Karjalanpaisti: Karelian Hot Pot of Pork and Beef Slow-Baked with Onions

Karjalanpaisti of pork and beef stewed in an earthenware pot, served with mashed potatoes and pickles
Prep
20 min
Cook
3 hr 55 min
Total
4 hr 15 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Finnish (Karelian)

Karjalanpaisti, the meat stew of Karelia in eastern Finland, made with pork shoulder, beef shank, plenty of onions, allspice and bay leaf: its bread-oven origin, why the onions fry for 40 minutes, 3 hours at 120°C, and checking the pork is cooked.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Fry the onions for 40 minutes

Frying thinly sliced onions in a heavy pot until brown
Color them over high heat, then drop to medium and take 40 minutes to reach a deep brown

Put 1 tbsp vegetable oil in a heavy lidded pot and fry the sliced onions over high heat. If using star anise, add it here. When the onions start to turn golden, drop to medium heat and keep frying for about 40 minutes, stirring from the bottom every few minutes so they don't scorch. The onions are ready when they have softened to a deep brown and a sweet aroma rises. If the bottom threatens to scorch, add 2 tbsp water and scrape up the stuck-on savoriness.

STEP22 / 6

Cube the meat and sear it

about 15 min

Searing cubed pork and beef in a skillet in small batches until browned
Sear in small batches over high heat, browning only the surface deeply

While the onions fry, cut the pork shoulder and beef shank each into 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes. Heat 1 tbsp vegetable oil in a skillet over high heat and sear the meat in several batches rather than all at once. Keep each batch to an amount where the pieces don't touch, and cook 2–3 minutes per side until each is deeply browned. You don't need to cook it through. Putting in a lot at once drops the temperature, the meat releases water and it stews instead of browning.

STEP33 / 6

Combine the meat and spices in the pot

about 5 min

Putting the seared meat, allspice and bay leaves into the onion pot and pouring in water
Pour in just enough water to cover the meat, bring to a boil once on the stove and then put on the lid

Preheat the oven to 120°C (250°F). Move the seared meat to the onion pot and add 10 allspice berries, 2 bay leaves and 1 tbsp salt. Scrape the pan juices left in the skillet with a little water and add them to the pot. Pour in water until it just covers the meat (about 800 ml) and bring to a boil over medium heat. When the surface bubbles, lightly skim off the foam and put on the lid.

STEP44 / 6

Stew in a 250°F (120°C) oven for 2 and a half hours

Putting the covered heavy pot into a 120°C oven to stew
Stew quietly at 120°C and check the liquid once at about 1 hour

Put the covered pot in the oven and stew at 250°F (120°C) for 2 and a half hours. After about 1 hour, lift the lid and check that the meat isn't sticking out far above the liquid. If the liquid has reduced and the upper half of the meat looks dry, add about ½ cup (100 ml) hot water. Aim for a quiet simmer, where the surface only trembles slightly.

STEP55 / 6

Add the carrots and stew 30 minutes more

Adding carrots to the finished pot and checking the tenderness of the meat with a spoon
Done when a skewer goes into the carrots and the beef breaks apart with a spoon

After 2 and a half hours, take out the pot, add the carrots cut into 1 inches (2 cm) cubes and the rosemary, and push them down lightly. Put the lid on and return it to the oven for another 30 minutes. It is done when a bamboo skewer slides easily into the carrots and the beef shank breaks apart when pressed with a spoon. If the meat is still firm, extend by 30 minutes at a time and check. At the end, put a thermometer into the largest piece of pork and check that the center reaches 167°F (75°C) and holds it for at least 1 minute. Taste, and add a pinch of salt if it needs it.

STEP66 / 6

Make the mashed potatoes and plate

about 25 min

Karjalanpaisti served beside mashed potatoes with cucumber pickles
Let the mashed potatoes soak up the broth and add sour pickles

Make the side dish in the last 30 minutes of stewing. Peel 1.25 lb (600 g) potatoes and quarter them, put them in a pot with enough water to cover and a little salt over medium heat, and boil for about 15 minutes after it boils, until a bamboo skewer slides in easily. Drain, shake the pot over low heat for about 1 minute to drive off moisture, then mash, adding 20 g butter and warmed milk little by little to make a smooth purée. Put mashed potatoes on a plate, spoon plenty of meat and broth over them and add pickles.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Pork shoulder (in a piece) 1 lb (500 g) Pork shoulder loin also works. Cut into 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes
Beef shank (in a piece) 1 lb (500 g) Local recipes use beef cheek. Beef chuck for stewing also works. Cut into 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes
Onions 5 large Thinly sliced
Carrots 2 Cut into 1 inches (2 cm) cubes
Allspice (whole) 10 berries 1/2 tsp if ground
Bay leaves 2 Dried is fine
Rosemary 1 sprig It can be made without
Star anise 1 Optional. Fry with the onions
Salt 1 tbsp Slightly more is fine if coarse salt
Vegetable oil 2 tbsp Divided between the onions and the meat
Water About 3¼ cups (800 ml) Enough to cover the meat. Varies with the size of the pot
2 / 2

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Potatoes 1.25 lb (600 g) Made into mashed potatoes
Butter 20 g For the mashed potatoes
Milk ½ cup (100 ml) For the mashed potatoes. Adjust for thickness
Cucumber pickles As needed (for 1 person, 2–3 slices) Even better if you have lactic-fermented pickles
0 / 0

The big stone oven that baked the bread first thing in the morning kept the whole house warm long afterward. In Karelia, in eastern Finland, one oven did both jobs. Once the fire had died and only the heat remained, an earthenware pot of meat, onions, whole spices and water went in. By evening the meat was tender enough to fall apart under a spoon. This is karjalanpaisti, a meat stew cooked in the oven's residual heat. The seasoning is astonishingly plain, just salt, allspice and bay leaf, yet meat and onions cooked for hours give a broth of deep flavor. At home, a heavy lidded pot that can go in the oven stands in for the bread oven.

Karjalanpaisti, the oven stew of Karelia

An earthenware pot being put into the stone oven of an old Finnish farmhouse to stew

Karelia is the easternmost region of Finland, bordering Russia. Karjalanpaisti is one of its best-known dishes, alongside karjalanpiirakka, the rye pastry filled with rice porridge. In Karelian it is called päččiliha, and in Finnish-speaking Karelia people often just say "paisti (stew)" or "uunipaisti (oven stew)." The pot has its own names, uuniruukku or pata, both meaning a deep pot that goes into the oven.

When meat was precious, this stew was a dish for celebration days and a harvest-season feast. As meat became easier to get in the 20th century, it turned into everyday food all over Finland.

Good to know

In 2007, readers voted karjalanpaisti Finland's "national dish." In a vote held in autumn 2016, it came in second after rye bread.


Ingredients (serves 4)

Ingredients: pork shoulder, beef shank, onions, carrots, allspice, bay leaves and rosemary laid out

Stew

Side dishes

Allspice is a spice whose single berry has an aroma like cinnamon, clove and nutmeg together, and in Finland it is called maustepippuri ("spice pepper"). The ground form is easier to find in a supermarket spice aisle, but for this stew whole berries suit it. Over 3 hours of simmering, the aroma comes out gradually, and it doesn't cloud the broth the way ground does.

Tip

Beef shank is sometimes sold diced as "for curry and stew" at supermarkets. It has a lot of sinew, but the longer it simmers, the more the sinew melts and loosens, so it actually suits this dish. For pork, choosing the fatty shoulder keeps it from drying out.

Choosing the meat and spices for karjalanpaisti

Differences in the ingredients of stews combining pork, beef, lamb and root vegetables, laid side by side

Use more than one kind of meat. Pork and beef are the basis, and some households add moose (elk) or lamb. Stewed together, they give you the richness of pork fat and the firm fibers of beef in the same pot. Any cut will do, and game works too. Root vegetables such as carrots and onions can go in as you like.

There is no fixed formula for the spices either. Some households use only allspice, others whole black peppercorns, others add bay leaf, and all are accepted as Karelian flavor.

Good to know

Allspice, the star of karjalanpaisti, is made by drying the berries of a myrtle-family tree native to the Caribbean and Central America. A spice from that far south, carried here by trade, sets the aroma of a stew in northern Karelia.


How to make karjalanpaisti

Prep takes about 20 minutes. Slice the onions and cube the meat. If you sear the meat during the 40 minutes the onions are frying and heat the oven meanwhile, nothing is wasted. Once it goes in the oven, it takes almost no effort for 3 hours.

Caution

Heat the center of the pork at 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute. Even fresh pork can cause food poisoning or hepatitis E virus infection if the inside isn't heated thoroughly. A whitish center is a sign, but for large pieces, a thermometer is more reliable.

Tip

If you don't have an oven, or can't use it for a long time, you can stew the same length of time in a heavy pot on very low heat. The bottom scorches more easily, so stir gently from the bottom every 30 minutes, and add hot water if the liquid has reduced.

Tip

Karjalanpaisti is a stew whose flavor settles better after a night. When it cools, the fat sets white on the surface, so if that bothers you, remove it before reheating.

Serving and variations

A Finnish home table with mashed potatoes, karjalanpaisti and pickles
Eat it letting the mashed potatoes soak up the broth

With mashed potatoes and sour pickles

Karjalanpaisti is served with smooth mashed potatoes and lactic-fermented pickles. The broth isn't thickened, so the potatoes soak it up on the plate and do the work of a sauce. Then a bite of sour pickle makes the richness of the fat clear away at once; the acidity lightens meat that has cooked for hours.

Ordinary cucumber pickles are fine at home. If you can find lactic-fermented cucumber or cabbage pickles, you'll be closer to the way it's eaten locally.

The plain oven method

This recipe takes a few extra steps compared with the traditional way: the onions fry for 40 minutes, the meat is browned, and rosemary goes in at the end. The plainest version puts only meat, whole raw onions, peppercorns, salt and, if you like, bay leaf into the pot, with water to cover. The surface sears at 425°F (225°C), then the oven drops to 300°F (150°C) for 3 hours in total; check early on that there is enough liquid. The flavor is milder, but the effort is far less, so it's a good choice on busy days. Each household's version grew out of these everyday ways of using the oven's leftover heat.

For another gentle, northern-style Finnish dish, try lohikeitto, which simmers salmon and potatoes in milk.

Frequently asked questions

Putting a thermometer into a piece of pork stewed in a heavy pot to check the center temperature

Can I make it with only pork, or only beef?

You can, but combining two or more meats is the basis of this dish. Pork alone comes out fattier and softer, beef alone lighter. Either way, make sure the center of the pork reaches 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute.

What can I use if I don't have allspice?

10 whole black peppercorns can stand in, and some Finnish households use black pepper anyway. The aroma changes, but the meat and onions still carry the flavor.

Can I shorten the stewing time?

You can with a pressure cooker, though the texture differs a little from meat whose fibers loosen slowly in the oven. Set the pressure time according to the instruction manual, and check the center temperature of the pork at the end.

Can I make it ahead?

Yes. The flavor settles overnight, so it suits making the day before. Cool it slightly, refrigerate, and eat it promptly. When reheating, heat until the center is thoroughly hot.

Are there allergy ingredients to watch for?

The stew itself contains no major allergens, but the mashed potatoes use butter and milk (dairy). To avoid dairy, loosen the potatoes with their cooking water and olive oil instead.

Sources