Rosto: Gibraltar's Home-Style Beef and Tomato Braise with Penne

Gibraltar-style rosto: cubes of beef and penne coated in tomato sauce
Cuisine
Gibraltarian

How to make rosto, a Gibraltarian family dish of beef braised with tomato, carrot and white wine, finished with separately boiled penne. Follows one published Gibraltar recipe's amounts as written, marks what that recipe leaves unspecified, and explains how other families make it differently.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Soften the onion and garlic in olive oil

Chopped onion and garlic starting to soften in a pot
Cook the onion and garlic in a thin film of oil until the onion turns soft and translucent

Finely chop the onion and garlic. Warm a little olive oil in the heavy pot and cook them gently, stirring with a wooden spoon. Move on when the onion is soft and translucent.

STEP22 / 5

Add the tomatoes and sliced carrots

Tomatoes and thinly sliced carrots added to the softened onion and garlic
Tomatoes and carrots go in before the meat

Add the tinned tomatoes and the thinly sliced carrots to the softened onion and garlic. Stir to combine.

STEP33 / 5

Add the beef, wine and stock cube, then braise covered on low

Beef in the tomato sauce with white wine and a stock cube added, lid ready for a low braise
The beef, wine and stock cube go in at the same stage, then the pot is covered for a gentle braise

Cut the beef into cubes and add it to the pot. Pour in the white wine and add the stock cube. Cover and cook over low heat until the beef is tender. Stay at a gentle simmer, check from time to time, and test a piece of beef: it is ready when it is tender enough for your liking.

Toward the end of the braise, the beef should be tender, with the carrots in the tomato sauce. The pasta has not gone in yet.

Tender beef and carrots in a thick tomato sauce near the end of braising
Near the end of the braise: tender beef, carrot slices and a sauce that clings to the spoon
STEP44 / 5

Boil the penne separately until al dente

Penne boiling on its own in a separate pot of water
Boil the penne on its own and stop at al dente

In a separate pot of water, boil the penne for 9–10 minutes until al dente, then drain and rinse. If your package gives a different cooking time, keep in mind that the pasta will cook a little more in the next step.

STEP55 / 5

Fold the pasta into the braise and simmer about 5 minutes

Drained penne folded into the beef, carrot and tomato sauce
Fold the penne into the braise and let it take up the sauce for about 5 minutes

Add the drained penne to the beef and tomato sauce and fold it in. Let everything cook together for about 5 minutes so the flavors come together. You are looking for pasta that takes up some of the sauce while some sauce still remains in the pot. Keep the heat gentle so the penne holds its shape.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Braising/stewing beef 1 lb (500 g) The heart of the braise; cut into cubes
Tinned tomatoes, chopped or pasteurised 14 oz (400 g) Base of the sauce
Pasta (penne or macaroni) 3.5 oz (100 g) Boiled separately, then folded in at the end
Onion 1 small or 1/2 large Finely chopped and softened first
Garlic 1 large or 2 small cloves Finely chopped, cooked with the onion
Carrots 2 large or 3 small Thinly sliced; sweetness and body in the sauce
Dry white wine 1/2 glass Added with the beef
Stock cube as needed Added with the wine
Olive oil as needed For softening the onion and garlic
0 / 0

Ask a Gibraltarian family about rosto and you'll hear about Sunday lunches and a recipe learned in someone's kitchen. Every household makes it a little differently. This version is a family-style one: cubed braising beef simmered slowly with tinned tomatoes, carrots, onion, garlic and a splash of white wine. Short pasta cooks in its own pot and gets folded in at the end.

Rosto in Gibraltar's Kitchens

Rosto belongs to Gibraltar's shared food heritage, passed on in family kitchens rather than written down. Gibraltarian cuisine draws on many influences, among them Spain, Italy, Malta, Britain and Morocco, along with the adaptations each family makes. Nobody is quite sure where rosto came from, or where its name comes from.

The dish also changes across the border, in the Campo de Gibraltar. The Gibraltar version uses less tomato relative to the meat and has a more complex vegetable sauce than the La Línea version. These traditions keep evolving.

Within Gibraltar itself, a rosto can be beef or pork, made with tinned tomatoes or purée, finished with Edam or left plain. One family's version, passed down by word of mouth, uses pork and tomato purée and comes to the table with grated Edam. The beef-and-penne pot here is one family-style version among several.

About this recipe

Where the source gives no amount, the table says so; no number has been filled in. The source also gives no yield, braising time or total cooking time, so this article does not give them either.

Ingredients

Ingredients for rosto laid out: beef, tomatoes, carrots, onion, garlic, white wine and penne
The beef-and-penne version: braising beef, tinned tomatoes, carrots, onion, garlic, dry white wine, olive oil, a stock cube and dry penne

This version uses beef and penne (chicken or macaroni also work), with 3.5 oz (100 g) of pasta to 1 lb (500 g) of meat.

Mushrooms are optional; they are left out of this version.

Equipment

  • A heavy saucepan or pot with a lid, for the braise
  • A separate pot for boiling the pasta
  • A colander or strainer
  • A wooden spoon
  • A knife and cutting board

Choosing the Beef, Pasta and Stock Cube for Rosto

Beef. Choose a cut sold for braising or stewing, such as beef shin or stewing beef. These cuts suit a long, gentle, covered simmer.

Pasta. Penne is used here. Macaroni works just as well; boil it for the time on its package.

Stock cube. Stock cubes vary widely in saltiness and in ingredients, including possible allergens, so read the label before you buy.

Wine. Use half a glass of dry white wine. Some alcohol can remain even after a long braise. If you leave the wine out for children, pregnancy or any other reason, expect the flavor to change.

Allergens

The pasta contains wheat. Stock cubes and any cheese you serve alongside vary by product, so check the labeling of each.

Method: A Slow Covered Braise, Then Pasta at the End

Before you start

Judge the braise by how tender the meat is, not by the clock, and only start the pasta once you can see the beef is nearly there.

Fixing Common Rosto Problems

The two things that matter most

Braise the beef gently under a lid until it is tender. Boil the pasta separately to al dente, then let the two come together for only a short final simmer.

Problem Likely cause What to do
The tomato tastes too sharp The acidity of the tinned tomatoes Add a little sugar. Start with a small pinch and taste as you go
The beef is still tough The braise has not gone on long enough for the cut Keep it covered on low and keep checking. Don't add the pasta until the beef is tender
The pasta has gone too soft It was boiled past al dente, or went into the braise too early Boil it separately only to al dente, and add it only for the final 5 minutes
The pasta is breaking up Stirring hard or simmering too strongly at the end Fold gently and keep the heat low during the final simmer

Rosto Variations

Other families take the dish in their own directions, and each of these is best treated as its own version rather than mixed into the recipe above.

  • Mushrooms. Some cooks add them; they're optional.
  • A pork family version. This rosto uses pork, tomato purée, carrots, onion, garlic and oregano with macaroni or penne, served with grated queso de bola (Edam). It comes without quantities or times, so think of it as a separate dish rather than an adjustment to this one.
A bowl of rosto with a small separate dish of grated Edam
Grated Edam on the side reflects another family's way of serving rosto; it is not part of the recipe above

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make it with something other than beef?

Chicken works too, though its cooking time differs from beef's and the amounts here are for the beef version, so you'll need to judge doneness yourself. Pork belongs to another family's version, which is a different recipe.

Do I need cheese on top?

Not for this version. Grated Edam (queso de bola) is the finish for the pork family version, and you can add it if you like.

How long does the beef need to braise?

Keep the pot covered on low heat and judge by tenderness, since the time depends on your cut and your pot.

Sources

  • Mama Lotties | Gibraltar's Recipe Website, "Rosto." The main recipe: the ingredient list and method, including 500 g of meat (chicken or braising beef), 400 g of tinned tomatoes, 100 g of macaroni or penne, a covered braise on low heat, separately boiled pasta and a final five-minute mix. This page gives no exact quantities for the onion, garlic, carrots, olive oil, wine or stock cube, and no yield. https://mamalotties.com/rosto/
  • GastroRob, "Gibraltar." The author's own family rosto, passed down orally: pork, tomato purée, carrots, onion, garlic and macaroni or penne, served with grated queso de bola (Edam), and the view that family variations are accepted. No quantities or cooking times are given. https://gastrorob.com/2012/05/21/gibraltar/
  • Manuel J. Ruiz Torres, Grupo Gastronómico Gaditano, "Panorámica de la cocina del Campo de Gibraltar." A regional overview of the cooking of the Campo de Gibraltar that contrasts the Gibraltar and La Línea versions of rosto and notes that these traditions evolve and vary. It is an essay, not a recipe. https://grupogastronomicogaditano.com/Articulos/CocinaCampoGibraltar.htm
  • Your Gibraltar TV, "'A Legacy of Recipes from Lely's Kitchen' Book Released - Author Interview." Cookbook author Jessica Montado on rosto as part of shared Gibraltarian food heritage, on recipes learned in family kitchens and at Sunday lunches, and on the many cultural influences and family adaptations in the cuisine. https://www.yourgibraltartv.com/daily/a-legacy-of-recipes-from-lelys-kitchen-book-released-author-interview