Chile Relleno: Mexico's Stuffed Roasted Pepper

A plate of cheese-filled chile relleno with red tomato sauce and Mexican rice
Prep
40 min
Cook
45 min
Total
1 hr 25 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Mexican

How to make chile relleno: charring and peeling the pepper, stuffing it with cheese, the egg batter, frying oil temperature and tomato sauce, set for a home kitchen. Poblano substitutes, choosing cheese, common failures, storage and serving ideas.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Char the chili skins

10 min

Charring the skins of poblanos black over a gas flame and in a skillet
To peel the skin, char the surface of the chili in black patches

Roll the chilies over a medium to medium-high direct flame, a fish grill or a strongly heated skillet until about 70% of the surface is black with char. Over a flame, that takes about 2 minutes per side. In a skillet, 8 to 10 minutes in total. Keep charring until the skin puffs up and the flesh softens and bends slightly.

STEP22 / 7

Steam and peel

15 min

Peeling the black skin from steamed chilies by hand
Steaming lifts the charred skin and makes it easy to peel by hand

Put the charred chilies in a bowl and cover with a plate. Let them steam for 10 minutes in the residual heat, with no more heat. Once the skin has softened, rub off the black skin with your fingers or a paper towel. Do not wash them under running water; it washes away the aroma. Leave a little char on. Torn parts will be supported later by the dusting flour and batter, so handle them gently here.

STEP33 / 7

Simmer the tomato sauce

18 min

Simmering onion, tomatoes, garlic and oregano in a pot to make red sauce
Cook the tomato sauce down to drive off the wateriness until it clings to the batter

Put 1 tbsp rice bran oil in a pot over medium heat and cook the onion 4 minutes until it turns translucent. Cook the garlic 30 seconds, then add the tomatoes, water, dried oregano, cumin and salt. When it bubbles, simmer over medium-low heat for 12 minutes until the trail of a wooden spatula remains for a moment. Add rice vinegar only if the acidity is weak.

STEP44 / 7

Stuff with cheese

12 min

Stuffing peeled chilies with cheese
Make the slit on one side only and leave room so it can close even when stuffed with cheese

Cut a slit 7 to 9 cm long on one side of each chili and remove the seeds and the thick white ribs. Sprinkle a little salt inside and stuff with the stick of mozzarella and shredded cheese. Close the opening with about a 0.5 inch (1 cm) overlap and, if needed, fasten with toothpicks in just two places. Overfilling lets the cheese leak in later steps, so leave a finger's width of room.

STEP55 / 7

Make the egg batter

8 min

Whipped egg whites, yolks and flour-dusted chilies laid out for the batter step
Whipping the whites first and then combining them with the yolks makes the batter puff up well

Separate the eggs into whites and yolks. Add 1/4 tsp salt to the whites and whip with a whisk until the peaks are soft. In another bowl mix the yolks with 1 tbsp flour, fold in a third of the whites first, then gently combine the rest. Stopping before it is fully mixed, with a few white streaks remaining, keeps the batter light.

STEP66 / 7

Fry at 350°F (170–180°C)

12 min

Frying a batter-coated chili while checking the oil temperature with a thermometer
If the oil temperature drops, the batter gets heavy, so fry one at a time and let the temperature recover

Pour about 1 inch (2 cm) of oil into a pot and heat over medium heat to 350°F (170–180°C). Dust the stuffed chilies thinly with 1.5 oz (45 g) flour, coat all over with the egg batter and put them straight into the oil. Fry one at a time, 2 minutes per side and 2 minutes after turning, and take it out when the surface is pale golden and the batter has puffed and set. If the oil temperature falls below 325°F (165°C), wait a little before adding the next.

STEP77 / 7

Warm in the sauce to finish

8 min

Warming fried chile relleno back in red tomato sauce
Warming it in the sauce after frying brings the batter and cheese together

Reheat the tomato sauce over low heat and lay the fried chiles rellenos in it. Spoon the sauce over from above so the batter doesn't break, and warm for 5 minutes at a gentle bubble over low heat. Turn off the heat when the cheese is soft inside and a little red oil seeps onto the surface of the sauce. Remove the toothpicks before moving to a plate.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 4

Chilies and filling

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Poblano peppers 4, 450–520 g total If none, 4 large bell peppers; or 6–8 long sweet chilies
Low-moisture mozzarella 6.5 oz (180 g) In 0.5 inch (1 cm) wide sticks. String cheese works
Shredded cheese 2.75 oz (80 g) Mozzarella-type or a mild blend
Salt 1/3 tsp Sprinkled lightly inside the chili
Soft (low-protein) flour 1.5 oz (45 g) For dusting before applying the batter
Bamboo skewers or toothpicks 8 To lightly close the opening. Remove before eating
2 / 4

Tomato sauce

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Tomatoes 1 lb (500 g) 3 medium. If they are not ripe enough, 14 oz (400 g) canned whole tomatoes
Onion 4 oz (120 g) Cut into 0.5 inch (1 cm) dice
Garlic 2 cloves, about 10 g Coarsely chopped
Rice bran oil 1 tbsp For the sauce
Dried oregano 1 tsp Preferably Mexican-type oregano
Ground cumin 1/3 tsp A little only; too much moves it into another dish
Salt 1 tsp Adjust at the end with about 1/4 tsp
Water ½ cup (150 ml) With canned tomatoes, adjust from ½ cup (100 ml)
Rice vinegar 2 tsp Adds acidity if the tomatoes are very sweet
3 / 4

Egg batter and frying oil

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Eggs 4 Separate into whites and yolks
Salt 1/4 tsp For the egg whites
Soft (low-protein) flour 1 tbsp Mixed into the yolks to stabilize the batter
Rice bran or canola oil 2 cups (500 ml) A guide is 1 inch (2 cm) deep in a 9.5 inch (24 cm) diameter pot
4 / 4

To finish

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Warm rice or Mexican rice 1.25 lb (600 g) For 4 servings
Lettuce 5.5 oz (160 g) Cut 0.5 inch (1 cm) wide
Radishes 4 Sliced 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick. Daikon works
Lime 1 Cut into 4 wedges
Cilantro 20 g Green onion works
0 / 0

Hold a chili pepper close to a direct flame and the first thing you smell isn't heat. It's the sweet smell of green skin scorching. The surface blackens and blisters, and after a few minutes of steaming in a bowl the skin peels away. Stuff the pepper with cheese, wrap it in a batter of whipped egg white, fry it and set it in red tomato sauce, and you have chile relleno: a Mexican "stuffed chili." With egg and cheese inside, this vegetable dish makes a solid main.

Chile relleno ingredients on a table: poblanos, cheese, eggs, tomato sauce and dried oregano
The combination of chili, cheese, egg batter and red sauce makes up the outline of chile relleno

Chile relleno in Mexico

The local name is chile relleno, plural chiles rellenos, and in English it sometimes goes by "stuffed poblano." The dish is associated with Puebla. Its best-known form is a poblano stuffed with cheese or picadillo, wrapped in egg batter, fried and served in a tomato-based sauce. Some regions stuff it with meat, but at home three things matter most: char and peel the poblano, fill it with a soft, melting cheese, and fry the egg batter lightly so it stays thin. Skip those and you end up with a plain fried pepper.

Element Local axis What to keep elsewhere
Chili Poblano; in some regions another green chili Choose a fleshy one at least 4 inches (10 cm) long whose skin can be charred and peeled
Filling Oaxaca cheese, Chihuahua cheese, picadillo and so on Mix mozzarella and shredded cheese and make up the saltiness
Batter Egg batter of whipped egg whites Coat lightly with flour and fold the batter on without breaking the foam
Oil Frying oil to set the batter 350°F (170–180°C) for a short time, without letting the temperature drop too far
Sauce Tomato, onion, garlic, herbs Simmer to drive off the wateriness to a thickness that clings to the batter

If you'd like to go further into Mexican sauces and their aromas, try mole poblano. For a corn breakfast, there's chilaquiles.

Ingredients (serves 4)

This amount makes 4 large chiles rellenos. As a main, one per person; alongside pozole rojo or a bean dish, half each is enough.

Green chilies, tomatoes, onion, eggs, cheese, flour and spices for chile relleno laid out in a kitchen
Sorting the ingredients ahead keeps the steps of charring, stuffing and frying from getting mixed up
Allergies and food safety

This uses egg, milk and wheat. Cheese-stuffed chilies don't heat through easily at the center, so don't bite into one right out of the oil; warm it through in the sauce before serving. If you closed it with toothpicks, be sure to remove them before plating.

Choosing peppers, cheese and seasonings for chile relleno

Dried oregano, cumin, a cooking thermometer, oil, tomatoes and green chilies laid out in a kitchen before shopping
Only items related to aroma and oil temperature control are worth singling out

Poblano is the standard in Mexico, but it isn't always easy to find, so check what your nearby store has before you shop. Large bell peppers are close in shape and mild in heat, which makes them a good choice for a family version. Their thinner flesh tears more easily when you peel it, though, and can split once it's stuffed with cheese. Long sweet chilies, such as shishito-type or manganji peppers, smell good but hold very little. Use less cheese, thin the batter and serve them as a side dish.

Mozzarella is the main cheese. Fresh, high-moisture mozzarella on its own tends to leak before it even reaches the oil, so mix in low-moisture mozzarella or shredded cheese to keep the filling in place. Feta or cheddar can take over with their saltiness and aroma, so go light with them the first time.

Dried oregano is what keeps the tomato sauce from tasting like a plain Western tomato braise and moves it toward Mexican cooking. You only need 1 tsp, and it also works in tacos al pastor and sope. Cumin plays a supporting role. Just 1/3 tsp leaves a dry aroma behind the sweetness of the tomato and onion, and any leftover cumin is easy to use in bean dishes, kebabs and curries.

A thermometer is worth having. The main risk with chile relleno is the oil temperature dropping, which lets the batter soak up oil and turn heavy. If you keep the oil at 350°F (170–180°C), the first pepper holds together and the rest fry at the same pace.

Method

Char and steam the chilies first, and make the sauce while they steam. After stuffing, fry before the batter's foam collapses, so set out the oil, flour, cheese and toothpicks before you start.

Common chile relleno failures and fixes

Checking causes of failure in a kitchen with a chili that leaked a little cheese next to one that stayed closed
Tears, overstuffing and a drop in oil temperature are the main causes of failure in chile relleno

Chile relleno itself isn't hard. It gets hard when the steps happen out of order. If you simmer the sauce before charring, the chilies sit there cooling. If you make the batter and then fuss over the filling, the foam falls. Settle the order of preparation first and most failures go away.

What happens Main cause Fix
The skin won't peel Char too shallow, not steamed enough Char 2 more minutes and cover and steam 5 minutes
The chili tears Rubbed the skin too much, pulled the seeds hard Don't widen the slit; dust lightly with flour and let the batter support it
Cheese leaks Overstuffed, oil too cool Reduce the cheese by 20% and start frying at 350°F (170°C) or higher
Batter is heavy Weak foam in the whites, oil temperature dropped Whip to firm peaks and fry one at a time
Sauce is watery Tomatoes are very watery Simmer 3 to 5 more minutes over medium-low heat

When one tears, check the oil temperature and the amount of filling first. Even if the skin splits a little, the flour, batter and sauce, in that order, will hold it together at the table. If you keep frying in oil that's too cool, the next one turns heavy too, so let the pot come back to 350°F (170°C) before adding another.

With large bell peppers, peel off only the skin that comes away easily and leave the rest as toasty flavor, since it's thinner than a poblano's. Bell peppers are sweet, fleshy and watery, and with cheese the whole dish leans sweet. Balance it by making the sauce a little more acidic rather than adding more cumin.

Serving, nutrition and storage

Serving chile relleno

Chile relleno, tomato sauce, rice and lime divided between a storage container and a plate
On days you store it, keeping the sauce and the main separate keeps the batter from collapsing

Eat it fresh, while the batter is puffed and light and before it soaks up too much sauce. Rice, warm tortillas, lettuce and lime balance the richness of the cheese. At home, rice, beans or a salad pair better with it than a bread dish like cemita poblana.

Nutrition

Chile relleno, Mexican rice, lettuce, radishes and lime on one plate
Cheese and batter make it satisfying, so add light acidity and vegetables on the side

The whole recipe comes to about 2160 kcal for 4 servings, with one serving being 1 chile relleno, the sauce and 5.5 oz (150 g) rice. Protein comes from the cheese and egg, and fat from the oil. It's fried, but the meatless version isn't too heavy for a main, and the acidity of lettuce and radishes makes it easier to eat.

Item Guide for 4 servings total Guide per serving
Energy 2160 kcal 540 kcal
Protein 3 oz (82 g) 20.5 g
Fat 4.5 oz (132 g) 1.25 oz (33 g)
Carbohydrate 4.5 oz (130 g) 1.25 oz (32.5 g)
Fiber 20 g 5 g
Salt equivalent about 10.7 g about 2.7 g

For less salt, check how salty your cheese is and use 3/4 tsp salt in the sauce.

Storage

State Storage Reheating
Charred, peeled chilies Refrigerate 1 day. Wrap in paper towel in a container Wipe off moisture before stuffing
Stuffed Refrigerate 1 day. Dust with flour just before frying Coat and fry while cold
Fried main Refrigerate 2 days. Keep apart from the sauce 5 minutes in a 325°F (160°C) toaster oven, then 3 minutes in the sauce
Tomato sauce Refrigerate 3 days, freeze 3 weeks Warm in a small pot until bubbling

For a lunch box, pack the sauce in a separate container, because the batter will get damp. You can eat it cold, but the cheese hardens. If you can, warm it in the microwave at 600 W for 40 to 60 seconds, then pour the sauce over.

FAQ

Charred chilies, sauce, cheese, eggs and flour laid out in the kitchen while checking the preparation
Clearing questions first keeps you from stalling after the batter is made

Which vegetable is closest if I don't have poblanos?

Large bell peppers are the easiest to handle. They're milder, but you follow the same steps: char and peel the skin, stuff with cheese and fry in egg batter. Long sweet chilies smell much the same but hold less, so halve the cheese.

Can I stuff it with meat?

Yes. In Mexico there are versions stuffed with picadillo. This recipe uses cheese because it's easier to get right the first time. If you use meat, cool the stir-fried ground meat completely and cook off its moisture before stuffing.

Can I skip the batter and just bake it?

You can, but it becomes a different dish. The batter gives chile relleno its fluffy exterior and makes the sauce cling. To cut down on oil, thin the batter and shallow-fry in 0.5 inch (1 cm) of oil.

What should I add if I want it spicy?

Leave habanero and chili powder out of the batter and keep the sauce mild. Then let each person add chopped green chili or hot salsa at the table, which is much easier to adjust.

How much can I prepare the day before?

You can char, peel and stuff the chilies ahead of time. Make the tomato sauce the day before too, so the flavor settles. The batter has to be made on the day, because the foam falls. Store the sauce apart from the fried chilies, or the batter will absorb its moisture.

Sources