Bún Cá: Old Hanoi Fish Noodle Soup with Boiled Snakehead and Clear Broth (Canh Bún Cá)

Hanoi-style canh bún cá: boiled snakehead flakes, water celery and dill in a bowl of clear hot broth
Cuisine
Vietnamese

How to make canh bún cá, the boiled-fish version of Vietnamese bún cá that recipe author Bùi Thủy presents as an old Hanoi dish: snakehead poached with ginger and shallots, a clear non-sour broth of fish bones and pork bones, one seasonal green, dill, scallion and crisp pork cracklings. Includes how it differs from fried-fish bún cá, fish safety, and an honest note on the amounts this recipe does not give.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 10

Clean the fish with chanh and coarse salt

Rubbing chanh and coarse salt over a raw snakehead, then rinsing it

Working on a separate board by the sink, rub chanh and coarse salt all over the cleaned whole snakehead to remove the slime and fishy smell. Rinse the fish thoroughly. Wash your hands, the board and the knife before touching anything else.

STEP22 / 10

Boil the whole fish with ginger, shallots and salt

Boiling the snakehead in a pot with ginger, shallots and a little salt

Fill a pot with water as needed. Add part of the ginger, smashed, 2 of the dried shallots and a little salt. Boil the whole fish in it until the thickest part reaches 63°C / 145°F on a food thermometer. If you can't use a thermometer, cook until the flesh is opaque and flakes easily. Don't judge doneness by color alone. Lift the fish out.

STEP33 / 10

Lift the meat off the bones and season it

Lifting cooked fish off the bones and tossing it with fish sauce and pepper

Using clean utensils kept apart from the raw-fish ones, pull the cooked meat off the bones and flake it. Look closely for small bones as you go, and pick them out with tweezers. Toss the flakes with a little fish sauce and black pepper. Keep the head and bones for the broth.

STEP44 / 10

Blanch the pork bones, then simmer them with the fish bones

Blanched pork bones and fish bones simmering gently with ginger and shallots

Blanch the pork bones briefly, discard that water, and rinse the bones several times. Put them in the stockpot with the fish head and bones, the remaining ginger, some of the remaining dried shallots and water as needed. Simmer gently. Leave the bones whole; crushing them clouds the broth. Add no lime, vinegar or other sour ingredient.

STEP55 / 10

Strain the broth and season it

Straining the fish and pork bone broth through a fine-mesh strainer

Pour the broth through a fine-mesh strainer into a clean pot, so that no bones or bone fragments end up in the broth. Discard the spent bones and aromatics. Season the broth to taste with salt, fish sauce and MSG, and keep it hot.

STEP66 / 10

Parboil the pork fat, then fry it into tóp mỡ

Frying blanched and rinsed pork fat into crisp tóp mỡ

Parboil the raw pork fat briefly and rinse it. Fry it in a pot until crisp and golden, then lift out the cracklings with a slotted spoon. Leave the melted pork fat in the pot.

STEP77 / 10

Fry the shallots in the pork fat

Frying shallots in the rendered pork fat

Fry the rest of the dried shallots in the reserved pork fat, then lift them out with the slotted spoon.

STEP88 / 10

Dip the fresh bún in hot water

Dipping fresh rice vermicelli in hot water to warm it

Put the fresh rice vermicelli in a wire strainer basket, dip it in hot water to warm it, and drain.

STEP99 / 10

Blanch the seasonal green just before serving

Blanching water celery just before serving

Blanch your one chosen green, water celery here, in hot water just before you assemble the bowls, then lift it out.

STEP1010 / 10

Assemble the bowls and pour over the hot broth

Pouring hot clear broth over rice noodles, flaked fish, water celery, dill and scallion

Put the bún in the bottom of each bowl. Top with the flaked fish, the blanched green, dill and scallion. Ladle the hot broth over everything. Serve the tóp mỡ, fried shallots, black pepper and chili paste on the side.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Snakehead fish (cá quả), whole 1 fish, about 2.25 lb (1 kg) Boiled whole; the meat is flaked for the bowl, the head and bones go into the broth
Pork bones (xương hom) 1.75 lb (800 g) Blanched, rinsed, then simmered with the fish bones for the broth
Dried shallots 5–6 2 go into the fish pot; the rest go into the broth and are fried for topping
Ginger 1 piece Smashed; used in the fish pot and in the broth
Dill 1 handful Fresh herb on top of the bowl
Scallions 1 handful Fresh herb on top of the bowl
Fresh rice vermicelli (bún) as needed Warmed in hot water; goes in the bottom of the bowl
Water celery (rau cần) as needed The one seasonal green, blanched just before serving
Raw pork fat as needed Rendered into crisp cracklings (tóp mỡ); its fat fries the shallots
Lime for cleaning the fish (chanh) as needed Rubbed on the raw fish with coarse salt, then rinsed off
Coarse salt as needed For cleaning the fish
Salt a little, then to taste In the fish pot and for seasoning the broth
Fish sauce to taste Seasons the flaked fish and the broth
MSG to taste Seasons the broth
Black pepper to taste Seasons the flaked fish; also served at the table
Chili paste (ớt chưng) to taste Served on the side
Water as needed For boiling the fish and simmering the broth
0 / 0

Soft white flakes of snakehead rest on fresh rice noodles with a single blanched green, a handful of dill and scallion, and hot broth poured over the top. The broth is clear, not red or sour. Next to the bowl sit crisp pork cracklings (tóp mỡ), fried shallots, black pepper and chili paste, so everyone can finish their own bowl.

This is canh bún cá, a fish noodle soup from old Hanoi. A whole snakehead (cá quả) is boiled with ginger and shallots, and its meat is lifted off the bones. The bones then go into a gently simmered stock with pork bones. The result is a clean, mild bowl with no sourness, and the pork fat on the side adds richness and crunch. For more dishes from the same country, see Vietnam.

Bún Cá in Hanoi and Beyond

Bún cá is a family of dishes, not a single formula. The name simply means "fish with rice noodles," and across Vietnam it covers many different bowls. In Hanoi, bún cá is often eaten at lunch, either in broth (chan) or as a dipping style (chấm). One broth version has fried fish pieces and greens, with cilantro and dill as the herbs. A home-style Hanoi version uses tilapia marinated with turmeric, coated and fried, then served in a broth of fish stock and pork-bone stock with tomato and pineapple.

The dish changes from region to region. The usual Hanoi bowl has a sour broth and fried fish. In Hai Phong, cooks add heat and pile on several fish toppings, using both fried fish and fried fish cake (chả cá). Thái Bình uses a rich stock with no sourness and turmeric fish, and Nha Trang pairs a clear fish-bone broth with seafood. Canh bún cá is defined by what it leaves out: the fish isn't fried, and the broth has no tomato, no pineapple and nothing sour.

Don't confuse bún cá with chả cá Lã Vọng, another famous Hanoi fish dish. For chả cá Lã Vọng, turmeric fish is grilled, finished with herbs and eaten with rice noodles, peanuts and mắm tôm. It's a dish of its own, not a noodle soup with broth poured over.

Ingredients for Old Hanoi Canh Bún Cá

Ingredients for canh bún cá: snakehead, pork bones, fresh rice noodles, shallots, ginger, dill, scallions, water celery and pork fat

Allergens

This dish contains fish and pork. Check the labels of your fish sauce, MSG and chili paste for allergens such as soy.

Equipment

  • A pot large enough to boil the whole fish
  • A stockpot for the bone broth
  • A separate cutting board and knife for the raw fish
  • A food thermometer for checking the fish
  • Fish-bone tweezers for picking small bones out of the flaked meat
  • A fine-mesh strainer for the broth
  • A slotted spoon for the cracklings and fried shallots
  • A wire strainer basket for dipping the noodles
  • A ladle

Choosing the Fish, Greens and Noodles

The fish. Use snakehead (cá quả). A different fish makes a different bowl.

The green. Choose one seasonal green: water celery (rau cần), crown daisy (cải cúc) or rau rút. They're different plants with different flavors, and each one changes the bowl, so use just one at a time.

The noodles. Use fresh bún.

The lime. Chanh is the citrus here, and its only job is cleaning the raw fish. Rinse it off afterward. No citrus juice goes into the broth.

Water, noodles, greens, pork fat and seasonings are up to you. Use them as needed or to taste.

Method: From Whole Fish to a Clear Bowl

Fish safety

Cook the fish to an internal temperature of 63°C / 145°F, checked with a food thermometer. Without a thermometer, cook until the flesh is opaque and separates easily with a fork. Color and texture alone are not a safe test. Keep raw fish away from other foods, and wash hands, boards and utensils after handling it.

The order matters: the fish is cooked first, so its bones are ready for the broth. The pork fat is rendered before the shallots are fried, because the shallots are fried in that fat.

Bún Cá Troubleshooting

Problem Likely cause What to do
The broth is cloudy The bones were crushed Keep the bones whole and simmer gently next time; strain through a fine-mesh strainer
Bone fragments in the broth Straining was too coarse Strain again through a fine-mesh strainer; never serve the bones or shards
Small bones in the fish Missed while flaking Go over the flakes again with tweezers before they go into the bowls
Unsure whether the fish is cooked Judging by look alone Check for 63°C / 145°F with a food thermometer, or opaque flesh that flakes easily
The broth tastes sour Citrus or another sour ingredient got into it Rinse the fish well after cleaning, and keep lime out of the pot
The broth tastes flat Not yet seasoned Adjust a little at a time with salt, fish sauce and MSG, tasting as you go

Judge when the fish and the bone stock are done by the checks in the method, not by the clock.

Serving, Variations and Storage

The condiments go on the table, so each person sets their own heat. The chili paste is optional, and anyone who wants a mild bowl can skip it. The broth stays the same either way. You can also leave out the tóp mỡ or the fried shallots, though the bowl loses some of its pork-fat richness and crunch.

Don't leave the fish, broth or other perishable parts at room temperature for long.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I add something sour to the broth?

No. Canh bún cá has no sour element. Chanh is only for cleaning the raw fish, and you rinse it off before cooking.

How do I know the fish is cooked?

Cook the fish to an internal temperature of 63°C / 145°F, checked with a food thermometer. If you don't have one, cook until the flesh is opaque and flakes easily. Because the fish is boiled, it never turns golden, and color and texture alone aren't a safe test.

Do I need to add oil for frying the shallots?

No. Fry the shallots in the fat rendered from the pork when you make the tóp mỡ.

Sources