Banana Poke: Cook Islands Ripe-Banana Pudding with Coconut Cream

Cook Islands poke, a banana pudding baked a deep amber, spooned into a bowl and generously topped with white coconut cream
Prep
25 min
Cook
1 hr 10 min
Total
1 hr 35 min
Serves
6 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Cook Islands / Polynesian

Banana poke is a Cook Islands celebration dessert of ripe bananas, tapioca starch and coconut cream. Shows how to mash the bananas and judge doneness.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Cook down and mash the bananas

Cooking sliced very ripe bananas in a heavy pot while mashing them with a wooden spoon
About 10 minutes, until the lumps are gone and it is thick

Peel the bananas, remove any blackened bruised parts, and cut into rounds about 0.5 inches (1 cm) thick. Put them in a heavy pot over medium heat and cook for about 10 minutes, mashing with a wooden spoon or masher. When the bananas have become a thick liquid and the lumps are gone and the color has deepened a little, that is enough.

STEP22 / 6

Add the tapioca starch and work it in

Adding tapioca starch to the bananas in a low-heat pot and working it with a wooden spoon until sticky
Add the starch in several portions and knead for about 5 minutes

Start preheating the oven to 400°F (200°C). Turn the pot to low heat, add the tapioca starch in 3–4 portions, and each time stir broadly from the bottom of the pot with a wooden spoon. After kneading for about 5 minutes the dough turns heavy and clings to the spoon, a very sticky dough.

STEP33 / 6

Put it in the dish and smooth the surface

Putting the banana dough into the oiled dish and smoothing the surface flat with a wet spatula
Smooth it flat with a wet spatula and cover with foil

Lightly brush the inside of the baking dish with vegetable oil. While the dough from step 2 is hot and soft, transfer it to the dish and smooth the surface flat with a spatula wetted with water. It will be about 1 inches (3 cm) thick, and it is enough when the surface is smooth and level. Meanwhile check that the oven has reached 400°F (200°C). Cover the dish tightly with aluminum foil. Do all this quickly, in about 3 minutes.

STEP44 / 6

Bake 50 minutes under foil

Banana dough baked to a translucent amber in a baking dish in the oven with the foil removed
Baked when it is a translucent amber through to the center

Bake in the oven preheated to 400°F (200°C) for 50 minutes. Lift the foil a little and press the center with a spoon; if the whole dough has turned a translucent amber and is springy, it is baked. If the center is still white and cloudy, bake 10 minutes more.

STEP55 / 6

Remove the foil and brown the top

Poke with a deep brown color on the surface after the foil is removed
10 minutes at 230°C to give the surface a deep brown color

Remove the foil and lightly brush the surface with vegetable oil. Raise the oven temperature to 450°F (230°C) and bake about 10 minutes more. It is done when the surface has a deep brown color, the edges are bubbling, and a light press with a finger meets a smooth, springy dough that pushes back.

STEP66 / 6

Warm the coconut cream and pour it on

Pouring plenty of warmed coconut cream over poke spooned into a bowl
Warm over low heat and pour on once it has thickened a little

Put the coconut cream in a small pot over low heat and warm for 5–8 minutes, stirring now and then. It is enough when the surface starts to bubble gently and it has thickened a little. Spoon the baked poke into bowls and serve with plenty of warm coconut cream poured over.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Poke dough

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Very ripe bananas 8 (about 1.75 lb (800 g) peeled) With skins that have turned brown
Tapioca starch 9 oz (250 g) Arrowroot also works
Vegetable oil 1 tbsp For the dish and the surface
2 / 2

Coconut cream

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Coconut cream 1¾ cups (400 ml) Coconut milk also works
0 / 0

At Christmas lunch, with the relatives gathered, a big baking dish comes out of the oven. Inside is a banana pudding baked a deep amber, wobbly and glossy. An adult spoons it into bowls and pours plenty of warmed coconut cream over the top, and the children can't wait to reach in. This is poke, the dessert people in the Cook Islands make for celebration days. It is soft, chewy and a little sweet, just from the ripe bananas.

Poke on Cook Islands celebration days

At a Cook Islands family gathering, a baking dish full of banana poke and a bowl of coconut cream set on the table

The Cook Islands is a country of 15 islands in the South Pacific, northeast of New Zealand. Poke is a dish made on special days like Christmas, Easter and birthdays, and people learn it from their aunties and grandmothers. About 20,000 people live in the Cook Islands, while more than 58,000 people of Cook Islands descent live in New Zealand and Australia. So poke gets handed down in kitchens far from the home islands too, Auckland among them.

There are only three ingredients: very ripe bananas, starch and coconut cream. The bananas are cooked and mashed, worked together with a starch such as arrowroot, and baked slowly. What comes out is a translucent amber dough with a springy, mochi-like chew and a jelly-like gloss. The basic way adds no sugar at all; the bananas do the sweetening.

Good to know

The name poke comes from an old Polynesian word meaning “to mix” or “to knead.” In Tahiti the “k” sound drops and it is called “po'e,” and it is eaten in the Cook Islands, French Polynesia including Tahiti, and Easter Island. Despite the same name, it is a different dish from Hawaii's fish salad “poke.”

In the past, the dough was wrapped in banana leaves and steam-roasted in an earth oven dug in the ground. Today it is usually baked in an oven.


Ingredients (serves 6, one 8 × 8 inches (20 × 20 cm) dish)

Very ripe bananas, tapioca starch, coconut cream and vegetable oil measured out for poke

Note

Bananas are among the fruits that easily cause a reaction in people with a latex (natural rubber) allergy. People with a banana or coconut allergy should not eat this.

Choosing bananas, starch and coconut cream for poke

Very ripe bananas with browned skins, tapioca starch and a can of coconut cream

How ripe the bananas are decides how good your poke will be. Use bananas whose skins have turned almost brown. Supermarket bananas need a few days at room temperature (or some time in the sun) until the skins are covered in black spots and brownish all over. The riper they are, the sweeter the pudding and the deeper its amber color.

The “pia” used in the Cook Islands is arrowroot or tapioca starch. Arrowroot is hard to find elsewhere, but tapioca starch turns up at baking-supply shops and online, so use that.

Tip

Tapioca starch gives a translucent gloss and spring when baked. Use it if you want the characteristic texture of poke.

Coconut cream is richer than coconut milk, with more fat, and comes in cans and cartons. If you can't get it, use coconut milk and simmer it a little longer when warming so that it thickens; the result is close.


How to make banana poke

Working the dough takes about 15 minutes, and then it bakes in the oven for about an hour. If you warm the coconut cream while it bakes, you can eat as soon as it comes out.

Tip

After the tapioca starch is added, the dough is very heavy and apt to stick to the bottom of the pot. Be sure to keep the heat low, and stir without pausing, scooping up from the bottom. If your arm gets tired, it is fine to turn off the heat and rest for a moment.

Tip

Layer hot poke and hot coconut milk alternately in the bowl and let them blend before serving. Mixing the coconut cream into the dough gives a creamy, soft-textured way to eat it.

Note

While you are cooking down the bananas or working the tapioca starch, the hot dough can spatter. To avoid burns, use a long-handled wooden spoon and do not bring your face too close to the pot. Baked poke is very hot all the way through, so let it cool a little before eating.

Serving and varying banana poke

A plate of warm poke in a bowl with plenty of white coconut cream over it
Warm poke with warm coconut cream

Freshly baked poke is soft enough to scoop with a spoon. Once the coconut cream coats it, the sweet banana aroma and the richness of coconut come together for a taste that is simple yet rich. In the Cook Islands it is usually eaten as a side dish in place of bread or potatoes, though it works just as well as a dessert, or even a salad.

As it cools, poke sets firmly. Chilled and cut into squares, it has a chewy bite like yōkan or uiro, a different kind of deliciousness from the warm version. Pour on more coconut cream before eating.

Poke made with pumpkin instead of banana, baked orange and topped with coconut cream

Pumpkin or taro can stand in for the banana. For pumpkin, remove the skin and seeds, steam it until soft, mash it, and use the same amount as the bananas (about 1.75 lb (800 g)). Pumpkin is less sweet, so add 2–3 tbsp sugar to taste.

Papaya and mango are also well-known variations in Polynesia. Mash the fruit and make it the same way for a poke with a tropical color and aroma. Swapping half the banana for mango adds a refreshing tartness.

Frequently asked questions

Will it be sweet without adding sugar?

With very ripe bananas, yes. Under-ripe bananas give a poke that lacks sweetness and browns only lightly, so wait until the skins turn brown. If it still seems not sweet enough, dissolve a little sugar in the coconut cream as you warm it.

Cut poke arranged in a storage container to refrigerate

Can I make it ahead?

Once it has cooled, cut it up, put it in a storage container, and finish it within 2 days in the refrigerator. It hardens in the fridge, but 30 seconds to 1 minute in the microwave brings back the chewy texture. Keep the coconut cream separate and warm it just before pouring on.

The center stays white and cloudy and won't turn translucent.

Either the baking time was too short or the dough was too thick. Keep the foil on and bake 10 minutes at a time. Tapioca starch turns translucent as it cooks, so once the center is done, the whole pudding turns amber.

Sources