Bara: Indian Fried Dhal Rings with Two Kinds of Lentil

Indian-style bara made from two kinds of dhal and aromatics, fried into rings with a center hole and served with chilli chutney
Serves
50 serves
Cuisine
Indian

How to make the Indian-style bara published by SBS Food: small fried rings of chana dhal and de-skinned urad dhal with onion, herbs and spices. Covers Australian cup measures, soaking, shaping, frying at 140°C, oil safety, and how this bara differs from Nepal's dish of the same name.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Soak the dhals separately

Yellow split chana dhal and de-skinned urad dhal soaking in water in separate bowls
Two bowls, two measures of water, no mixing yet

Put the chana dhal in one bowl with 1 quarts (1 L) water and the urad dhal in another with 1 cups (250 ml) water. Soak overnight, for 8 hours. In the morning, drain each one, keeping a little of the soaking water.

STEP22 / 6

Grind each dhal

The two drained dhals ground separately into thick, coarse pastes
A spoonful of soaking water at most; the paste should stay thick

Grind the drained chana dhal finely in the food processor, then do the same with the urad dhal, keeping them separate. If needed, add just a little soaking water so the mixture holds together. Keep it thick, not loose.

STEP33 / 6

Mix the batter

Onion, coriander, spring onions and spices being mixed into the two dhal pastes
Everything except the oil and chutney goes in here

Put both ground dhals in a large bowl. Add the salt, baking powder, turmeric, ginger, garlic, green chilli, cumin, fennel seed, onion, coriander and spring onions. Mix well.

STEP44 / 6

Heat the oil and shape

Damp hands shaping a small disc of dhal batter with a hole in the center
Damp hands stop the batter sticking

Heat the oil in a small saucepan or kadhai over medium heat and keep it at 275°F (140°C), checking with a thermometer. Set the plate lined with paper towels nearby.

Wet your hands with water, shaking off any drips so none reach the oil. Take 1 flat tablespoon of batter, shape it into a disc about 2.5 inches (6 cm) across, and make a hole in the center.

STEP55 / 6

Fry in small batches

Four bara rings frying in vegetable oil at 140°C, with the first side starting to color
Four or five at a time, with gentle bubbles

Carefully slide 4 or 5 pieces into the oil, keeping your fingers away from it. Don't drop them in, because the oil can splash and burn you. Adding batter can change the oil temperature, so check the thermometer and keep it at 275°F (140°C).

Fry for about 2–3 minutes on each side, until golden brown. Lift out with a slotted spoon, let the excess oil drain against the side of the pan, and set on the paper towels. Repeat with the rest of the batter.

Bara golden on both sides being lifted from the oil on a slotted spoon to drain
Let the oil run back into the pan before moving them to the paper towels
STEP66 / 6

Serve warm

Freshly fried small bara served warm at the table with red and green chilli chutney
Chutney stays on the side, so it's easy to leave out

Serve the bara warm, with red or green chilli chutney on the side if you like.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Split yellow pea dhal (chana dhal) 2 cups Main body of the batter
De-skinned urad dhal 1/2 cup Second dhal, soaked and ground separately
Salt 3 tsp Seasoning
Baking powder 1 tsp Lightens the batter
Ground turmeric 1/2 tsp Color and earthy aroma
Ground ginger 1 tsp Aroma
Ground garlic 1 tsp Aroma
Ground green chilli 1 tsp Heat
Ground cumin 1 1/2 tsp Toasty aroma alongside the dhal
Fennel seed 1/2 tsp Sweet aroma
Onion, finely chopped 1 Flavor and texture in the batter
Coriander, chopped 1/2 bunch Fresh, green aroma
Spring onions, finely chopped 4 Green aroma
Vegetable oil 500 ml (2 cups) For frying; not all of it is eaten
Red or green chilli chutney as needed Optional, served on the side
0 / 0

Small golden rings come out of the oil, each with a hole in the middle, and go to the table warm with red or green chilli chutney. Bara is an Indian fried snack made from chana dhal and de-skinned urad dhal. Ginger, garlic, green chilli, cumin, fennel, onion, coriander and spring onion give the batter its aroma. The recipe makes 50 serves, a good number for small canapé portions. Plan ahead, because the dhals need 8 hours of soaking.

Key points

Two dhals soaked and ground separately, a thick batter with as little added water as possible, a hole in the center of every piece, and oil held at 275°F (140°C).

About Bara

In India, these dhal rings are served as a canapé at weddings, Hindu festivals and casual dinner parties. You'll find more of the country's dishes on our India page.

The name covers a lot of ground, so it's easy to mix up. Nepal's Newari bara, or wo, is a black lentil pancake cooked on a griddle, so its shape, mix and method all differ. The bara in Trinidad's doubles belongs to a different dish altogether.

Even within India, bara changes from recipe to recipe. One version shapes the ring from urad dal, semolina, onion, ginger, green chilli, baking soda and asafoetida, then serves it with yellow-pea curry or chutneys. Chhattisgarhi bara is a festival snack for celebrations such as Pola, shaped into a ring from split skinless urad dal.

Ingredients: Two Dhals and a Bowl of Aromatics

Chana dhal, de-skinned urad dhal, onion, coriander, spring onions, spices and vegetable oil laid out in separate containers
Keep the two dhals apart until the batter stage; the chutneys are served on the side

Wash the coriander and spring onions well under running water before chopping. The onion, coriander and spring onions all go into the batter and are fried, not scattered on raw at the end.

Equipment

  • 2 bowls for soaking
  • Food processor
  • Large mixing bowl
  • Measuring cup with ml markings and measuring spoons, including a 20 ml tablespoon
  • Small saucepan or kadhai, deep and stable
  • Cooking thermometer
  • Slotted spoon
  • Plate lined with paper towels

Choosing Dhals and Seasonings for Bara

Try an Indian grocer. It helps to search for these English names, or show them to the staff: chana dal, split yellow peas and de-skinned urad dal. Measure the dhals and salt by volume.

Each substitution changes the dish, so swap carefully:

Ingredient Notes on substitutes
Chana dhal Whole chickpeas and soybeans give a different result
De-skinned urad dhal Whole, skin-on urad soaks and eats differently. If you can't find de-skinned, ask at the shop
Baking powder Use baking powder, not baking soda
Ground ginger and garlic Fresh ginger and garlic don't swap in at equal measure
Fennel seed Keep the fennel; cumin is already in the batter
Vegetable oil Ordinary vegetable oil is right; mustard oil would take the dish somewhere else
Allergies

This recipe contains legumes. Check the labels on anything you buy, including spices and chutney, for allergens and cross-contact.

Frying Bara Safely and Fixing Problems

:::warning Frying safety This guidance comes from Japanese public safety bodies (Nishinomiya City Fire Bureau and NITE). It is general advice on oil fires, not specific to this recipe.

  • Watch the temperature. Cooking oil ignites at about 700°F (340–370°C) and can catch fire within minutes of being put on the heat. The 275°F (140°C) target is far below that, but confirm it with a thermometer and never leave oil unattended on high heat.
  • Stay with the pan. Don't walk away while frying. If you must leave, turn off the heat first.
  • Don't fry in too little oil. A small amount heats up very quickly. Use a deep, stable pan and follow its manual on oil quantity.
  • On an induction cooktop, use the frying mode and a suitable pan, and never a pan with a warped base.
  • Don't count on an overheat sensor. Keep watching the oil anyway.
  • Keep water out of the oil. It makes the oil spit.
  • If the oil catches fire, never pour water on it. The water vaporizes suddenly, throwing burning oil and spreading the fire. While the fire is small, use an extinguisher from a distance, aiming to cover the surface of the oil.

Most problems come back to two things: water and oil temperature. Keep the batter thick and use a thermometer, and you avoid most of what's below.

Problem Likely reason What to do
Batter sticks to your hands Hands are dry Wet your hands only. Water mixed into the batter makes pieces more likely to fall apart
Batter feels loose Too much soaking water went in during grinding Next time, add soaking water only if needed, and only a little
Oil temperature falls Too many pieces went in at once Fry 4 or 5 pieces at a time and let the thermometer guide the heat
Oil splashes Batter was dropped in, or water got into the oil Slide pieces in gently and shake the water off your hands first
Unsure of the oil temperature No thermometer Use one. You can't reliably judge 275°F (140°C) by the look of the oil

Serving and Adjusting Bara

Serve the bara warm with chilli chutney on the side. The chutney is optional, so the rings can also go out on their own.

To try a smaller batch first, scale every ingredient down in the same proportion, for example to half. For milder or hotter bara, change the amount of ground green chilli.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use my usual measuring cup and spoons?

Check their size first. This recipe uses a 250 ml cup and a 20 ml tablespoon. A Japanese cup, for example, holds 200 ml and a Japanese tablespoon 15 ml. The safest approach is to measure by the ml markings and use a 20 ml spoon for shaping.

What temperature should the oil be, and for how long do I fry?

Keep the oil at 275°F (140°C) and fry for about 2–3 minutes on each side, until golden brown. Your pan and the size of each batch change the result, so watch both the thermometer and the color.

Do I need a kadhai?

A small saucepan or kadhai works, and so does any deep, stable pan you already own. A cooking thermometer matters more.

Sources

  • SBS Food, "Bara," recipe by Roshilla Singh. The recipe used in this article: ingredients, Australian measures, soaking, shaping, frying temperature and times, yield, serving, and its introduction as a canapé at weddings, Hindu festivals and casual dinner parties. It is an Australian recipe source, not evidence of a single pan-Indian recipe. https://www.sbs.com.au/food/recipe/bara/qdm04oiia
  • Simmy's Spices & Flavours, "BARA." A personal recipe blog, cited only as an example of a different India-tagged bara with urad dal and semolina. Not combined with the recipe above. https://www.simmysspicesandflavors.com/2013/05/bara.html
  • Desi Food Khazana, "Chhattisgarhi Bara." Cited only as an example of a separately named regional version, a ring-shaped festival snack of split skinless urad dal associated with celebrations such as Pola. https://desifoodkhazana.com/recipes/chhattisgarhi-bara
  • Nishinomiya City Fire Bureau, "天ぷら油火災の注意" (Cautions on cooking-oil fires, in Japanese). General guidance on ignition temperature, not leaving the pan, the danger of small amounts of oil, the limits of overheat devices, not using water, and using an extinguisher. https://www.nishi.or.jp/kurashi/anshin/shobokyoku/kasaiyobo/konrokasai/tenpura-chui.html
  • NITE Product Safety Center, "IH調理器の事故(天ぷら油の過熱・発火)" (Induction cooktop accidents: overheating and ignition of frying oil, in Japanese). Staying with the pan, using the specified amount of oil, avoiding warped pans, and using the frying mode and a suitable pan on induction. Parts of it don't apply directly to gas burners. https://www.nite.go.jp/data/000080063.pdf