The coconut milk in the pot cooks down at a steady bubble. As the white liquid loses its water, the solids on the bottom go from pale brown to a deep caramel, and a sweet, toasty smell fills the kitchen. Then the rice goes in to be coated in the oil, followed by water and raisins. This is arroz con coco, the caramel-colored coconut rice of Colombia's Caribbean coast, and in the walled city of Cartagena it is nearly always on the plate next to fried fish.
Arroz con coco on Colombia's Caribbean coast

Lunch by the sea in Cartagena means fried fish. A mojarra (a kind of tilapia) or a snapper comes straight out of a big pot of boiling oil and onto the plate with arroz con coco, patacón (green plantain smashed and fried), and a salad. Here the rice is one of the foundations of the local cooking.
Coconut palms grow all along the Caribbean coast, and rice has long been cooked with coconut there. The coast's food still carries much of the culture of the descendants of people brought from Africa, and many dishes that use coconut generously are particular to this region. One woman from Bogotá learned arroz con coco from an aunt in Cartagena. "When we went to the coast we ate it every day," she remembers. Back home in inland Bogotá, the days they made it were special.
White and black arroz con coco
Arroz con coco comes in two kinds, white (blanco) and black (negro). White is cooked simply in coconut milk. Black gets its color from titoté, made by cooking coconut down, and has a stronger sweetness and toastiness. The version here is the black kind, with raisins.
Titoté

Titoté decides both the flavor and the color of the dish. Traditionally, fresh coconut flesh is grated, blended with water, and strained to get the milk. When that milk and pulp are heated in a pot, the water cooks off, the oil separates, and the solids brown. That brown mass and oil, just short of scorched, is titoté: it becomes the oil for toasting the rice and gives the finished dish its color.
Ingredients (serves 4)

There are only 6 ingredients. For that reason, how you cook down the coconut milk decides everything.
For the coconut milk, one that is high in fat with no emulsifiers separates its oil more easily and makes better titoté. Check the ingredient list on the can and choose one with only coconut and water. Mixing in some coconut cream cooks it down even faster.
Long-grain rice stays loose, with grains that come apart, when cooked. With short-grain rice, the result is a sticky, pilaf-like dish. Both are good, but if you want to get closer to the texture in Cartagena, choose long-grain.
Choosing coconut milk and sugar for arroz con coco

Making titoté from fresh coconut takes effort and time, so Colombian supermarkets also sell it in jars. Where jars are hard to find, canned coconut milk works well: cook it down for about 30 minutes. Liquid coconut milk from a can or carton is the best choice. Coconut milk powder dissolved in hot water can work, but many products are low in fat, so the titoté takes longer or the oil won't separate easily.
For the sugar, brown sugar gives a depth close to Colombia's panela (sugar made by boiling down sugarcane juice) and makes the color deeper still. It's the easiest way to get closer to the Colombian flavor with ordinary kitchen ingredients.
How to make arroz con coco
Cooking down the coconut milk takes about 30 minutes, cooking the rice about 20 minutes, and resting 5 minutes. Don't leave the pot while it cooks down, and scrape the bottom from time to time.
The oil and solids of the cooked-down coconut are extremely hot. Use a long-handled wooden spoon so you don't get burned by spattering oil at the moment the rice goes in or when scraping the bottom.
Scorched or pale titoté: common failures

Nearly every failed arroz con coco comes down to scorched titoté. Only 1 to 2 minutes separate caramel from burnt black, so stay at the stove once the oil starts to separate. A heavy pot passes heat slowly, which makes the color change more gently.
To judge the color, scoop a little of the mass from the bottom with a wooden spoon and check it on a white plate. The inside of the pot is dark, so the titoté tends to look darker than it is.
The opposite problem is titoté that isn't cooked down enough. The rice comes out pale and tastes close to the white version, which is good too, but it lacks the toastiness of the black. Be patient until the oil clearly separates and turns transparent.
Serving, variations, and storage

For a Cartagena-style plate, serve it with a whole fried fish and a salad. A small whole fish such as a snapper or a small sea bream, salted and deep-fried plain, is ideal. Squeeze lime over the fish, take a bite with the sweet coconut rice, and sweetness, saltiness, and acidity arrive in turn.
To stay in Colombia, try it alongside ajiaco, the potato and chicken soup of inland Bogotá: rice from the coast next to a soup from the mountains. For another Caribbean dish with coconut milk, there's Jamaica's coconut stew run down.

If you don't like the sweetness of raisins, leave them out. Cutting the sugar to 1 tbsp makes a less sweet coconut rice that pairs more easily with fish and meat dishes. For a white version, cook the rice in coconut milk and water without cooking the milk down, and season with salt only.
Leftovers keep up to 2 days in a sealed container in the refrigerator. Reheat them in the microwave with a little water sprinkled on so they don't dry out.
Frequently asked questions
Can I make it in a rice cooker?
The titoté has to be made in a pot. Once the rice is toasted in it, you can move everything to the rice cooker's inner pot with the water and seasoning and cook it normally. Scrape the pot clean with a wooden spoon as you transfer it, so no scorched titoté ends up damaging the inner pot.
Does sweet rice go with the main dish?
In Cartagena it's the standard pairing for salty fried fish. If the sweetness bothers you, cut the sugar or leave out the raisins, and it fits more easily into everyday meals.
How do I remove the scorching from the pot?
The pot you made the titoté in can keep a brown film on the bottom. Fill it with lukewarm water and let it sit a while; the film softens and comes off more easily.













