Pan Bagnat: The Nice-Style Soaked Sandwich

Cross-section of a Nice pan bagnat on a plate: a round roll filled with tuna, boiled egg, tomato, black olives and basil
Prep
30 min
Cook
9 min
Total
1 hr 15 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
French / Niçoise

Pan bagnat, the market sandwich of Nice, for a home kitchen. How to choose the round roll, soak it with tomato juice and olive oil, layer tuna, anchovy, egg and vegetables, press and rest it, plus storage and substitutes, with the local name, regional differences and shopping notes.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Boil the eggs and cut the vegetables

18 min

Boiling eggs for pan bagnat and plunging them in cold water, with tomatoes, radishes, green pepper, spring onion and basil being cut
Boil the eggs 9 minutes over medium heat and slice the vegetables thin so they sit easily in the bread

Bring water to a boil in a pot and gently add 4 eggs when it boils. Bring back to a boil over high heat, then lower to a medium heat that keeps the bubbling going and boil for 9 minutes. Right away put them in ice water, cool for 5 minutes, peel and cut into 0.25 inch (5 mm) slices.

Cut 3 tomatoes into 0.25 inch (5 mm) rounds and halve the remaining one for rubbing on the bread. Sprinkle 2 g salt on the tomato rounds and leave for 10 minutes. Slice the radishes 0.125 inch (2 mm), the green pepper 0.125 inch (3 mm), and the spring onions into thin rounds. If the vegetables are too thick, the bread cracks when wrapped. Cut them thin enough that the cut faces lie flat against each other.

STEP22 / 5

Open the bread and soak in oil and tomato juice

8 min

Opening a round roll, taking out a little of the crumb and rubbing in garlic and olive oil
Take out a little of the crumb to make room for the tomato juice, olive oil and vinegar

No heat is used. Cut the round roll in half horizontally and take out about 2 tablespoons of crumb from the top side. If you take out too much from the bottom half, the juice runs through, so only scrape the bottom thinly. Rub the cut face of the garlic lightly on the inside, and press the halved tomato against it to move its juice in.

In a small bowl, mix 3 tbsp (45 ml) olive oil, 2 tsp (10 ml) white wine vinegar and black pepper, and brush it on the inside of the bread, divided. The guide is that the crumb takes on the sheen of oil and feels slightly moist when pressed with a finger. If you put in so much that liquid pools at the bottom, it collapses after resting.

STEP33 / 5

Layer the tomato, fish, egg and vegetables

7 min

Layering tomato, tuna, anchovy, boiled egg, radish, green pepper, black olives, capers and basil on oil-soaked round rolls
Don't pile the filling high; layering it flat keeps it from collapsing when wrapped and pressed

No heat is used. On the bottom bread, place 2 to 3 slices of the salted tomato each. Put on the tuna flaked into large pieces, and lay 2 anchovy fillets thin on each. Layer the egg, radish, green pepper, spring onion, black olives, capers and basil.

Hold off on the salt here. Since anchovy, olives and capers go in, add the 1 g finishing salt at the end only if it is lacking. Stop the filling a little above the edge of the bread. It gets lower when pressed, so it is fine to mound a little, but if you pack it so that egg or tomato falls off the sides, it becomes hard to eat.

STEP44 / 5

Wrap, press and let the flavors settle

35 min

Wrapped pan bagnat pressed and resting under a heavy pot and a frying pan
Wrapping and putting a light weight on it lets the oil and tomato juice enter the bread and the filling become one

No heat is used. Put the top bread on and press lightly with your palm. Wrap in parchment paper, then wrap in a cloth or plastic wrap over it. Put it on a cutting board, place a heavy pot or frying pan on top and rest for 30 minutes. The guide is when the height of the bread has gone down by 1 to 2 cm and a few spots of oil show on the wrapping. If resting in the refrigerator, take it out 15 minutes before eating and bring it back to room temperature.

You don't need much weight. Press until the bread drops 1 to 2 cm and a few spots of oil show on the wrapping. If a large amount of juice seeps out, the tomatoes were too watery. Next time, take out some of the seeds and do not use all the water released from salting the tomatoes.

STEP55 / 5

Cut and eat at room temperature

5 min

Opening the pressed and rested pan bagnat and cutting it in half to show the cross-section
A rested pan bagnat cut at room temperature has a cross-section that holds together better

No heat is used. Open the wrapping and cut in half with a sharp knife. It is done when the tomato juice and oil of the cross-section have entered the bread and the filling has settled a little. Taste, and if the salt is lacking sprinkle the remaining salt on the cut face, just a little. Drizzle the 1 tbsp (15 ml) finishing olive oil in a thin stream over the whole.

Room temperature suits it for eating. Straight from the refrigerator the oil is stiff and the bread feels hard. On days you take it outdoors in summer, carry it with an ice pack and take it out just before eating. Left long at room temperature, egg and fish spoil faster.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Hard round rolls 4 (1 roll is 90 to 110 g) A small campagne, ciabatta or thick baguette also works. Avoid brioche
Ripe tomatoes 4, about 1.25 lb (550 g) 1 is for moving juice into the bread. On watery days take out some of the seeds
Eggs 4 Leaving them at room temperature for 10 minutes makes them less likely to crack
Canned or jarred tuna 5.5 oz (160 g) net Oil-packed suits it. If packed in water, add 2 tsp (10 ml) olive oil
Anchovy fillets 8 (about 20 g) If salt-packed, rinse for 20 seconds. Half if you dislike them
Radishes 6, about 2 oz (60 g) 0.125 inch (2 mm) slices. 2.75 oz (80 g) cucumber also works
Green pepper 1/2, about 2.5 oz (70 g) 0.125 inch (3 mm) strips. A little red bell pepper makes it sweeter
Spring onions or new onion 1.5 oz (40 g) 2 spring onions, or 1.5 oz (40 g) thinly sliced onion
Black olives 16, about 2 oz (55 g) Pitted is fine. Wipe off the liquid
Capers 12 g Not essential locally, but used to help the saltiness on days when the black olives are weak
Basil 10 g Tear if the leaves are large
Garlic 1 clove (5 g) Rubbed on the bread. If you dislike a strong aroma, just stroke the cut surface lightly
Extra-virgin olive oil ¼ cup (60 ml) 3 tbsp (45 ml) for the bread, 1 tbsp (15 ml) for finishing
White wine vinegar 2 tsp (10 ml) 1 tsp (5 ml) if the acidity is strong. With rice vinegar, start from 1.5 tsp (7 ml)
Salt 3 g 2 g for the tomatoes, 1 g for finishing
Black pepper 1/4 tsp Coarsely ground
0 / 0

Split a ripe tomato against the cut face of a round roll and the red juice runs straight into the white crumb. Then come olive oil, tuna, egg, black olives and basil, and before you've even picked up the knife, your cutting board feels a little closer to a seaside market. This is pan bagnat (pan banhat in Niçois), the sandwich of Nice, and the name means "bathed bread." A firm round roll drinks up tomato juice, a little vinegar and olive oil. It comes out moist and salty, with a bright edge of acidity.

Pan bagnat in Nice

The name holds on to an old kitchen habit: hard bread never went to waste. Stale bread was softened with water or tomato juice and eaten with the vegetables and salted fish of a Niçoise salad. Eventually the bread itself became the container, and the salad turned into something you could carry. You can buy pan bagnat at bakeries and markets all over Nice today, but it began as a plain lunch for someone working since early morning, made to be eaten with one hand.

Niçois cooking draws on both the hills and the sea: tomatoes, peppers, young onions, radishes, basil, olives, eggs and salted fish, with influences from neighboring Liguria and Provence. Nice's other famous bread dish, pissaladière, is topped with cooked onions. Pan bagnat is never cooked. The juice and oil of raw vegetables move into the bread instead.

The fish has its own history. Tuna and anchovy were not traditionally used together. Anchovy was the everyday salt, and tuna was the filling for a slightly richer day. These days both often go in, each in a small amount.

This isn't a sandwich stacked neatly on a plate. It is pressed in its wrapping, it leaks juice when you cut it, and a bit of filling escapes when you hold it, and that mess is part of what makes it easy to eat. So resist cutting it right away. Wrap it and leave it for 30 minutes. Once the filling settles and the oil soaks into the bottom of the roll, you have real "bathed bread."

Ingredients (serves 4)

Round rolls, tomatoes, tuna, anchovy, eggs, radishes, green pepper, black olives, capers, basil and olive oil laid out in a kitchen for pan bagnat
Rather than adding ingredients, thinking separately about moisture, oil and salt helps pan bagnat come together

Makes 4 servings with 4 round rolls. You can also make one large campagne and slice it, but for the first time wrapping one portion at a time makes it easier to control the moisture.

Allergies and salt

This recipe uses wheat, egg and fish. Anchovy, tuna, olives and capers are high in salt, so if you are on a low-salt diet follow the instructions of your doctor or dietitian. If making it for children, halving the anchovy and leaving out the capers makes it easier to eat.

Choosing ingredients for pan bagnat

Round rolls, tomatoes, tuna, anchovy, black olives, eggs, capers, olive oil and wine vinegar laid out in a kitchen as shopping for pan bagnat
What is worth seeking out is the oil that wets the bread, the vinegar for a thin line of acidity, and the capers for points of saltiness

The bread, tomatoes, eggs, tuna, radishes and peppers can all come fresh from a nearby supermarket. Take more care over the olive oil, white wine vinegar and capers. Anchovies and black olives are also sold at import food shops, but small cans or jars are plenty the first time. A big jar of an overly salty brand will make everything taste heavy long before you finish it. Lettuce, ham and cheese stay out.

Bread

The bread is the hard part outside Nice. A local pan bagnat roll is firm outside and built to soak up juice inside. Look for one that springs back a little when you press it. Soft dinner rolls and brioche collapse when wrapped and pressed, and sweet bread can't hold the moisture, so the bottom turns into something like a sweet dumpling. Hard round rolls, a small campagne, ciabatta or a thick baguette all work. Cut campagne into single portions, and if your baguette is thin, go easy on the filling. Whatever you use, pull out a little crumb to make room for the tomato juice and oil.

Tomatoes and tuna

Choose tomatoes with aroma. Sweetness matters less than juice that runs when you cut them. If all you have are hard tomatoes, slice them, salt them and leave them for 10 minutes, then use the juice that comes out on the bread. Oil-packed tuna suits this best. With water-packed tuna, flake it and mix in 2 tsp (10 ml) olive oil and black pepper before layering.

Oil, vinegar and salty accents

The olive oil goes straight into the bread, so a green, rounded oil works better than one that is only sharply bitter. The amount looks generous, but split among 4 rolls it comes to 1 tbsp (15 ml) each. The vinegar is there to cut the oiliness a little. Too much turns the sandwich sour, so start modestly.

Capers are a supporting player. On days when the olives and anchovy are mild, a few of them keep the flavor from going flat. Leftovers are good in fish dishes, potato salad and creamed chicken. If anyone at the table dislikes fishy flavors, skip the anchovy and finely chop black olives and capers to scatter through the filling. That sharpens the taste better than extra tuna, which only makes it read as an ordinary tuna sandwich. Anchovy on its own makes for a very grown-up saltiness. For your first time, go down the middle: 5.5 oz (160 g) tuna and 8 anchovy fillets is easiest to eat.

Substitutions

You don't need every Niçois ingredient. What you have to protect is whatever wets the bread: tomato juice, oil, and the salt of fish or olives.

Where you hesitate Local-leaning Realistic elsewhere What to protect
Bread A round hard roll for pan bagnat Small campagne, ciabatta, thick baguette Avoid sweet bread, sandwich bread, thin rolls
Fish Anchovy, or tuna Oil-packed tuna as the star, with a little anchovy No mayonnaise binding
Vegetables Tomato, young onion, pepper, radish, seasonal beans or artichoke Tomato, spring onion, green pepper, radish are enough Slice watery vegetables thin
Olives Small black olives from Nice Pitted black olives, a little Kalamata Wipe off the liquid, keep the saltiness
Acidity A little wine vinegar White wine vinegar, a little rice vinegar Vinegar stays in the background
Resting Flavor goes in as you carry it wrapped Weight it and rest for 30 minutes Cut only after resting

Lettuce makes it look more like a sandwich, but it throws off the moisture and texture. If you really want it, use one small leaf with the thick rib cut out and the water wiped off well.

Method: wet it, layer it, press it and rest it

Pan bagnat uses almost no heat. For that reason, be exact about the egg boiling time, the width of the vegetable cuts, the moisture put in the bread, and the time to wrap and press.

Pan bagnat troubleshooting

State Main cause Fix
Soggy bottom All the tomato moisture went in, the bread is soft Next time take out some tomato seeds and use only half the water released by salting
Filling spills Vegetables thick, bread not hollowed Slice radish 0.125 inch (2 mm), pepper 0.125 inch (3 mm), egg 0.25 inch (5 mm)
Too salty Anchovy, olives and capers stacked up Leave out the capers and reduce anchovy to 1 fillet per roll
Taste is blurred Used water-packed tuna as is, too little oil Mix 2 tsp (10 ml) olive oil and black pepper into the tuna before layering
Bread tastes sweet Used brioche-type or dinner-roll bread Switch to hard round rolls, ciabatta or campagne
Egg crumbles Boiled too short, not cooled before cutting Boil 9 minutes over medium heat and cool 5 minutes in ice water before cutting

If it turns out watery, don't put it in the toaster. Pan bagnat is a cold sandwich, so adjust the moisture next time. For now, open the wrapping and lightly blot off the extra juice. If the bread came out dry, drip about 1 tsp olive oil on the cut face.

Serving and storing pan bagnat

Pan bagnat is better held in its paper than eaten with a knife and fork. For lunch, cold water, a light soup and some fruit are all you need. Cut small as a starter, it sits well next to Nice's pissaladière, the Mediterranean bread dish panzanella, and dakos, which handles tomato and oil in a similar way. Side by side they show how differently bread can soak up juice.

Eat it the day you make it. Wrapped and refrigerated, it keeps for 8 hours. Because it contains egg and fish, don't hold it longer than that, and the bread only gets wetter overnight anyway. To carry it, wrap each one separately and pack it with an ice pack. A cut face dries out, so slice it just before eating.

Leftover ingredients are easy to use up. Extra tomato and bread make panzanella. Black olives and capers go into Catalonia's esqueixada, and olive oil with white wine vinegar makes Brazil's vinagrete.

FAQ

Can I put in mayonnaise?

It's more authentic without. The fat comes from olive oil and the acidity from vinegar and tomato juice. Mayonnaise makes it easier to eat, but it ends up closer to an ordinary tuna sandwich.

Can I make it with a baguette?

Yes. Cut a thick baguette into 4, open each piece horizontally and pull out a little crumb. A thin baguette holds less and tends to crack when pressed, so cut the filling by about 20%.

Can I make it the day before?

Make it the same day, since it contains egg and fish. If you need a head start, cut the vegetables the night before, then assemble and press it the morning you eat it.

Are capers essential?

No. If your black olives and anchovy are salty enough, leave them out. When the olives you can find are mild, scatter 12 g over the whole batch to tighten the flavor.

Sources

I consulted the following to check the name of pan bagnat, the local view of its ingredients, the custom of pressing and resting it, and the adjustment of amounts for home cooking. In the text, amounts and steps are adjusted so they are easy to reproduce in a home kitchen.