How to Make Étouffée: Louisiana Shrimp in a Rich Sauce over Rice

Louisiana étouffée: a thick shrimp sauce spooned over white rice
Prep
30 min
Cook
55 min
Total
1 hr 25 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Louisiana

A recipe for Louisiana étouffée in a home kitchen: a light roux, the holy trinity of aromatic vegetables, how to cook the shrimp through, how to pair it with white rice, the difference between Cajun and Creole, shopping, and storage.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 9

Cook the rice

22 min

Long-grain rice cooking in a small pot, with small bubbles coming from the edge
Cook the rice separately from the sauce. Cooking quietly over low heat helps the grains stay distinct

Wash 10 oz (280 g) long-grain rice twice, until the water is only faintly cloudy, and drain in a colander for 5 minutes. Put the rice, 1½ cups (390 ml) water, and 1/4 tsp salt in a small pot and bring to a boil over medium-high heat. Once it is bubbling all over, lower to low heat, cover, and cook for 12 minutes. Turn off the heat, steam for 10 minutes, and fluff lightly with a fork. It is done when the grains are plump and no water is left at the bottom of the pot. If you use short-grain rice, cook it firm and spread it on a plate to let the steam escape.

STEP22 / 9

Make the shrimp stock and chill the shrimp

12 min

Simmering shrimp shells in a small pot and dividing peeled shrimp onto a chilled plate
With shell-on shrimp, make a short stock from the shells. Keep the shrimp meat cold until just before it goes into the sauce

Peel 1 lb (500 g) shell-on shrimp and devein them. Coat the meat with 1/4 tsp salt and 1/8 tsp cayenne and return it to the refrigerator until the sauce is ready. Put the shells in a small pot, add 2¼ cups (550 ml) water, bring to a boil over medium heat, then simmer over low heat for 10 minutes. When the shells turn orange and the stock has taken on a shrimp aroma, strain and measure out 2 cups (500 ml). If using peeled shrimp, skip the stock in this step and use 2 cups (500 ml) unsalted chicken stock. Do not leave the shrimp meat at room temperature for long; go on to the next step while it is cold.

STEP33 / 9

Make a light roux

10 min

Cooking butter and flour to a pale peanut-colored roux in a heavy pot
Do not make the étouffée roux as dark as gumbo's. Stop at a pale peanut color, without black specks

Put 1.75 oz (50 g) unsalted butter in a heavy pot and melt it over medium-low heat. When the foam settles, add 1.5 oz (45 g) cake flour and cook for 8–10 minutes, scraping the bottom with a wooden spoon. Keep the heat at medium-low. Stop when the roux turns from white to a pale peanut color and the raw-flour smell is gone. If black specks appear, the bitterness will not go away, so start over. Do not take it to the dark chocolate color of gumbo.

STEP44 / 9

Saute the trinity in the roux

9 min

Adding onion, celery, and bell pepper to the roux and sauteing
Onion, celery, and bell pepper over medium heat, without scorching, coated in the roux, to bring out sweetness

Raise the heat to medium and add 6.5 oz (180 g) onion, 3.25 oz (90 g) celery, and 4 oz (120 g) bell pepper. The roux coats the vegetables, so for the first minute stir in big sweeps, scraping the bottom. Saute for 6 minutes, until the moisture from the vegetables loosens the roux a little, the corners of the onion turn translucent, and the green smell of the bell pepper rounds out. Add 15 g garlic for 1 minute, then 15 g tomato paste and saute for another 1 minute. If the bottom of the pot gets too dry, add just 1 tbsp of shrimp stock to loosen it before it scorches.

STEP55 / 9

Thin it with stock a little at a time

8 min

Pouring shrimp stock into the pot of aromatic vegetables and roux and stirring with a wooden spoon
Do not pour in the stock all at once; add it while loosening the roux and lumps are less likely

Pour ¾ cup (200 ml) of the 2 cups (500 ml) shrimp stock in 3 additions. Keep the heat at medium. After each addition, scrape the bottom with a wooden spoon, loosen the roux, then add the next. Add the remaining 1¼ cups (300 ml), 1 bay leaf, 1/2 tsp thyme, 1/2 tsp oregano, 1 tsp smoked paprika, 1/4 tsp cayenne, 1/2 tsp black pepper, 3/4 tsp salt, and 2 tsp Worcestershire sauce. Move on once everything is bubbling, the vegetables and roux have not separated, and a light thickness has appeared.

STEP66 / 9

Reduce before adding the shrimp

15 min

Étouffée sauce reduced until it bubbles in small bubbles and a short trail remains after the wooden spoon
Decide the thickness before the shrimp. A trail from the wooden spoon that lasts about a second is right

Bring it to a boil once over medium-high heat, then immediately lower to medium-low. Simmer uncovered for 12–15 minutes. It is ready when small bubbles keep coming from the edge of the pot, a line drawn with the wooden spoon stays for about a second, and the sauce on the spoon clings loosely instead of running off thin. If it is still thin, simmer 3 minutes more; if it is thick and heavy, add 2 tbsp stock. Taste here and adjust so it seems a little strong, since it will go over rice. If it needs more, add salt up to 1/4 tsp.

STEP77 / 9

Add the shrimp

4 min

Adding shrimp to the étouffée sauce, the gray flesh beginning to turn pink
Add the shrimp last. Do not boil hard; lower the heat just before they turn opaque through the center

Return to medium heat and spread the chilled shrimp over the sauce. Stir once in a big sweep with the wooden spoon so the shrimp do not overlap too much and the sauce coats the surface of the flesh thinly. After 2 minutes, turn them over and cook another 1–2 minutes. Do not boil the sauce hard; keep the surface just trembling slightly. Turn off the heat when the shrimp go from gray to pink, are white and opaque through the center, and the sauce clings to the shrimp instead of running off thin. If you use a thermometer, aim for 63 degrees C at the center of the thickest shrimp.

STEP88 / 9

Finish with scallions and parsley

3 min

Adding scallions and parsley to the étouffée with the heat off
Add scallions and parsley after the heat is off, and the green aroma stays in the thick sauce

Turn off the heat and take out the bay leaf. Add 3 scallions and 10 g parsley and fold from the bottom in big sweeps. Rest 2 minutes on the residual heat so the juices of the shrimp settle into the sauce. Taste. If it tastes heavy, add 1 tsp lemon. If the aroma feels flat, add only 1 tsp hot sauce. If you re-cook here, the shrimp turn tough, so leave the heat off. Only if the sauce has stiffened before going over the rice, warm it over low heat for 30 seconds and loosen with 1 tbsp stock.

STEP99 / 9

Spoon it over the rice

4 min

Étouffée spooned over white rice, plated with scallions and hot sauce on the side
Loosening the rice just before topping keeps the thick sauce from becoming too heavy

Mound the cooked long-grain rice on a plate and spoon the étouffée over it. No heat is needed. Do not press the rice down. Loosen it with a fork before plating so the sauce works its way between the grains. Add a few more scallions to finish, and adjust the heat with hot sauce at the plate. The sauce should be thick enough that it does not run to the bottom of the plate right away, but stays on the mound of rice. Spoon it over first rather than mixing the sauce and rice together, and keep the contrast of the thick sauce and the white rice. That is how étouffée is meant to be eaten.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Shrimp and rice

Ingredient Amount How to buy and substitutes
Shell-on shrimp 1 lb (500 g) About 360–380 g net once peeled. 14 oz (400 g) if peeled
Salt 1/4 tsp To season the shrimp
Cayenne pepper 1/8 tsp To season the shrimp. Leave out if you dislike heat
Long-grain rice 10 oz (280 g) Jasmine, basmati, Calrose. If using short-grain, cook it firm
Water 1½ cups (390 ml) For the long-grain rice. Adjust to the type of rice
Salt 1/4 tsp For the rice
2 / 3

Light roux and aromatic vegetables

Ingredient Amount How to buy and substitutes
Unsalted butter 1.75 oz (50 g) If using salted butter, reduce salt by 1/4 tsp
Cake flour (low-protein) 1.5 oz (45 g) Sift first to avoid lumps
Onion 1 (6.5 oz / 180 g) 0.25 inch (7 mm) dice. The base of sweetness
Celery 1 stalk (3.25 oz / 90 g) Chop a few leaves too
Bell pepper (green) 3 (4 oz / 120 g) Use green bell pepper
Garlic 3 cloves (15 g) Minced
Tomato paste 15 g Gives Creole-style thickness. Without it, the sauce is browner
3 / 3

Stock and spices

Ingredient Amount Role
Shrimp stock or unsalted chicken stock 2 cups (500 ml) Stock made from the shells if using shell-on shrimp. Chicken stock if short
Bay leaf 1 Aroma for the simmer
Dried thyme 1/2 tsp Herbal aroma
Dried oregano 1/2 tsp Cuts the weight of the shrimp and butter
Smoked paprika 1 tsp Adds smokiness and red color
Cayenne pepper 1/4 tsp Heat in the pot. Start modest
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Coarsely ground
Salt 1 tsp Adjust at the end by the saltiness of the stock and shrimp
Worcestershire sauce 2 tsp Savoriness and acidity. Some products contain wheat, so check the label
Scallions 3 Sliced thinly. For finishing
Parsley 10 g Coarsely chopped
Lemon 1/2 Add acidity at the plate
Hot sauce about 2 tsp Adjust at the table
0 / 0

Stir butter and flour slowly in a pot, and the roux goes from white to a pale peanut color. When the onion, celery, and bell pepper go in, a sweet smell and a green smell rise together, and your kitchen starts to smell like a New Orleans diner. Étouffée (Étouffée / Etouffee) comes from Louisiana: shrimp or crawfish wrapped in a thick sauce and spooned over white rice. The name is French for "smothered" or "cooked covered." Over rice, the sauce drops between the grains, and the sweetness of the shrimp and the aroma of butter spread slowly.

Étouffée in Louisiana Cooking

Étouffée turns up in both Cajun and Creole cooking, and the core is shared: crawfish or shrimp, the holy trinity of vegetables, a thick sauce, and rice. Cajun versions often leave out tomato, while Creole versions sometimes use a butter roux and tomato. This recipe takes a middle path with a light butter roux and a small amount of tomato paste instead of diced tomato, so the result is a thick sauce of butter and shrimp stock rather than a red sauce.

It helps to set étouffée beside its neighbors. Gumbo is a soup in which a dark roux and the other ingredients cook a long time. Jambalaya cooks the rice in the pot. Shrimp Creole stews shrimp in a red tomato sauce. Étouffée is a thick shrimp gravy spooned over white rice, less soupy than gumbo and without the tomato push of shrimp Creole, and the thickness of the sauce clinging to the rice matters as much as the shrimp.

Crawfish étouffée is the famous version, but shrimp étouffée is common too, and large shrimp give more reliable results at home since crawfish are hard to buy. A short stock made from shell-on shrimp adds some of the depth that crawfish fat would give. Because the rice and sauce are made separately, you can fix each one on its own, which cuts failures a good deal in a home kitchen.

Key points first

Étouffée is decided by the light roux, the holy trinity, and the thickness before the shrimp go in. Cook the shrimp for only 3–5 minutes at the end, and stop when they are white and opaque through the center. Add hot sauce at the plate rather than in the pot, so everyone can set their own heat.

Ingredients (serves 4)

Shrimp, shrimp shells, rice, onion, celery, bell pepper, butter, flour, tomato paste, and spices laid out in a kitchen as étouffée ingredients
Keep the shrimp chilled, and set the roux and vegetables aside first so the flow at the pot does not stop

The amounts are for a heavy pot or deep frying pan 24–26 cm across. Peeled shrimp work, but shell-on shrimp give a deeper sauce, so make a short stock from the shells. Use long-grain rice, which holds up under the sauce. Jasmine rice, basmati, and Calrose are good choices.

Allergies and food safety

This recipe uses shrimp, wheat, dairy, and Worcestershire sauce, and some Worcestershire sauces contain wheat, so check the label. If anyone at the table has a crustacean allergy, do not substitute in the same pot; keep the utensils separate too. Shrimp are done when the flesh is white, opaque, and firm. If you use a food thermometer, use 63 degrees C as the target for seafood.

Choosing Ingredients for Étouffée

Smoked paprika, oregano, thyme, bay leaf, long-grain rice, a thermometer, and hot sauce laid out in a kitchen as shopping ingredients and tools
What is worth looking for is the spice that shapes the outline of aroma, and a thermometer to read the doneness of the shrimp

Shrimp, onion, celery, bell pepper, butter, and flour are all at an ordinary supermarket. What makes the difference is a couple of spices that pull the flavor back toward Louisiana when it drifts toward tomato or butter, and a thermometer so the shrimp don't overcook.

Smoked paprika stands in for the andouille or crawfish fat you won't have at home. Étouffée contains no smoked meat, but a little smoke keeps the butter-and-flour sauce from tasting like a Western-style cream stew. It earns its place in the pantry, too, if you also cook gumbo and jambalaya. Oregano, even in a small amount, ties together the butter, shrimp, and bell pepper; if your jar is old, smell it, and buy a new one if the aroma is weak.

Frozen peeled shrimp hold a lot of water, so pat them dry after thawing. Doneness is easy to misread in a thick sauce, and with large shrimp, thawed frozen shrimp, or a first-time pot, a thermometer tells you whether to cook one more minute or stop now.

Long-grain rice suits the sauce best and changes the impression of the dish a great deal. Short-grain rice works if you cut the water slightly, cook it firm, and spread it on a plate or tray for about 5 minutes to let the steam escape; thick sauce over soft short-grain rice makes everything heavy.

Method

Make the rice, the shrimp, and the sauce as separate steps. Do not scorch the roux to deepen it. Keep it light, so it holds the aromatic vegetables and shrimp stock. Settle the thickness before the shrimp go in, and once they are in, do not hesitate.

Fixing Étouffée Thickness and Cooking

Three small plates comparing étouffée that is too thin, just right, and too thick
Failures of étouffée are easier to fix if you divide them into the thickness before the shrimp and the cooking time after

In étouffée, mistakes in thickness stand out more than mistakes in seasoning. Too thin and the rice turns watery; too thick and the heaviness of the flour wins. Reducing after the shrimp are in makes them tough, so settle the thickness by step 6.

Condition Cause How to fix
The sauce is thin Too little roux, not reduced enough, too much water from the shrimp Add 3–5 minutes at medium-low before adding the shrimp. Next time, pat the shrimp dry
Floury Roux undercooked; lumps from adding stock all at once Work it in over low heat for 3 minutes. Next time, cook the roux to a pale peanut color in step 3
Bitter Black burnt specks in the roux The bitterness does not come back. Start over the moment it burns
Thick and heavy Reduced too far; the sauce is too rich for the rice Add 2–4 tbsp stock and cook over low heat for 1 minute. A little lemon at the plate
Tough shrimp Reduced after adding the shrimp; boiled hard Stop the shrimp at 3–5 minutes. Next time, settle the thickness first
The aroma leans Western-style Left out the bell pepper; weak spices Keep the trinity and add a little smoked paprika and oregano

Serving, Storing, and Variations

A kitchen with étouffée and white rice in separate containers, and a small pot reheating a little
Store the sauce and rice separately. It contains shrimp, so do not leave it at room temperature; reheat only what you will eat

Serving étouffée

Étouffée tastes best freshly made. Set hot sauce, lemon, and scallions out separately so each plate can be adjusted. For sides, skip a heavy meat dish in favor of cucumber pickles, a leafy salad, or a tart coleslaw. If you're cooking Louisiana food all week, use up leftover celery and bell pepper in dirty rice or red beans and rice.

Storage and reheating

To store it, turn off the heat, separate the sauce and rice, let them cool, and put them in shallow containers. Because it contains shrimp, don't leave it at room temperature; refrigerate it and finish within about 1 day. You can freeze it, but the shrimp turn tough, so if you're making it ahead, use a little less shrimp and eat the sauce part first.

To reheat in a pot, add 1 tbsp stock or water per serving and warm over low heat for about 3 minutes, stopping as soon as it bubbles. In a microwave, put it in a deep dish, cover loosely with plastic wrap, heat at 600 W for 1 1/2 minutes, stir once, and add 30 seconds at a time until hot through the center. Fresh scallions and lemon on top make it taste freshly made.

Creole and Cajun directions

For a hint of tomato in the Creole direction, 15 g of tomato paste is easy to work with; a lot of diced tomato moves it toward shrimp Creole. To lean Cajun, leave out the tomato paste, make the roux only a little darker, and add cayenne and black pepper at the plate.

Frequently Asked Questions

What color should I cook the roux to?

A pale peanut color. Taking it to milk chocolate, as for gumbo, brings toastiness, but it tends to weigh down the sweetness of the shrimp. Stop once the raw-flour smell is gone and before black specks appear.

How spicy is it?

It is mild in the pot: cayenne totals 3/8 tsp, and hot sauce goes on at the table. Raising the heat all at once in the pot makes the saltiness and acidity feel strong too, so add hot sauce at the plate first, and next time raise the cayenne to 1/2 tsp.

Is there a substitute for people with a crustacean allergy?

Make it as a separate dish rather than swapping in the same pot. To get close to the flavor, cut 12.5 oz (350 g) chicken thighs small, sear the surface before step 4 and set it aside, return it in step 6, and cook to a core temperature of 74 degrees C. Keep utensils and cutting boards separate from anything that has touched crustaceans.

Sources