Anguillian Johnny Cakes: Fried Bread with Flour and a Little Cornmeal

Browned Anguillian Johnny Cakes piled in a basket
Serves
18 Johnny cakes
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Anguillian

How to make fried Anguillian Johnny Cakes from plain flour and a little cornmeal, with notes on the island's coal-oven baked form, the shapes they take, and serving them with saltfish, butter, jam or stew.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Combine the dry ingredients

Cornmeal and sugar being mixed into the flour and other dry ingredients
Mix the dry ingredients before any liquid goes in

Sift the flour, baking powder and salt into a large bowl. Add the cornmeal and sugar, and mix well.

STEP22 / 6

Add the oil and water

Vegetable oil and water added to a well in the flour and brought together into a dough
Add the water gradually and stop to feel the dough as it comes together

Make a well in the center and pour in the ¼ cup (60ml) of vegetable oil. Work it into the dry mixture. Add the 1½ cups (360ml) of water a little at a time, not all at once, until you have a soft dough that isn't sticky.

STEP33 / 6

Knead and rest

Smoothly kneaded dough covered and left to rest
Cover the smooth ball of dough for its 15-minute rest

Knead until smooth, then shape the dough into a ball. Cover it and let it rest for 15 minutes.

STEP44 / 6

Divide and flatten

Dough divided into small pieces, with one being flattened into a round under the palm
Flatten each piece into a round

Lightly dust your work surface with flour and roll the dough into a log. Cut it into 18 equal pieces and roll each one into a ball. Flatten each ball with your hands or a rolling pin.

STEP55 / 6

Fry on both sides

A Johnny cake frying on its first side in oil covering the base of the pan
Fry the first side over medium heat until golden

Pour enough oil into a heavy-bottomed pan to cover the whole base, and heat it over medium heat. Fry a few cakes at a time without crowding the pan. Fry the first side for 2–3 minutes, until golden.

Turn the cakes carefully and fry the other side until lightly colored.

A golden Johnny cake being turned to fry the other side
Once the first side is golden, turn and color the second side
STEP66 / 6

Serve warm

Johnny cakes on a table with saltfish, butter and jam
The same bread works with a savory meal or a sweet spread

Serve the Johnny cakes while they are warm. Have them with saltfish, spread them with butter and jam, or use them to wipe up the gravy from a curry or stew.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Plain flour 1 lb (500g) The main body of the dough
Cornmeal 1.25 oz (35g) Grain flavor and texture
Baking powder 2 tbsp Raises the dough
Salt 1 tbsp Seasons the dough
Sugar 1.75 oz (50g) Sweetens the dough
Vegetable oil, for the dough ¼ cup (60ml) All of it goes into the dough
Water 1½ cups (360ml) Added little by little to bring the dough together
Flour, for dusting a little Keeps the dough from sticking to the work surface
Oil, for frying enough to cover the whole base of the pan Kept separate from the ¼ cup (60ml) in the dough. The amount depends on the width of your pan
0 / 0

Picture a small round of fried bread on the table, crisp on the outside and soft inside. At a meal it might sit beside saltfish. As something lighter, it gets butter and jam. Johnny cakes are one of Anguilla's classics, and this version is fried. The dough is mostly wheat flour with a little cornmeal worked in.

Johnny Cakes in Anguilla

Johnny cakes became popular in Anguilla in the 18th and 19th centuries as food for long journeys. Today you'll find them at breakfast, served alongside other meals, or used to wipe up the gravy from a curry or stew.

The name covers more than one kind of bread, and Anguilla alone has several. The old-fashioned form is baked in a coal oven, and some places bake them in a community rock oven. Fried Johnny cakes are made alongside the baked ones. Recipes vary from maker to maker and from restaurant to restaurant, and so do the shape and texture. Some cakes are flat, some have a hole in the center, and others have slits cut in the top.

Names can mislead here. Bajan fish cakes from Barbados are also fried, but they are made with fish and are a different dish.

Ingredients: Makes 18

Flour, cornmeal, baking powder, salt, sugar, vegetable oil and water
A dough built mostly on wheat flour, with a small amount of cornmeal

Equipment

  • Sieve
  • Large mixing bowl
  • Clean kitchen towel or other cover
  • Work surface or board
  • Rolling pin (optional)
  • Heavy-bottomed pan
  • Slotted turner

Choosing Flour and Cornmeal for Johnny Cakes

Flour: Use plain flour. If you swap in another flour from your cupboard, you're changing the recipe, so make a note of how the dough behaves.

Cornmeal: Cornmeal comes in different grinds, so compare the labels when you buy it. Potato starch won't work in its place.

Allergens

These contain wheat. Check the cornmeal label for possible allergen cross-contact.

Method: Soft Dough, Medium Heat

Frying safely

Keep water away from the hot oil, and keep the area around the pan dry. Don't crowd the pan, and take care when turning the cakes.

Troubleshooting Johnny Cakes

Frying time depends on your pan and how many batches you fry, so go by color and feel rather than the clock. Make small adjustments as you go.

Problem What to do
The dough is sticky Work in a little flour at a time until it is soft but no longer sticky
The dough is stiff Work in a little water at a time
The cakes are slow to turn golden Be patient and don't rush them over high heat
The pan feels crowded and turning is awkward Fry fewer cakes at a time
The oil spatters Make sure the dough, your tools and the area around the pan are dry

Serving and Variations

Johnny cakes are best served warm, soon after frying, while the outsides are still crisp.

You can cut a hole in the center or slits in the top before frying, but you don't have to. Here the oil only covers the base of the pan. Fried rounds puff best when they're fully submerged in oil, so if you want more puff, use deeper oil. Another version of the dough uses butter and leaves out both the cornmeal and the sugar.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a Johnny cake a kind of cornbread?

Not this one. Recipes differ from place to place, and this Anguillian version is mostly wheat flour with only a small amount of cornmeal.

Is frying the only way to make them in Anguilla?

No. An older form is baked in a coal oven, and it's still made alongside the fried ones.

How much oil goes in the dough, and how much in the pan?

All ¼ cup (60ml) of oil goes into the dough. That works out to about 1 tbsp of fat per cup of flour. Keep a separate supply of oil for frying, and use enough to cover the base of a heavy pan.

What temperature should the oil be?

Use medium heat and judge by color. The first side takes 2–3 minutes to turn golden.

Sources