Mpanatigghi: Modica's Chocolate Pastry Filled with Beef

Sicilian mpanatigghi from Modica on a plate with espresso
Prep
55 min
Cook
28 min
Total
1 hr 23 min
Serves
12 pieces
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Italian

A recipe for Sicilian mpanatigghi from Modica, made in a home kitchen. Covers the background of this meat-filled chocolate pastry, cooking the beef, closing the thin dough, substitutes for Modica chocolate, the almond and spice mix, preventing open seams, storage, and serving with espresso.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Bring the dough together and rest

15 min, plus 30 min chilling

Combining flour, cold butter, egg, and Marsala in a bowl to bring the dough together
Do not knead too much; refrigerate the dough to rest once it holds when pressed with the fingers

In a bowl, mix 9 oz (250 g) flour, 1.5 oz (40 g) raw cane sugar, and 2 g salt, and add 3.25 oz (90 g) cold unsalted butter in 0.5-inch (1 cm) cubes. Crush the butter with your fingertips, and when the flour looks like coarse breadcrumbs, add 1 egg and 2.5 tbsp (40 ml) Marsala. While some dry flour still shows, add 2 tsp (10 ml) cold water, and press with the palm 3 to 4 times to bring it into one mass. Kneading until the surface is smooth makes the baked pastry hard, so shape it into a disc that still has a few cracks, wrap in plastic, and rest it in the refrigerator for 30 minutes.

STEP22 / 7

Cook the ground meat fine

8 min

Breaking up and cooking lean ground beef finely in a skillet
Cook the meat over medium heat to drive off moisture until the red is gone and it is a fine crumble

Put 1 tsp olive oil in a small skillet, warm it over medium heat for 30 seconds, and spread in 4 oz (120 g) lean ground beef. Cook for 4 minutes, pressing with a wooden spoon, and when the red is gone, lower to low heat and keep moving it for 2 more minutes. It is time to stop when the meat pieces are fine, about 3 to 5 mm, in a loose crumble with no liquid collecting on the bottom of the pan and a toasty smell rising. If a lot of fat comes out, spread it on paper towel for 5 minutes to cool and take off only the extra fat.

STEP33 / 7

Make the chocolate filling

10 min

Mixing chopped chocolate, cooked beef, almonds, cinnamon, and citrus zest into a dense filling
The filling should hold together like wet sand and keep its shape when pressed with a spoon

Chop 3.25 oz (90 g) dark chocolate into pieces of about 0.25 inch (5 mm), and chop 2 oz (60 g) almonds coarsely with a knife. In a bowl, put the chocolate, almonds, 1.5 oz (40 g) raw cane sugar, 10 g cocoa powder, 1/3 crushed cinnamon stick, 0.2 g ground cloves, zest of 1/2 fruit, and 1 g salt. Add the still-warm meat and mix for 30 seconds, and when the corners of the chocolate have rounded a little, add 1 oz (30 g) egg white and 1 tbsp Marsala and bring it together until even. Check that it is around 95°F (35°C), a little below body temperature. It should feel like wet sand: a spoonful pressed down holds its shape in a mound without crumbling.

STEP44 / 7

Roll the dough thin and cut

12 min

Rolling the rested dough thin and cutting with a round cutter
Roll the dough 2 mm thick and cut 12 circles 12 cm across

Sprinkle about 2 tsp of the 20 g dusting flour onto the work surface and divide the dough in half. Roll with the pin from the center outward to a thickness of 0.125 inch (2 mm), with a smooth surface and no large cracks. Cut 6 circles with a 4.5-inch (12 cm) ring cutter, and roll the rest the same way for 12 in total. Gather the trimmings only once, press lightly, and rest 5 minutes before rolling. Re-kneading many times shrinks the pastry when baked and makes the edge open easily.

STEP55 / 7

Fill and seal the edge

15 min

Placing the chocolate and meat filling on a round of dough and closing it into a half-moon
Keep the filling toward the center, leave an 8 mm border, and close into a half-moon

Put 20 g filling in the center of one round of dough, leaving a 0.375-inch (8 mm) border. Wet a fingertip with water and trace around the edge, then fold the dough in half and close it, pushing the air out. Press the edge about 0.125 inch (4 mm) with the tip of a fork, leaving marks of the same depth to the end of the half-moon. Poke 2 small holes about 0.25 inch (5 mm) long in the surface with a bamboo skewer. Without holes the steam cannot escape while baking, and the filling tends to seep out from the side.

STEP66 / 7

Bake at 350°F (180°C)

18 to 20 min

Arranging the filled half-moon mpanatigghi on a baking sheet and putting them into the oven
Bake in a 180°C oven until the edges are a light golden brown

Preheat the oven to 350°F (180°C). Line the baking sheet with parchment and arrange the sealed mpanatigghi 1 inch (2 cm) apart. If you have egg white left, thin it with 1 tsp water and brush the surface very thinly. Bake on the middle rack at 350°F (180°C) for 18 minutes, until the edges and bottoms are a light golden brown and the surface is dry and the dough does not keep denting when pressed lightly. If the color is pale, add 2 minutes, and take them out before they turn dark brown. Do not go above 400°F (200°C), so the bitterness of the chocolate does not stand out too much.

STEP77 / 7

Cool and dust with powdered sugar

25 min

Cooling the baked mpanatigghi on a rack, dusting with powdered sugar, and showing the cross-section
As they cool, the filling settles and the layers of chocolate, meat, and almonds come together

When baked, leave them on the tray for 5 minutes, and once they no longer break easily, move them to a rack. Cool on the rack for 20 minutes, and when steam has left the center and the filling has set, dust with 15 g powdered sugar through a tea strainer. It has worked if, when broken open, the chocolate does not run and fine meat and almonds are evenly scattered through the dark filling. After they have cooled completely and then rested another hour, sweetness, spice, and the toastiness of the meat blend better than when freshly baked.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Dough

Ingredient Amount How to choose
All-purpose (soft) flour 9 oz (250g) Prepare another 20 g separately for dusting
Raw cane sugar 1.5 oz (40g) Granulated sugar also works
Salt 2g Tightens the sweetness of the dough
Unsalted butter 3.25 oz (90g) Cut into 0.5-inch (1 cm) cubes and chill in the refrigerator
Egg 1, about 1.75 oz (50 g) For the dough. Take out of the refrigerator and rest 10 minutes
Marsala 2.5 tbsp (40ml) Semi-dry or dry is easier to handle than sweet
Cold water 2 tsp (10ml) Add only as the dough needs it
2 / 2

Chocolate and meat filling

Ingredient Amount How to choose
Lean ground beef 4 oz (120g) Low in fat. Lean beef is better than a pork-beef mix
Olive oil 1 tsp, 4 g For cooking the meat
Dark chocolate 3.25 oz (90g) Around 70% cacao. Avoid sweet milk-style bars
Almonds 2 oz (60g) Unsalted, dry-roasted. Skin-on also works
Raw cane sugar 1.5 oz (40g) For the filling
Cocoa powder 10g Unsweetened
Cinnamon stick 1/3 stick, about 2 g Crush finely before use. If powder, 1/2 tsp
Ground cloves 0.2g A little under 1/10 tsp. Too much tastes medicinal
Lemon or orange zest from 1/2 fruit Grate, avoiding the white pith
Egg white 1 white, about 1 oz (30 g) Binds the filling
Marsala 1 tbsp, 15 ml Scents the filling
Salt 1g Brings out the bitterness of the chocolate
Powdered sugar 15g To finish
0 / 0

Dust the baked half-moons with powdered sugar and they look like plain little chocolate pies. Break one open, though, and the dark filling holds finely cooked beef, almonds, cinnamon, and citrus zest. It can feel strange at first. But cook the meat well, keep the chocolate from scorching, and let the spices come through, and you get a deep Sicilian pastry, sweet with just a little depth of meat, that pairs well with coffee.

Mpanatigghi and Modica chocolate

Mpanatigghi ('Mpanatigghi / mpanatigghi') are a traditional sweet of Modica in southeastern Sicily: small half-moons of dough wrapped around chocolate, beef or veal, almonds, sugar, and spices, then baked. The Italian spelling is impanatiglie, and locals simply call them "meat sweets." This half-moon of meat and chocolate is specific to Modica.

The town is known for its grainy chocolate. Cioccolato di Modica IGP (PGI) is made by combining cocoa mass and sugar and processing them at low temperature, so sugar crystals stay in the bar and give it a gritty mouthfeel, quite unlike ordinary smooth chocolate. That graininess suits the filling. It isn't a smooth ganache; the meat, nuts, sugar, and cacao each stay a little grainy.

There are several stories about where the sweet came from: hiding meat inside sweet chocolate, a link to the Spanish-era empanada, tales tied to convents and Lent, and the idea that chocolate helped the sweets keep longer. Either way, the pairing of meat and chocolate is bound up with preservation and religious food customs. It works only when Modica's grain, Sicilian citrus, nuts, spices, and thin dough come together. That's when the beef stops being odd and becomes depth.

Other Sicilian sweets go in different directions. Nzuddi are dry sweets made with coarse almonds and citrus that wrap nothing, and their aroma is very different. Look further across southern Europe and you'll find shared threads: the richness of nuts and sugar in baklava, the warm scent of cinnamon in moussaka, and the wrapping culture of empanadas.

Ingredients (makes 12)

This amount makes 12 fairly large half-moons from 4.5-inch (12 cm) circles. They are bigger than the usual small pastry shop size, but they are easier to fill at home, and you can see the filling. For smaller ones, cut 3.5-inch (9 cm) circles and use about 12 g filling each. That makes about 18.

Flour, butter, egg, ground beef, dark chocolate, almonds, cinnamon, and citrus laid out as mpanatigghi ingredients
Mpanatigghi combines the ingredients of a sweet with a small amount of well-cooked beef
Allergens and food safety

This recipe contains wheat, egg, dairy, almonds, beef, and alcohol. The Marsala is cooked, but if you want to avoid alcohol entirely, use 2 tbsp (30 ml) white grape juice and 2 tsp (10 ml) lemon juice in the dough, and 1 tbsp white grape juice in the filling. Because it contains meat, do not leave it long at room temperature. Keep it refrigerated.

Ingredients and tools that give you pause when shopping

Spend your effort on the spices, not the meat or butter. Strongly scented spices are hard to get nearby. You also need a tool to roll the dough thin and even, a cutter for equal sizes, and a brush for a thin layer of egg white. You can start with a high-cacao bar of chocolate, but if the cinnamon is weak, the oddness of "chocolate with meat" comes forward.

Start by getting cinnamon sticks in a small size. Choosing a stable, fragrant one meant for baking and cooking gives the filling a clearer outline than powder alone.

Aim for a rolling pin about 12 inches (30 cm) long and a 4.5-inch (12 cm) ring cutter. Without specialty tools, a clean bottle or the rim of a plate works. For thin, even dough, the right tool makes the edge easier to close.

A brush only applies a thin layer of egg white, so it is a low priority to buy. A folded paper towel is enough at home.

Priority What to prepare What to look for Substitute
High Chocolate around 70% cacao One where cacao aroma comes ahead of sugar Sweet baking chocolate
High Cinnamon stick One with a strong sweet scent when scraped 1/2 tsp ground cinnamon
Medium Rolling pin around 12 inches (30 cm) Easy to roll the dough thin and even Roll with a clean bottle
Medium Ring cutter 4.5 inches (12 cm) across Cuts the same size every time Trace around the rim of a plate about 4.5 inches (12 cm) across
Low Heatproof brush Applies a thin layer of egg Fold a paper towel and apply

Choosing ingredients for mpanatigghi

Local recipes use veal and lard, which can be hard to find. Lean ground beef and unsalted butter work well at home, and Marsala, dark chocolate, almonds, and cinnamon bring the flavor close to the Modica version. Dough made with lard is crumbly and light, as it is locally, but its aroma can be strong. Butter is easier to handle.

Think of the meat as something that adds toastiness and density, not as the star of the filling. A small amount, cooked fine and dry, gets you closer to the real thing than piling more in to make it obvious. For the chocolate, look for bitterness and aroma more than sweetness: a bar of around 70% cacao, chopped. Cinnamon, cloves, and citrus zest, each in small amounts, round off the smell of the meat.

Getting mpanatigghi right

Unlike risotto, where you watch the pot the whole time, mpanatigghi are decided by prep and shaping. Cook the ground meat dry and fine, melt the chocolate over low heat and stop as soon as it begins to melt, then roll the dough thin and seal the edge firmly. Get those three right and even supermarket ingredients will give you something close to a Modica sweet.

Element What to aim for At home
Meat No moisture or fat left, fine enough to blend into the chocolate Dry lean ground beef over medium to low heat
Chocolate Bitterness and aroma over sweetness Chop a bar of around 70% cacao
Spices Cinnamon and citrus to round off the meat Cinnamon, cloves, and citrus zest in small amounts
Dough A half-moon that isn't too thick 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick, 4.5 inches (12 cm) across
Baking Chocolate unscorched, dough only lightly colored 350°F (180°C) for 18 to 20 minutes, no deep browning
What happened Cause How to fix next time
Smell of meat stands out Moisture and fat left in the meat After the red is gone, dry it over low heat for 2 minutes and blot off the fat with paper
Filling runs Chocolate is too hot, too much egg white Cool the meat 5 minutes before mixing, and stop the egg white at 30 g
Dough is hard Overkneaded, trimmings rolled many times Only press it together, and use the trimmings once
Color is dark and bitter Oven temperature too high Keep to the middle rack at 350°F (180°C) and stop before deep brown
Edges open Border too narrow, air left in Leave a 0.375-inch (8 mm) border and let the air out before folding

The most common mistake is adding more meat to "show" it, and the more you add, the more the sweet falls apart. The meat is right when it sits behind the chocolate and almonds as toastiness, so that afterward you think, "Oh, now that you mention it, there is meat."

Storing and serving mpanatigghi

Storage

Because mpanatigghi contain meat, store them with care. Once they're completely cool, wrap each one in parchment, put them in an airtight container, and eat within 3 days refrigerated. Don't leave them out long, even in a cool season; at the table, serve within 2 hours.

To freeze, wrap each one before dusting with powdered sugar, put them in a freezer bag, and keep for about 2 weeks. Move them to the refrigerator the day before. On the day, warm them in a 325°F (160°C) toaster oven for 4 minutes, cool on a rack for 10 minutes, and dust with powdered sugar again, and the edges turn crisp once more. Microwaving alone softens the dough and brings the oil in the filling forward. Whichever way you rewarm them, stop when the center is just slightly soft, not piping hot. That keeps the meat aroma in check and leaves a clean finish of chocolate and citrus.

Serving

Straight from the refrigerator, the butter and chocolate are firm and the aroma is closed. For guests, take them out 30 minutes ahead and let them come to room temperature on a plate, then dust with sugar so the surface stays white and doesn't get damp. If you're serving them cut small, cut just before eating, since the cut face dries quickly.

They're sweet, but the finish carries meat and chocolate, so bitter drinks suit them better than sweet, milky ones: unsweetened espresso, strong tea, or a dry-leaning Marsala. After a meal, one per person is plenty.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it without meat?

Without meat it's still a chocolate-and-almond half-moon, but it loses much of what makes it mpanatigghi, so think of it as a different sweet. To get closer to the density, add 20 g toasted almonds and 5 g cocoa powder.

Can I use pork or a pork-beef mix instead of beef?

Lean ground beef is easiest to handle. Pork and mixed ground meat have more fat, and the fat flavor lingers once cool. If you use them, choose lean cuts and blot off the fat thoroughly with paper after cooking.

Can't I make it without Modica chocolate?

You can. Modica chocolate gets the grain and aroma closer, but it can be hard to find. Chop dark chocolate of around 70% cacao fine, then add grain with cocoa powder and almonds. It works well as a home version.

What can substitute for Marsala?

In the dough, use 2.5 tbsp (35 ml) white wine and 5 g honey. In the filling, use 1 tbsp white wine. To avoid alcohol, use white grape juice and lemon juice. The aroma is lighter, but if you work in the chocolate, cinnamon, and citrus carefully, the flavor still holds together.

What does done look like?

The edges and bottom of the dough are a light golden brown, and the surface is dry but not deep brown. Break one open: the filling shouldn't run, the chocolate should hold together dark, and the bits of meat and almond should look even. The aroma settles better once they've cooled than straight from the oven.

Sources