Bermuda Fish Chowder: Tomato Broth, White Fish, Dark Rum and Sherry Pepper Sauce

Bermuda fish chowder: white fish and vegetables in a tomato-colored broth
Cuisine
Bermudian

How to make Bermuda fish chowder, the tomato-based fish soup presented as a quintessential Bermudian dish. Follows one published Goslings formula: a separate fish stock, a tomato and aromatic base, about two hours of simmering, and a finish of black rum and sherry pepper sauce. Includes fish and ingredient choices, pot planning, food-safety notes and honest substitution limits.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 8

Make the fish stock

A pot of water simmering with white fish, thyme, bay leaves, peppercorns and cloves
At the stock stage the pot holds only water, fish and spices

Bring the 4 quarts of water to a boil in the first large pot. Add the sea bass fillets, fresh thyme, bay leaves, peppercorns and ground cloves, and simmer for 45 minutes.

Skim off any foam that rises to the surface for a cleaner-looking stock. The fish builds the stock, so the fillets will soften and begin to fall apart. That is expected; you do not need to keep them whole.

STEP22 / 8

Sauté the onions and garlic

Onion and garlic sautéing in butter and olive oil in a separate pot
Cook the onion and garlic until golden before the green vegetables go in

While the stock simmers, melt the butter with the olive oil in the second large pot. Add the chopped onions and minced garlic and cook until golden. Keep the heat moderate so they turn golden and fragrant without darkening at the edges.

STEP33 / 8

Add the celery and green peppers

Celery and green bell pepper added to the sautéed onion and garlic
Celery and green pepper are sautéed only briefly, before the tomatoes

Add the chopped celery and green bell peppers and sauté briefly: stop while the vegetables still look bright and distinct, before anything scorches on the bottom of the pot.

STEP44 / 8

Simmer the tomatoes with the chicken broth

Chopped tomatoes and chicken broth simmering with the aromatic vegetables
The tomato base simmers for 30 minutes before the stock and fish join it

Add the seeded, chopped tomatoes and the chicken broth to the vegetables, and simmer for 30 minutes.

STEP55 / 8

Strain the stock into the tomato base and return the fish

Fish stock poured through a strainer into the pot of tomatoes and aromatics, leaving the spices behind
Transfer the stock a ladleful at a time, leaving the spices in the strainer

Lift out the cooked fish and set it aside. Ladle the stock a little at a time through a fine-mesh strainer into the pot with the tomato base, rather than tipping the whole heavy pot at once. Discard the bay leaves, peppercorns and thyme left in the strainer. Then return the fish to the pot.

Check the fish for any bones before returning it, even with boneless fillets. If you used grouper heads, strain out every bone and pick the meat over carefully.

STEP66 / 8

Add the remaining ingredients and simmer for about 2 hours

Tomato soup gently simmering with fish, potatoes, carrots and parsley
During the long simmer the fish breaks into small flakes among the vegetables

Add the potatoes, carrots, parsley, ketchup, Worcestershire sauce and lemon juice. Set the lid slightly ajar and simmer for about 2 hours.

Add all of these remaining vegetables together at this point.

Keep the heat gentle rather than high. Stir from the bottom now and then so nothing catches, and adjust the heat as you watch the potatoes and carrots soften.

STEP77 / 8

Season with pepper, then finish with rum and sherry pepper sauce

Dark rum and sherry pepper sauce being added to the finished chowder
Rum and sherry pepper sauce go in last, once the fish and vegetables are tender

Season with freshly ground pepper to taste. Taste for salt as well, and add only what your broth, ketchup and sauces leave room for.

At the end, add the 2 oz of Goslings Black Seal Rum and the 4 tbsp of sherry pepper sauce. Because continued heating changes the aroma and the alcohol content, add them just before you turn off the heat.

STEP88 / 8

Serve hot

Hot Bermuda fish chowder with white fish and root vegetables being served at the table
Serve hot, with extra rum and sherry pepper sauce on the side if you like

Ladle the chowder into bowls while it is hot. Offer extra rum and sherry pepper sauce at the table, in whatever amount each person likes. These extras are separate from the amounts in the pot, so don't split the measured rum and sauce between the pot and the table.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Water 4 quarts (about 3.785 L) Liquid for the fish stock
Sea bass fillets, skinless and boneless (or rockfish) 2 lb (about 907 g) Base version of the fish; flavors the stock and breaks into flakes in the finished soup. Grouper heads, 5 lb (about 2.27 kg), are an either/or alternative; never use both
Fresh thyme 1 tbsp Herbal aroma in the stock
Bay leaves 6 Aroma in the stock
Peppercorns 20 Gentle pepper in the stock
Ground cloves 1/4 tsp Warm spice note in the stock
Butter 2 tbsp Fat for sautéing the aromatics, together with the olive oil
Olive oil 2 tbsp Fat for sautéing the aromatics
Bermuda onions, chopped 3 Sweetness and body in the base
Garlic, minced 1 clove Aromatic base
Celery, chopped 1 stalk (8 ribs) Savory depth in the base
Green bell peppers, chopped (large bell type) 2 Fresh, green note in the base
Whole tomatoes, seeded and chopped 28 oz can (about 794 g net) The tomato-red body of the soup
Chicken broth 1 1/2 cups (about 355 ml) Simmering liquid for the tomato base
Ketchup 1 cup (about 237 ml) Tomato sweetness and acidity
Parsley, chopped 1/2 cup (about 118 ml) Fresh herb flavor
Worcestershire sauce 2 tbsp Savory seasoning
Fresh lemon juice 2 tsp Brightness
Potatoes, peeled and diced 2 lb (about 907 g) Body and thickness
Large carrots, peeled and diced 6 Sweetness and color
Freshly ground pepper to taste Final seasoning
Goslings Black Seal Rum 2 oz (about 59 ml, read as fluid ounces) Finishing aroma, added at the end
Sherry pepper sauce 4 tbsp Heat and acidity, added at the end
0 / 0

A red soup that has simmered for a long time, with flakes of white fish caught between cubes of potato and carrot, and the warmth of clove and bay underneath. At the last moment, a splash of black rum and a few spoonfuls of sherry pepper sauce go in, and the aroma changes. If "chowder" makes you picture something white and creamy, this one will surprise you. Bermuda fish chowder is tomato-based and full of root vegetables, and it carries the island's signature finish of rum and peppery sherry.

Bermuda Fish Chowder on the Island

Fish chowder is one of Bermuda's quintessential local dishes, built on tomatoes with potatoes, onions, carrots, green peppers and celery. Every cook's pot is a little different. Almost all of them share two additions: Outerbridge's Original Sherry Peppers and black seal rum. Both go in at the very end, and they are what make the chowder taste of Bermuda.

Bermudian cooking as a whole reflects Caribbean, British, West African, Native American and Portuguese influences. The chowder's own variations show how loosely the dish is held together. One older version lists white fish, potatoes, carrots, celery, tomatoes, ketchup, consommé, Worcestershire sauce, rum and sherry pepper sauce. It follows a similar rhythm to the recipe here: simmer fish and spices for 30–45 minutes, sauté vegetables with tomato and consommé for 30 minutes, then simmer the combined soup for 2 hours. Its quantities differ, though, so treat it as a point of comparison rather than something to blend with the formula below.

Ingredients: One Large-Pot Batch

White fish, aromatic vegetables, tomatoes, potatoes, carrots, thyme, bay leaves, dark rum and sherry pepper sauce
The base version uses skinless, boneless white fish fillets rather than fish heads

The tomato weight is the net weight of the can, and the weight after seeding will be less.

Broth, ketchup, Worcestershire sauce and sherry pepper sauce all carry salt, so taste at the end before deciding whether to add any.

Equipment

  • Two sufficiently large pots: one for the fish stock, one for the tomato base and the final simmer
  • Fine-mesh strainer
  • Ladle
  • Cutting board and knife
  • Measuring spoons and measuring cups

The water alone is close to 4 liters, and the second pot has to hold the strained stock, the tomato base, the fish and a large amount of vegetables. Do not assume a 6-liter pot is big enough. Before you start, check the volume of everything you have bought, and choose pots with room to stir and for the soup to boil without spilling over. Do not try to cook the whole batch in a deep skillet.

Choosing Fish, Vegetables, Rum and Sauce for Bermuda Fish Chowder

Fish. There are two routes: rockfish or sea bass fillets, or grouper heads. The base version uses skinless, boneless sea bass fillets. In Bermuda, "rockfish" means black grouper. Any mild white fish from your local shop will cook fine, but the stock's flavor and richness will differ. If you go with heads, ask your fishmonger to clean them, and plan to strain out every bone.

Onions and green peppers. Use Bermuda onions; ordinary yellow onions work as a substitute, with some difference in sharpness and sweetness. For the peppers, use two large green bell peppers. Small, thin-walled green peppers such as Japanese piman differ in both amount and flavor, so they need adjusting rather than a one-for-one swap.

Celery and tomatoes. "1 stalk (8 ribs)" means eight individual ribs. The tomatoes come in a 28 oz can; where cans come in other sizes, aim for a total close to 794 g, or make a note that you've changed the amount.

Broth, thyme and lemon. Keep the broth chicken, since switching to fish or other stocks changes the recipe. If you dissolve a bouillon cube, check its salt. Fresh thyme is best; with dried, add a small amount and judge by aroma. Fresh lemon juice has a brighter aroma than bottled.

Potatoes. Choose potatoes that hold their shape, so the cubes stay intact through the long simmer.

Rum. Use Goslings Black Seal Rum. Another dark rum will bring different molasses and aged notes.

Sherry pepper sauce. This is the signature Bermudian condiment, so look for Outerbridge's Original Sherry Peppers. It has its own character, distinct from ordinary hot sauce, chili-infused sherry or a homemade mix of chili and vinegar, and no known substitute matches it.

Allergens, alcohol and food safety

This chowder contains fish, celery and milk (butter). Store-bought Worcestershire sauce and broth can contain soy, wheat or other allergens, so check the labels.

The rum goes in at the end, so some alcohol can remain in the finished soup. Leaving out the rum is not enough to make the pot alcohol-free: sherry-based pepper sauces can also contain alcohol, so check their labels. To avoid alcohol entirely, expect the finished dish to taste different from the traditional version.

Keep raw fish and its juices away from vegetables that won't be cooked further, and from boards and tools used for other foods. Heat the center of the food to 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute. A long simmer alone is not enough, so check that the center reaches that temperature.

Method: Fish Stock, Tomato Base, a Long Simmer and a Last-Minute Finish

info How the work splits The fish stock and the tomato base are made in two separate pots, then combined. Allow 45 minutes for the stock, 30 minutes for the tomato base and about 2 hours for the combined simmer. Some of this overlaps, so these times are not a total. :::

Fixing Common Bermuda Fish Chowder Problems

Problem Likely reason What to do
The fish has fallen into flakes 45 minutes in the stock plus about 2 hours of simmering This is expected with this method. For visible pieces, see Variations
The pot is too full to stir or keeps boiling over The final pot is too small for the stock, tomato base, fish and vegetables Move to a larger pot. Check the volume of all ingredients before you begin
Something is catching on the bottom Heat too high during the long simmer, or not stirred Lower the heat and stir from the bottom now and then
The onions went dark before the celery and peppers Heat too high in step 2 Lower the heat; aim for golden, not brown
A bone turns up in the soup Bones left on the fillets, or not strained from heads Check the fish carefully before returning it in step 5
The soup tastes too salty Salt from broth, ketchup, Worcestershire and pepper sauce Taste before adding any salt; next time check the salt in your broth or bouillon

Storing and Varying Bermuda Fish Chowder

Storage and reheating

This is a large batch, so expect leftovers. Divide them into small portions in shallow containers and cool them quickly. When reheating, heat thoroughly to 167°F (75°C) or above.

Variations

Each of these changes the recipe, so it helps to know what you're altering before you try one.

  • A different white fish. Within the options of rockfish or sea bass, the type of fish changes the stock and the texture of the flakes.
  • Fish heads instead of fillets. Use grouper heads, 5 lb (about 2.27 kg), in place of the 2 lb of fillets. Never combine the two. Heads require careful straining and bone removal.
  • Sherry pepper sauce at the table only. Letting each person add their own, instead of adding it to the pot at the end, changes the standard formula.
  • Without rum. For people avoiding alcohol, this removes one of the dish's two signature flavors. The bowl still contains alcohol if the pepper sauce does.
  • Potato texture. Potato variety and dice size change how thick the soup becomes.
  • Fish in visible pieces. A shorter cook keeps the pieces intact, but this formula builds its flavor by simmering the fish into the stock, so the soup will taste different.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Bermuda fish chowder a white, creamy soup?

No. It is tomato-based, with potatoes, onions, carrots, green peppers and celery, finished with sherry pepper sauce and black rum.

What if I can't find sherry pepper sauce?

No substitute is known to match it, so any replacement will give a finish that differs from the Bermudian one.

How many people does this serve?

This recipe makes a large-pot batch. Check your pot size before you begin.

Sources