Chanasan Makh: Mongolian Bone-In Lamb Boiled with Water and Salt (Чанасан мах)

Chanasan makh: bone-in lamb boiled with only water and salt, served on a plain plate
Serves
About 3–4 servings
Cuisine
Mongolian

How to make chanasan makh (чанасан мах), Mongolian boiled meat, in a pared-back home version made with only bone-in lamb, water and salt. Covers washing the meat, skimming at a gentle heat, adding salt in three parts, judging doneness by the meat around the bone rather than the clock, serving without sauce, and how this version differs from other published recipes.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Wash the lamb and drain it

Rinsing bone-in lamb in water before draining it in a colander
Wash off small bone fragments and blood, then drain

Rinse the bone-in lamb well in plenty of water, washing away small bone fragments and blood that cling to cut bone surfaces. Lift the pieces into a colander and let the water drain off.

STEP22 / 6

Put the lamb and water in a large pot

Water being poured over bone-in lamb in a large pot
Start with the lamb and 3L of water in a roomy pot

Place the drained lamb in a large pot and pour in the 3.25 quarts (3 L) of water. If the meat sticks out well above the water, switch to a pot of a better size or adjust the water so the meat is reasonably submerged.

STEP33 / 6

Heat gently and skim the foam

Skimming foam from the surface of a gently heating pot of lamb
Lift away the foam and keep the surface calm rather than at a rolling boil

Set the pot over the heat. As foam rises to the surface, skim it off. Do not let the pot boil hard; keep the heat low enough that the surface of the water just moves gently.

STEP44 / 6

Add the salt in three parts

Adding a small amount of salt to the pot of bone-in lamb
Salt goes in a little at a time, in three additions

Add the 1 oz (30 g) of salt in three separate additions rather than all at once, tasting the liquid as you go. Let the taste guide how much goes in each time. Nothing else goes into the pot.

STEP55 / 6

Simmer quietly until the meat around the bone is tender

A large pot of bone-in lamb simmering quietly over low heat
A low simmer with small bubbles, not a vigorous boil

Keep the pot at a low, quiet simmer. Allow about 1–1.5 hours, depending on the cut and the size of the pieces. The meat is done when it is cooked through around the bone and tender. If it is still tough, simmer longer. Check the temperature at the center of the thickest piece, as described in the food safety note.

STEP66 / 6

Lift onto a platter and eat it first without sauce

Lifting tender, cooked bone-in lamb from the pot onto a large platter
Move the meat to a platter once it is cooked through around the bone and tender

Lift the cooked lamb out of the pot, let it drain, and move it to a large platter. Eat it first as it is, without any sauce, cutting it with a knife to share.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Bone-in lamb about 2.25 lb (1 kg) The dish itself. Any bone-in lamb that fits your pot
Water 3.25 quarts (3 L) The cooking liquid. Change the pot size or adjust the water if the meat sits well above the surface
Salt 1 oz (30 g) The only seasoning. Added in three parts while tasting
0 / 0

A large pot, a kilo of bone-in lamb, three liters of water and a small bowl of salt. As the pot warms, grey foam rises and is lifted away with a spoon, the heat comes down until the surface barely trembles, and the salt goes in a little at a time. That really is the whole of chanasan makh (чанасан мах), Mongolian bone-in lamb boiled with water and salt.

Chanasan Makh in Mongolia

The name translates roughly as "boiled meat." In its older form the dish is meat, usually mutton, cut into manageable bone-in pieces and boiled in salted water until cooked, and that alone makes a complete meal. Adding vegetables and condiments is a later habit, so recipes under this name now differ in their amounts and extras, with some including long onion or ginger.

The version here stays with the core: bone-in lamb, water, salt and slow boiling. If you'd like to see more of the country's cooking, browse the Mongolia recipes.

Spelling

In Mongolian Cyrillic the dish is written чанасан мах. In English you will see Chanasan makh, and sometimes Chanasan mah. These are spelling differences, not different dishes.

Ingredients: Bone-In Lamb, Water and Salt

Bone-in lamb, water and salt laid out as the only ingredients
This version uses only bone-in lamb, water and salt

These amounts make about 3–4 servings. Long onion and ginger are optional. This recipe leaves them out, since the dish is just lamb, water and salt.

Equipment

  • A large pot that holds about 2.25 lb (1 kg) of bone-in lamb with 3.25 quarts (3 L) of water
  • A bowl and a colander, for washing and draining the meat
  • A spoon or ladle for skimming foam
  • A food thermometer, for the safety check below
  • A large platter
  • A knife and cutting board for cutting and sharing at the table

Choosing Lamb and a Pot for Chanasan Makh

Any bone-in cut works. When shopping, check two things: that the label says the lamb is bone-in, and that about 2.25 lb (1 kg) of it will fit in your pot with 3.25 quarts (3 L) of water. The amounts and timing are written for bone-in lamb, so boneless meat or a different meat would make a different recipe.

The pot matters as much as the cut. If 3.25 quarts (3 L) of water leaves much of the meat exposed, switch to a better-sized pot or adjust the water until the meat is reasonably submerged. Go by what you see in the pot.

Method: A Quiet Pot, Salt in Three Parts

Decide by the meat, not the clock

Allow about 1–1.5 hours, depending on the cut and size of the meat. Finish when the meat around the bone is cooked through and tender. If it is still tough, keep simmering.

Fixing Common Chanasan Makh Problems

Most trouble with this pot comes down to heat, pot size or patience. Finish when the meat around the bone is cooked through and tender, not when a timer rings.

Condition Likely reason What to do
The meat is still tough The pieces are large, or the cut needs longer Keep simmering gently and check again; larger pieces need more time
The meat sits well above the water The pot is too small or too wide for the pieces Change pots, or adjust the water so the meat is reasonably submerged
The pot is boiling hard The heat is too high Turn it down until the surface only moves gently
Foam keeps collecting Normal as the pot heats Keep skimming it off
Unsure about the salt All three additions are not in yet Add the salt in parts and taste between additions
The meat looks done but you're not sure Color and appearance are not proof Check that the center of the thickest piece has reached about 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute
Food safety

Boiling times depend on the cut and the size of the pieces, so the time in this recipe is an estimate. Color alone does not tell you the meat is safe. Heat it until the center of the thickest piece reaches about 167°F (75°C) and holds there for at least 1 minute. Use a food thermometer at the center of the thickest piece. Keep raw meat juices away from cooked food and anything eaten raw, and wash cutting boards and knives before using them again.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need the onion and ginger?

No. Long onion and ginger are optional extras, and this recipe uses only lamb, water and salt.

Is 1–1.5 hours always enough?

No. The time changes with the cut and size of the meat. Keep simmering until the meat around the bone is cooked through and tender, and use a thermometer for the safety check.

How much salt goes in each time?

Add the 1 oz (30 g) in three parts rather than fixed amounts, tasting the liquid between additions.

What about the broth?

There is no separate broth. Taste the cooking liquid, adjust it with salt, and serve it as a soup.

Sources