At a beach bar in Antigua in 2013, the bowl of goat water came scented with clove and cinnamon, with small dumplings in the stew and fungee on the side. The cook said it is traditionally a Saturday dish. Goat water is bone-in goat simmered slowly with cloves, allspice and mace, lit up with Scotch bonnet heat, in a broth that is thickened only lightly at the very end. Plan on 20 minutes to prep and 160 minutes on the stove, 180 minutes in all, most of it the pot quietly doing its work.
Goat Water Across the Islands

Goat water is the national dish of Montserrat, and Antigua and its neighbors each claim it as their own. Where it began is not clear. Despite the name, it is a spicy, deeply flavored stew rather than a thin soup.
In Antigua and Barbuda, goat water is a local staple, seasoned with hot peppers, cloves and cinnamon. Recipes vary from restaurant to roadside stand, and a bowl may come with small dumplings and fungee on the side.
On Montserrat it is made with male goat and cooked to a body that is neither too thick nor too thin. It is served with bread or rice and is linked to Friday lunch and communal occasions. On St. Maarten, goat water is counted among the local dishes.
Ingredients for 6 Servings

Equipment
- Large heavy pot with a lid
- Food processor
- Large bowl and colander
- Paper towels
- Spoon or ladle for skimming foam
- Small bowl for the cornflour mixture
- Separate knife and cutting board for raw meat
Choosing Ingredients for Goat Water
- Goat: this is the ingredient most worth tracking down, and it usually means a specialty supplier. Ask for bone-in pieces. If goat is out of reach, lamb works, though the flavor and simmering time will differ, so judge by tenderness.
- Mace: cloves, allspice and mace are the core of the flavor. Nutmeg is a different spice and will change the aroma.
- Scotch bonnet: it brings both heat and aroma. Another hot chili, such as habanero, will shift both.
- Gravy browning: it is there for color. Worcestershire sauce is a different product.
- Cornflour: potato starch is a different ingredient and may thicken differently.
- Sugar: brown sugar or molasses can go in the pot at step 2.
Fixing Common Goat Water Problems
| What you notice | Likely reason | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Bitter, burned smell from the caramel | The sugar went too dark | Add the meat while the caramel is golden, before it blackens |
| Vegetables turn to liquid | Processed too long | Stop while the paste still has visible texture |
| Meat is still firm | Age or cut of the goat | Keep simmering, covered, until very tender |
| Broth is heavy or pasty | Too much starch | Keep to 1 tsp and stop at a light, pourable body |
| Too hot | Scotch bonnet seeds and flesh | Remove the seeds next time |
Serving and Storing Goat Water

Serve the stew hot, with bread for dragging through the broth. If you want it milder next time, remove the seeds from the Scotch bonnet; both the heat and the aroma will soften.
Do not leave the stew at room temperature for long, and do not cool it in the pot at room temperature. The spores of Clostridium perfringens (a food-poisoning bacterium) survive ordinary cooking. Divide leftovers into shallow containers and cool them quickly, then refrigerate at 50°F (10°C) or below or freeze at −15°C or below. Reheat while stirring well, until the stew reaches 167°F (75°C) or above. Throw away anything that has been kept too long.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to wash the meat in lemon water?
No. Washing raw meat can spread bacteria onto counters and tools. Pat the meat dry with paper towels instead.
How much thickener should I use?
Use 1 tsp cornflour, mixed with 3.5 tbsp (50 ml) water. The ingredient list also has a line for 1–2 tsp plain flour or cornflour, but no step in the method uses it.
Are the cloves and allspice whole or ground?
The recipe does not say. Only the mace is specified as ground, so use 2 tsp of each as written.
Why is there no salt?
Neither the ingredient list nor the method includes salt. Taste at the end and add salt if you want it.
How many days does it keep?
No number of days is given. Follow the cooling, temperature and reheating advice in the storage section above, and throw away food kept too long. The spore advice written for curry applies to this stew too.













