Butter Tarts: Canada's Sweet Baked Filling in Pastry

Canadian butter tarts baked with a maple-colored filling, raisins and walnuts
Prep
1 hr 10 min
Cook
25 min
Total
1 hr 55 min
Serves
12 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Canadian (Ontario)

Make Canada's Ontario favorite, butter tarts, in a batch of 12. Covers the regional variations with raisins and walnuts, maple syrup substitutes, lining the pans, judging doneness by the wobble of the center, rescuing mistakes, and storage and allergies. Also includes the local history and the ingredients worth sourcing.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Make the dough crumbly and chill it

35 min

Butter tart dough with bits of cold butter remaining
Make a crumbly dough with the butter remaining in small pieces

Mix 6.5 oz (190 g) flour and 2 g salt in a bowl and add 4.5 oz (125 g) cold unsalted butter. Crush it with your fingertips into a state like damp sand, with the butter remaining in pieces from rice-grain to adzuki-bean size. Add 3.5 tbsp (55 ml) ice water and 1 tsp (5 ml) vinegar and press together while a little dry flour still shows. If much dry flour remains, add ice water up to 2 tsp (10 ml) more. Don't knead it smooth; shape it into a flat disc, wrap in plastic and rest in the refrigerator for 30 minutes.

STEP22 / 6

Roll out the dough and line the pan

35 min

Butter tart shells with dough lined into a 12-cup muffin pan
Roll the dough, line the pan, and chill it without pulling

Divide the chilled dough into 12 and roll each piece on a lightly floured surface to 4 inches (10 cm) across and about 0.125 inch (3 mm) thick. Place it in the muffin pan and press the bottom and sides lightly against the pan with the pads of your fingers. Pulling the edge thin makes it shrink while baking, so don't push in leftover dough; cut it off at the rim of the pan. Don't prick the bottom with a fork, because filling will leak. Return the whole pan to the refrigerator and chill for 30 minutes.

STEP33 / 6

Prepare the dried fruit and filling

25 min

Maple-colored filling with soaked raisins and chopped walnuts
Mix the syrup and eggs without making foam, and combine the fillings last

Pour boiling water over 2 oz (60 g) raisins and 1.5 oz (40 g) currants, leave for 20 minutes, drain in a strainer, and wipe the surface moisture with paper towels. Chop 2 oz (60 g) walnuts to about 0.25 inch (5 mm). In a separate bowl, gently mix 5 oz (140 g) brown sugar, 4 oz (120 g) maple syrup, 2.5 oz (70 g) melted butter, 2 eggs, 2 tsp (10 ml) vinegar and 2 g salt so it doesn't gain foam. When the sugar grains have disappeared and it is a smooth, flowing liquid, add the walnuts and fruit and stop.

STEP44 / 6

Pour in the filling two-thirds to three-quarters full

10 min

Twelve unbaked butter tarts with the filling poured in
Leave 5 mm at the rim and distribute the fruit and walnuts evenly

Into the chilled shells, first divide the raisins, currants and walnuts evenly. Pour in 40 to 45 g filling per tart, two-thirds to three-quarters of the depth of the cup, leaving about 5 mm from the rim. If the fruit gathers to one side, move it with chopsticks, but don't keep stirring to pop the bubbles. Fill it to the top and during baking the swelling liquid goes over the edge and sets between the pastry and the pan.

STEP55 / 6

Bake at 350°F (180°C) until the center wobbles

20–25 min

Butter tarts baking in the oven
Bake until the edges are golden, leaving a wobble at the center

Preheat the oven to 350°F (180°C) and put the pan toward the lower rack. Check at 20 minutes: take it out if the edge of the pastry is golden, fine bubbles appear on the surface of the filling and it is a deep amber, and when you shake the pan lightly only the center sets like jelly while trembling. If the liquid moves so much that the whole surface ripples, extend by 3 minutes at a time. If the edges darken first, drape aluminum foil loosely over them. Total time is usually 20 to 25 minutes at 350°F (180°C), depending on the depth of your pan and your oven.

STEP66 / 6

Cool in the pan, then remove

30 min

Baked butter tarts cooling in the pan
Rest 20 minutes in the pan and remove after the center has set

Set the baked pan on a rack and let it cool as it is for 20 minutes. Lift it while hot and the still-soft center pushes the pastry outward. Run a thin knife along the rim of the pan, remove the tarts one at a time and cool 10 more minutes. They are done when the center feels lukewarm to the touch, the surface does not run, and the bottom is firm enough to lift. If it has set too hard, leave it at room temperature for 15 minutes before eating and the butter aroma returns.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Pastry

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Cake or all-purpose flour 6.5 oz (190 g) All-purpose gives a little more bite. Bread flour alone tends to shrink
Salt 2 g Tightens the outline of the sweetness
Unsalted butter 4.5 oz (125 g) Cut into 0.5-inch (1 cm) cubes and chill until just before use
Ice water 3.5 tbsp to ¼ cup (55–65 ml) Add a little at a time, watching how dry the flour is
Apple cider vinegar or white wine vinegar 1 tsp (5 ml) Keeps the dough from tightening too much; if you have none, increase the ice water by the same amount
2 / 2

Filling

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Brown sugar or raw cane sugar 5 oz (140 g) It bakes with white sugar alone, but the molasses aroma is weaker
Maple syrup 4 oz (120 g) Golden syrup or corn syrup in the same amount. The aroma changes
Unsalted butter 2.5 oz (70 g) Melted and cooled to 104°F (40°C) or below
Eggs 2 (about 3.5 oz, 100 g net) Cracked and beaten, not too cold
Apple cider vinegar or white wine vinegar 2/3 tbsp (10 ml) Tightens the sweetness. The acidity doesn't remain strongly once baked
Salt 2 g Reduce to 1 g with salted butter
Raisins 2 oz (60 g) Seedless. Soak in boiling water for 20 minutes and wipe dry
Currants 1.5 oz (40 g) You may replace them with 2 oz (60 g) raisins
Unsalted walnuts 2 oz (60 g) Chopped to about 0.25 inch (5 mm). Can be omitted for no nuts
0 / 0

A butter tart fresh from the oven still trembles in the center. Leave it alone in the pan for 20 minutes, even if it looks liquid. As the egg-and-butter filling settles, the edge turns crumbly and the center becomes a thick, custard-like cream. This small Canadian sweet is butter, eggs, sugar and syrup poured into a pastry shell and baked, and it is rich and sticky with a soft, barely set heart.

A table with butter tarts filled with maple-colored filling arranged on a plate
Freshly baked, the center wobbles; as it cools, a butter tart sets thick and dense

About Butter Tarts

The best-known butter tart has raisins or currants and walnuts in the filling. Whether to add fruit or nuts, and how runny to leave the center, is up to you. This version is baked in a 12-cup muffin pan, with an all-butter pastry and a filling of maple syrup, raisins, currants and walnuts.

The butter tart is a small sweet for coffee or tea, not a festive savory pie like tourtière. Each one is a single serving, so everyone gets their own sweet center.

Butter tart history

No single inventor is behind the butter tart. A 1900 cookbook from Barrie, Ontario, has a "Filling for Tarts" made with sugar, butter, eggs and currants. Families passed down recipes by hand, possibly before anything was printed, so the cookbook records the tart's early history in Canada but does not prove where it began.

A 1908 filling used sugar, butter, eggs, currants and salt. In 1911, several recipes were collected from farm households around Ontario. Farm kitchens already had everything the tart needed: butter, eggs, sugar, flour and lard for the pastry. That is one reason the recipe varied from house to house.

Where butter tarts are eaten

The name is used across Canada, including Manitoba, Nova Scotia and the Yukon, but it is most closely tied to Ontario. The tart is related to the French-Canadian tarte au sucre. That tart usually has no eggs, though, so the two are different sweets.

Regional differences show up more at the bakery counter than on the map. Ontario bakeries sell classic, raisin, pecan and maple walnut versions. In Kawarthas Northumberland, a butter tart tour has run since 2011 and visits more than 50 bakeries, cafés and restaurants. The tour has made the tart a reason to visit small-town bakeries.

Raisins, nuts or plain

People argue over raisins versus nuts, but it is more useful to choose by texture. Raisins and currants add a soft sweet-sourness, and walnuts bring a little bitterness and some bite to the liquid center. Pecans give a toastier aroma, and a plain filling lets the smoothness of egg and syrup come forward. The butter tart is a sweet in which even whether it has a filling becomes a household's memory.

Ingredients: 12 to take up the liquid's sweetness

Flour, butter, brown sugar, maple syrup, eggs, dried fruit and walnuts for butter tarts
Divide the ingredients into pastry and filling, and sort out the moisture of the dried fruit first

Use a 12-cup muffin pan with 7.5 to 8 cm cups. If the pan is shallow, some filling will be left over, so don't force it all in, and don't bake it in an empty ovenproof dish. If egg-containing liquid spills outside the pan, it scorches easily before the bottom of the pastry sets.

Putting 3.5 oz (100 g) of raisins and currants in total scatters the fruit's sourness through the sweet liquid. Combine currants, golden raisins and walnuts, or raisins with walnuts or pecans. If currants are hard to find, use raisins instead; it is still a butter tart.

For maple syrup, don't use flavored pancake syrup; choose one that lists maple syrup as the main ingredient. To keep the aroma, use pure maple syrup. For a steadier sweetness and stickiness, use golden syrup or corn syrup, which gives a milder syrup taste.

It uses wheat, milk, egg and walnuts. Even if you swap walnuts for pecans or seeds, watch for contamination from shared equipment if anyone has a nut allergy. Check the ingredient labels on store-bought syrup and dried fruit for milk or wheat.

Whether to buy extra walnuts

For a raisin-only butter tart, it works without walnuts. When making a walnut version, choose unsalted ones with no old-oil smell when opened as your basis. If you need only 2 oz (60 g), buying a small bag nearby wastes less, and if you will also use them in other baked sweets or salads, choosing about 7 oz (200 g) online makes sense. On the product page, check for an "unsalted" label and the quantity.

If you bake the plain version without walnuts, or want to finish buying with just these 12, you can make it with what you have on hand.

Choosing Ingredients and Substitutes for Butter Tarts

The pastry uses butter alone, with no lard, so it is easy to shop for. The syrup and add-ins are where you can make changes. Maple gives the most aroma. Golden syrup or corn syrup gives a plainer, lighter sweetness.

Change Result Judgment
Maple syrup A woody aroma with a slight bitterness Choose it when you want the aroma to be the star
Golden syrup or corn syrup Rounder sweetness and a milder syrup aroma Replace in the same amount if you don't keep maple on hand
Raisins only Soft fruitiness with no walnut bitterness Use for nut allergies or adjusting for children
Walnuts only Toastiness and bite come forward Choose when you don't want fruity sweet-sourness
Change to pecans A stronger aroma and more of the richness of baked sweets Same amount as walnuts
No filling added The smoothness of egg and butter is the center Good when you first want to check how the filling sets

Honey changes the direction of the aroma, not only the sweetness. It often has a strong floral note, so golden syrup stays closer to the Canadian butter tart.

Method: 6 steps that leave the wobble in the center

Do not boil the filling. Don't whip the eggs too much, keep the pastry cold, and let the liquid set slowly in a 350°F (180°C) oven. Judging by browning alone can leave the center runny though the edges are done, so look at the state at each step.

Fixing Common Butter Tart Problems

A cross-section of a cooled butter tart with a softly set center
The center can be cut, yet has a softness that melts in the mouth

The hardest call at home is how long to bake the filling. If you overbake it, the egg turns firm. If you take it out too early, the tart won't come out of the pan. Roll the pastry thin, don't overfill, and stop when the center wobbles like jelly.

When the filling runs

If the center runs onto the plate after the tart seems cool, it probably hasn't cooled enough. Wait 30 minutes at room temperature. If it is still liquid, return the tarts to the pan and bake 5 to 8 minutes more at 325°F (160°C), and cover with foil if the top is already brown enough. If the egg is still weak after that, pour 1.5 oz (40 g) per tart next time, and judge doneness by how the center moves instead of stopping at 20 minutes.

When the filling gets hard

If you bake until the center no longer moves, the egg firms up even more as it cools. The tart is still good to eat, but it loses its thick, custardy quality. Next time, don't go by color. Stop when only the central 2 inches (5 cm) trembles as you shake the pan.

When the pastry shrinks or the bottom is damp

There are four common causes. You stretched the dough as you pressed it into the pan, you skipped the chilling time, you used too much filling, or you didn't dry the soaked fruit. Keep the pastry cold and about 0.125 inch (3 mm) thick. Use extra dough to build up the sides instead of rolling it out again. Pat the fruit dry and divide it among the shells before pouring, so liquid doesn't pool at the bottom.

Serving, Storing and Varying Butter Tarts

To make a meal of it, serve a chicken-and-potato soup from eastern Canada, such as fricot, and finish with the tarts. Modern versions add chocolate or coconut. For a first batch, though, focus on getting the sugar, egg and syrup to set.

Store baked tarts in a single layer in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 24 hours. Let them cool completely before you cover them. Refrigerate them instead if your room is hot or you are taking them on a long trip. Before eating, leave refrigerated tarts out for 15 to 20 minutes to bring back the butter aroma and the soft center.

To freeze leftovers, cool them completely, wrap each one, and put them in the freezer. Thaw them in the refrigerator, then bring them to room temperature, still sealed so the surface doesn't dry out. The filling has egg and dairy, so eat refrigerated or frozen tarts soon.

FAQ

Can't I make it without maple syrup?

Yes. Use golden syrup or corn syrup in the same amount. The sweetness and thickness come close, but the woody aroma is weaker. Sugar alone changes the amount and thickness of the liquid, and the tart won't bake the same, so use a syrup.

Is it still a butter tart without raisins?

Yes. Raisins, currants and nuts are common, but the name doesn't require them. Some homes make it with no add-ins, and some shops use only nuts. Without add-ins, the liquid fills each shell evenly, so pour about 1.5 oz (40 g) per tart.

May I remove them right after baking?

No. If the filling hasn't set, the thin pastry tears and the center runs. Leave them about 20 minutes in the pan, then 10 more on a rack. The cooling time is part of the cooking.

What if I have only tart pans, not a muffin pan?

Use twelve shallow tart pans of about 10 cm, or make one large tart in a shallow 20 cm pan. One large tart has a thicker center, so the baking time and the wobble will change. With a 12-cup pan, you can use these amounts and the 20 to 25 minute time as written.

What can I use in place of walnuts?

Pecans, almonds or pumpkin seeds work in the same amount. Nuts and seeds differ in aroma, oiliness and allergen labeling, so the tart will taste different. If you avoid nuts, leave out the add-ins or use seeds whose allergen labels you have checked, and wash your equipment again.

Note: the nutrition values are an estimate converted to the whole batch from the per-tart values in Canadian Living's 12-tart formula. They vary with the products used for sugar, butter, syrup, dried fruit and nuts.

Sources