Leg Soup: Yemenite Cow Foot Soup with Hawaij and Tomato (מרק רגל תימני)

A bowl of finished Yemenite cow foot soup, with tender foot pieces in a reddish tomato and hawaij broth
Serves
10–12 portions
Cuisine
Yemenite

How to make a Yemenite cow foot soup from a recipe by Boaz Brothers of Shuk HaTikvah, published by the FOODISH project of ANU Museum: two boils in plain water, soup hawaij, tomato, and a covered 8-hour simmer until the foot pieces are soft. Also covers choosing the foot pieces and hawaij, how it differs from related soups, and what the recipe does not specify.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Parboil the foot pieces and discard the first water

Foot pieces boiling in plain water with foam on the surface
The first boil brings foam to the surface

Place the 10 foot pieces in the empty pot, then wash your hands. Pour in plain water until the pieces are submerged, without any seasoning, and bring the pot to a boil. Lift off the foam that gathers on the surface with a heatproof skimmer. Set the colander securely in the sink, then carefully pour in the foot pieces and water, keeping your hands and face clear of the steam, and discard the water.

STEP22 / 7

Boil the foot pieces again in fresh water

A skimmer lifting foam from the second boil
One more skim before the seasonings go in

Use tongs to return the foot pieces to the pot, and pour in fresh plain water until they are submerged. Bring the pot back to a boil. Skim off the remaining foam until the surface is clear and the pot is ready for the seasonings.

STEP33 / 7

Add the spices, paste and salt

Tomato paste being added to the spiced pot
Tomato paste goes into the spiced pot

Add 2 tablespoons of soup hawaij, 1 tablespoon of sweet paprika and 3 tablespoons of tomato paste to the pot. Add the 8 crushed garlic cloves and 1 tablespoon of salt. The water should turn reddish as the spices and paste settle into it.

STEP44 / 7

Add the vegetables and cilantro, then bring to a boil

Reddish seasoned soup boiling in the pot
The seasoned soup comes back to a boil

Add the chopped onion, the 4 grated tomatoes and the 2 tablespoons of chopped cilantro, so that the cilantro cooks in the soup. Stir well with a heatproof spoon until the foot pieces and seasonings are evenly mixed. Bring the seasoned soup to a boil once more, until the reddish soup bubbles across the pot.

STEP55 / 7

Cover and simmer on low for 8 hours

A covered pot simmering gently, with a narrow edge of reddish broth visible
Low heat with the lid on

Put the lid on the pot, handling it carefully, and turn the heat down to low. Cook, covered, for 8 hours. Stay with the pot and check it now and then. If the liquid gets low, add water as needed so it doesn't boil dry. A narrow edge of reddish broth should stay visible around the gently simmering pot.

STEP66 / 7

Check that the foot pieces are soft

Metal tongs lifting a cooked foot piece over the soup pot
Check softness with a heatproof tool

Lift out a foot piece with heatproof tongs, without touching it with bare fingers, and check that it is soft. If it isn't soft yet, cover the pot and keep cooking on low. The foot pieces should be soft, sitting in the broth with the onion, tomato and cilantro that cooked in it.

STEP77 / 7

Ladle into bowls and serve hot

A bowl of finished foot soup served with plain bread on a side plate
Serve the soup hot, with bread on the side if you like

Leave the foot pieces in the soup, and ladle pieces and broth into bowls. Add no fresh herbs or other toppings. If you want bread, put plain purchased bread on its own plate and keep it out of the pot. Bring the bowls to the table while the soup is still hot, with the bread alongside if using.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Cow or calf foot pieces, commercially processed and food-grade 10 pieces The body of the soup
Water as needed Two separate rounds: one for the first boil and fresh water for the second
Soup hawaij 2 tablespoons Savory spice blend for soup, not sweet hawaij
Sweet paprika 1 tablespoon Sweet, not hot, spice for the broth
Tomato paste 3 tablespoons Concentrated tomato, used in addition to the grated tomatoes
Garlic, crushed 8 cloves Aromatic, simmered in the broth
Salt 1 tablespoon Seasoning
Onion, chopped 1 Aromatic, simmered in the broth
Tomatoes, grated 4 Tomato base of the broth
Cilantro, chopped 2 tablespoons Goes into the pot before the long simmer, not on top at serving
0 / 0

Ten pieces of cow or calf foot go into a pot of plain water. It comes to a boil, the foam is skimmed off, and that water is poured away. Then fresh water goes in, and the pot is boiled and skimmed a second time. Only after that come the soup hawaij, sweet paprika, tomato paste, garlic, salt, onion, grated tomatoes and cilantro, then a lid, low heat and a long, quiet simmer until the foot pieces turn soft.

About Yemenite Leg Soup

Despite its name, leg soup (מרק רגל תימני) is made with cow or calf foot, not shank or neck. It belongs to a family of related Yemenite soups rather than one fixed recipe. Some cooks use the same "Yemenite leg soup" name for a different pot of neck meat, calf-leg bone slices and potatoes. It also sits close to marak temani, the Yemenite chicken soup with vegetables and hawaij. The version here is the foot soup: the two boils in plain water clear the pot, and the hawaij, paprika and tomato carry the flavor through the long cook. For more from the country, see our Yemen recipes.

Ingredients: 10–12 Portions

Cow foot pieces, onion, garlic, chopped cilantro, soup hawaij, sweet paprika, tomato paste, salt, grated tomatoes and water set out separately
Everything for the pot, set out separately

Equipment

  • Large, stable pot with a lid
  • Heatproof skimmer
  • Stable heatproof colander that sits securely in the sink
  • Heatproof spoon
  • Heatproof tongs
  • Ladle
  • Knife, cutting board and grater
  • Soup bowls, plus a side plate if serving bread

Choosing Foot Pieces, Hawaij and Tomato

Foot pieces. Buy cow or calf foot that has already been commercially processed for food. No particular weight, thickness or cut is called for, so use the pieces as they're sold.

No equivalent cuts. Shank, neck meat, pig's feet and chicken feet make a different soup, and these amounts and steps won't work for them. If you can't find cow or calf foot, it's better to choose another soup than to swap the cut.

Hawaij. Look for the blend meant for soup. Sweet hawaij is a different mix, so if that's all you have, track down the soup blend before you start.

Tomato. Use both the tomato paste and the grated tomatoes. They're separate ingredients, and the soup needs each of them.

Method: Two Boils, Then the Lid

Hot water, raw foot pieces and long cooking
  • Use a stable heatproof colander when draining, and keep bare hands and your face away from steam and hot food.
  • Keep raw foot pieces away from foods that won't be cooked. Wash your hands and any tools that touched them.
  • Plan the simmer for a time when you can stay with the pot. Don't leave it unattended or let it boil dry.
  • Softness tells you about texture, not safety.

Before you start, chop the onion and cilantro, crush the garlic and grate the tomatoes. The seasonings go in one at a time below, so each is easy to follow.

Leg Soup Troubleshooting

What you notice What to do
The foot pieces aren't soft after 8 hours Keep the pot covered on low and check again. Softness is the sign to stop, along with the listed time
The liquid is running low Add water as needed and return to a low simmer. Never let the pot boil dry
The soup is boiling hard under the lid Turn the heat down
Foam remains after the second skim Skim once more before adding the seasonings

Serving Leg Soup

At the table, you can lift the foot pieces out or leave them in. Here they stay in the bowl, with plain bread on a separate plate if you like. Potatoes, rice and bread stay out of the pot itself.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this made with leg or foot?

Foot. "Leg soup" is the name of the dish, but it's made with cow or calf foot pieces, with no shank or neck meat.

How much water do I need?

Enough to cover the foot pieces.

Should I finish it with fresh cilantro?

No. The cilantro cooks in the pot, going in before the 8-hour simmer.

Do 8 hours and soft foot pieces mean the soup is safe?

Not on their own. Heat cooked food to 167°F (75°C) for 1 minute, and keep raw foot pieces away from food that won't be cooked.

How long does it keep, and how should I reheat it?

Don't leave the soup sitting out at room temperature for long.

Sources