) 2 tbsp Up to 3 tbsp for stronger color and aroma
Salt 1 1/2 tsp Used in two halves
Tomato 1 Roughly chopped. Peel it by blanching if the skin bothers you
Green pepper 1 Cut into rings. Stands in for the pale green Hungarian pepper. 1/2 yellow bell pepper also works
Water ½ cup (120 ml) Add a little at a time if it reduces too far
2 / 3

Cream finish

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Sour cream 2 tbsp Keep about 4 tbsp more aside for serving
Flour 1 tbsp All-purpose
Heavy cream 2 tbsp Use one with a high milk-fat content
3 / 3

Nokedli (dumplings to serve alongside)

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bread flour 5 oz (140 g) All-purpose also works
Salt 1/4 tsp Salt for the cooking water is separate
Eggs 2 Large
Sour cream 2 tbsp Plain yogurt can stand in
Milk 2 tbsp Adjust to the firmness of the batter
Butter 10 g Tossed with the cooked dumplings to keep them from sticking. Olive oil is fine
0 / 0

Midday in Budapest. On street corners you still find the old-fashioned canteens called étkezde, and one of their standard plates is chicken stewed in a red sauce: paprikás csirke, also called csirkepaprikás. Both names mean "chicken cooked with paprika." Onions sweat gently in lard, the pot comes off the heat so the paprika can melt into the fat, and the chicken simmers quietly. A spoonful of sour cream at the end turns the vivid red into a soft salmon color, and a red sauce brought together with cream is exactly what sets it apart from goulash, the other great dish of paprika country.

Everything you need is in an ordinary supermarket. There are only two tricky parts: don't scorch the paprika, and don't let the sour cream boil and split. Get those right and this is about an hour of simmering in a home pot.

The story of csirke paprikás

A pot of paprika chicken on a Hungarian family table

From the Great Plain to the town canteen

On the Alföld, the Great Plain that spreads across eastern Hungary, 19th-century farmers stewed beef and mutton with onions and paprika. Chicken gradually joined them, and poultry stews became widespread. In 1840s Hatvan, serf households ate "pörkölt hús" and "paprikás hús" made with beef, mutton, and chicken as everyday food.

The oldest written recipe dates from 1830, from the kitchen of Archduke Joseph's court. It fries onion, paprika, and allspice in butter or lard, adds the chicken, and thickens the sauce with flour, stock, and sour cream, which is almost exactly how it's made today. In 1834 an innkeeper in Nyíregyháza listed "Paprikás Tsirke" at 18 krajcár, a little more than the 15 krajcár he charged for the meat stew "paprikás hús."

Did you know?

Paprika has many old names: "Turkish pepper" (törökbors), "red pepper" (vörösbors), "Spanish pepper" (spanyol bors), and more. All of them mean "a pepper that came from somewhere else." The route by which New World chilies traveled around Europe and finally reached Hungary survives in the names.

Sour cream (tejföl in Hungarian) also said something about a dish's standing. A stew finished with it had risen from the peasant's pot to the kitchens of the town middle class, and from there it spread back to ordinary tables. By the end of the 19th century it was on restaurant menus and travelers to Hungary were recommending it. It even turns up in an 1897 novel: on his way to Transylvania, Jonathan Harker eats "paprika hendl," likes it, and jots down a note to get the recipe for his fiancée Mina.

Paprikás and pörkölt

A chicken sauce finished with paprika and sour cream, next to a paprika stew made without cream

Hungarian cooking has four paprika-based stews: gulyás, pörkölt, tokány, and paprikás. Paprikás and pörkölt are very close, with one difference. Paprikás is finished with sweet cream or sour cream, while no cream of any kind goes into pörkölt (or gulyás).

The choice of meat follows from that. Veal and chicken suit paprikás, while beef, mutton, game, goose, duck, and pork usually go into pörkölt; the mildness of cream is paired with lean, delicate meats, and fattier or stronger-flavored ones are cooked without it. Mushrooms or fish are sometimes stewed the paprikás way too.

Did you know?

If you save the cooking liquid from a paprikás, the next day it can turn into Hortobágyi palacsinta. Crêpes are rolled around a meat filling and topped with the paprikás sauce with a little more sour cream added.

Paprikás beyond Hungary

Paprika chicken with regional sides such as polenta, potatoes, and dumplings

The dish has traveled, changing as it went. In Romania it is traditionally served with mămăligă, a cornmeal porridge, and in Czechia often with knedlíky, bread-style dumplings. It also became a home dish of the Danube Swabians, the German-speaking emigrants who lived along the Danube.

In Jewish households in Hungary and Czechoslovakia it was passed down as a Sabbath dish. Because dietary law forbids eating meat and dairy together, many cooks leave out the sour cream and bring the sauce together with tomato instead. Bulgarian paprikash (паприкаш) is a different dish altogether, with less paprika and diced sweet peppers in the lead.

Tip

To make it without dairy, use 2 tomatoes, skip the cream finish, and after adding the pepper simmer about 10 minutes longer, which thickens the sauce.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Bone-in chicken, onions, paprika, tomato, green pepper, sour cream, and lard laid out

This sauce is made almost entirely of paprika flavor. Look for sweet paprika without heat; most ground paprika sold in supermarkets is sweet and can be used as is. If you can find Hungarian sweet paprika (édesnemes), the color and aroma go deeper still. Whether to mix in a little hot paprika (csípős) is up to you. One thing to watch: paprika loses its aroma once it has been open a while. If your jar has turned brownish at the back of the shelf, replacing it makes a clear difference in the result.

Tip

Cooking the chicken with the skin on gives the sauce depth and richness. If you dislike the skin, cook it on and remove it when serving. If you cannot find bone-in meat, use 1.75 lb (800 g) of boneless thigh and shorten the simmering time by about 5 minutes.

Allergy notes

This dish contains milk (sour cream, heavy cream, butter, milk), wheat (flour, bread flour), and egg (the nokedli). If you are serving someone with an allergy, check the relevant ingredients.


How to make csirke paprikás

Prep takes about 15 minutes: chop the onions, cut the tomato and pepper, and mix the nokedli batter. The stew takes about 55 minutes counted from sweating the onions. Boil the nokedli while the chicken simmers and the whole meal is ready in about 1 hour 10 minutes.

Cook the chicken through

Cook the chicken until the center has been held at 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute. This is what prevents Campylobacter food poisoning. The meat around the bone is the slowest to cook, so do not judge by color; check with a thermometer. Wash the cutting board and knife used for raw chicken before using them on other foods.

Tip

If the cream splits and the sauce turns speckled and grainy, take the pot off the heat, stir in 1 tbsp heavy cream, and mix quickly. Boiling is the main cause of splitting, so after adding the cream, go no further than a few small bubbles at the edge of the pot.

Tip

If the nokedli batter is too stiff, it will not pass through the holes of the grater. If it is too loose, it falls apart in the water, so do not add the milk all at once; add 1 tbsp at a time and check. You can also spread the batter on a wooden board and scrape it into the water bit by bit with a knife.

Serving csirke paprikás

Csirke paprikás and nokedli on a plate with a cucumber salad
Plate the chicken and nokedli, pour plenty of sauce over, and add sour cream

In Hungary, csirke paprikás almost always comes with nokedli. Also called galuska, these are small egg dumplings related to German spätzle, only shorter and stubbier, and they soak up sauce beautifully. Put the chicken on one half of the plate and the nokedli on the other, then ladle plenty of sauce over everything.

A sweet-and-sour cucumber salad is the classic side, its vinegar cleaning the palate after the rich sauce. On days when you don't have time for nokedli, boiled potatoes sprinkled with parsley, soft polenta, or store-bought egg-based short pasta carry the sauce just as well.

Leftover sauce can become Hortobágyi palacsinta, or you can toss it with nokedli for a light lunch. Try it alongside goulash, which stews beef with the same paprika, and you'll taste how much the sauce changes depending on whether or not there is cream. Rakott krumpli, baked layers of potatoes and sausage, is another Hungarian home dish built on the same sour cream.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it with chicken breast?

Inserting a thermometer into the thickest part of the chicken to check the internal temperature

You can, but breast meat turns tough more easily than thigh. For boneless breast, cut it into bite-size slices and shorten the simmering in step 3 to about 15 minutes. With any cut, check with a thermometer that the center has been held at 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute.

Can I use hot paprika?

Yes. In Hungary it is made with both sweet and hot paprika. Hot paprika alone gives a strong heat, so start by swapping 1 teaspoon of the 2 tablespoons of sweet paprika for hot and see how you like it.

My sauce split. Can I fix it?

Take it off the heat, add 1 tbsp heavy cream, and mix quickly; sometimes the smoothness comes back. To prevent splitting, whisk the sour cream and flour together first, thin them with a little hot sauce before returning them to the pot, and keep it from boiling afterward.

Can I make it ahead?

Let the stew cool a little, then refrigerate it and eat it soon. Reheat slowly over low heat without letting the cream sauce boil hard, and make sure the chicken is thoroughly heated through to the center before eating.

Sources