Pasty Recipe: The Michigan Mining Town's Hand-Held Meat Pie

A baked half-moon pasty broken open to show the beef and potato filling of a Michigan meat pie
Prep
50 min
Cook
55 min
Total
1 hr 45 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
American

A recipe for the pasty beloved in Michigan's Upper Peninsula. Covers beef, potato, a rutabaga substitute, a sturdy dough, folding, baking temperatures, storage, reheating, and the ketchup question.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Make the cold dough

15 min, plus 30 min resting

Pasty dough with cold butter cut into the flour until crumbly
Leaving some butter pieces keeps the crust from baking heavy

Heat/temperature: No heat is used. Keep the butter cold

Put the soft flour, bread flour, and salt in a bowl and add the cold butter and lard. With your fingertips or a food processor, cut them in until the butter is in pieces from the size of a grain of rice to that of an adzuki bean. Combine the cold water and vinegar; add ½ cup (100 ml) first and mix, and if it does not come together add 2 tsp (10 ml) at a time. Without kneading, press it together, divide into 4, shape into flat discs, and rest in the refrigerator for 30 minutes.

STEP22 / 6

Cut the filling small and mix

15 min

Beef, potato, root vegetables, and onion cut small and mixed as pasty filling
Do not fry the filling; cut it fine and raw and wrap it. Root vegetables cut too large do not cook through

Heat/temperature: No heat is used

Cut the beef, potato, turnip, daikon, onion, and carrot into roughly 0.25 inch (7 mm) cubes. Large potato pieces stay hard in the center, so cut the potato slightly smaller than the meat. Put everything in a bowl and mix with the salt, black pepper, and Worcestershire sauce. Stop once the salt and pepper are worked through. The filling should stay as loose cubes with only a thin dampness on the surface, not clump together. Start wrapping within 10 minutes, before liquid collects in the bottom of the bowl.

STEP33 / 6

Roll the dough into rounds

10 min

Rolling pasty dough into a round with a rolling pin
Aim for about 22–23 cm across and about 3 mm thick, and it does not tear when you wrap the filling

Heat/temperature: No heat is used

Dust lightly with flour and roll each rested piece of dough to 9 inches (22–23 cm) across and about 0.125 inch (3 mm) thick. Slightly uneven edges are fine. If it tears easily, lift it from the counter and turn it 90 degrees as you roll. If you roll it too thin, the meat juices leak, so stop before you can see the counter through it.

STEP44 / 6

Fill and close into a half-moon

10 min

Placing the pasty filling on a rolled round of dough before folding it into a half-moon
Do not fill all the way to the edge; leaving a margin keeps the juices from leaking during the bake

Heat/temperature: No heat is used

On the near half of the dough put about 5.5 oz (160 g) filling, leaving 1 inches (2 cm) at the edge. If you pile the filling too high it is hard to close, so spread it slightly lower in the middle. Brush a thin layer of water on the edge, fold the far side over to make a half-moon, press out a little air from inside, and press the edge with your fingers.

STEP55 / 6

Crimp the edge and cut a vent

10 min

Folding the edge of the half-moon pasty with fingers and brushing the surface with egg wash
The edge is not decoration; press it firmly as a wall to seal in the meat juices

Heat/temperature: No heat is used

Fold the edge in little by little from the outside to the inside, closing it like a thick rope. Pressing with a fork also works, but folding it sideways keeps it from collapsing when you hold it. Cut 2–3 small slits in the surface with a knife and brush on a thin layer of egg wash.

STEP66 / 6

Bake in the oven

40–45 min

Taking pasties with baked color out of the oven on the baking sheet
High heat in the first half lifts the dough; 180°C in the second half cooks the filling through

Heat/temperature: 400°F (200°C) for 15 minutes, then 350°F (180°C) for 25–30 minutes. Aim for 165°F (74°C) in the center

Line a baking sheet with parchment and arrange the pasties with space between. Bake in an oven preheated to 400°F (200°C) for 15 minutes, and when the dough has puffed and taken a light color, lower to 350°F (180°C) and bake 25–30 minutes. It is done when the surface is a deep golden brown and a thermometer inserted into the thickest part reaches 165°F (74°C) in the center. Rest 10 minutes after taking out before cutting.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Dough

Ingredient Amount Role
All-purpose (soft) flour 10.5 oz (300 g) The base of a crumbly crust
Bread (strong) flour 2.75 oz (80 g) Adds resistance to tearing
Unsalted butter 4 oz (120 g) Cut into 0.5 inches (1 cm) cubes and keep refrigerated until the last moment
Lard or shortening 1 oz (30 g) If unavailable, substitute 1 oz (30 g) unsalted butter
Salt 1 tsp Tightens the flavor of the crust
Cold water About ½ cup (120 ml) Adjust by 2 tsp (10 ml) while checking the dough
Vinegar 1 tsp Makes the dough a little easier to handle
2 / 3

Filling

Ingredient Amount How to choose
Lean beef 9 oz (260 g) Steak or stir-fry cuts, cut into 0.25 inch (7 mm) cubes. Ground beef releases juice easily
Potatoes 10.5 oz (300 g) A waxy potato keeps its shape; a floury one leans fluffier
Turnip 4 oz (120 g) Peel thickly and cut into 0.25 inch (7 mm) cubes
Daikon 1 oz (30 g) A small amount, just to offset the turnip's moisture
Onion 4 oz (120 g) 0.25 inch (7 mm) cubes, a little larger than minced
Carrot 2 oz (60 g) Some Michigan cooks leave it out. Use it to adjust sweetness
Salt Just under 1 tsp Combined with the butter crust, so do not make it too strong
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Coarsely ground suits it
Worcestershire sauce 1 tsp Adds aroma where the beef substitutes for other meats. Do not overuse
3 / 3

Finishing and serving

Ingredient Amount How to use
Egg 1 Mix with 1 tsp water and brush on the surface
Ketchup As desired A common way to eat it in the Upper Peninsula
Butter 20g A little on the hot cut surface
Pickles, green salad As desired Lightens the plate
0 / 0

Open the oven door and the sweet smell of potato and onion reaches you before the buttery crust does. A little fat from the meat has soaked into the inside of the crust, and the crimped edge is a deep golden brown. Cut into one straight from the oven and the steam will burn your fingers, but that heat is part of the pleasure. The pasty is a half-moon meat pie that came to North America from Cornwall, England, with immigrants, and it put down deep roots in the mining towns of Michigan's Upper Peninsula. Beef, potato, onion and rutabaga are wrapped in dough and baked into a filling meal you can hold in one hand.

A baked pie wrapped in paper, broken open by hand to show the meat and potato filling
Remember the pasty not as a plated feast but as a lunch wrapped to be carried, and the reason for its shape becomes clear

The Michigan Pasty and How It Is Eaten

In Michigan, it's "PASS-tee," not "PAY-stee." People eat it for lunch, buy it at roadside shops and keep it in the home freezer. It's served plainly, with no elaborate sauce. Where city chicken is a Great Lakes meat dish whose name keeps its history, the pasty survived in the same Midwest as a working person's lunch. It lacks the rush of aroma you get from Louisiana's jambalaya. What it offers instead is a filling meal made from nothing more than flour, meat and root vegetables.

Pasty and Cornish pasty

The Cornish pasty of Cornwall, England, has a protected name and its own method. The pasty here is the Michigan version from the Upper Peninsula: made with rutabaga, eaten with ketchup or butter, and often bought at a roadside shop.

Ketchup or Butter

Several baked half-moon pies lined up with sauces on the table
Even with the same shape, what goes with a pasty changes by place and household

In the Upper Peninsula, ketchup almost always comes up. That may seem odd for a dish of Cornish origin, but at roadside shops and at home, people put ketchup on a hot pasty. Some add a little butter to the cut surface instead. The ketchup brings acidity that cuts through the sweet root vegetables and meat, and the butter brings fat that rounds them out.

Regional Fillings and History

The filling varies too: beef alone, beef and pork, more potato, more rutabaga, with carrot, heavy on onion. Because it survived as a mining-town lunch, there are as many formulas as there are households and shops.

A migrants' dish became everyday food in an American place. The half-moon pie known as the meal of Cornish miners still turns up around the iron mines, copper mines and roadside shops of the Great Lakes region, where winters are long. The name hasn't changed, but ketchup, frozen sales and buying one on a drive to take home have changed what it means on the plate. When you make it at home, size each pasty as a full lunch. That shows the dish's character better than a small, refined one does.

Ingredients: Evoke Rutabaga with a Little Turnip

Flour, butter, beef, potato, root vegetables, egg, and a rolling pin laid out in the kitchen for pasty
Not many ingredients, but cutting the root vegetables small and preparing to wrap in cold dough is what matters

Makes 4 pasties, each large enough to be a lunch. Rutabaga is hard to find in many places, so use 4 oz (120 g) turnip and 1 oz (30 g) daikon to adjust the aroma and moisture. Turnip alone becomes too soft and sweet, and daikon alone too watery. Cut both small and go a little lighter on the salt, and you get close to the root-vegetable character of the pasty.

Allergens and cooking caution

This dish contains wheat, egg, dairy, and beef. Because the filling is wrapped raw, check the finished pasty by inserting a thermometer into the thickest part and aiming for 165°F (74°C) in the center. Browning alone makes it hard to judge how cooked the inside is.

Choosing Ingredients and Tools for Pasty

A rolling pin, thermometer, food processor, and baking sheet set out in a kitchen for making pasty
For pasty, tools show in the result more than ingredients. It is reassuring to roll the dough evenly and be able to check the center temperature

Rutabaga is worth finding, and if you see it at an import produce shop, try it. In many places it's hard to buy reliably, though, so on a first try use 4 oz (120 g) turnip and 1 oz (30 g) daikon instead, and spend your effort on getting the cutting and baking right. Turnip leads with sweetness and softness, and a little daikon supports it, though daikon gives up its moisture easily. You can salt and drain the vegetables after cutting, but that makes the saltiness of the whole filling hard to judge, so use them as they are and keep the amounts modest.

For the meat, lean beef cut small gets closer to the right texture than stew-cut scraps. Some cooks include carrot and some leave it out. It adds color and sweetness, so start with a small amount that won't overpower the potato and onion.

The tool that prevents the most failures is a plain rolling pin that rolls cold dough evenly to around 9 inches (23 cm). A cooking chopstick is too thin and gives uneven thickness. A small food processor is optional, since you can rub the butter in by hand. In summer or in a heated kitchen, though, it combines the butter with the flour before it melts, so the dough sags less. Use a thermometer you already have to check the center temperature, at least the first time, because the filling goes in raw and the outside browns before the inside is done.

Instructions: Stack Short Tasks, and Bake to the Center

A pasty is not simmered in a pot. It is a small steam-bake inside the oven. Since the filling is not sautéed, the size of the cut and the amount of the wrap show directly in how it cooks. Don't raise the temperature partway through. Start hot to lift the dough, then drop to 350°F (180°C) in the second half to cook through.

Common Pasty Mistakes and Fixes

A baked pasty broken open on a plate to check the moisture of the meat and root-vegetable filling
Too much moisture in the filling makes the bottom damp. Aim for a state where juice comes out when cut but the crust does not fall apart

At home, the hard part is keeping moisture out, more than the ingredients themselves. The meat goes in raw, never fried first. You cut the filling small, wrap it, and let the oven seal in the meat juices and the vegetable moisture. A thin crust tears, and a thick one lets the filling dry out before it cooks. The flavor comes down to three things: the size of the cut, how much you wrap, and the baking temperature.

The most common failure is cutting the filling too large. If the potato or turnip is in 0.5 inch (1.5 cm) cubes, the crust bakes but the center stays hard. Mince too finely and the vegetables release water, which turns the bottom sticky. About 0.25 inch (7 mm) cooks through and still keeps some texture.

Keep the dough cold. On a warm day it sags while you roll, and working in extra flour makes it tough, so when it softens, put it back in the refrigerator for just 5 minutes. Cold dough looks like it will crack, but it rolls more easily as it warms slightly in your hands. Resting it is faster than panicking and reworking it.

Leaks from the bottom come from too little margin at the edge and too much filling. More than about 5.5 oz (160 g) per pasty puts pressure on the seal, so bake any leftover filling in a small heatproof dish. The holes in the top let a little steam escape so the pasty doesn't burst. Cut them too large and the juice runs out.

If the flavor seems flat, taste it with ketchup or butter before adding salt. A pasty seasoned strongly enough to eat alone tastes too salty once it cools. If you serve it with ketchup the local way, keep the filling's salt slightly low. On days you add butter, don't push the salt any higher, or it gets tiring to eat.

Serving and Storing Pasty

A kitchen where baked pasties are cooling and being prepared for wrapping and storage
Cooling after baking and then wrapping keeps the crust from collapsing when reheated after freezing

Storage and Reheating

Bake first, then freeze. Freezing raw dough and filling together makes the vegetables release water, and the bottom tears easily. Cool the baked pasties and wrap each in plastic wrap. They keep for 3 days in the refrigerator or 1 month in the freezer.

To reheat from the refrigerator, warm in a 350°F (180°C) oven or toaster oven for 12–15 minutes. From frozen, thaw in the refrigerator for half a day, then warm the same way. If you're in a hurry, microwave at 600 W for about 1.5–2 minutes, then toast for 5 minutes so the center and surface both come out right. For safety, reheat leftovers until the center reaches 165°F (74°C).

For a packed lunch, let the pasty cool completely before you wrap it, because steam trapped under paper makes the crust damp. Pack the ketchup in a separate container and carry the pasty whole so it doesn't break. If you're carrying half, cool it cut side up and wrap it once the juices settle.

What to Serve Alongside

A pasty is a full meal, so skip a second heavy meat dish that day and serve a soup or something acidic on the side. For more American regional cooking, jambalaya, with rice and spices, and the po' boy, with its filling in bread, show how the South differs from the Great Lakes region.

If you'd like to compare other wrapped dishes, Bolivia's salteña shares the idea of sealing in liquid, and Argentina's empanada differs in how the filling is seasoned and how thick the dough is. Russia's pelmeni is a good comparison among boiled wrapped dishes.

FAQ

A close view of the edge and cross section of a baked pasty, showing the color and the wrapping
The way you close the edge, the amount of filling, and the baked color become steadier as you get used to it

Can I make it with ground beef?

You can, but it isn't recommended. Ground meat releases water easily once salted, and the bottom of the dough turns damp. If you use it, use 9 oz (250 g) ground beef, cut the vegetables slightly smaller, and wrap right after mixing the filling. The result is closer to a meat pie than a pasty.

Does ketchup really go with it?

It does. It's a common way to eat pasty in the Upper Peninsula. If you prefer butter, melt about 1 tsp on the cut surface. A lot of both at once gets heavy, so try half and half.

Can I make it without an oven?

You can use just a frying pan, but the pasty scorches easily and the center temperature is harder to control. Brown both sides in a thick frying pan with a little oil over medium-low heat, then cover and steam-fry over low heat for around 20 minutes. Turn it several times along the way and take off the lid at the end to drive off moisture. For a first try, the oven is more reliable.

Can I prepare it the day before?

The dough can be made the day before. Keep it in the refrigerator overnight and take it out 20 minutes before use. Cut the filling on the day, since cutting it ahead draws out water. If you must prep ahead, cut only the vegetables and store them separately, then combine them with the salt and meat just before wrapping.

Sources