Mute: Colombian Hominy Soup from Santander

Colombian mute, a stew of hominy, beans, beef, pork, and root vegetables
Prep
35 min
Cook
1 hr 45 min
Total
2 hr 20 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Colombian (Santander)

How to make mute, a hominy and meat soup from Santander, Colombia. Beef, pork, tripe, beans, and root vegetables, organized as a pressure-cooker version that is easy in a home kitchen, with annatto, substitutes, heat control, how it is eaten locally, and storage.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Blanch the tripe and meat

15 min

Blanching beef, pork, and tripe over high heat to remove the scum
Blanch the tripe and meat once over high heat and discard the water, removing scum and smell before the main simmer

Cut the tripe into 1.5 inches (4 cm) pieces, the beef into 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes, and the pork into 1 inches (3 cm) cubes. Put the meat and tripe in a pot with water to cover and bring to a boil over high heat; once boiling, boil for 5 minutes. When large gray scum rises and the water turns cloudy, turn off the heat, drain in a sieve, and rinse the scum from the surface with lukewarm water. Getting the smell out here keeps the finished soup from becoming too heavy.

STEP22 / 7

Make the meat broth

45 min

Simmering beef, pork, and aromatics in a pressure cooker to make broth
In a pressure cooker, after reaching high pressure, cook over low heat and make broth until the meat is tender

Put the blanched meat, 3.5 oz (100 g) onion, the green part of the leek, 2 cloves garlic lightly cracked with the flat of a knife, the bay leaf, 1.5 quarts (1.4 L) water, and 1 tsp salt in a pressure cooker. Cover and bring to pressure over medium heat; once at high pressure, lower to low heat and cook for 25 minutes, then turn off the heat and let it release naturally for 10 minutes. In an ordinary pot, simmer for 75 to 90 minutes over low heat, with the surface gently trembling. The broth is ready when a chopstick slides easily into the beef and the pork fat turns nearly translucent.

STEP33 / 7

Make the achiote aromatic base

8 min

Cooking onion, leek, garlic, and cumin in the oil colored by annatto
Bring out the annatto oil's color over low heat without scorching, and cook the onion until translucent

Put 2 tbsp oil and 1 tsp annatto seed in a separate large pot and warm over low heat for 2 minutes. When the oil takes on a red tint, remove the seeds, add 3.5 oz (100 g) onion, 2 oz (60 g) leek, and 12 g garlic, and cook over medium-low heat for 4 minutes. When the onion is translucent and the aroma rises as you mix in 1 tsp cumin seed and 1 tsp paprika, you have a base that will hold the kernels and meat.

STEP44 / 7

Simmer the kernels and root vegetables

20 min

Simmering hominy, beans, potatoes, squash, and carrots in the achiote-colored broth
Cook the hominy and beans quietly over low heat and wait until the potatoes and squash are tender

Strain the broth from step 2, discard the aromatics, and pour 1.25 quarts (1.1 L) into the pot with the aromatic base. Add the hominy, chickpeas, red kidney beans, potatoes, squash, and carrot, and bring to a gentle bubble over medium-low heat. Once it boils, lower to low heat and cook for 15 minutes, until a skewer goes into the potato and the corners of the squash are slightly rounded. To keep the kernels from breaking, when you stir, turn from the bottom with a wooden spoon just once, keeping a sheen on the surface of the hominy.

STEP55 / 7

Return the meat and let the flavors meld

15 min

Returning tender meat to the hominy and bean soup and melding over low heat
Once the meat is back, cook over low heat so fat and broth coat the kernels

Cut the reserved meat and tripe to a size that is easy to eat and return them to the pot. Cook over low heat for 15 minutes, until fine bubbles show on the surface, so the fat of the meat and the sweetness of the beans meld. It is enough when small rings of oil float on the surface and the beef falls apart when pressed with a wooden spoon. Taste and add 1/2 tsp salt and 1/3 tsp black pepper.

STEP66 / 7

Adjust the thickness with pasta

10 min

Adding small shell pasta to the hominy and meat soup to adjust the thickness
Add the short pasta near the end and cook over medium-low heat until the core is gone

Add 1.75 oz (50 g) short pasta and cook over medium-low heat for 8 to 10 minutes. It sinks to the bottom easily, so stir by stroking the bottom only once every 2 minutes. Cook until the white core of the pasta disappears and the soup coats the wooden spoon lightly. If it is too thick, add ½ cup (100 ml) boiling water; if too thin, simmer with the lid off over medium-low heat for 3 minutes.

STEP77 / 7

Scatter the herbs and rest

8 min

A pot of mute finished with cilantro and scallion scattered on top
Scattering herbs after the heat is off leaves a green aroma in mute's heavy broth

Turn off the heat, add 15 g cilantro and the sliced scallion, and rest for 3 minutes. Put the meat in the center of the bowl with hominy, beans, and root vegetables visible around it, and serve with the remaining 5 g cilantro, lime, and avocado. If it tastes too salty, squeeze the lime first; if the fat feels heavy, use a little avocado, and it stays easy to eat to the end.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Meat and broth

Ingredient Amount Notes
Beef shank or beef chuck 12.5 oz (350 g) 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes. Bone-in beef ribs also work
Pork shoulder or pork belly block 8 oz (220 g) 1 inches (3 cm) cubes. For a fattier cut, 6.5 oz (180 g) is enough
Pre-cleaned honeycomb tripe 5.5 oz (150 g) 1.5 inches (4 cm) pieces. If you dislike it, replace with 5.5 oz (150 g) beef sinew
Onion 1/2 (3.5 oz (100 g)) For the broth. Cut in half
Green part of a leek 1 stalk's worth For the broth
Garlic 2 cloves (12 g) Crushed
Bay leaf 1 For the broth
Water 1.5 quarts (1.4 L) Adjust so as not to exceed the pressure cooker's max fill line
Salt 1 tsp For the broth. Add more at the end
2 / 2

Kernels, vegetables, and finish

Ingredient Amount Notes
Canned hominy 1 can (drained weight about 15 oz (430 g)) Drain in a sieve
Canned chickpeas 5.5 oz (150 g) Drained
Canned red kidney beans 4 oz (120 g) Drained. White beans also work
Potatoes 2 (9 oz (260 g)) 1 inches (2 cm) cubes
Squash 6.5 oz (180 g) 1 inches (2 cm) cubes. Leave some of the skin on here and there
Carrot 1 (5 oz (140 g)) 0.5 inches (1.5 cm) cubes
Onion 1/2 (3.5 oz (100 g)) 0.5 inches (1 cm) dice
Leek or scallion 2 oz (60 g) Sliced thinly
Garlic 2 cloves (12 g) Finely chopped
Short pasta 1.75 oz (50 g) Small shells, macaroni, or conchiglie
Annatto seed 1 tsp 1/2 tsp ground achiote also works
Cumin seed 1 tsp 3/4 tsp if ground
Paprika 1 tsp Color help if the achiote is weak
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp For bringing out the annatto's color
Black pepper 1/3 tsp To finish
Cilantro 20 g Roughly chopped
Lime 1 Cut into 4 wedges
Avocado 1 To serve
0 / 0

Late morning on a day off, beef and pork broth rises from the pot, and in go white hominy, chickpeas, red beans, potatoes, and squash. The clear soup slowly turns a cloudy yellow, and when you drag a wooden spoon across the bottom, the kernels and meat shift lazily. Mute santandereano is a hearty soup from Santander in Colombia that brings together corn, beans, beef, pork, mondongo (beef tripe), root vegetables, and short pasta. It's earthy and filling, the kind of dish you make when you've decided that today is the day to tend a pot.

Mute Santandereano and Its Place in Colombian Cooking

Mute, written Mute in Spanish and Mute santandereano for the Santander version, is an emblematic soup of the region. Traditional versions use beef mondongo and feet, white corn, chickpeas, potatoes, squash, and hogao. Local recipes share a common core of beef, pork, tripe, hominy, beans, carrot, potato, achiote, cumin, and short pasta.

Each town and household makes it a little differently. Some add beef feet, some add chorizo, some mix in yellow corn, and some use guascas for aroma. Locally, mute is a hearty, rich dish. Think of it less as a light soup, like Japanese miso soup, and more as a main course where you scoop up kernels with a spoon.

Among Colombian soups, Bogotá's ajiaco is enjoyed for the aroma of chicken and potatoes. Mute is earthier, and you eat it for the texture of kernels and meat. Set it beside the platter dish bandeja paisa, and you see that Colombian cooking eats meat boldly but also makes deep use of beans, corn, and aromatics.

Other corn-and-bean dishes make a useful comparison. Kenya's githeri is closer to a stir-fried stew, and Argentina's locro is richer still with squash and beans. Mute sits between them, with enough liquid to drink as a soup while the meat and kernels stay the stars.

Ingredients (serves 4)

Even pre-cleaned tripe gets blanched once at the start. For canned hominy, choose the large-kerneled white kind, not sweet corn, to get closer to mute's "soup you chew."

Ingredient and allergy notes

This uses beef, pork, tripe, beans, and wheat pasta. Tripe can retain an odor even when pre-cleaned, so blanch it over high heat and discard the water before the main simmer. If you are avoiding wheat, omit the pasta and add 2.75 oz (80 g) more potato.

Ingredients That Cause Confusion When Shopping

A shopping guide with hominy, annatto seed, beans, and a pressure cooker laid out in a kitchen
Secure canned hominy and annatto seed, and the kernel texture and color of mute are easier to reach in a home kitchen

The meat can be made from beef shank and pork shoulder from a supermarket. What causes confusion when shopping is hominy, annatto, and the pot used for long simmering. Replacing hominy with sweet corn changes the sweetness and the firmness of the kernels, and it becomes quite a different dish. Even a little annatto gives the soup a South American color, so it is worth getting once rather than settling for paprika alone.

Canned hominy saves the time of soaking dried corn. Do not put the canning liquid into the dish; drain it in a sieve before using, so the soup does not get too cloudy.

Annatto seed can be used without grittiness if you bring out its color in oil over low heat and then remove it. If you use achiote powder, it scorches easily, so add the onion about 30 seconds after it goes into the oil.

If you make it with dried corn or dried beans, a pressure cooker makes it suddenly realistic. This quantity can be made in an ordinary pot, but the tenderness of the meat and tripe is more consistent in a pressure cooker.

Choosing Ingredients and Substitutes for Mute

Hominy, beans, meat, root vegetables, and short pasta for mute laid out in a kitchen
Mute layers white hominy, beans, beef, pork, root vegetables, and short pasta in one pot

Beef feet and whole local corn are hard to find for most home cooks, so this recipe uses canned hominy, beef shank, pork shoulder, and pre-cleaned honeycomb tripe. Rather than hunting down every unusual cut, make sure each role in the table below is covered.

Role Local representative Realistic approach at home
Kernel core maíz mute, maíz pelado Canned hominy, or dried corn for pozole
Broth and gelatin Beef feet, beef ribs, mondongo Beef shank, beef sinew, pre-cleaned honeycomb tripe
Fat and body Pork, chorizo Pork shoulder, a little pork belly
Fluffiness Potato, squash, beans Russet potato, squash, chickpeas, red kidney beans
Color and aroma Hogao, achiote, cumin Scallion, onion, garlic, annatto seed, cumin

If you dislike tripe, leave it out and make the soup with beef shank and pork. Still, the chew and aroma of mondongo are a big part of what makes mute taste like mute. For a first try, use just 5.5 oz (150 g) of tripe and let the meat and kernels take the lead.

How to Make It: Soften the Meat Without Breaking the Kernels

Mute is a one-pot dish, but if you put everything in from the start, the kernels split and the meat stays tough. Layer it in the order of pre-boiling the meat, making the broth, the aromatic base, kernels and root vegetables, and the finish, and even canned hominy keeps its texture.

Fixing Watery or Heavy Mute

Comparing watery mute with mute that has built its thickness
If mute is too watery the kernels float, and if over-reduced it turns heavy, so adjust the thickness along the way

Mute's failures are easy to spot in the pot. If the hominy sits in a thin, clear broth, the broth and root vegetables haven't come together. If the squash and potato have all broken down like porridge, it was stirred too much or cooked too long.

State Cause Fix
Watery and bland Too much broth, beans and root vegetables undercooked Remove the lid and simmer 5 minutes over medium-low heat
Meat is tough Pressure time too short, or the heat too high in an ordinary pot Return only the meat and cook 20 more minutes over low heat
Tripe smell is strong Not blanched enough Next time, blanch for 5 minutes and put 2 tsp lime juice in the blanching water
Kernels split Cooked over high heat, stirred too much Add the hominy and beans from step 4 on, and cook quietly over low heat
Fat is heavy Too much pork belly, beef sinew fat left on Skim off about 2 tbsp of the oil from the surface and serve with lime

A little richness is just right, so don't chase a light broth.

Serving and Storing Mute

What to Serve with Mute

A table with mute served in a bowl alongside avocado, lime, arepa, and white rice
With avocado, lime, arepa, and white rice, mute becomes the main dish of the table

One bowl of mute is quite filling. With white rice, avocado, lime, and a Colombian arepa alongside, it makes a full lunch. Put the lime on the table instead of squeezing it into the pot, so everyone can adjust the acidity to their taste.

For a Colombian-themed meal, let mute be the star with a small salad on the side rather than piling on starters. Leftovers spooned over white rice the next day become a rich, bean-filled rice porridge.

Storage and Reheating

Mute divided into shallow storage containers with the pot in the kitchen
Divide mute into shallow containers to cool, and add herbs and lime just before eating

With all that meat and beans, mute cools slowly in a deep pot. After eating, divide it into shallow containers and refrigerate as soon as the heat is off. It keeps 2 days in the refrigerator or 2 weeks in the freezer.

To reheat, return it to a pot, add 3.5 tbsp (50 ml) to ½ cup (100 ml) water or broth, and warm over low heat. Beans and pasta sink, so stir once from the bottom before it boils. In a microwave, put it in a deep dish, heat at 600 W for 2 minutes, stir once, and add 1 more minute. Store the soup without herbs, lime, and avocado, and prepare those fresh just before eating so the aroma comes back.

FAQ

Can I make it without tripe?

Yes. Use 5.5 oz (150 g) beef sinew, or add 5.5 oz (150 g) more beef shank. The elasticity and aroma of the tripe will be weaker, but as long as the backbone of hominy, beans, achiote, and cumin remains, it's a delicious mute-style Colombian soup.

Can I use sweet corn instead of canned hominy?

It's best avoided. Sweet corn is quite sweet, and its kernels lose firmness when simmered. If you must substitute, add only 3.5 oz (100 g) frozen corn kernels on the side, and let white beans or chickpeas carry the kernel role, since they hold together better.

What if I don't have achiote?

Use 1 tsp paprika, 1/4 tsp turmeric, and 1 tsp cumin for color and aroma. Achiote's red color and earthy aroma are hard to match, though, so try annatto seed next time and you'll taste the difference.

How long does it take with dried beans and dried corn?

Soak dried chickpeas and dried corn overnight. In a pressure cooker, cook for 20 to 25 minutes at high pressure; in an ordinary pot, simmer for 70 to 90 minutes over low heat. The flavor is deeper than with canned hominy, but for a first time, canned hominy is the easier way to learn the dish.

Sources

Mute's ingredient makeup, its place in Santander, household regional differences, and the treatment of tripe and hominy were organized by cross-checking the following materials.