Bajan Fish Cakes: Barbados's Fried Salt Cod Fritters

Golden-brown Barbadian salt cod fish cakes with pepper sauce
Prep
30 min
Cook
20 min
Total
2 hr 50 min
Serves
4 servings (about 24 pieces)
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Barbadian

A recipe for the fish cakes that are a breakfast and street-stall staple in Barbados, made with soaked salt cod, onion, herbs, hot pepper, flour and baking powder. Covers the bread-and-two sandwich, why the batter rests, and a cassava flour version.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Boil the dried cod, discard the water, and soak it in hot water to remove the salt

4 hours or more

Boiling dried cod, discarding the water and soaking it in fresh hot water to remove the salt
Boil once and drain, then soak in fresh hot water for 4 hours or more

Put the dried cod in a pot, pour in enough water to cover and bring to a boil over medium heat, then discard the water. Pour in fresh water, bring to a boil again, turn off the heat and leave it to soak for 4 hours or more (overnight is fine). It is enough when a nibble from the edge of the flesh tastes clearly salty but not too salty.

STEP22 / 5

Chop the salt cod and aromatics in a food processor

about 5 min

Chopping salt cod, onion and herbs fine in a food processor
It becomes a paste of fine, even bits

Drain the desalted cod, remove the bones and skin, and flake finely with your fingers. Put the cod, onion, Scotch bonnet, scallions, thyme, marjoram and parsley in a food processor and pulse several times for 10 seconds each, adding a little water. It has come together when the whole is an even paste of fine bits.

STEP33 / 5

Combine with the flour to make the batter, and rest 2 hours

2 hours

Mixing flour and salt cod paste in a bowl into a sticky batter
A heavy, sticky batter that plops off the spatula when scooped

In a large bowl mix the flour and baking powder, add the cod paste and mix with a spatula. Adding water 2 tbsp at a time, make a heavy, sticky batter that drops in a plop when scooped with the spatula. Season with salt and white pepper, cover with plastic wrap and rest 2 hours at room temperature (or overnight in the refrigerator). It is ready when the batter has swelled a little and small bubbles are visible on the surface.

STEP44 / 5

Heat the oil to 350°F (175°C) and fry the batter dropped from a spoon

about 15 min

Dropping balls of batter shaped with spoons into 175°C oil to fry
They are done when golden brown all over and floating

Pour oil to about half the depth of a deep pot and heat it over medium heat to 350°F (175°C). Dip two teaspoons in the oil, shape the batter into balls about 1 inches (3 cm) across and gently lower them into the oil. Do not crowd the pot; fry 6 to 8 at a time. Turning occasionally, fry 3 to 4 minutes, until they are an even golden brown all over and bob up to the surface.

STEP55 / 5

Drain, and check that the middle is cooked

about 2 min

Draining fried fish cakes on a rack and breaking one open to check the inside
Broken open, it is fluffy and cooked all the way through

Put the fried fish cakes on a rack to drain. Break the first one in half and check that the inside is a fluffy, dry crumb. If the center is sticky and raw, lower the oil temperature slightly and extend the frying time by 1 minute.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Salt cod and aromatics

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Dried salt cod 150 g (about 1 cup flaked) A boneless, skinless fillet is easiest to handle
Onion 1 Roughly chopped
Scotch bonnet 1 Habanero can substitute. If you dislike heat, use half or omit
Scallions 1/2 cup (about 4) In place of the local chives. Roughly chopped
Thyme (dried) 1 tsp
Marjoram (dried) 1 tsp If none, 1/2 tsp oregano
Parsley (fresh) 1/4 cup Roughly chopped
2 / 2

Batter and frying oil

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
All-purpose (low-protein) flour 250 g (about 2 cups) For a wheat-free version, cassava flour
Baking powder 2 tsp
Water 150–200 ml Add according to how the batter looks
Salt and white pepper A little of each Adjust to the saltiness of the cod
Frying oil As needed (up to 1/2 the depth of the pot) Soybean or vegetable oil
0 / 0

On a Barbadian morning at a street-corner stall, small balls of batter bob in the oil as they turn golden. The seller tucks a fresh one into a round bun, lays on cheese, and brushes on a stripe of yellow pepper sauce, and workers on their way carry it off in one hand. These are Bajan fish cakes, the fried salt cod balls you find everywhere on the island. Flaked salt cod goes into a flour batter that fries up crisp outside and fluffy within. With a desalted piece of dried cod and time to rest the batter, you can make them just the same at home.

Bajan fish cakes and "bread and two"

Frying fish cakes at a Barbadian stall and tucking them into bread

"Bajan" means Barbadian, and these salt cod fish cakes are an island specialty, found wherever people gather. Roadside sellers serve them as a morning snack with bread, cheese and a mustard-based pepper sauce, a combination called "bread and two." The "two" are the two fillings: fish cakes and cheese in a salt bread, usually with a little hot sauce and ketchup. At the rum shop they're a standard bite between games of dominoes, and at weddings and parties they come piled high on platters.

Salt cod is a preserved food that has long been shipped to the Caribbean islands. It kept in the days before refrigerators and flavors a lot with a little, so fish cakes, which stretch it through a flour batter, are a dish full of everyday wisdom. They're fritters rather than a pounded fish paste like Japanese satsuma-age. The star is the saltiness of the fish and the aroma of herbs; the batter is there to hold them.

A bit of background

Each cook builds the aroma differently. One Barbadian chef, twice named Barbados's chef of the year, adds dill, thyme, marjoram, chives, cumin and even curry powder to his batter, and serves the cakes with a dip of mayonnaise, mustard and lime juice.


Ingredients (serves 4, about 24 pieces)

Salt cod, onion, herbs, hot pepper, flour and baking powder for fish cakes

Tip

Dried salt cod is sold under the name "bacalao" at import grocers and online. To make the batter smooth, chop the salt cod and aromatics fine in a food processor before mixing them into the flour. Chopping finely by knife is fine, but if large strands of fish remain, the batter holds together poorly when fried.

Caution

Scotch bonnet is a very hot pepper. Wear disposable gloves when chopping it, and do not touch your eyes or face while working.

Choosing ingredients for Bajan fish cakes

Dried cod, cassava flour, dried thyme and marjoram laid out

Thyme, marjoram and parsley are the basic herbs. Add a little dill or cumin if you want to push the aroma further. One beaten egg is also welcome: it helps the batter hold together and makes the fried cakes plumper.

Fish cakes made with cassava flour

For a wheat-free version, use 2 cups of coarse cassava flour in place of the flour. Cassava flour makes the surface crisper and the inside chewy. Start with less water than you would for wheat flour, and bring the batter to the same plop-off-the-spoon firmness.


How to make Bajan fish cakes

Desalting takes 4 hours or more and resting the batter takes 2 hours. Hands-on time is about 30 minutes of prep and about 20 minutes of frying. You can also start the desalting the night before, make the batter, and rest it in the refrigerator overnight.

Caution

Keep the frying oil no more than half the depth of the pot, and lower the batter gently from close to the oil surface with a spoon. If the oil gets too hot, turn off the heat to bring the temperature down, and do not leave the pot.

Tips for fluffy fish cakes

Cross-section of a fish cake, crisp outside and fluffy inside

The step that makes the difference is resting the batter for 2 hours before frying. During the rest the flour absorbs moisture and settles, and the baking powder helps the batter swell. Fry in a hurry and the surface browns while the inside stays heavy.

Tip

Batter that's too loose spreads flat in the oil; if it flows right off the spoon, add flour 1 tbsp at a time. Batter that's too stiff won't puff when fried.

Tip

If the oil is too cool, the batter soaks it up and turns greasy; too hot, and it burns before the middle cooks. No thermometer? Drop in a little batter: it should sink once and then rise at once, wrapped in fine bubbles.

Serving Bajan fish cakes

Fish cake and cheese in a round bun as a bread and two
Fish cake and cheese in a round bun, served with pepper sauce

The easiest way is to eat them hot, dipped in pepper sauce. For breakfast, cut a round bun in half and fill it with 2 to 3 fish cakes and a slice of cheese for a "bread and two." A little whole-grain mustard stirred into hot sauce gets you close to the mustard-based pepper sauce of Barbados.

For more from Barbados, try the national dish, cornmeal and okra cou-cou with cou-cou and flying fish. Jamaica's ackee and saltfish is another Caribbean dish built on salt cod.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make it with lightly salted cod (amashio-dara)?

Yes. Lightly salted cod needs no desalting; remove the skin and bones, boil 10 minutes and flake finely before using. It's milder than dried cod, so add a pinch of salt to the batter.

Can I make it ahead?

Make the batter ahead instead: it can rest overnight in the refrigerator, so mix it the night before and fry in the morning. Fried fish cakes go limp as they cool, so fry them just before eating. Refrigerate any leftovers, eat them soon, and reheat thoroughly in a toaster oven.

How do I reduce the heat?

Halve the Scotch bonnet or leave it out. Everyone can then adjust the heat with the pepper sauce served alongside.

What allergens should I watch for?

The fish cakes contain cod (fish) and wheat, and egg if you add it. Cassava flour can replace the wheat.

Sources