Boxty: Irish Potato Pancakes Made with Grated Raw and Mashed Potato

Boxty with golden-browned surfaces stacked on a plate
Cuisine
Irish

How to make pan boxty, the Irish potato cake that brings grated, squeezed raw potato and boiled, mashed potato together with flour, baking soda and buttermilk. Covers the source recipe's amounts, how firm the mixture should be, judging color and doneness in the pan, the regions boxty is tied to, and why its origins remain open.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Boil and mash the first portion of potato

Mashing boiled, softened potatoes in a bowl
Mash the boiled potato before anything else goes into the bowl

Cut the 255g of peeled potato into 1-inch (about 2.5 cm) pieces. Boil in salted water until tender: the potato is ready when a skewer slides into the center of a piece without resistance. Drain and mash all of it.

STEP22 / 7

Grate the second portion finely and squeeze it

Finely grating peeled raw potato
Use the fine side of the grater for the raw potato

Finely grate the other 9 oz (255g) of peeled raw potato. Gather the grated potato in a clean cloth and squeeze out the excess liquid over a bowl. There is no need to weigh the potato again afterward.

Squeezing the liquid from grated raw potato in a clean cloth
Gather the grated potato in a cloth and squeeze out the excess liquid
STEP33 / 7

Combine the two potatoes with the flour, baking soda and salt

Mixing flour, baking soda and salt into the mashed potato and squeezed raw potato
A coarse mixture before any buttermilk goes in

In a large bowl, combine the mashed potato and the squeezed grated potato. Add 2.75 oz (75g) flour, 3g baking soda and 2g salt, and mix until the flour is evenly distributed and you have a coarse, rough mixture.

STEP44 / 7

Add the buttermilk a little at a time

Adding buttermilk a little at a time to form a thick, cohesive mixture
Add buttermilk gradually and stop at a firm, mashed-potato texture

Add the buttermilk gradually, mixing as you go, until the mixture is like firm mashed potatoes. Stop when it reaches that texture, even if some of the ½ cup (125ml) is left. It should stay thick, not loosen into a thin pancake batter.

STEP55 / 7

Heat the pan and fry the first side

Cooking one side of small boxty in a skillet lightly coated with vegetable oil
Preheat the pan, then cook over medium-low until the underside is golden

Heat a heavy skillet over medium-high heat, then brush it lightly with vegetable oil. Drop in a heaped tablespoon of the mixture and spread it with the back of the spoon into a round about 2 inches (about 5 cm) across. Once the pan is preheated, cook over medium-low heat for about 3 minutes; look for the underside turning golden brown before you turn it.

STEP66 / 7

Turn and cook the second side

Turning a browned boxty to cook the other side
Turn once the first side is golden, then brown the second side

Turn each boxty and cook for about another 3 minutes, until the second side is golden brown as well. Check the color on both sides, since the pan and thickness change the timing.

STEP77 / 7

Keep the cooked boxty warm while you fry the rest

STEP 7

Move the cooked boxty to a baking sheet and keep them warm in a 300°F (150°C) oven while you cook the remaining mixture. The oven only holds finished boxty warm. Do not rely on it to cook underdone potato.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

For the mixture

Ingredient Amount Role
Potato, peeled, cut into 1-inch (about 2.5 cm) pieces 255g (9 oz), weighed peeled and raw Boiled until tender, then all of it is mashed
Potato, peeled, for grating 255g (9 oz), weighed peeled and raw Grated finely and squeezed in a cloth to remove excess liquid
All-purpose flour 75g Holds the two potatoes together
Baking soda 3g Leavening. Do not swap for baking powder
Salt (for the mixture) 2g Seasons the mixture
Buttermilk (liquid) up to 125ml Add a little at a time until the mixture is like firm mashed potatoes. Stop there, even if some is left
2 / 2

For boiling and frying

Ingredient Amount Role
Water for boiling as needed For boiling the chopped potato
Salt for the boiling water as needed Separate from the 2g of salt for the mixture
Vegetable oil a thin coating for the pan Brushed onto the skillet for frying
0 / 0

Grated raw potato goes into a clean cloth and gets squeezed until the pale liquid runs out, while potato boiled until tender waits in the bowl beside it, already mashed. The two meet in the same bowl with flour, baking soda and salt, and a little buttermilk pulls everything into a thick, rough mixture. Spooned into a hot, lightly oiled pan, it starts out soft and turns brown on the underside before you flip it. This is boxty, an Irish potato dish, and this version is a pan boxty: mashed and grated raw potato, bound with buttermilk and fried in a skillet.

Boxty in Ireland

Regions and Styles

Boxty is especially associated with the north midlands, north Connacht and southern Ulster, with Sligo, Mayo, Leitrim and Cavan named in particular. Other accounts point to the north-west, including Leitrim, Cavan, north Longford, Mayo and Fermanagh, so the lists overlap and there is no single fixed boundary. For more dishes from the same country, see Irish recipes.

The dish comes in more than one form: boiled, baked and pan. Boiled boxty is better known in Cavan and Fermanagh. The versions differ, but they share finely grated raw potato and frying.

In the north-west, boxty is served in shops and restaurants. It is also part of a traditional breakfast, where it often appears as a pancake-style dish.

Origins and Other Names

Where boxty began is not settled. The earliest written reference is from 1828, and the idea that it was born as a famine dish is disputed. A folklore account from Kilkerrin, County Galway describes grating or scraping potatoes and squeezing them, combining them with flour, salt and boiled potatoes, and cooking them on a griddle. That is one person's recollection, though, and it doesn't show that boxty started in the Famine. You may also hear it called rasp or stampaí.

Ingredients: Two Portions of Raw Potato, One Firm Mixture

Raw potatoes for boiling and for grating, flour, baking soda, salt, liquid buttermilk, vegetable oil and water for boiling
Two separate portions of peeled raw potato, plus the dough salt kept apart from the salt for the boiling water

Each potato portion is 9 ounces (255g), weighed peeled and raw: one is chopped and boiled, and all of it is mashed and used; the other is weighed before grating and squeezing. Don't top up or trim the boiled potato to bring it back to 255g, and don't reweigh the grated potato after squeezing.

Allergens

This recipe contains wheat (flour) and milk (buttermilk). Check product labels if you are cooking for anyone with allergies.

Equipment

  • Box grater with a fine side
  • Clean cloth or tea towel for squeezing
  • Pot for boiling
  • Potato masher
  • Large mixing bowl
  • Measuring jug
  • Heavy skillet
  • Spatula
  • Baking sheet and oven, for keeping cooked boxty warm

Choosing Flour, Buttermilk and Potatoes for Boxty

Flour. Use all-purpose flour. If it is sold under another name where you live, look for a medium-protein flour; in Japan, for example, that's chūrikiko. Low-protein cake flour won't work in its place.

Baking soda. Use baking soda (bicarbonate of soda). Baking powder is a different product and won't substitute here.

Buttermilk. Use liquid buttermilk. Swapping in 4.5 oz (125g) of buttermilk powder or ½ cup (125ml) of plain milk changes the acidity and texture, so neither works one-for-one. Add the buttermilk gradually, up to ½ cup (125ml), and stop when the texture is right; you may not need all of it.

Potatoes. Any potatoes that are easy to find where you live will do.

Method: Squeeze, Mash, Combine and Fry

Judge by the pan, not only the clock

Cook about 3 minutes per side. Thickness, heat and the pan all change this, so check the color of each side as you go.

Cooking through

Golden color alone does not show the inside is cooked. The grated potato goes into the pan raw, so make sure each boxty is cooked through to the center. For leftovers, divide them into shallow containers to cool quickly, refrigerate promptly and reheat thoroughly.

Fixing Common Boxty Problems

Grated potato varies in how much water it holds, so aim for a firm, mashed-potato texture rather than a set amount of squeezing, and adjust the buttermilk to match. Most other problems come down to heat and size.

Condition Likely cause What to do
The mixture is wet and spreads like batter Too much buttermilk, or the grated potato was not squeezed enough Add buttermilk a little at a time and stop at a firm, mashed-potato texture. Squeeze the grated potato well before mixing
The mixture is dry and crumbly Not enough buttermilk yet Keep adding small amounts, within the ½ cup (125ml), until it holds together
The outside browns before 3 minutes Heat too high, or the pan was not turned down after preheating Cook over medium-low after preheating, and lower the heat further if your pan runs hot
Pale after 3 minutes Heat too low, or a thicker cake Give it more time and judge by color rather than the clock
Brown outside but you are unsure about the center Thicker cakes take longer Keep to a heaped tablespoon and a thin round about 2 inches across, which is also easier to turn, and make sure they are cooked through before serving

Serving Boxty

Warm boxty served on a plate with no accompaniments
Serve the boxty warm on its own, adding sides as you like

Serve the boxty warm. It's good on its own, but since it belongs to the traditional breakfast, bacon, eggs or tomatoes can sit alongside if you like.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should each side cook?

About 3 minutes per side over medium-low heat, after preheating the pan. Pans, heat and thickness all change the timing, so turn when the underside is golden brown and check both sides.

Can I store leftovers?

Divide leftovers into shallow containers so they cool quickly, refrigerate them promptly and reheat them thoroughly.

Sources