Nutmeg Ice Cream: A Cold Dessert from Grenada, the Spice Island

Grenadian nutmeg ice cream sprinkled with freshly grated nutmeg, with whole nutmegs
Prep
15 min
Cook
15 min
Total
4 hr 30 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Grenadian

Nutmeg ice cream is Grenada's signature dessert of milk, cream, eggs, sugar and fresh grated nutmeg. Covers heating the custard to 79°C and freezing.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Heat the milk and cream to just below a boil

5 min

Heating milk and cream in a pot to just below a boil
Turn off the heat when small bubbles form at the edge and steam rises

Put the milk and cream in a pot over medium heat. When small bubbles form around the edge of the pot and steam rises from the surface, turn off the heat right away without letting it boil. A hard boil forms a skin on top and spoils the texture.

STEP22 / 6

Mix the eggs, sugar, and nutmeg

3 min

Whisking eggs, sugar, and grated nutmeg in a bowl
The sugar is no longer gritty and the mixture is an even pale yellow

In a bowl, combine the eggs, granulated sugar, 1 tbsp grated nutmeg, salt, and vanilla extract, and whisk well for about 1 minute. When the sugar no longer feels gritty and the whole mixture is an even pale yellow, it is enough.

STEP33 / 6

Add the hot milk to the eggs a little at a time

2 min

Pouring warm milk into the egg mixture a little at a time while whisking
Pour in small amounts so the eggs blend in without setting

First pour about ½ cup (120 ml) of the warmed milk and cream into the egg bowl a little at a time, whisking quickly. Once the eggs have warmed and blended in, pour the contents of the bowl back into the pot and mix everything together. If you add all the hot liquid at once, the eggs will set and turn lumpy.

STEP44 / 6

Cook the custard to 174°F (79°C) over medium-low heat

8 min

Stirring the custard in the pot with a wooden spoon and checking for 79°C with a thermometer
A thin coat on the back of the spoon, with the finger line holding

Set the pot over medium-low heat and stir constantly with a wooden spoon, brushing the bottom of the pot. Heat until a thermometer reads 174°F (79°C). It is done when the custard forms a thin, glossy coat on the back of the spoon and a line drawn with a finger stays clean. Eggs begin to set well above 176°F (80°C), so take the pot off the heat as soon as it reaches temperature.

STEP55 / 6

Chill it quickly over ice water

15 min

Straining the custard into a metal bowl and cooling it over ice water
Stir over ice water until it is cold

Strain the custard through a fine-mesh sieve into a metal bowl, leaving only a smooth, glossy liquid. Set that bowl in a slightly larger bowl holding about 2 inches (5 cm) of ice water. Chill for about 15 minutes, stirring now and then, until it feels cold when you put a finger in. Press plastic wrap directly onto the surface and chill in the refrigerator for 1 more hour.

STEP66 / 6

Freeze it in the freezer, stirring as it sets

3 hours

Stirring partly frozen ice cream with a fork in the freezer
Smooth, thickly set, and firm enough to scoop

Move the chilled custard to a metal storage container and put it in the freezer. After 1 hour, when it begins to set at the edges, stir everything well with a fork or whisk, then stir the same way 2 to 3 more times at 45-minute intervals. When the whole mixture is smooth, thick, and scoopable with a spoon, it is done. If you have an ice cream maker, freeze it according to its manual.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Custard

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Milk 1½ cups (360 ml)
Heavy cream (35% milk fat or more) 1½ cups (360 ml)
Eggs 3 (large)
Granulated sugar 5.5 oz (150 g)
Nutmeg (whole) 1 (grated, 1 tbsp) Ground nutmeg: 2 tsp. The aroma will be weaker
Salt a pinch (1/8 tsp)
Vanilla extract 1 tsp
2 / 2

To finish

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Nutmeg (whole) a little Grate and sprinkle just before serving
0 / 0

Look closely at the flag of Grenada, a small island nation in the Caribbean, and inside the green triangle on the left you'll spot a small nut. That's a nutmeg, and it's the reason Grenada is called the "Spice Island". On a hot afternoon there, what you want is nutmeg ice cream: softly sweet and fragrant with plenty of freshly grated nutmeg. It takes only milk, cream, eggs, sugar, and whole nutmeg. If you've only ever used nutmeg to season a burger patty, you'll be surprised how beautifully it perfumes a sweet dessert, and you can make it in your freezer without an ice cream maker.

Nutmeg and Grenada, the Spice Island

A Grenadian nutmeg fruit and the red lacy mace around the seed

The nutmeg on Grenada's flag stands for the island's main export. When Grenada became independent in 1974, the nutmeg was the only design carried over from the previous flag, which shows how closely the island's life and economy are tied to this spice.

It hasn't always gone smoothly for the island's nutmeg. In September 2004 Hurricane Ivan hit Grenada, the first direct hit from a hurricane in 49 years, and damaged nine out of ten homes. Together with Hurricane Emily the following year, 2005, it dealt a heavy blow to agriculture, and especially to the nutmeg industry. The industry is expected to recover gradually as newly planted trees mature.

Good to know

Nutmeg is the seed of the fruit of the nutmeg tree. The red lacy covering around the seed, dried, becomes another spice, mace. So one fruit gives two spices. Much of Grenada's nutmeg is produced by small farms. More than 70 percent of growers are small farmers who sell under 507 pounds (about 230 kg) a year.

Nutmeg ice cream is the Spice Island's sweet treat. It's an egg-and-milk custard flavored with nutmeg, and it tastes as familiar as a chilled version of the winter drink eggnog.


Ingredients (serves 4, about 1 quarts (1 L))

Nutmeg ice cream ingredients: milk, cream, eggs, sugar, and whole nutmeg

Tip

Do not use pre-ground nutmeg, because ground nutmeg quickly loses the oils that carry its aroma and flavor. Whole nutmeg is available at spice shops, international grocers, and online. Grate it just before use on a fine grater or a nutmeg grater.

Warning

Nutmeg is strongly aromatic and is not something to eat in large quantities at once. Use one nutmeg for 4 servings, and do not add several because you want a stronger aroma.


How to Make Nutmeg Ice Cream

Allow about 30 minutes to make the custard and about 4 hours to chill and freeze it. If you use an ice cream maker, the freezing time is shorter.

Warning

The custard contains eggs, so once it reaches 174°F (79°C), chill it quickly and do not leave it at room temperature for long. Move it to the freezer the same day you make it, even while it is chilling.

Tips for Smooth Nutmeg Ice Cream

Scooping smooth nutmeg ice cream with a spoon

If you're making it without an ice cream maker, the most important thing is to stir many times while it is still partly frozen. Each stir breaks up large ice crystals and works in air, so the ice cream melts smoothly in the mouth.

Tip

A thermometer makes it foolproof to heat the custard to 174°F (79°C). If you do not have one, judge by running a finger through the coat on the back of the spoon: the line should stay clearly and not run.

Tip

Nutmeg infused into the milk while the custard heats gives a mellow flavor, while nutmeg grated over the top at the end gives a vivid one. Using both adds depth to the aroma.

Serving Nutmeg Ice Cream and a Richer Version

How to Eat It

Finished nutmeg ice cream sprinkled with freshly grated nutmeg
Scooped into a dish with a little nutmeg grated over it

Scoop it into chilled bowls and grate a little nutmeg over it at the table. The moment the aroma rises is the best part. It's also lovely next to warm apple pie or baked apples, or, Caribbean style, with sautéed bananas flambéed with rum.

To cook one more dish from Grenada, try oil down, the national dish of breadfruit, salted meat, and dumplings simmered in coconut milk until the liquid is gone. For another Caribbean sweet, there's Haiti's baked sweet potato pudding, pen patat.

A Richer Version with Only Yolks

A rich nutmeg ice cream made with only egg yolks

Made with egg yolks instead of whole eggs, the ice cream turns a deeper yellow and tastes richer, more like custard. For this version, use 2½ cups (600 ml) milk, 1½ cups (360 ml) cream, 7 oz (200 g) granulated sugar, 3 egg yolks, and 1 tsp grated nutmeg.

Warm the milk and cream with half the sugar and the nutmeg. Whisk the remaining sugar with the yolks until pale, then combine them with the milk. This carries the nutmeg's aroma into the milk well and gives an ice cream with a soft, rounded aroma.

FAQ

Whole nutmegs and a nutmeg grater laid out

Can I make it with ground nutmeg?

You can, but the aroma will be much weaker. Use about 2 tsp ground nutmeg, and still grate whole nutmeg over the top just before serving.

How long does it keep?

It keeps in the freezer, but over time it picks up frost and the aroma fades, so finish it soon. If it gets too hard, move it to the refrigerator 10 minutes before serving so it's easier to scoop.

Is it safe for children?

At the quantity in this recipe, each person gets only a tiny amount of nutmeg. Nutmeg can make you ill in large amounts, so keep to the amount given.

Which ingredients are allergens?

It contains eggs and dairy (milk and cream).

Sources