Tomato and oxtail cook together for hours until the meat slides off the bone, and the soup that comes out of the pot is gently sour and gently sweet. In Macau, this soup is ladled over a bowl of cooked macaroni for a favorite local breakfast, and it's a common sight on restaurant menus too. The rule that holds every version together is simple: the oxtail simmers low and slow, the macaroni cooks in its own pot, and the two meet only in the bowl. This home version serves 4–5 and fills out the soup with potatoes, bay leaves, fresh thyme and dried basil.
Macaroni in Oxtail Tomato Soup in Macau
There is no single fixed version of this bowl, and the ingredients change from shop to shop. Most start from oxtail, carrot, onion, tomato, celery and cabbage. This recipe adds potatoes and leaves the cabbage out.
The soup gets its flavor from two directions. Fresh tomatoes and a little tomato puree bring the tartness and sweetness, while bone-in oxtail and beef stock give it a meaty depth. Carrots, onion and celery round it out, and the potatoes go in near the end.
The macaroni never simmers in the soup pot. It's cooked separately according to its pack, divided into bowls, and the hot soup is poured over it right before serving, so the pasta keeps its bite.
How It Differs from Similar Dishes
Hong Kong's tomato beef macaroni soup is easy to mix up with this one. It also cooks the macaroni separately, but it uses sliced beef rather than oxtail and is seasoned with ketchup, soy sauce and oyster sauce. Jamaican oxtail stew, Taiwanese beef noodle soup and Ukrainian borscht share some of the same ingredients, yet each has its own cuts, spices and structure.
Ingredients (4–5 servings)

Equipment
- A saucepan for blanching the oxtail
- A colander
- A large, heavy pot for the soup
- A separate pot for the macaroni
- A spatula
- A ladle
- A teaspoon
- Serving bowls
Choosing the Oxtail, Stock and Macaroni
Oxtail. The 2.25 lb (1 kg) is jointed bone-in oxtail as you buy it, bones and all, not 2.25 lb (1 kg) of meat trimmed from the bone.
Beef stock and salt. Shop-bought stocks vary a lot in saltiness and strength, so taste the finished soup before you add any salt. Top up with enough water to cover the meat and vegetables; how much you need depends on your pot and your pieces of oxtail.
Tomato puree. The puree is the only tomato product here besides the fresh tomatoes. Ketchup and other sauces belong to the Hong Kong version.
Herbs. Bay leaves, fresh thyme and dried basil do the work. Fresh basil isn't used as a garnish.
Macaroni. Ordinary dried short macaroni from the supermarket works well. The 5.5 oz (150 g) is for the whole batch, not a single bowl.
Method: Blanch, Simmer Low, Cook the Macaroni Apart
Go by the meat, not the clock. It is ready when it comes away from the bone. Oxtail pieces differ in size, so the time will vary.
Fixing Common Problems with Oxtail Tomato Soup
Two things need your judgment: the meat, which should come away from the bone, and the salt, which depends on your stock. Throughout, keep the soup at a low, gentle simmer.
| Problem | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| The meat still clings to the bone after 2–3 hours | Larger pieces, or the simmer hasn't reached its endpoint | Keep simmering on the same low heat and check again. Go by the meat, not the clock |
| The soup is bubbling hard | Heat too high | Turn it down to a gentle simmer |
| The potatoes are breaking down | Added too early, or cooked too long | Add them only for the last 15 minutes |
| The soup tastes too salty | Salty stock, or salt added before tasting | Next time, taste the finished soup before adding any salt |
| The soup tastes flat | Not enough salt for your stock | Add salt a little at a time and taste again |
| The macaroni is soft and swollen | Cooked in the soup, or left sitting in it | Cook it in a separate pot and pour the soup over it just before serving |
Storing Leftovers and Variations
Refrigerate leftovers within two hours of serving and eat them as soon as you can. When you reheat, bring the whole portion completely to above 167°F (75°C).
Once you've made the basic bowl, a few changes are easy to try:
| Idea | How to approach it |
|---|---|
| Heat at the table | If you want spice, let each person add a chili condiment to their own bowl |
| More macaroni | Cook a larger amount of pasta if you like, still in its own pot |
| Cabbage | Cabbage is common in shop versions; adding it makes a different variant of the soup |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is cabbage supposed to go in?
Many shops in Macau add cabbage, and their recipes differ from one another. This version uses potatoes instead, but adding cabbage gives you another common variant.
Should the macaroni be cooked in the soup?
No. Cook the macaroni separately according to its pack, divide it into bowls, and pour the hot soup over it.
What if the oxtail still isn't coming off the bone?
Keep simmering on the same low heat and check again. The meat is ready when it comes away from the bone, not when the 2–3 hours are up.

















