Colcannon: Irish Mashed Potatoes with Savoy Cabbage

Colcannon in a white bowl, with salted butter melting in a well at the center
Serves
4 servings
Level
Beginner
Cuisine
Irish

How to make colcannon, the Irish dish of mashed potatoes and savoy cabbage, from a four-serving heritage recipe. Covers when to pour off the potato water, how to add hot milk and salted butter, regional variations from kale to leeks, and Halloween records from County Wexford and County Galway.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Cover the diced potatoes with cold salted water

Diced potatoes covered with cold salted water, ready to start cooking
Start the diced potatoes in cold salted water

Peel the potatoes and cut them into dice. Put them in a saucepan and add enough cold, salted water to cover them. Start the heat from cold and bring the water to a boil.

STEP22 / 7

Pour off two-thirds of the water and steam with the lid on

Potatoes steaming over low heat with the lid on, after two-thirds of the water was poured off
With the lid closed and the heat low, the potatoes finish in the remaining water

After about 10 minutes, when the potatoes are just beginning to soften, pour off about two-thirds of the water. Do not drain all of it. Put the lid on and let the potatoes steam over low heat until a skewer slides into the center without resistance.

When the potatoes are tender, drain off any water left in the pot before you mash.

STEP33 / 7

Cook the cabbage separately and drain it

Drained cabbage, cooked separately, with a little butter being stirred in
Drain the cabbage well before adding a small piece of the butter

While the potatoes steam, put the shredded savoy cabbage in a separate pot with a small amount of water. Boil until the leaves are limp and tender, and stop before the color fades. Drain well, season with salt, and stir in a small knob of butter taken from the 3 tablespoons.

STEP44 / 7

Bring the milk to a boil

Whole milk coming to a boil in a separate small saucepan
Heat the milk in its own small pan and take it off as soon as it boils

In a small saucepan, bring about ½ cup (100 ml) of whole milk to a boil. Watch it closely so it does not boil over, and turn off the heat as soon as it boils.

STEP55 / 7

Mash the warm potatoes with hot milk and most of the butter

Warm potatoes being mashed with milk and butter, more milk waiting beside the pot
Mash while the potatoes are warm and add the hot milk gradually

Return the drained, warm potatoes to the pot and mash them. Add the hot milk and most of the remaining butter, working it in until smooth. Pour in the milk a little at a time, and watch how the mash comes together.

Add more milk beyond the ½ cup (100 ml) if the mash needs it. Keep the butter within what you prepared, and save a small piece for serving.

STEP66 / 7

Fold in the cabbage and season

Cooked cabbage being folded into mashed potatoes
Fold the drained cabbage through the mash until soft but holding its shape

Fold the cabbage into the mash and season with salt and white pepper. Aim for a mixture that is soft but holds its shape and does not run. If it has cooled, warm it over low heat for 1–2 minutes, if needed. Add no extra water or cream at this stage.

STEP77 / 7

Serve in a warm bowl with a butter well

Hot colcannon with the reserved butter set in the center
The reserved butter melts into the well at the center

Spoon the colcannon into a warmed bowl. If you like, make a well in the center and set in the butter you saved from the 3 tablespoons, letting it melt.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Potatoes (Golden Wonders or Kerr's Pinks) 2.25 lb (1kg) The body of the dish. Peel and dice
Savoy cabbage 14 oz (400g) The leafy texture through the mash. Shred finely
Whole milk about ½ cup (100ml) Brought to a boil and added hot to loosen the warm potatoes
Salted butter 3 tbsp Divided between the cabbage, the mash and the butter well at serving
Salt to taste For the potato water, the cabbage and the final seasoning
White pepper to taste Final seasoning
Water as needed Cold water to cover the potatoes, plus a small amount for the cabbage
0 / 0

A hot bowl of soft mashed potato, cabbage running all through it, and a pool of butter melting in a well at the center. Colcannon is Irish comfort food at its simplest: potatoes mashed with milk and butter, with cooked cabbage folded in. This traditional version keeps to just a few ingredients (potatoes, savoy cabbage, whole milk and salted butter) seasoned with salt and white pepper. The mash should be soft without running, and the cabbage gives every spoonful some texture.

Colcannon in Ireland

Colcannon is Ireland's traditional Halloween dish, though what goes into it changes from place to place. Curly kale, spring onions and leeks all turn up in different local versions. You can read more about the country's food on the Ireland page.

Halloween and local records

Folklore records from the 1930s give a closer look at particular places. One from Faythe, County Wexford, calls 31 October "Cabbage Stump night" or "Colcannon day," and describes cabbage leaves used as a cover to hold in the steam, with money put into the meal. Another, from Liatra, County Galway, describes colcannon made at Halloween to mark the end of potato digging, with the first plate set aside for the fairies without salt.

Each of these customs belongs to its own community. Together they show how closely colcannon was tied to Halloween in those places, rather than one custom shared across all of Ireland.

Hidden objects

Coins, rings or thimbles were hidden in the dish. Do not recreate this by putting coins or other objects into food. They can be swallowed or cause choking.

The Mayo version

In County Mayo, colcannon is mashed potato with kale or cabbage, milk or cream, and butter, and its Irish name is "Càl ceannann." The Mayo recipe is its own dish: 1 lb (500g) Roosters potatoes, 9 oz (250g) curly kale or savoy cabbage, 1 onion, ½ cup (100ml) cream and 2 oz (60g) butter. The vegetables are boiled separately for 15–20 minutes, then combined with browned onion. It's a good illustration of how much the dish varies, so follow its amounts and steps on their own rather than mixing them into the recipe here.

Ingredients: Four Servings of the Basic Cabbage Version

Peeled potatoes, sliced savoy cabbage, milk and salted butter set out as ingredients
The basic version uses only potatoes, savoy cabbage, whole milk, salted butter, salt, white pepper and water

These amounts make four servings. A tablespoon here means 1 tbsp (15 mL).

Milk allergy

This dish contains milk and butter. It is not suitable for anyone with a milk or dairy allergy.

Equipment

  • Peeler and knife
  • Saucepan with a lid, for the potatoes
  • A separate pot, for the cabbage
  • A small saucepan, for the milk
  • Potato masher
  • Skewer, to test the potatoes
  • Colander or sieve

Choosing Potatoes, Cabbage and Butter for Colcannon

Potatoes. Golden Wonders or Kerr's Pinks are the traditional choice. Outside Ireland they're harder to find, so reach for a floury potato instead. Waxier potatoes give off a different amount of water and won't mash as smoothly.

Cabbage. If you can't find savoy cabbage, ordinary cabbage is a practical stand-in. Its leaves differ in thickness, sweetness and water, so cook it until it looks soft and drain it carefully.

Milk and butter. Stick with whole milk and salted butter; cream or unsalted butter makes a different dish. If the mash needs loosening, add more milk, but keep the butter to the amount listed.

Method: Steam the Potatoes, Then Bring Everything Together While Warm

Reading the times

Pour off part of the potato water after about 10 minutes. Warm the mash over low heat for 1–2 minutes at the end, if needed. Neither is a total cooking time, so judge each step by how the food looks and feels.

Fixing Watery, Gluey or Wet Colcannon

Most problems come down to too much water or too much mashing. Mash while the potatoes are warm, add the hot milk gradually, and make sure the cabbage is well drained.

Problem Likely cause What to do
The potatoes are watery Too much water left after steaming, or milk added all at once Let the steaming drive off the remaining water, drain what is left, and add the milk in small amounts
The mash turns gluey Worked too long Mash while warm, and once the cabbage goes in, stop as soon as the mixture is even
The cabbage makes it wet Cabbage not drained well Drain the cabbage thoroughly before folding it in, especially ordinary cabbage
The mash has cooled Steps took longer than expected Warm over low heat for 1–2 minutes if needed
Too salty Salted butter plus salt in each step Taste before the final seasoning and adjust salt and white pepper last

Serving Colcannon and Regional Variations

Colcannon is eaten on its own as a main course or, more recently, alongside bacon; in Mayo it comes with ham or Irish bacon at Halloween. Serve it in a hot bowl with butter melting in the center.

Once you know the basic cabbage version, the regional additions are easy to explore. Each is its own local take, so try them one at a time rather than piling them all into one bowl.

  • Curly kale. The Limerick tradition, and a regional version distinct from the cabbage recipe.
  • Spring onions or leeks. Regional and household differences, mixed in either raw or cooked first. Both add sweetness and aroma.
  • Chives or parsley. Also found as regional additions.
  • Parsnip or carrot. Linked to traditions such as those of Wexford and Carlow. They bring sweetness and color.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make it with kale?

Yes. Curly kale is the Limerick tradition, and the Mayo recipe uses kale or savoy cabbage. The amounts in this recipe are written for cabbage, so for kale, follow the Mayo recipe and its own amounts.

Is colcannon only a Halloween dish?

It's closely linked with Halloween, and folklore records from Wexford and Galway describe Halloween customs around it. Those customs belong to specific places and times, though, and colcannon is also eaten as a main dish on its own or as a side for bacon.

Can I make it ahead or keep leftovers?

Divide leftovers into clean, shallow containers so they cool quickly, and reheat them thoroughly, using 167°F (75°C) or above as a guide.

Sources