Stewed Saltfish: Saint Kitts and Nevis Saltfish in Tomato and Coconut Milk

Stewed saltfish cooked in tomato and coconut milk, scattered with coriander and spring onion
Serves
4 servings
Cuisine
Saint Kitts and Nevis

How to make stewed saltfish from Saint Kitts and Nevis, based on chef Keshia Sakarah's published recipe for four. The saltfish is simmered for 15 minutes, then cooked with onion, sweet peppers, Scotch bonnet, tomato and coconut milk. Includes how to choose saltfish, when to taste for salt, how to handle the heat, and how the stew fits with dumplings and breadfruit.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Simmer the saltfish in water for 15 minutes, then drain

Saltfish simmering in water in a saucepan
Start the saltfish in cold water, bring it to a boil, then lower to a gentle simmer

Put the 1 lb (500 g) saltfish in a saucepan and add cold water to cover. Bring to a boil, lower the heat to a simmer, and cook for 15 minutes.

Drain the fish in a colander and set it aside. This 15-minute simmer is the only preparation step for the fish. Leave the salt decision for the end.

Simmered saltfish draining in a colander
Drain the simmered saltfish and set it aside in large pieces
STEP22 / 5

Soften the onion, garlic and peppers in oil

Cutting the onion, garlic, sweet bell peppers and Scotch bonnet
Cut the onion, garlic, sweet peppers and Scotch bonnet before heating the pan

Peel and roughly dice the onion, peel and crush the garlic, deseed and dice the sweet bell peppers, and dice the Scotch bonnet.

Heat the 2 tbsp rapeseed oil in a frying pan. Add the onion, garlic, sweet peppers and Scotch bonnet and sauté until they are just beginning to soften. This is not a browning step, so stop before the vegetables color.

Handling Scotch bonnet

Scotch bonnet is very hot. After cutting it, wash your hands, knife and board, and keep your hands away from your eyes and face.

Onion, garlic, sweet peppers and Scotch bonnet softening in rapeseed oil
Soften the aromatics and peppers in oil and stop before they brown
STEP33 / 5

Add the tomatoes, black pepper and saltfish

Tomatoes, black pepper and saltfish added to the softened aromatics
Toss the tomatoes, black pepper and large flakes of saltfish with the softened vegetables

Add the tomatoes, the 2 tsp black pepper and the drained saltfish to the pan, and toss everything together. Turn the fish gently so it stays in large pieces rather than breaking into shreds.

STEP44 / 5

Fold in the coconut milk and simmer, covered, for 5 minutes

Coconut milk folded into the saltfish before covering and simmering
Fold in the coconut milk gently, then cover and simmer once the edges bubble

Pour in the 1¼ cups (300 ml) coconut milk and fold it in gently, keeping the fish pieces whole. When the sauce starts to bubble lightly, lower the heat to a simmer, cover, and cook for 5 minutes.

STEP55 / 5

Taste, then finish with coriander and spring onion

Coriander and spring onion scattered over the finished stewed saltfish
Scatter coriander and spring onion over the stew just before serving

Once the fish is cooked through, taste the finished stew. Add salt only if it needs it, since saltfish varies. Scatter over the 2 tbsp chopped coriander and the sliced spring onions and serve.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Saltfish, skinless and boneless 1 lb (500 g) The main ingredient. Simmered first, then folded into the sauce in large pieces
Cold water Enough to cover the fish For the first 15-minute simmer of the saltfish
Rapeseed oil 2 tbsp For softening the aromatics and peppers
Brown onion 1, peeled and roughly diced Sweetness and body in the sauce
Garlic 2–3 cloves, peeled and crushed Aroma
Sweet bell peppers 3, deseeded and diced Color and a mild, sweet pepper flavor
Scotch bonnet 1, diced Heat and fruity pepper aroma. It is a very hot chili
Tomatoes 2, roughly diced Acidity and color in the sauce
Black pepper 2 tsp Seasoning
Coconut milk 1¼ cups (300 ml) Makes the creamy sauce around the fish
Coriander (cilantro) 2 tbsp, roughly chopped Fresh finish
Spring onions 2, trimmed and finely sliced Fresh finish
0 / 0

Boneless saltfish sits in a pale orange sauce of coconut milk and tomato, with pieces of sweet bell pepper, onion and a little Scotch bonnet running through it. Chopped coriander and spring onion go on top just before it reaches the table. This is stewed saltfish, also called saltfish stew, as it's made in Saint Kitts and Nevis, the two-island federation in the Eastern Caribbean. The coconut milk makes it creamy and mellow, the peppers add sweetness, and the Scotch bonnet adds a little heat underneath.

Saltfish and Dumplings in Saint Kitts and Nevis

Saltfish and dumplings is considered the national dish of Saint Kitts and Nevis and a culinary staple. The stew usually comes with coconut dumplings and roast breadfruit. There is no single official recipe, and every household and cook makes it a little differently. This version uses coconut milk.

Saltfish came to the region from the North Atlantic as early as the 15th century, traded for sugar during the transatlantic slave trade, and it has been part of the islands' cooking ever since. In 2021, a local chef cooked the national dish for the National Day menu at Expo 2020 Dubai. The menu included saltfish and coconut dumplings, sautéed breadfruit, spicy fried plantain and goat water. For another Caribbean dish, try Trinidadian callaloo.

Ingredients for 4 Servings

Saltfish, onion, garlic, sweet bell peppers, Scotch bonnet, tomatoes, coconut milk and the finishing herbs
The ingredients for the four-serving stew, with coriander and spring onion for finishing

These amounts serve four. The fish is prepared first, then the stew is built in a separate pan.

The recipe gives no salt quantity. Saltfish saltiness varies from product to product, so taste the finished stew and add salt only if it needs it.

Choosing Saltfish, Peppers and Herbs

Saltfish is not the same as fresh or lightly salted cod

Saltfish is fish preserved by salting and drying. The recipe calls for skinless, boneless saltfish. Fresh cod and lightly salted fish fillets sold in ordinary supermarkets are different products, with different saltiness and moisture, so don't treat them as a direct replacement in this recipe.

  • Saltfish: Look for saltfish or salted cod at Caribbean or import grocers. Skinless and boneless is best, since that's what the recipe is written for. Saltiness varies from product to product, so hold off on salt until you taste the finished stew. If the packet gives its own preparation instructions, follow the packet.
  • Scotch bonnet: A very hot chili. Leave the seeds in for full heat, or remove them to tone it down. Another chili will change how hot the stew is.
  • Sweet bell peppers: Deseed them.
  • Coriander: The leaves, called cilantro in some countries. It's the only herb in the pot.
  • Spring onions: Also sold as scallions or green onions.

Equipment

  • Saucepan, for simmering the saltfish
  • Colander, for draining the fish
  • Large frying pan with a lid
  • Wooden spoon or spatula
  • Knife and cutting board

Method: Simmer the Fish, Soften the Peppers, Finish with Coconut Milk

The two simmers in this recipe

15 minutes for the saltfish, then 5 minutes covered in coconut milk. Cook the vegetables only until they begin to soften, not until they brown.

Stewed Saltfish Troubleshooting

You want the saltfish in large flakes, not a paste, with onion, sweet pepper and tomato still visible in the creamy sauce. Most problems come down to stirring too hard, browning the vegetables, or guessing the salt.

Problem Likely cause What to do
The fish broke into shreds Stirred too hard after the fish or coconut milk went in Fold gently from step 3 onward. Next time, add the drained fish in large pieces and stir as little as possible
The vegetables browned or scorched Sautéed too long or too hot In step 2, stop as soon as the vegetables begin to soften. The sauce should taste of sweet pepper and tomato, not of browning
The stew tastes too salty Saltfish saltiness varies Don't add salt. There is no further desalting step
The stew tastes flat The fish was less salty than expected Add salt a little at a time, tasting as you go
Too hot Scotch bonnet strength Next time, remove the seeds. Serve pepper sauce on the side rather than adding heat to the pot

Serving Stewed Saltfish and Variations

Stewed saltfish served with coconut dumplings and roasted breadfruit
Keshia Sakarah serves the stew with coconut dumplings and roast breadfruit on the side

Serve the stew with coconut dumplings and roasted breadfruit, and put hot pepper sauce on the table so everyone can choose their own heat while the pot stays mild. Sautéed breadfruit, spicy fried plantain and goat water also turn up alongside it, as they did on the Expo menu.

Other cooks take a different route altogether. One method soaks the saltfish overnight, boils it and flakes it, then cooks it with green pepper, tomato, garlic, oil, butter or margarine, scallions and parsley.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use fresh cod or lightly salted fish fillets instead of saltfish?

Not as a straight swap. Saltfish is salted and dried, so fresh cod and lightly salted fillets behave differently in both saltiness and moisture. Using them makes a different dish.

What if I can't find a Scotch bonnet?

Use another chili and adjust to taste, keeping in mind it will make the stew hotter or milder. Or leave the chili out of the pot and serve hot pepper sauce at the table.

Why coconut milk?

It's what makes the sauce creamy enough to coat the fish and vegetables. Some saltfish stews are made without it.

Sources