Pai Susu: A Whole Balinese Milk Custard Tart for the Home Oven

A home-style pai susu baked as one whole tart in a single pan
Serves
8 servings
Cuisine
Indonesian

A home version of pai susu baked as one 9-inch tart rather than as small Bali souvenir tarts. It has a flour-and-butter crust and a strained filling of egg yolks, sweetened condensed milk and water, with clear guidance on checking the center temperature, chilling and unmoulding.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 8

Cut the butter and mix the dough

Flour, butter and sugar being mixed with a pastry cutter
Stop when the dough barely holds together

Cut the chilled butter into 1/2-inch cubes on a clean board, keeping it cold until it goes into the flour. Put the flour, butter and sugar in a bowl. Work them together with a pastry cutter, two knives or your hands. Do not add water. Stop when the mixture barely holds together as a ball.

STEP22 / 8

Shape the shell

Dough being pressed up the sides of a tart pan
Work around the pan so the sides are even

Put the dough in the tart pan and press it evenly across the bottom with your fingers, leaving enough dough for the sides. Press the remaining dough evenly up the sides of the pan. Prick the bottom of the raw shell lightly with a fork. The shell should have an even base and even sides.

STEP33 / 8

Make and strain the filling

The liquid filling being poured through a sieve into a clean bowl
Strain the filling for a smooth custard

Whisk the egg yolks, sweetened condensed milk and water until combined. Wash your hands, and clean anything that has touched raw egg before using it for another job. Pour the filling through a sieve into a clean bowl. Straining is for a smooth texture only. It does not make raw egg safe. The filling should be a smooth liquid.

STEP44 / 8

Fill the shell and preheat the oven

Strained filling being poured into the raw tart shell
The filling goes into the unbaked shell

Preheat the oven to 325°F. Pour the strained filling into the unbaked shell. If the oven is not ready yet, keep the filled shell in the refrigerator instead of leaving it out at room temperature. Once the oven has reached 325°F, the tart is ready to go in.

STEP55 / 8

Bake the tart

A baked tart in its pan with a golden crust and set custard
A golden crust and set surface are visual cues, not a temperature reading

Using oven mitts, slide the filled pan onto the middle rack. Bake for 30 to 35 minutes, until the crust is golden and the custard is set. Then move the pan to a clean heat-safe rack with oven mitts. Do not stop at the clock: check the center in the next step.

STEP66 / 8

Check the center temperature

A thermometer probe inserted into the center of the baked custard
Measure at the center of the custard

Insert a clean thermometer probe into the center of the custard. The center must be at 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute. If it falls short, return the tart to the oven, keep baking, and check again with a clean probe. Do not serve this tart with a raw or soft-set center.

STEP77 / 8

Chill the tart in the pan

The baked tart in its metal pan on a support inside a refrigerator
The tart stays in its pan while it chills

Without waiting for the tart to cool completely at room temperature, put it in the refrigerator, still in its pan on a clean heat-safe support. Make sure the refrigerator is at 40°F or below. Chill until the tart is cold.

STEP88 / 8

Remove the pan and slice

A clean knife cutting a slice from the chilled tart
Cut only after the tart has chilled

Once the tart is cold, support the removable base from below and lift the outer ring away. Do not try to slide out a hot tart. Cut the cold tart with a clean knife into pieces of the size you want. The slices should hold their shape cleanly.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
All-purpose flour 250g Crust
Butter, chilled 125g Crust; cut into 1/2-inch cubes
Sugar 1 tablespoon Crust
Egg yolks 3 Filling; whites are not used
Sweetened condensed milk 200g Filling; weigh it
Water 100ml Filling
0 / 0

Pai susu, sometimes spelled pie susu, is a milk custard tart from Bali. Small versions are a popular souvenir there. It has two layers: a butter crust pressed into the pan by hand, and a smooth custard made from egg yolks, sweetened condensed milk and water. This home version is baked as one large tart in a 9-inch removable-bottom pan, then chilled before you unmould and slice it.

What Pai Susu Is

The crust is simple, just flour, cold butter and a little sugar. Yolks, sweetened condensed milk and water make up the entire filling, which gives it a pure milky flavor. The baking time is set for one large tart, so it won't work for mini tarts or muffin pans. Bake the recipe as written rather than doubling it.

Other recipes go by the same name and use different formulas. Some, for example, cook a custard of milk, sugar and cornstarch in a teflon pan. Keep those ingredients out of this tart, and stick to the pan size, flour and condensed milk listed here.

If you'd like to cook more from the region, browse recipes from Indonesia. Ayam betutu, sate lilit and sambal matah are Balinese dishes, and klappertaart is a sweet from another island.

Ingredients: One 9-Inch Tart, 8 Servings

The ingredients for pai susu, divided into those for the crust and those for the filling
Three ingredients for the crust and three for the filling

Equipment

  • Removable-bottom tart pan, 9 inch x 1.125 inch
  • Kitchen scale and a tablespoon
  • Cutting board and knife
  • Mixing bowl
  • Pastry cutter, two knives, or clean hands
  • Fork
  • Whisk and a bowl for the filling
  • Sieve and a second clean bowl
  • Oven mitts
  • Clean heat-safe rack or other support
  • Food thermometer with a probe
  • Clean knife for slicing

Choosing Ingredients for Pai Susu

Condensed milk. Weigh out 7 oz (200g) rather than guessing at 1/2 can, because can sizes vary.

Water, not milk. Together, the sweetened condensed milk and water are the whole liquid base. Swapping in milk turns it into a different formula.

Butter. Keep the butter chilled. The recipe calls for no separate salt.

Flour. Use all-purpose flour. Cake flour or starch won't give you the same crust.

Raw egg needs care, so wash your hands and clean anything it touches.

Allergens and raw ingredients

This tart contains wheat, milk and egg. Check the labels on what you buy, including any cross-contact statements. Do not taste the raw dough or raw filling before baking. Wash your hands, tools and work surfaces before and after handling raw eggs.

Method: From Pressed Crust to Chilled Slice

The filled shell goes straight into the oven without blind baking. You can switch the oven on earlier than step 4 so that the filled shell does not have to wait.

Common Pai Susu Problems and Fixes

A golden crust and a set surface are good signs, but they can't tell you what's happening in the middle. The center of the custard has to reach 167°F (75°C) and stay there for at least 1 minute, so measure it every time.

What you notice What to do
The dough only barely holds together That is the target. Press it into the pan without adding water
The filling has bits in it Pour it through the sieve into a clean bowl before filling the shell
The tart looks done, but you have not measured it Measure anyway. A golden crust and set surface do not show the center temperature
35 minutes have passed and the center is below 167°F (75°C) Keep baking and check again. The 30 to 35 minutes is a guide, not a guarantee
The crust is getting darker while you continue baking The temperature check still comes first. Extra baking can change color and texture
The tart still feels warm when you go to unmould it Return it to the refrigerator and try once it is cold

Serving and Storing Pai Susu

A single slice of pai susu on a plate
One slice, served without garnish

Serve the tart cold, straight from the refrigerator. Put leftovers back in quickly and keep them at 40°F or below. Egg dishes shouldn't sit at room temperature for more than 2 hours, or more than 1 hour above 90°F.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this the same as the small tarts sold as souvenirs in Bali?

No. This home version is made as one tart in a 9-inch pan, and its baking time doesn't carry over to mini tarts.

Should I add milk, cornstarch or vanilla to the filling?

No. The filling is just yolks, sweetened condensed milk and water.

Is a golden crust enough to know it is done?

No. Watch for a golden crust and set custard, and also measure 167°F (75°C) at the center for at least 1 minute. If it hasn't reached that yet, keep baking and check again.

How long does it take?

The recipe gives timings of 15, 35 and 50 minutes. Those cover only parts of the process. The center check, chilling and unmoulding add more time, and if the center needs longer in the oven, keep baking.

Sources