Kartoffelsalat: Southern German Potato Salad Dressed with Warm Broth

Southern German Kartoffelsalat in a shallow ceramic bowl, the thin potato slices glossy with broth and oil
Cuisine
German

How to make a southern German Kartoffelsalat dressed with hot broth, white wine vinegar and oil instead of mayonnaise, following one Bavarian cook's recipe with its original amounts. Covers how it differs from the mayonnaise style, choosing broth, vinegar and potatoes, salting the cucumber, fixing common problems, and regional variations.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Boil the potatoes

Whole unpeeled potatoes simmering gently in a pot
Boil the potatoes whole in their skins and check with a fork that they are tender but intact

Boil the 4.5 lb (2 kg) of potatoes in their skins in a large pot of water. Don't go by the clock: they are ready when a fork or skewer slides into the center but the potatoes still hold together, not split open.

STEP22 / 6

Peel and let them cool slightly

Peeling boiled potatoes that have cooled just enough to handle
Peel the boiled potatoes and let them cool slightly until they can be handled

Drain the potatoes, peel them, and let them cool a little until you can handle them. They are very hot straight from the pot, so use a clean cloth or heat-resistant gloves to protect your hands while peeling.

STEP33 / 6

Slice them thinly into the bowl

Slicing peeled potatoes into thin rounds beside a mixing bowl
Slice the potatoes thinly and evenly, then layer them into the bowl

Cut the peeled potatoes into thin slices and put them in a large bowl. Aim for even slices so they take up the dressing evenly. If the potatoes are still so hot that they crumble under the knife, give them a little more time to cool first.

STEP44 / 6

Dress with the seasonings, hot broth, vinegar and oil

Pouring hot broth over sliced potatoes in a bowl, with mustard, vinegar and oil nearby
Pour the hot broth over the potato slices along with the vinegar, oil and seasonings

Season the potatoes with salt, pepper, sugar and the sharp mustard, then add the hot broth, white wine vinegar and oil, in any order. Keep back some of the salt for the cucumber in step 5, and if your broth is salty, start with less salt overall. You can also begin at the lower end of the broth range and add the rest if the potatoes take it up. Turn the slices gently from the bottom with a broad spoon so the liquid reaches them without breaking them.

STEP55 / 6

Add the onion and the salted cucumber with its liquid

Folding onion and cucumber into the broth-dressed potatoes with a broad spoon
Add the onion, the salted cucumber and its liquid, and fold gently without breaking the potatoes

Salt the thinly sliced cucumber and let it stand until liquid comes out. Use part of the salt from the ingredient list for this rather than adding extra. Then add the finely chopped onion, the cucumber and all of the liquid the cucumber released to the potatoes. Don't squeeze the cucumber or pour the liquid away. Fold everything together gently with big strokes so the potato slices stay whole.

STEP66 / 6

Finish with chives and adjust the seasoning

Scattering chopped chives over Kartoffelsalat as the final step
Finish with fresh chives, then taste and adjust

Scatter fresh chopped chives over the salad. Taste, and adjust the salt and sourness within the listed amounts. You can let the flavors settle before eating if you like.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Notes
Potatoes (Kartoffeln) 4.5 lb (2 kg) Any variety
Onion (Zwiebel) 1 Finely chopped
Salt (Salz) 1½–2 EL Part of this total is used to salt the cucumber
Pepper (Pfeffer) to taste Seasoning
Sugar (Zucker) 1 EL
Hot Tafelspitz broth (heiße Tafelspitzbrühe) 400–500 ml Beef broth from boiled Tafelspitz; vegetable or beef broth can replace it
Sharp mustard (scharfer Senf) 1 EL
White wine vinegar (Weißweinessig) ½ cup (125 ml) 5% acidity recommended
Oil (Öl) ¼ cup (62.5 ml) Any type
Cucumber (Salatgurke) 1 Thinly sliced
Chives (Schnittlauch) to finish Fresh, scattered at the end; no amount given
0 / 0

Hot broth goes over freshly sliced boiled potatoes, and the cut surfaces drink it in and begin to shine. Vinegar adds a clean sourness, a little oil softens it, and thin slices of cucumber and fresh chives finish the bowl. This is Kartoffelsalat as southern Germany makes it: warm and tangy, with the potato slices kept whole and soaked through instead of coated in a creamy dressing.

Kartoffelsalat Across Germany

Many people outside Germany picture "German potato salad" as one fixed dish. In fact, Kartoffelsalat (Kartoffel, potato, plus Salat, salad) has no single national recipe. The same name covers more than one salad. In broad strokes, the north is known for mayonnaise-based versions, while the south dresses its potatoes with broth, vinegar and oil. The south also has its own words for the dish, such as Erdäpfelsalat, along with Härdöpfelsalat in Swabian and Swiss usage.

Treat that north–south split as a rough guide. Recipes differ from family to family even within one region. What matters in your kitchen is the direction of the flavor. Mayonnaise gives a cold, emulsified richness. In this style, warm broth and vinegar soak into the potatoes, and oil adds roundness.

The version here includes cucumber, chives, sugar and sharp mustard alongside the broth, vinegar and oil. Other southern recipes leave some of these out.

Ingredients (for 4.5 lb (2 kg) of potatoes)

Potatoes, onion, cucumber, chives, broth, white wine vinegar, mustard, oil, salt, pepper and sugar for Kartoffelsalat laid out on a counter
The full set for the broth-dressed version: no mayonnaise, no extra ingredients

These amounts make one batch with 4.5 lb (2 kg) of potatoes. "EL" is the German abbreviation for a tablespoon. The volumes 1/8 l and 1/16 l are shown in milliliters as a straight conversion.

Allergens and labels

This salad contains mustard. Store-bought broths and bouillon can contain wheat, soy, milk, celery or other allergens, so check the label of the one you use. Tafelspitz broth and beef broth are meat-based; vegetable broth is another option.

Equipment

  • A large pot for boiling the potatoes
  • A knife and cutting board
  • A large mixing bowl
  • A small bowl for salting the cucumber
  • A broad spoon or spatula for folding
  • A clean cloth or heat-resistant gloves for handling hot potatoes

Choosing Ingredients for Kartoffelsalat

Broth. The first choice is hot broth from Tafelspitz, the Austrian and Bavarian boiled beef dish. Vegetable or beef broth works in its place. Beef broth brings meatier depth, and vegetable broth keeps the salad free of animal products. Many prepared broths are already salted, so taste yours before seasoning and start the salt at the low end of the range.

White wine vinegar. Use white wine vinegar at 5% acidity, because a 10% vinegar is too sharp for this salad. Another vinegar can stand in if you can't find white wine vinegar, but its acidity and aroma will differ. Check the label, and never swap a stronger vinegar in at the same amount.

Potatoes. Choose a firmer, less floury potato so the slices stay whole. Very floury potatoes break up when you mix in the dressing.

Oil. Any type works. A neutral salad oil keeps the flavor close to the classic version, while olive oil will noticeably change the aroma.

Mustard. Look for a prepared mustard labeled sharp or hot (scharf). A mustard with a very different flavor will shift the balance of the dressing.

Chives. The green tops of scallions can stand in if fresh chives are hard to find. The aroma will be different.

Method: Boil, Slice, Dress, Then Add Cucumber and Chives

Before you start

Judge by the state of the potatoes rather than the clock. Seasoning can be adjusted at the end within the listed ranges.

Fixing Common Kartoffelsalat Problems

Problem Possible causes What to do
Potatoes break apart Floury potatoes, overcooking, uneven slices, mixing too hard Fold from the bottom with a broad spoon instead of stirring. Next time, stop boiling while the potatoes still hold together, and consider a firmer potato
The salad is watery Liquid from the broth and cucumber Start at the lower end of the 400 ml–2 cups (500 ml) broth range and add more only if the potatoes absorb it
The sourness is too sharp Vinegar stronger than 5% Check the label and use 5% vinegar
Too salty Salty broth on top of the full salt amount Taste the broth first, start the salt at the low end, and remember that some of it goes to the cucumber

Serving, Storing and Variations

Warm southern German Kartoffelsalat served beside a grilled sausage
A broth-dressed Kartoffelsalat as a side to grilled sausage

Kartoffelsalat is commonly eaten alongside sausages, schnitzel and roasted meats. Because it can be made ahead, some families serve it with sausages on Christmas Eve.

Food safety. Even without mayonnaise, this salad contains cooked potatoes, raw cucumber and onion, and possibly meat-based broth. Keep it out of room temperature once it's made.

A Swabian Kartoffelsalat from Albstadt shows how much the dish varies. It is dressed with vinegar and oil, and the ideal texture is schlonzig, a moist, loose consistency. That recipe uses 1 kg of salad potatoes, onion, 2 EL vinegar, 1 Tasse (cup) of hot broth, salt, pepper and 2–3 EL oil. The warm sliced potatoes are mixed gently and left to rest warm, and the hot broth softens the onion's sharpness while it dissolves and spreads the seasoning.

The Tasse has no stated volume, so treat the Albstadt version as its own recipe. Don't convert its amounts or combine them with the recipe above.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to mix the potatoes while they are piping hot?

No. The potatoes are boiled, peeled and cooled slightly before you slice and season them. Only the broth goes in hot.

How long does it keep?

Don't leave the salad out at room temperature.

Sources