Cemita Poblana: The Big Sesame-Bun Sandwich of Puebla

A cemita poblana: a round sesame-seed roll filled with milanesa, avocado, white cheese, onion and fragrant herb leaves
Prep
45 min
Cook
35 min
Total
1 hr 20 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Mexican and Pueblan

A cemita poblana recipe for a home kitchen: a sesame-seed roll, thin fried milanesa, chipotle, papalo and quesillo, and the role of each. Covers substitutes, oil temperature, assembly, storage, how to eat it, common causes of failure, where to draw the line on shopping, and links to related Mexican dishes.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Prepare the meat and filling

12 min

Pounding chicken breast thin and preparing avocado, onion, tomato, white cheese and herb leaves in a kitchen
With the filling cut beforehand, you can sandwich the milanesa while it is hot

No heat is used. Cut into the thick part of the chicken breast and open it like a book, sandwich it in plastic wrap, and pound it with a rolling pin or a bottle to 0.25 inch (7 mm) thick. Sprinkle 1 tsp salt and the black pepper on both sides. Cut the avocado 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick, the white onion in 0.125 inch (2 mm) rings and the tomato 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick. Tear the substitute cheese thin and mix in a pinch of salt. Wash the leaves and wipe off the water thoroughly. The aim is cheese loosened into strands with the salt faintly blended onto the surface, and leaves with no water droplets visible on the surface.

STEP22 / 6

Crush the chipotle sauce

6 min

Coarsely crushing chipotle, vinegar, oregano and garlic in a stone mortar to make a red sauce
Crush the chipotle sauce coarsely, and it won't go watery when spread on the bread

No heat is used. In a mortar, put 1.5 oz (40 g) chipotle, 1 tbsp tomato paste, 1 tbsp rice vinegar, the garlic, 1/2 tsp oregano and 1/4 tsp salt, and crush until some pieces remain. The aim is a consistency that doesn't drip when spread on the bread. If it is stiff, add water 1 tbsp at a time. If you use a blender, don't make it fully liquid; stop at a coarseness where spoon marks remain. The consistency should be a little looser than jam, forming a mass that falls slowly off a spoon.

STEP33 / 6

Bread the meat

10 min

Coating thinly pounded chicken in flour, beaten egg and breadcrumbs in turn
Apply the milanesa coating thin and even, and rest it 5 minutes to settle

No heat is used. Line up three trays holding the flour, the beaten egg, and the breadcrumbs with 1/2 tsp oregano. Pat the chicken dry with paper, coat it thinly with flour, shake off the excess, and then pass it through egg and breadcrumbs in that order. Don't press the coating too hard, and apply it evenly to the edges. Resting it for 5 minutes lets the coating adhere to the meat so it comes off less easily. The aim is a surface completely covered with dry crumbs, with no raw meat visible when pressed lightly with a finger.

STEP44 / 6

Fry the milanesa

12 min

Frying chicken milanesa in a heavy skillet, checking with an oil thermometer and tongs
Fry the milanesa at 170 to 175°C, checking a core of 74°C and a deep golden brown

Pour oil about 1 inches (2.5 cm) deep into a heavy skillet and warm to 350°F (170 to 175°C) over medium heat. Add the chicken one piece at a time and fry 2 minutes 30 seconds to 3 minutes on the first side, then turn and fry 2 minutes to 2 minutes 30 seconds. When the surface is a deep golden brown and the core reaches 165°F (74°C), lift onto a rack. If the oil falls below 325°F (165°C) the coating turns heavy, and above 350°F (180°C) it tends to burn before the center cooks.

STEP55 / 6

Re-toast the bread

3 min

Lightly re-toasting round sesame rolls cut side down on a griddle
Toast only the cut sides over medium heat so the bread becomes a base that chipotle sauce doesn't soak through easily

Warm a griddle or skillet over medium heat for 2 minutes, cut the rolls in half horizontally, and place them cut side down. Use no oil. Toast for 1 minute to 1 minute 30 seconds; take them out when the cut surfaces have a light toasting and feel slightly dry to the touch. Over-toasting makes them crack easily, so the outside doesn't need to be hard.

STEP66 / 6

Assemble and cut right away

7 min

Layering milanesa, cheese, avocado, onion and herb leaves onto sesame rolls spread with chipotle sauce
Put the herb leaves on last, and their aroma rises from the heat of the fried meat and the chipotle

No heat is used. Spread 1 tbsp chipotle sauce on each bottom half and lay the milanesa on it. Stack the white cheese, avocado, tomato and onion, and top with papalo or the substitute herb leaves last. Spread about 2 tsp chipotle sauce on the top half too, and press lightly all over with your palm. For ease of eating, cut diagonally in half and serve with lime.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Milanesa

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Chicken breast 1.25 lb (520 g) Open into 4 pieces. Pork loin works too, but change the doneness guide
Salt 1 tsp, about 6 g For seasoning the meat
Black pepper 1/3 tsp Freshly ground is best
All-purpose flour 2 oz (60 g) Shake off the excess
Eggs 2, about 3.5 oz (100 g) Beaten
Breadcrumbs 4 oz (110 g) Fine dry breadcrumbs give a thin coating
Dried oregano 1/2 tsp Mixed into the breadcrumbs
Rice bran or canola oil 3 cups (700 ml) About 1 inches (2.5 cm) deep. Adjust to the pot
2 / 3

Chipotle sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Chipotles in adobo 1.5 oz (40 g) Canned or jarred. If you can't find them, use the substitute below
Tomato paste 1 tbsp, 18 g Adds acidity and body
Rice vinegar 1 tbsp 2 tsp lime juice also works
Garlic 1 clove, about 5 g Grated
Dried oregano 1/2 tsp The core of the aroma
Water 1 to 2 tbsp Adjust to a spreadable consistency
Salt 1/4 tsp Adjust to the saltiness of the chipotle
3 / 3

Assembly

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Round sesame rolls 4, 1 roll 4 oz (90 to 110 g) A firm bun if you have no cemita roll
String-type mozzarella 4 oz (120 g) Stands in for quesillo. Tear thin
Salt a pinch, about 0.5 g Mixed into the substitute cheese
Avocado 1, about 6.5 oz (180 g) Cut 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick
White onion 2.75 oz (80 g) Cut in 0.125 inch (2 mm) rings. If sharp, soak in water for 5 minutes
Tomato 5.5 oz (160 g) Sliced 0.25 inch (5 mm) thick
Papalo 8 g If you can't get it, 12 g cilantro and 20 g arugula
Lime 1 Cut into wedges
0 / 0

The first thing you notice is the bread. Bite into a cemita poblana and the crunch of the breading, the smoky heat of chipotle, the richness of avocado and the green scent of papalo arrive one after another. This big sandwich comes from the state of Puebla, Mexico, and it is built on a round roll thickly coated in sesame seeds and re-toasted before a freshly fried milanesa goes on. Red chipotle sauce, avocado, white stringy cheese, onion and green aromatic leaves are piled on top. "Street-stall sandwich" might sound light, but the cemita is surprisingly tall and layered.

About the cemita poblana

In Puebla, the word cemita also means the round, sesame-coated roll itself, which has enough spring to stand up to its filling. The classic version stacks milanesa, quesillo or Oaxaca cheese, aguacate, chipotle, cebolla and papalo on that roll. The thinly pounded, fried meat gives the sandwich its body. Chipotle brings smoky heat and acidity that tighten everything up. Quesillo, a white cheese that pulls into strands, adds saltiness and a milky aroma, and papalo, with a green scent stronger than cilantro, goes on at the end.

Unlike dishes built on a corn base, such as sopes or chilaquiles, the cemita takes its shape from the bread. It's a street dish where fried meat and bread are eaten all at once.

Related Mexican dishes

For chipotle heat clinging to chicken, try tinga de pollo. For a corn base, make sopes. For a festive stew, make pozole rojo.

Ingredients (serves 4)

This amount makes 4 large cemitas. For lunch, 1 per person is plenty. For dinner, add bean soup or lime to lighten the heaviness.

Sesame round rolls, chicken, breading, avocado, chipotle, white cheese and herb leaves laid out in a kitchen for the cemita poblana
With the roll, milanesa, chipotle and herb leaves prepared first, you are less likely to hesitate when assembling the cemita

If you can't get chipotle, mix 2 tsp smoked paprika, 1/4 tsp cayenne, 1 tbsp tomato paste, 1 tbsp rice vinegar, 1/2 tsp sugar and 1/2 tsp oregano. You approach the smoky scent, but not the fermented-seeming deep heat of chipotle.

Allergy and food safety

This recipe uses wheat, egg, milk and chicken. Aim for a core temperature of 165°F (74°C) in the chicken breast, and if redness or clear juices remain after frying, cook it further. Frying oil gets very hot, so keep wet tools and watery ingredients away from it.

Choosing cemita ingredients and substitutes

Bread, chicken, avocado and cheese are easy to find at any neighborhood grocery, but swap everything for ordinary sandwich ingredients and you end up with a cutlet sandwich. When substituting, hold on to at least one of these: the spring of the bread, the smokiness of chipotle, the green scent of the leaves.

Local ingredient Ease of substitution Substitute What changes
Cemita roll Medium Round sesame roll, firm bun The aroma is close, but the light pull of the local bread is weaker
Papalo Low 12 g cilantro and 20 g arugula, or a little mint The distinctive green scent is weaker
Quesillo Medium 4 oz (120 g) string mozzarella with 0.5 g salt The pull-apart texture is close, but the saltiness is faint
Chipotle Low Smoked paprika, chile, vinegar, tomato paste The smokiness comes through, but the deep heat of chipotle is missing
Milanesa High Chicken breast, pork loin, beef round The meat's aroma changes, but the structure of thin frying is kept

Papalo, also called papaloquelite in Mexico, is an aromatic herb with a distinctive green scent. Cilantro alone makes the aroma too rounded, so add arugula or a little mint to bring back some of the leaf's bitterness and cool freshness.

Quesillo is sometimes sold as Oaxaca cheese, but it can be hard to find outside Mexican markets. Tear string-type mozzarella thin and add a pinch of salt to get close to its stretch and faint milky aroma.

The one thing not to compromise on the first time is chipotle. Canned chipotle is ideal. Bread and cheese can move to something close, but if the heat turns into plain chile, it can't cut through the weight of the avocado and cheese.

How to make it

The milanesa is freshly fried, the bread freshly re-toasted, and the herb leaves go last. Rushing everything at once makes a mess, so first cut the filling, make the sauce, and open the bread just before frying.

Common cemita poblana mistakes and fixes

State Cause Fix
Coating comes off Moisture left on the meat, or too much flour Pat dry with paper, and dust the flour thin before the egg
Meat is tough Fried while thick, or the oil was low and the time stretched Pound to 0.25 inch (7 mm) and keep the oil at 350°F (170 to 175°C)
Bottom of the bread is damp Under-toasted, or the sauce is watery Dry the cut sides over medium heat, and make the sauce thick enough that spoon marks remain
Aroma is blurred The substitute herb went on early and wilted Put the herb leaves on last, and cut right before eating
Whole thing is heavy Too much cheese and avocado Aim for 1 oz (30 g) cheese and 1.5 oz (45 g) avocado per sandwich

The urge to make the coating thick is understandable, but in a cemita the meat is the star and the coating is a layer that adds toastiness. Make it as thick as Japanese tonkatsu, and the aromas of chipotle and papalo lose out.

With a chicken-breast milanesa, judging by the color of the breading alone can leave the center underdone. A thermometer lets you check both the oil at 350°F (170 to 175°C) and the core at 165°F (74°C).

A lightly re-toasted cut surface keeps the bottom of the bread from turning damp under the chipotle sauce. A wide griddle lets you lay all the bread out at once, so the fried milanesa doesn't sit waiting. For the sauce itself, a blender works, but for a small amount a mortar crushes it coarsely and keeps it from going watery on the bread. If you make salsa often, or crush spices and garlic, you'll reach for the mortar again.

Serving and storing cemita poblana

Serving and pairing

The cemita puts staple and main in one, so rather than adding another heavy fried dish beside it, support it with acidity, moisture and the light sweetness of beans. For a street-stall feel, set out lime, thinly sliced onion and a hot sauce in small dishes so everyone can add as they go. Don't press down too hard when you eat, and the aroma stays. If you like heat, keep a little chipotle sauce on the side and add it partway through so the flavor doesn't get monotonous.

Pairing Role Easy combination
Lime and white onion Cut the weight of the fried coating and cheese Squeeze lime on the cut face of the meat, and soak the onion in water
Bean soup Adds satisfaction as a meal Simmer pinto or black beans on the thin side and season with salt and oregano
Acidic seafood Lightens the table On a hot day, add a small portion of aguachile
Corn snack Builds the flow of a Mexican meal Serve a small sope as a starter

For breakfast or brunch, make the cemita a little smaller and add a small portion of chilaquiles tossed in salsa. Both rely on the acidity of chipotle and salsa, so one shopping trip covers both.

Storage

An assembled cemita doesn't keep. Store the bread, sauce, fried meat and vegetables separately and assemble just before eating.

Component Storage Reheating
Milanesa Refrigerate 2 days. Wrap in paper, then put in a container 5 to 6 minutes in a 350°F (180°C) toaster oven. Heat through to the center
Chipotle sauce Refrigerate 4 days Bring to room temperature. If stiff, add 1 tsp water
Cut vegetables Same day Don't heat. Wipe off the water before sandwiching
Bread Room temperature 1 day, freezer 2 weeks Re-toast the cut sides over medium heat

FAQ

Can I use pork instead of chicken?

Pork loin works. Pound it to about 0.25 inch (7 mm) as well and cook it through to the center. Chicken calls for a core temperature of 165°F (74°C); with pork, make sure no strong redness remains.

Can I use hamburger buns?

Yes. Buns that are too soft sink under the sauce, so choose a slightly firm one with plenty of sesame, and be sure to re-toast the cut sides. Sandwich bread or brioche puts sweetness and softness up front, which weakens the cemita character.

How much can I prepare ahead?

The chipotle sauce can be made 4 days ahead, and the milanesa coating applied up to 2 hours before frying. Fried meat can be refrigerated, but once assembled the bread turns damp. Re-toast the bread just before eating, warm the meat, and add the leaves last.

Sources and food-safety references