Soupe à l'oignon: Paris Halles-Style Onion Soup Gratinée

French onion soup gratinée: a sweet-smelling onion soup topped with bread and Comté and baked until browned
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner to Intermediate
Cuisine
French

How to make soupe à l'oignon gratinée in the style of the Paris Halles: yellow onions gently stewed in butter and water under a lid, a light water-based broth, and a slice of country bread under Comté browned in individual grill-safe bowls. Covers the market history behind the dish, choosing liquid, bread and cheese, keeping the bread from sinking, safe bowls, and fixing common problems, for 4 servings.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Slice the onions thinly and evenly

Peeled yellow onions being cut into thin, even half-moon slices
Even half-moon slices soften together

Peel the 1.75 lb (800g) of yellow onions and slice them thinly. Keeping the slices an even thickness helps them soften at the same pace in the pot.

STEP22 / 6

Stew the onions in butter and water, covered, for 35–40 minutes

Yellow onions, butter and water in a heavy pot, with the lid ready to go on
Onions, butter and the 100ml of water go in together before the lid goes on

Put the 2.75 oz (80g) butter and the ½ cup (100ml) water into a heavy-bottomed pot, add the onions and cover with the lid. Cook over low heat for 35–40 minutes, stirring 3–4 times along the way.

This is not a hard sauté. Steam and butter draw out the onions' sweetness. Cook them without letting them brown (sans faire brunir), so do not turn up the heat to chase a deep brown color. Look for onions that are soft and translucent, with a little moisture still at the bottom of the pot. If the base of the pot starts to look dry, lower the heat.

Yellow onions after about 35 minutes over low heat, soft and translucent
Soft, moist and pale gold rather than dark brown
STEP33 / 6

Add the boiling water and simmer gently for 15 minutes

Hot water being poured over the soft onions
The boiling water goes straight onto the stewed onions

Pour the 1.5 quarts (1.5L) of boiling water over the onions. No flour goes in at this point; see the ingredients section.

Keep the soup at a gentle simmer, with small bubbles rising, for 15 minutes. Avoid a hard, rolling boil. Season with salt and black pepper at the end, tasting as you go.

Onion soup simmering over low heat with small bubbles
A quiet simmer, not a rolling boil
STEP44 / 6

Fill the bowls and top each with bread and cheese

One slice of bread placed on onion soup in a heatproof bowl
One slice of bread per bowl, floating on the broth

Set the 4 grill-safe bowls on a baking tray and ladle the soup into them. Bowls vary in size, so do not fill them to the brim; leave a safe margin below the rim.

Lay one slice of bread on the surface of each bowl.

Divide the 4 oz (120g) of grated Comté among the four bowls and scatter it over the bread. Work quickly: the bread should go under the heat before it sinks.

Comté divided and scattered over the bread floating on the soup
Cheese evenly over each slice, then straight to the oven
STEP55 / 6

Brown the cheese under the grill right away

Onion soup under the oven grill with the cheese melted and browned
Stop when the cheese is melted and browned in patches

Slide the tray into a preheated oven on the grill or top-heat setting for a few minutes. Bake until the cheese has melted and browned on top. How fast this happens depends on your oven and how close the bowls sit to the heat, so watch continuously and take them out by eye.

STEP66 / 6

Serve hot

STEP 6

Lift the bowls out with oven gloves, set each one on a dry heatproof mat or trivet and serve immediately. Tell everyone at the table that the bowls are very hot.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Yellow onions (oignons jaunes) 1.75 lb (800g) The heart of the soup. Weight as bought
Unsalted butter (beurre) 2.75 oz (80g) Softens the onions over low heat and rounds out the broth
Water (eau), for stewing the onions ½ cup (100ml) Goes into the pot with the butter so the onions stew under the lid
Boiling water (eau bouillante), for the soup 1.5 quarts (1.5L) The soup liquid. Chicken or beef stock (bouillon de volaille ou de bœuf) can be used instead
Country bread (pain de campagne) 4 slices, not too thick One slice floats on each bowl and soaks up the broth
Grated Comté (comté râpé) 4 oz (120g) Covers the bread and browns under the heat. Emmental also works
Salt (sel) and black pepper (poivre) To taste Adjust at the end
0 / 0

The spoon meets resistance first: a crust of cheese, blistered gold in places, stretched over the rim of a small bowl. Push through and the bread underneath gives way, soaked and soft, while steam rises from the onion broth below. This is soupe à l'oignon gratinée, the onion soup of the old central market of Paris. The onions are stewed slowly until soft and sweet rather than pushed to dark brown, and a light broth lets them lead, under one slice of bread and a cap of cheese.

Soupe à l'oignon and the Halles Market

Soupe à l'oignon simply means "onion soup" in French, and onion soups come in many forms. Soupe à l'oignon gratinée is the version topped with bread and cheese and browned under heat. The one tied to the market is called gratinée des Halles, and that is the soup made here.

The Halles were the great food market at the heart of Paris. Street vendors first sold onion soup there to warm the merchants and shoppers through the cold hours. By the middle of the 19th century it had moved onto the menus of the eating houses, restaurants and bars around the market and become a symbol of the city's night life.

The cheese has never been fixed to one kind. In 1852, people at the Halles were grating Parmesan over their onion soup; this recipe uses Comté, with Emmental as the alternative.

You may also hear that Louis XV improvised the soup in a hunting lodge from onions, butter and Champagne. It's a much-repeated story, but historians doubt it, so treat it as a legend.

Ingredients: 4 Servings, Following the Halles Recipe

Yellow onions, butter, water, bread, Comté cheese, salt and pepper laid out for soupe à l'oignon
Everything the Halles-style gratinée needs: onions, butter, water, bread, cheese and seasoning

These amounts serve four. You can use boiling water, chicken stock or beef stock for the soup liquid, and Emmental or Comté for the topping. This recipe uses water and Comté.

The ½ cup (100ml) and 1.5 quarts (1.5L) are the water you pour in, not the volume of finished soup.

About the flour

This recipe uses no flour, so expect a thinner, clearer soup.

Allergens

This soup contains milk (butter, cheese) and wheat (bread). If you use a commercial stock instead of water, check its ingredient label for allergens and salt.

Equipment

  • Chef's knife and cutting board
  • Heavy-bottomed pot with a lid
  • Wooden spoon or spatula
  • Kettle for the boiling water
  • Ladle
  • 4 individual bowls that the manufacturer explicitly states are safe under an oven grill (broiler)
  • Sturdy baking tray to carry the bowls
  • Oven with a grill or top-heat setting
  • Oven gloves and a dry heatproof mat or trivet for each bowl
Bowls under the grill

Use only bowls the maker clearly labels as suitable for oven-grill or broiler use. Do not assume that a bowl marked only "oven-safe" can also go under a grill. Never use bowls without a heat-resistance rating.

Choosing Liquid, Bread and Cheese for Onion Soup

Everything here comes from an ordinary supermarket: yellow onions, butter, water, country bread and Comté.

Liquid. Choose one of three: boiling water, chicken stock or beef stock. Water keeps the onions at the front and makes the salt easy to judge. Chicken stock adds savoriness, and beef stock brings a stronger meaty flavor. If you use stock cubes or granules, follow the package directions and taste before salting, since salt varies by product.

Butter. Salted butter works if it's all you have; just hold back on the salt you add at the end.

Bread. Use slices of pain de campagne that are pas trop épaisses, "not too thick," and put them on the soup untoasted. A baguette or other bread can stand in, but it changes how much broth the bread absorbs, how the top browns and how chewy it is.

Cheese. Emmental can replace the Comté in the same 4 oz (120g), and a melting Gruyère is also possible; either will shift the aroma and saltiness. Mozzarella and similar cheeses pull the flavor away from this soup.

Method: Slow Onions, a Gentle Simmer, Then Straight Under the Grill

Judge by what you see

Watch the onions for softness and the cheese for color, and stop by eye.

Onion Soup Problems and Fixes

Cooking time varies with the pot, the heat and the quantity, so judge the onions by how they look and feel. Aim for soft and pale; pushing them toward a very dark brown can bring bitterness.

Problem Likely cause What to do
Onions still white and watery Not yet cooked long enough After 35 minutes, check that they are translucent and soft, with a little moisture left in the pot. A pale color is right here
Bottom of the pot about to scorch Heat too high Lower the heat. If the pot is close to boiling dry, add only as much water as needed
Bread sinks into the soup Too long between filling the bowls and baking Top each bowl with bread and cheese right after filling, and move straight to the oven
Bowls get very hot before the cheese browns Distance from the grill Watch the color constantly and adjust how close the tray sits to the heat
Soup tastes thin Water chosen as the liquid, or under-seasoning Adjust salt and pepper at the end. Next time, try chicken or beef stock
Soup seems lighter-bodied than expected No flour This is expected, because no flour is used

Serving, Variations and Storing Onion Soup

Eating it

A spoon breaking through the browned cheese and bread to scoop up onion soup
Each spoonful brings up broth, onion, bread and cheese together

The pleasure of a gratinée is in the layers. Break the cheese with the edge of the spoon, push down through the softened bread and lift out broth and onion together. The sweetness of the onions, the roundness of the butter, the light broth, the bread that has drunk it in and the salty, toasted cheese all arrive in one spoonful.

Parmesan is another way to finish the bowl. For more French dishes, from slow-cooked stews to mountain cheese cooking, see the France page.

Leftovers and reheating

If you want to keep some soup, set it aside before adding the bread and cheese; the topping will also be at its best when you make the gratinée later. Divide the soup into clean, shallow containers, cool it quickly and refrigerate, without leaving it standing at room temperature for long.

When reheating, heat it thoroughly, to at least 167°F (75°C), until it comes to a boil. Then add fresh bread and cheese and brown it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do the onions need to be caramelized to a deep brown?

No. The onions are stewed under a lid over low heat without browning. Other recipes take them much darker, but going too dark can turn them bitter, and this soup aims for soft and sweet.

Should I toast the bread first?

No. The bread goes onto the soup untoasted, and the bowls go under the heat right away, before it sinks. Some recipes toast the bread first, but that is a different method.

Sources