Norfolk Island Pilhi: A Savory Bake of Very Ripe Bananas (Plun Pilhi)

Very ripe banana pilhi cut into pieces and served beside a fish dish on the table
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Norfolk Island

How to make plun pilhi, Norfolk Island's banana pilhi, from very ripe bananas, plain flour, salt and bicarbonate of soda. Includes how it differs from kumera and pumpkin pilhi, how it is served with fish or meat, and clear notes on what is still unconfirmed. This recipe has not been kitchen-tested.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Mash the bananas lightly

Peeled very ripe bananas being coarsely mashed in a bowl
Mash lightly and leave the texture uneven

Peel the 12 very ripe bananas and put them in a mixing bowl. Mash them lightly with a fork, leaving an uneven mash rather than a smooth puree.

STEP22 / 5

Add the salt and bicarbonate of soda

Salt and bicarbonate of soda being added to the mashed bananas
The salt and soda go in before the flour

Add 1/2 teaspoon salt and 1/2 teaspoon bicarbonate of soda to the bananas and stir them through. Keep the flour aside for now.

STEP33 / 5

Add the flour

Plain flour being added to the bananas with the salt and bicarbonate of soda
Add the flour last

Add 1 cup plain flour to the bowl and stir with a spoon to combine.

STEP44 / 5

Transfer to a baking tray

Banana mixture being transferred from a bowl into a plain baking tray
Move the mixture straight from the bowl to the tray

Tip the mixture from the bowl into a baking tray.

STEP55 / 5

Bake in a moderate oven

A tray of banana mixture going into a home oven
Bake for about an hour, then test the center with a skewer

Put the tray in a moderate oven, around 180°C (350°F), and bake for about an hour. Test the center with a bamboo skewer. If batter clings to it, bake a little longer and test again.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Very ripe bananas (plun) 1 dozen (12) The body of the dish
Plain flour 1 cup Brings the mixture together
Salt 1/2 teaspoon Seasons the mixture
Bicarbonate of soda 1/2 teaspoon Leavening; use food-grade
0 / 0

At the Island Fish Fry, a sunset gathering on the Norfolk Island coast, the tables fill with fried fish, salads, coconut bread and pilhi. Bananas and flour might make you expect a sweet cake. This pilhi is a savory banana slice instead. The very ripe banana version is called plun pilhi. It takes four ingredients and no added sugar, and islanders serve it as a vegetable with fish or meat.

Pilhi on Norfolk Island

Pilhi is a family of baked dishes common on Pitcairn and Norfolk Island, not one fixed recipe. Cooks make it from mashed or grated fruit and vegetables. Root vegetables are often the base, but banana or corn also appear, and some versions include coconut. On Norfolk, the best-known versions are made with banana, kumera (sweet potato) or pumpkin.

Pilhi has long belonged at community gatherings. The Bounty Picnic at Kingston is a communal lunch, and a 1946 picnic menu included pilhi, described there as a vegetable cake made with kumera, ripe banana or pumpkin.

Bananas have their own history on the island. Pitcairner settlers arrived in 1856, and banana growing and export followed, with a boom from the late 1920s into the early 1930s. Island kitchens used bananas at every stage of ripeness, sometimes as a vegetable. Plun pilhi uses the fruit when it is very overripe.

A still life of a grooved volcanic-stone grater shown as cultural background
An illustrative still life for cultural context; a grater is not used in this recipe

The yolor, a grater brought from Pitcairn in 1856, is part of the wider story of island cooking. Ripe bananas mash easily, so this version needs no grater. Island cooks worked with seasonal ingredients, limited supplies and substitutions, and families and the community shared their recipes.

Ingredients for Plun Pilhi

Twelve very ripe bananas, plain flour, salt and food-grade bicarbonate of soda laid out together
Four ingredients: very ripe bananas, plain flour, salt and bicarbonate of soda

Equipment

  • Mixing bowl
  • Fork
  • Spoon
  • Measuring cup and measuring spoons
  • Baking tray
  • Oven
  • Bamboo skewer

Choosing Bananas, Flour and Soda for Plun Pilhi

Very ripe bananas with brown speckles across their yellow skins
A guide to ripeness: plenty of brown speckles on the skin and soft fruit inside
  • Bananas: Look for skins with plenty of dark speckles and fruit that has gone soft. Green bananas belong in other dishes.
  • Flour: Ordinary plain flour, as the recipe calls for.
  • Bicarbonate of soda: Also sold as baking soda. Choose a food-grade product, and don't use baking powder in its place.
  • Additions: Stick to the four ingredients. Sugar, coconut, oil, kumera or pumpkin would make it a different recipe.
Allergy note

Plain flour contains wheat. Check the labels on the products you buy for other allergens and cross-contact.

Fixing Common Plun Pilhi Problems

Situation What to do
Batter clings to the skewer after about an hour Bake a little longer and test again.
The pilhi sticks to the tray Other pilhi methods use greased tins or banana leaves; treat those as separate methods.
Your bananas are still green Wait for very ripe fruit. Green bananas go into other dishes, such as mudda (dumplings cooked in milk) and green banana fritters.
It seems plain for something made with bananas Leave out the sugar. This version is meant for savory food, so taste it alongside the fish or meat.

Serving and Varying Plun Pilhi

A shared table with pilhi served alongside fish and meat dishes
Pilhi has its place beside the main dish, as a vegetable would

Cut the pilhi and set it on the plate beside fish or meat, as you would any vegetable. Expect some difference between batches, because bananas vary even within "very ripe." A different tray also changes how thick the pilhi bakes and how cleanly it releases.

Kumera and pumpkin pilhi are dishes in their own right, so they aren't simple swaps for the banana here. Make them from their own recipes rather than with these amounts. For more Pacific cooking, try banana poke from the Cook Islands, a sweet banana dish that shows how differently the same fruit can turn out. Panipopo from Samoa brings coconut and bread together.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is pilhi a sweet dessert?

Not this version. Very ripe bananas bring their own sweetness, but there's no added sugar. It's served with fish, meat or other savory dishes.

How much should 12 bananas weigh?

The recipe counts bananas instead of weighing them. Bananas vary in size, so go by ripeness: look for dark speckled skin and soft fruit.

What temperature is a moderate oven?

"Moderate oven" is a traditional term that generally means about 180–190°C (350–375°F). Cooks used it loosely before ovens had thermometers. Around 180°C is a sensible place to start.

Can I store or reheat it?

Treat it like any other cooked food and follow your local food-safety guidance for storing and reheating.

Sources