Chickpea Fatteh: The Levantine Breakfast of Pita, Chickpeas and Garlic Yogurt

Fatteh: toasted pita topped with warm chickpeas, yogurt sauce and pine nuts
Prep
15 min
Cook
10 min
Total
25 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Levantine

A Levantine breakfast, fatteh, made with chickpeas, pita, yogurt and tahini. Differences between the tables of Lebanon, Jordan and Damascus, how to layer without losing the crunch of the bread, substitutes, how to toast pine nuts without scorching, fixes when it goes wrong, and storage.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Cut the pita small, dry it and toast it

Pita cut into 2 cm squares baking on a tray, the edges lightly colored and drying
Dry the pita through the center, not only the surface, so a little crunch remains even under the yogurt

Cut 2 pitas into about 1 inch (2 cm) squares and bake in a 400°F (200°C) oven for 8 to 10 minutes, or in a dry frying pan over medium-low heat for 5 to 8 minutes. Turn once partway, and stop when the edges are light golden and the pieces are dry through the center and make a light sound. Do not bake until black. Frying works too, but at home, bake without oil to dry the surface. Thick naan or similar breads get heavy once they take up the yogurt, so avoid them.

STEP22 / 5

Warm the chickpeas with cooking liquid and cumin

Quietly warming chickpeas with a little cooking liquid and cumin in a small pot
Do not boil the chickpeas; leave a small amount of liquid that will not run too much when spooned over the bread

Put 11.5 oz (330 g) cooked chickpeas, ¼ cup (80 ml) cooking liquid or hot water, 1 g cumin and part of the 2 g salt in a small pot. Warm over medium-low heat for 5 to 7 minutes, until steaming. Do not boil; boiling breaks the beans down too much, so warm them gently. They are ready when they are soft when pressed with a spoon, coated in a thin film of liquid, with a little liquid left at the bottom of the pot. Hot beans, a little liquid. If they dry out, add liquid 1 tbsp at a time. Too much makes the bread soggy quickly.

STEP33 / 5

Smooth the yogurt and tahini sauce

Whisking yogurt smooth with tahini, garlic and lemon
Do not boil the yogurt sauce; whisk until thick enough to cover the bread

Take 1 lb (500 g) yogurt out of the refrigerator and leave it about 15 minutes. Crush 2 cloves garlic with a little salt and add, then 1 oz (30 g) tahini, 1.5 tbsp (20 ml) lemon juice and the remaining salt. Whisk until whitish and even. It should flow thickly off a spoon and cover the bread. If it is stiff, add chickpea cooking liquid 1 tsp at a time. If the garlic is too strong, dilute it with 2 more tbsp yogurt. Never boil the yogurt. If you warm it, stir constantly over very low heat and stop once it is lukewarm.

STEP44 / 5

Toast the pine nuts over low heat

Pine nuts moved over low heat in ghee, beginning to turn pale golden
Take the pine nuts off the heat when the color begins, so no bitterness comes out

Put 1 oz (28 g) unsalted butter or ghee and 1 oz (30 g) pine nuts in a small frying pan and keep them moving with a wooden spoon over low heat for 2 to 3 minutes. The point is to stop the heat at a pale golden color. The color keeps deepening from residual heat, so do not wait for dark brown. Do not return scorched, bitter pine nuts to the dish; toast a new batch. If you replace them with almonds, use slices and watch the color over low heat the same way.

STEP55 / 5

Layer on the plate and pour over hot fat

Layering toasted pita, warm chickpeas and yogurt sauce, and finishing with pine nuts and hot ghee poured over
Keeping the layers intact, pour on the pine nuts and hot fat and eat right away

Spread the toasted pita on a shallow wide plate. Put the warm chickpeas on with a little of their liquid, and cover with the yogurt sauce. Spoon over the pine nuts and the hot butter or ghee left in the pan, and scatter parsley and sumac. Do not mix it all in. Eat by scooping through the layers. The bread should have taken up just a little liquid, with a crisp part left in the center. The longer it sits, the more the bread soaks up yogurt and liquid, and the contrast fades. Carry it to the table as soon as it is finished.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Bread and chickpeas

Ingredient Amount Substitutes and notes
Cooked chickpeas (drained weight) 11.5 oz (330 g) Cook from dried, or use canned and check the drained weight on the label
Chickpea cooking liquid or hot water ½ cup (100 ml) Divided between warming the beans and what goes to the bread
Pita or thin Arabic bread about 4 oz (120 g) (2 sheets) Thin flatbread can substitute. Thick bread absorbs moisture easily
Ground cumin 1 g (1/2 tsp) Used when warming the beans. Add more a little at a time for stronger aroma
Salt 2 g For the beans. Adjust at the end together with the salt in the yogurt sauce
2 / 3

Yogurt sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes and notes
Plain yogurt (unsweetened) 1 lb (500 g) Full-fat gives body. Low-fat is lighter
Tahini 1 oz (30 g) (2 tbsp) White sesame paste can substitute. Contains sesame, so check the label
Garlic 2 cloves (about 8–10 g) Crush with a little salt. Start with 1 clove for a milder bite
Lemon juice 1.5 tbsp (20 ml) Adjust the acidity within 1–2 tbsp
Salt 2 g Add at the end according to the salt in the tahini and bread
3 / 3

Finish

Ingredient Amount Substitutes and notes
Pine nuts 1 oz (30 g) (3 tbsp) Sliced almonds can substitute. Aroma and texture change
Unsalted butter or ghee 1 oz (28 g) (2 tbsp) Olive oil gives a lighter result
Parsley 10 g Chopped. It only adds aroma at the end, so it can be omitted
Sumac 1 g (1/2 tsp) Not essential. Adds a dry acidity different from lemon
0 / 0

At the old hummus and foul shops of Damascus, fatteh is served from early morning until around noon, and you will rarely find it on an evening menu because the pot is empty before midday. Making it starts with crumbling bread by hand and laying it across the bottom of the plate. Warm whole chickpeas go on top, then yogurt beaten with garlic and tahini, then hot fat and pine nuts. You get toasted bread crunching at the bottom, soft beans in the middle and smooth, tangy yogurt on top, and layering three textures on one plate is what this dish is about.

Chickpea fatteh across the Levant

Chickpea fatteh (فتّة) is Levantine food, eaten across Syria, Lebanon, Palestine and Jordan. In Jordan, falafel and hummus are on the breakfast menu, including on Fridays, and falafel shops sell fatteh hummus too. The name stays the same from place to place, but the habits change. It might come from a breakfast shop's pot or be served on a family's large platter.

Good to know

Fatte and fatta come from a word for breaking bread, that is, for crumbs. The homestyle way is to bake or fry old pita or bread that has sat for a few days.

Damascus tables offer a much wider range of toppings. Alongside the chickpea version there's an eggplant fatteh (fattet makdous), meat versions, and a heavy Damascus version with lamb's feet, plus chicken, shrimp and vegetarian eggplant versions. The layering order stays the same in every one: bread at the bottom, then the topping, then yogurt, and finally hot fat and nuts.

Region or name Form of the dish Place at the table What to keep at home
Lebanon's chickpea fatte Fried or toasted pita, warm chickpeas, yogurt, tahini, nuts Breakfast. Also easy to assemble for iftar and suhoor during Ramadan The crisp bread layer, garlic yogurt, nuts at the end
Jordan's fattet hummus Layers of pita, tahini, yogurt and pine nuts or almonds Eaten at breakfast shops and falafel shops Keep the chickpeas warm and layer the ingredients on the plate
Damascus fatteh Besides the chickpea version, versions with eggplant, meat and lamb's feet Served from morning to before noon at old hummus and foul shops Even if you change the topping, put bread at the bottom, yogurt on top and hot fat last
Home chickpea version Toast dry or leftover bread and combine with beans and yogurt Breakfast for a few people, late breakfast, a light meal Assemble right before eating and do not leave the bread under liquid for long

The chickpeas in fatteh stay whole and warm. That sets it apart from Lebanese hummus, where the beans become a smooth paste, and from balila, where warm whole beans are eaten with seasonings but without the bread and yogurt. All three start with the same bean and end up as very different plates.


Ingredients (serves 4)

This table makes 4 servings, based on 11.5 oz (330 g) of drained cooked chickpeas. If using dried beans, soak them the day before, cook until soft and keep a little of the cooking liquid. For canned, check the drained amount on the label and, if short, adjust to the same drained weight. Use bread with no moisture left after toasting, and plain, unsweetened yogurt. Match the beans by drained weight and the bread by how dry it is, and you will get closer to the same plate each time. Cumin, tahini and sumac are listed under their common names.

Fatteh ingredients: chickpeas, pita, yogurt, tahini, garlic, lemon, cumin, sumac and pine nuts
Prepare the bread and chickpeas, the yogurt sauce and the pine nut finish separately
Tip

The easiest to gather at a nearby store are yogurt, chickpeas, lemon, garlic, butter and bread. What is most worth seeking at an import grocer or online is tahini, sumac, cumin and pine nuts, and tahini in particular gives the sauce its viscosity and sesame aroma at once. If you are going to buy something, start with tahini.

Caution

The basic form contains wheat (pita), dairy (yogurt, butter or ghee), sesame (tahini) and tree nuts (pine nuts). Store-bought bread, tahini, ghee and nuts can contain other ingredients such as soy, so check each product's label. If you are allergic to dairy, sesame, wheat or tree nuts, do not treat a substitution as the same dish. Skip it if you cannot eat the ingredients.

Choosing ingredients for chickpea fatteh

The base of the dish is bread, chickpeas, yogurt, garlic, tahini, and the fat and nuts that go on last. If Arabic bread is hard to find, toast a thin flatbread instead. Thick bread, or bread that's only lightly toasted, soaks up the yogurt quickly and makes the plate heavier than the Levantine original. You can use dried chickpeas you cook yourself or canned ones. Either way, aim for 11.5 oz (330 g) drained cooked weight the first time.

Some fatteh recipes leave out tahini. Without it the sauce is lighter and you lose the lingering sesame note. White sesame paste can stand in, but it changes the aroma, viscosity and bitterness, and brands differ in salt, sugar and oil, so adjust the salt last. Sumac isn't essential, but a small amount adds a dry, fruity acidity, while lemon on its own gives a sourness that's flatter and more direct.

For the finish, sliced almonds can replace pine nuts, swapping their oily fragrance for a brighter crunch. Unsalted butter or olive oil can replace ghee. Olive oil is lighter, and butter or ghee carries the nutty aroma better. The last few minutes of layering matter most, because the time you spend layering at the end decides texture before flavor. Have everything ready so you can move through them without stopping.

Method

With cooked or canned chickpeas, plan on about 25 minutes. Soaking and cooking dried beans takes separate time. The bread and pine nuts can be made ahead, but assemble the plate right before serving. Until you layer, protect the four components separately. Prepare the bread, beans, sauce and nuts each on their own, and layer them together at the end.

Tip

Finish the bread, beans, yogurt sauce and nuts separately first. If someone is carrying the plate to the table, keep the bread and beans apart until just before plating, and hand over the yogurt and nuts last. Do not take photos or start cleaning up after the sauce goes on; eat right after plating. Fatteh is not a make-ahead dish; it is completed on the final plate.

Common chickpea fatteh problems and fixes

When a plate goes wrong, the cause is almost always one of five things: how long the bread was toasted, how much cooking liquid went with the beans, the temperature of the yogurt, the heat under the pine nuts, or how long the plate sat between assembling and eating. You can usually spot it by looking at dryness, thickness, color and steam. Fix the state of the layers, not the seasoning. Piling on more lemon or salt won't solve any of these.

Symptom Why it happened How to restore
The bread went soft quickly Underbaked, too much liquid, or time passed after assembling Toast fresh 1 inch (2 cm) squares and add a small amount on top right before eating. Next time reduce the liquid to 1 tbsp at a time and layer at the very end
The chickpeas are dry and powdery No cooking liquid used when warming Return to the small pot, add 1–2 tbsp cooking liquid or hot water and warm over low heat 2–3 minutes. Bring back to where they crush under a spoon
The yogurt sauce is grainy Mixed cold, or heated strongly Remove from heat and return to room temperature; add plain yogurt 1 tbsp at a time and mix. If it separated from boiling, make a new sauce
Garlic too strong The sharpness of crushed garlic rose over time Dilute with 2 tbsp yogurt and adjust salt and lemon last
Pine nuts are bitter Heat too high, not moved, or toasted to a dark color Do not use the scorched ones; toast new pine nuts over low heat. Take the pan off the heat at pale golden

Soggy bread is the most common complaint, and the best fix is to assemble at the last moment. Narrow the fix to one place, so next time you'll know what made the difference.

Serving, storing and varying chickpea fatteh

Serving

Fatteh is at its best when the beans are warm, the yogurt has lost its chill, and the bread still crackles. Serve it as soon as it's assembled, with any extra sauce on the side so everyone can add more. At breakfast it shares the table with falafel and hummus. Get it from the stove to the table quickly so the first spoonful still crunches.

Storage

Once assembled, fatteh doesn't keep, because the bread drinks up the liquid. Store the parts separately instead. Keep the chickpeas and the yogurt sauce in their own containers in the refrigerator, and the toasted bread in a dry container. If you want to freeze anything, freeze only the chickpeas, never the yogurt sauce or the toasted bread. Treat the times in the table as a guide, check them against your refrigerator's temperature and the product labels, and don't leave anything at room temperature for long.

What to store How to store How to use the next day
Cooked chickpeas Airtight in the refrigerator with a little cooking liquid. Keep for 2 days Warm in a small pot over low heat, adding a little liquid if dry
Yogurt sauce Airtight in the refrigerator. Keep for 2 days Leave at room temperature about 15 minutes, then check the smoothness
Toasted pita Keep in a dry container away from moisture Check that the crisp part remains; re-toast if damp
Pine nuts and butter or ghee Use the toasted nuts the same day If the flavor has dropped or they scorched, make new
Assembled fatteh Not for storage The bread texture does not come back, so assemble only what you will eat, on the spot
Caution

Take out only the amount of yogurt sauce you will eat, and do not leave it for long after assembling. Follow the product's storage label, your refrigerator's temperature and your home's hygiene practices. Do not carry a leftover assembled plate over to the next day, for texture or for hygiene.

Variations

The variations keep the bread, the yogurt and the hot fat, and swap only the middle layer. For dinner, an eggplant, meat or chicken version makes the plate more filling.

Variation What goes in the middle Result and handling
Eggplant fatteh Roasted or fried eggplant More moisture and toastiness than chickpeas. If you make fattet makdous, keep the same order of bread and yogurt
With meat Beef or lamb mince cooked with cumin Heartier, suited to lunch or dinner more than breakfast. Cook the mince through, and do not drain the fat so thoroughly that it chills the yogurt
With chicken Boiled, shredded chicken Keeping some chickpeas or leaving them out changes the weight
With shrimp Shrimp cooked with garlic and oil Do not pour the seafood's moisture directly on the bread; keep the topping warm
Changing the nuts From pine nuts to sliced almonds Almonds have a lighter aroma and a stronger crunch
Dairy-free home version Plant-based yogurt and olive oil A different dish from the traditional form. Check labels for dairy, sesame, wheat and nuts

Frequently asked questions

Are dried or canned chickpeas better?

Canned chickpeas are quick: rinse them and warm them with a little hot water or cooking liquid. Dried beans need soaking and cooking the day before, but their cooking liquid makes it easier to keep the bean layer soft. Start with canned to get a feel for the layers, then try dried to see what the liquid adds.

Can I warm the yogurt sauce?

Use it close to room temperature, about 15 minutes out of the refrigerator. If you do warm it, stir constantly over very low heat, stop at lukewarm, and never let it boil. If it splits into grains, a fresh batch of sauce will give you a better texture than heating it longer.

Can I replace pine nuts with something other than almonds?

Other tree nuts such as walnuts change both the aroma and the allergens, so the dish won't taste the same. If you'd rather skip nuts, pour on just the hot butter or ghee and let the crisp bread carry the finish.

How is it different from hummus?

Lebanese hummus is chickpeas crushed into a smooth paste. Fatteh layers whole beans with bread and yogurt, so it feels completely different in the mouth even with the same chickpeas and tahini. Balila is another breakfast dish, warm whole beans with seasonings and no bread or yogurt layers.

Sources