British Apple Pie: Bramley Apples in an Egg Shortcrust

An apple pie with a golden pastry lid, cut open to show the thin pastry and layers of apple
Serves
8 servings
Cuisine
British

A British double-crust apple pie made with tart Bramley cooking apples and an egg-enriched shortcrust, serving 8. Covers drying the apple slices, chilling and lidding the pastry, baking at 190°C (fan 170°C), apple substitutions, the Bramley's history, the medieval Tartys in Applis, and handling leftovers.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Slice the apples and dry them on paper

Apples sliced about 5mm thick, spread out on kitchen paper
Lay the slices out in a single layer so the paper can take up their surface moisture

Peel and core the apples, then cut them into slices about 5mm (about 3/16 in) thick. Spread the slices out on kitchen paper so the surface moisture is drawn off. The less loose juice you carry into the dish, the less there is to soak into the bottom crust as the pie bakes.

STEP22 / 7

Make the pastry

Adding flour to a bowl of butter, sugar and egg and bringing the pastry together
Add the flour in three additions and stop once the dough holds together

Separate the second egg. Set the white aside for the glaze.

Combine the room-temperature butter with the 1.75 oz (50g) of golden caster sugar. Mix in the whole egg and the yolk of the second egg. Add the 12.5 oz (350g) of plain flour in three additions and stop as soon as the mixture comes together into a dough. There is no need to keep working it beyond that point.

STEP33 / 7

Chill, then roll out the base

Rolling out the larger piece of chilled pastry and lining a round pie dish
About two-thirds of the pastry lines the dish; the rest waits for the lid

Wrap the dough and chill it for 45 minutes. Meanwhile, preheat the oven to 190°C (about 375°F), or 170°C (about 340°F) for a fan oven.

Use about two-thirds of the pastry to line the base and sides of the 8–8.5-inch (20–22cm), 1.5-inch (4cm) deep pie dish. Keep the remaining third for a lid about 11 inches (28cm) across. If the pastry turns soft and difficult to handle, return it to the fridge until it firms up a little. This rest is separate from the 45-minute chill.

STEP44 / 7

Season the apples just before filling

Quickly tossing sliced apples with sugar, cinnamon and flour by hand
Coat the raw slices quickly, right before they go into the dish

Mix the 5 oz (140g) of golden caster sugar, 1/2 tsp of cinnamon and 3 tbsp of plain flour. Toss the mixture through the dried apple slices quickly, by hand, until the slices are coated. Do this just before filling the pie, because sugar draws juice out of the apples the longer they sit. The filling stays raw. No cooked apples and no extra spices go in.

STEP55 / 7

Fill the pie

Piling the seasoned apples high in the pastry-lined dish
Mound the apples high; the lid will settle as they soften in the oven

Pile the seasoned apples into the pastry-lined dish straight away, mounding them high in the centre. If some juice has collected in the bowl, don't pour it all over the base at once. Lift the apples in and leave most of the loose liquid behind, so the bottom crust isn't sitting in juice before it reaches the oven.

STEP66 / 7

Put on the lid and cut five vents

Covering the apples with a round of pastry, sealing the edge and cutting slits in the top
Seal the edge with water, cut five vents, and brush on the egg white

Brush the rim of the pastry base with water. Lay the 11-inch (28cm) lid over the apples and press the edges together to seal. Cut five steam vents in the top, then brush the lid with the reserved egg white.

Finish the lid with a sprinkle of caster sugar. It is not part of the 6.5 oz (190g) on the shopping list.

STEP77 / 7

Bake until golden, then rest

A golden apple pie just taken out of the oven and set on the counter
Bake until the lid is golden, then give the pie 5–10 minutes before cutting

Bake in the preheated oven at 375°F (190°C), or 350°F (170°C) fan, for 40–45 minutes, until the top is golden. Take the pie out and leave it for 5–10 minutes, then serve it warm with softly whipped cream.

Ovens vary, so use the golden colour of the lid as your guide within the 40–45 minutes.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Filling

Ingredient Amount Notes
Bramley apples 2.25 lb (1kg) Peel, core and slice about 0.25 inch (5mm) thick
Golden caster sugar 5 oz (140g) For the filling only
Ground cinnamon 1/2 tsp
Plain flour (flour with no raising agent) 3 tbsp For the filling only. Tossed with the apples
2 / 3

Pastry

Ingredient Amount Notes
Butter 8 oz (225g) At room temperature
Golden caster sugar 1.75 oz (50g) For the pastry only
Eggs 2 1 whole egg plus the yolk of the second go into the pastry. Keep the second white for the glaze
Plain flour (flour with no raising agent) 12.5 oz (350g) Added in three additions
3 / 3

To finish and serve

Ingredient Amount Notes
Reserved egg white From the 2nd egg Brushed over the lid
Softly whipped cream To serve The recipe gives no amount
0 / 0

The pie has just come out of the oven. The lid is golden, and a little juice is still bubbling at the edge. Let it sit on the counter for 5–10 minutes before you slice, so the hot filling can settle and the first piece comes away with its layers of apple intact, then bring it to the table warm with a spoonful of softly whipped cream.

This is a modern British home apple pie: sharp Bramley cooking apples between two layers of short, egg-enriched pastry, with steam vents cut into the lid. The apples soften in the oven but keep their tartness. The method comes down to a few habits: dry the apples, keep the pastry cool, and wait a few minutes before you cut.

Apple Pie in Britain and the Bramley

A Long, Shared History

Apple pie has no single shape and no single origin. A medieval recipe from about 1390, linked to the court of Richard II, is called "Tartys in Applis." It is a baked fruit tart of apples, spices, figs, raisins and pears, coloured with saffron. That is a different dish from a different era, and it doesn't show where the first apple pie was made.

Food historians also trace a line between apple pies on both sides of the Atlantic. The typical American apple pie descends from fifteenth-century English forms, and by the late sixteenth century English recipes were already fairly close to the modern type. Crusts, sweeteners, spices and fruit have varied by period and place, and the dish belongs to both countries.

The Bramley's Seedling

The apple at the centre of this pie has its own history. Bramley's Seedling was raised by Mary Ann Brailsford in Southwell, Nottinghamshire, at some point between about 1809 and 1813, from a tree she had planted. Nurseryman Henry Merryweather later propagated it and named it after Bramley, who by then owned the property. The apple was shown to a horticultural society in 1876, after its commercial introduction in 1865, and it has become a widely grown cooking apple in Britain.

British markets have long sold eating apples and cooking apples separately. Bramley is prized among the cooking apples because its flavour and texture hold up well to heat, and its high malic acid and low sugar keep it sharp after cooking. A traditional Bramley apple pie filling is built mainly on Bramley pieces, sugar and water, with purée, cornflour and lemon juice as options.

Ingredients: 8 Servings, Filling and Pastry Kept Separate

Ingredients for apple pie set out separately: apples, flour, butter, eggs, sugar and cinnamon
Sugar and flour each appear twice, once in the filling and once in the pastry. Weigh them separately.

Sugar and flour appear in both the filling and the pastry, so each part has its own amounts.

US conversions: 1kg is about 2¼ lb, 140g about 5 oz, 225g about 8 oz, 50g about 1¾ oz and 350g about 12⅓ oz.

Equipment: a round pie dish about 8–8.5 inches (20–22cm) across and 1.5 inches (4cm) deep, a rolling pin, kitchen paper, and a pastry brush.

Time: about 2 hours 30 minutes in total, including a 45-minute chill for the pastry and 40–45 minutes in the oven.

Choosing apples

The recipe is built on the Bramley, a British cooking apple. It is sharp, and it softens as it cooks. Its tartness comes from relatively high malic acid and low sugar. If you can find Bramleys, use them; the rest of the recipe assumes them.

If you can't find Bramleys, try Kogyoku, a Japanese apple that balances sweetness and acidity, has a good aroma and holds its shape after cooking. Expect the juiciness, sweetness and baked texture to differ from Bramley's. Keep the recipe quantities as written.

Shopping list

  • Apples: Bramley apples, 2.25 lb (1kg). If you need them, search for "Bramley cooking apples."
  • Golden caster sugar: 6.5 oz (190g) in total (5 oz (140g) for the filling, 1.75 oz (50g) for the pastry).
  • Plain flour: 12.5 oz (350g) for the pastry plus 3 tbsp for the filling.
  • Butter: 8 oz (225g).
  • Eggs: 2.
  • Ground cinnamon: 1/2 tsp.
  • Cream for whipping: enough to serve.
  • Pie dish: a deep round dish, about 8–8.5 inches (20–22cm) across and about 1.5 inches (4cm) deep. The depth lets you pile the apples high and still close the lid over them.
About sugar and flour names

"Golden caster sugar" and "plain flour" are the names the recipe uses. If you buy a local product, check that it is the same type before you start.

Allergens

This recipe contains wheat, eggs and dairy (butter and cream).

Choosing Apples for British Apple Pie

The sugar amount is written for Bramleys, and the sweetness and texture of the filling depend on the apple you use. If you can't find Bramleys, try Kogyoku. It balances sweetness and acidity and holds its shape after cooking. Keep the recipe quantities as written, but expect the juiciness, sweetness and texture to differ a little.

Akane is harvested earlier than Kogyoku and can stand in for baking when Kogyoku isn't available, so check the variety label when you shop. For more texture, mix some firm eating apples in with the Bramleys. Fuji, sweet with a crisp bite, is one option; the filling will come out sweeter and firmer.

Method: Wrapping the Apples and Baking the Pie

The order that matters

The apples are sliced and dried first, the pastry chills, and the apples are seasoned only just before they go into the dish. The filling goes in raw. There is no pre-cooking step.

Troubleshooting British Apple Pie

Most problems come down to two things: how much juice reaches the pastry, and how warm the pastry gets while you handle it.

Problem Likely reason What to do
The bottom crust is soggy Wet apple slices, or pooled juice poured into the base Dry the slices well on paper (step 1), toss them with sugar only at the last minute (step 4), and leave loose juice in the bowl (step 5). Don't put a hot or pre-cooked filling on the pastry
The pastry is too soft to roll or lift The dough has warmed up Return it to the fridge until it firms a little, then carry on
The lid isn't golden yet at 40 minutes Ovens differ Keep baking within the recipe's 40–45 minutes and judge by colour
The slice collapses and the juice runs Cut too soon Let the pie rest fully before slicing
The filling tastes sweeter or firmer than expected A different apple was used The sugar amount is written for Bramleys; other apples change the result
The two cues to watch

A golden lid in the oven and juices that have settled after resting tell you the pie is ready. Watch for both rather than relying on the clock alone.

Serving British Apple Pie and Other Versions

A slice of warm apple pie with softly whipped cream
Serve the pie warm, after resting, with softly whipped cream

Serve the pie warm with softly whipped cream; custard and ice cream are good with it too. Other British versions take different routes. One combines Bramley and Braeburn apples, uses a spelt pastry and finishes the top with a lattice, served with custard or ice cream.

For more dishes from the same country, see recipes from the United Kingdom.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make it without wheat, eggs or dairy?

Not as written. This recipe contains all three.

What size dish do I need?

A round pie dish about 8–8.5 inches (20–22cm) across and 1.5 inches (4cm) deep. The lid is rolled to about 11 inches (28cm) to cover the mounded apples.

How should I handle leftover pie?

Treat it like any cooked leftover:

  • Don't leave the pie at room temperature for long.
  • Handle it with clean utensils.
  • Cool it quickly; dividing it into shallow containers helps.
  • Seal it in an airtight container or wrap, refrigerate it promptly, and eat it soon.
  • Throw it away if too much time has passed.
  • If you reheat it, heat it thoroughly to 75°C (167°F) or higher.

Sources