American Buttermilk Pancakes: Fluffy Griddle Cakes with Butter and Maple Syrup

American buttermilk pancakes served with butter and maple syrup
Serves
14–16 pancakes, about 4 in (about 10 cm) each
Cuisine
American

How to make American buttermilk pancakes from one published source formula: flour, buttermilk, baking powder and baking soda, rested uncovered for 15 minutes and cooked a quarter cup at a time. Covers when to flip by bubbles and underside color, the Greek yogurt and milk substitute, fixing flat or scorched pancakes, and serving with butter and pure maple syrup.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 9

Whisk the dry ingredients together

Whisking flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda and salt in a bowl
Mix the dry ingredients well before any liquid goes in

In a large bowl, whisk the flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda and salt until evenly combined. Break up any clumps of flour so the leaveners are spread through the whole bowl rather than concentrated in pockets, which can leave some pancakes flat and others uneven.

STEP22 / 9

Whisk the wet ingredients separately

Whisking egg, buttermilk and melted butter in a separate container
Combine the liquids on their own before they meet the flour

In another bowl or jug, whisk the egg, buttermilk, and the melted butter or oil, plus the vanilla if you are using it. Make sure the butter is liquid but not sizzling hot.

STEP33 / 9

Combine until fairly smooth

Pancake batter mixed with a few small lumps left
Fold until no dry flour pockets remain, leaving small lumps

Pour the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients and mix until the batter is fairly smooth. A few small lumps can stay. Don't stop while large pockets of dry flour remain, but don't keep mixing in pursuit of a perfectly even batter either; extended mixing makes the pancakes tighter and less tender.

STEP44 / 9

Rest the batter uncovered for 15 minutes

Pancake batter resting in an uncovered bowl
Rest the batter uncovered for 15 minutes

Leave the batter uncovered for 15 minutes. This is not a fermentation step; the rest simply lets the batter settle. No cloth or lid is needed. Use this time to heat the pan.

STEP55 / 9

Preheat and lightly grease the pan

Lightly greasing a skillet preheated over medium heat
A thin sheen of fat, not a pool, before the batter goes in

Heat a griddle to 350°F (about 177°C), or heat a skillet over medium heat. Grease the surface with a thin film of butter or oil, a light sheen rather than a pool. Because home pans vary, cook one pancake first and use its color to decide whether to turn the heat up or down.

STEP66 / 9

Pour 1/4 cup of batter per pancake

Pouring one portion of pancake batter onto the hot pan
One quarter cup per pancake, left to spread on its own

Pour 1/4 cup of batter onto the hot surface for each pancake. Let it settle into its own round; don't press it or spread it out forcibly. Leave room between pancakes so they don't run together.

STEP77 / 9

Flip when bubbles form and the underside is browned

A pancake with bubbles on top and color starting on the underside
Bubbles on the surface and a browned underside signal it's time to flip

Cook for about 1–2 minutes, until bubbles form on the surface and the underside has taken on color. Go by the bubbles and color rather than the clock. Flipping by the clock alone can leave the center underdone or the outside scorched.

STEP88 / 9

Cook the second side until colored

Cooking a pancake on its second side just after flipping
After flipping, wait for the second side to color as well

Flip the pancake and cook the second side for about another 1–2 minutes, until it too has browned. Check the color just as you did for the first side.

STEP99 / 9

Lift out and serve

Lifting a pancake browned on both sides out of the pan
Lift each pancake out once both sides are browned

Move the finished pancake to a plate and serve right away, with butter and maple syrup. If some people will eat later, hold pancakes briefly in a warm oven. Leftovers can be frozen on the day they are made and reheated in a 250°F oven.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Batter

Ingredient Amount Role and how to choose
All-purpose flour 8.5 oz (240 g) The structure of the pancake
Granulated sugar 1.25 oz (35 g) Light sweetness and browning
Baking powder 1 tsp Leavening
Baking soda 1 tsp Reacts with the acid in buttermilk. Do not swap it for baking powder; you need both
Table salt 1/2 tsp Seasoning
Large egg 1 Binds and adds richness
Buttermilk 1 lb (454 g) Tang and moisture. See the substitute below
Melted butter 1 oz (28 g) Richness. Or use vegetable oil, 25 g, instead; choose one, not both
Vanilla extract (optional) 1 1/2 tsp Aroma. Leave it out if you like
2 / 3

For the pan

Ingredient Amount Role and how to choose
Butter or vegetable oil A thin film For greasing the griddle only; separate from the butter in the batter
3 / 3

For serving

Ingredient Amount Role and how to choose
Butter As desired A pat on top of the stack
Pure maple syrup As desired Poured over at the table
0 / 0

A small stack of pancakes, each about the size of a palm, sits on a breakfast plate. A pat of butter softens on the top layer, and maple syrup runs down the sides and pools on the plate. For many people this is the American pancake: thick, tender rounds with a gentle tang, served with butter and maple syrup. The height comes from the batter itself. Buttermilk works with both baking powder and baking soda, and the batter rests briefly before it meets the griddle. After that, three things matter more than any topping: a batter mixed only until fairly smooth, a griddle that is hot but not scorching, and a flip timed by the bubbles on top and the color underneath.

The American Buttermilk Pancake

Many cuisines have a dish called a "pancake" in English, and each uses its own flour, liquid and leavener. There's the thin crêpe, Korean hotteok filled and made from a yeasted dough, Moroccan baghrir with its many holes from a semolina batter, and Somali canjeero, a thin fermented pancake eaten with meals. Nigerian sinasir is made from fermented rice batter. Each belongs to its own kitchen.

This one is an American buttermilk griddle pancake. It is leavened with baking powder and baking soda and poured a quarter cup at a time, which gives rounds of about 4 inches (about 10 cm). The acidity of buttermilk gives the crumb a gentle tang, and its reaction with the baking soda helps the pancakes rise.

Pancakes have a long history around the world, and the English word "pancake" dates to the Middle English period. What makes this version American is the flavor: a slightly tangy buttermilk crumb finished with butter and maple syrup. It also suits an ordinary weekday morning. The batter is simple, a flat round cooks through quickly, and each pancake spends only a few minutes on the heat. For more of the country's cooking, see the United States country page.

Ingredients

Flour, buttermilk, egg, sugar and leaveners for American pancakes
Batter ingredients, with a separate pat of butter and pure maple syrup set aside for serving

Use the gram weights where given. In volume, the same quantities are 2 cups flour, 3 tbsp sugar, 2 cups buttermilk, and 2 tbsp melted butter or vegetable oil. Measure the leaveners, salt and vanilla with spoons.

Allow about 10 minutes of hands-on time and 45 minutes in total.

The butter appears three times in this recipe, and each has a different job: 1 oz (28 g) melted into the batter, a thin film on the pan, and a pat on the finished stack. The pictured version uses butter in the batter; vegetable oil is an alternative, used in its place rather than alongside it.

If you can't find buttermilk

To replace the 2 cups of buttermilk, use plain Greek yogurt, 2/3 cup, plus milk, 1 1/3 cups. Keep these as volume measures. Expect a different flavor and thickness from cultured buttermilk. Ordinary, thinner plain yogurt is not the same as Greek yogurt, so don't use it at the same ratio and expect the same batter. Plain milk on its own lacks the acidity the baking soda needs, so it is not a straight replacement.

Allergens and raw batter

This recipe contains wheat, egg and milk. It is not an allergy-friendly recipe, and the substitutes above do not make it one. Do not taste the raw batter, which contains raw egg and uncooked flour.

Equipment

  • A large mixing bowl for the dry ingredients
  • A separate bowl or measuring jug for the wet ingredients
  • A whisk and a spatula
  • A 1/4 cup measure for portioning
  • A griddle or flat skillet, and a thin turner

A temperature-controlled electric griddle makes it easier to cook batch after batch at a steady surface temperature, but it is not required; an ordinary skillet over medium heat works.

Buttermilk Pancake Ingredients and Substitutes

Most of what goes into these pancakes is everyday supermarket stock: flour, sugar, baking powder, baking soda, salt, eggs, butter and milk. Buttermilk is the one thing worth looking for. If you find it, use it as written, because it supplies both the tang and the right amount of liquid. If you can't, the Greek yogurt and milk mixture from the tip above works, though the flavor and thickness will be a little different.

Read the label on the syrup, too. Pure maple syrup and pancake syrup blends are different products, so buy pure maple syrup if you want the flavor this pairing is known for. An ordinary skillet is all you need, but an electric griddle helps if you make pancakes often.

How to Make American Buttermilk Pancakes

Read the pan, not just the clock

Cook at 350°F, about 1–2 minutes per side. Home skillets heat unevenly, so let the first pancake tell you whether to adjust the heat.

Fixing Flat, Scorched or Broken Pancakes

Most problems come down to one of three things: how the batter was handled, how hot the pan was, or when the pancake was flipped.

Problem Likely cause What to do
Flat or dense Batter overmixed; leaveners mismeasured or old; pan not preheated Mix only until fairly smooth, measure the baking powder and baking soda carefully, and let the pan heat during the rest. Don't add extra leavener to compensate
Dark outside, raw inside Heat too high Start at medium and adjust using the color of the first pancake
Pale and slow to color Heat too low Raise the heat slightly and test again with the next pancake
Breaks or tears when flipped Moved before bubbles formed and the underside colored Wait for the visual signals before sliding the turner under
Pancakes run together Too little space in the pan Pour fewer at a time and keep each to 1/4 cup

Serving Pancakes with Butter and Maple Syrup

An American pancake breakfast served with butter and maple syrup
The basic way to serve: butter and maple syrup

The classic finish is the simple one: stack the pancakes, put a pat of butter on top, and pour the maple syrup at the table. The batter is only lightly sweetened, so the syrup carries most of the sweetness and everyone can choose how much to use.

  • Butter and pure maple syrup: the basic, and the best way to taste the buttermilk batter as written.
  • Blueberries on the side: spoon them over the cooked pancakes so the batter and cooking stay the same.
  • Blueberries in the batter: berries can change how the pancakes cook and color, so expect a little trial and error.
  • Sliced banana: a familiar modern topping at home.
  • Yogurt and fruit: lets you use less syrup and balances the sweetness.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I just use regular milk instead of buttermilk?

Plain milk on its own loses the tang of buttermilk and the acidity the baking soda reacts with. Use plain Greek yogurt, 2/3 cup, plus milk, 1 1/3 cups, instead. The flavor and thickness will be somewhat different from buttermilk.

Should I whisk out the small lumps?

No, small lumps can stay. Mix until the batter is fairly smooth with no large dry pockets, then stop. Mixing longer makes the pancakes less tender.

Can I freeze leftover pancakes?

Yes. Freeze them on the day you cook them, then reheat them in a 250°F oven.

Sources

  • King Arthur Baking, "Buttermilk Pancakes." The recipe followed in this article: ingredients and amounts, the order of mixing dry and wet ingredients, the 15-minute uncovered rest, cooking on a 350°F griddle or a skillet over medium heat for about 1–2 minutes per side, the yield of 14–16 pancakes about 4 inches across, the Greek yogurt and milk substitute, and the notes on holding, freezing and reheating. https://www.kingarthurbaking.com/recipes/buttermilk-pancakes-recipe
  • Smithsonian Magazine, "A Brief History of Pancakes." Background on pancakes around the world taking different forms, butter and maple syrup as the widely recognized American way of serving them, Melissa Clark's comments on the quick-cooking flat shape, and treating the long world history and the English word separately from any American origin. Not used as proof of a specific recipe or origin. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/a-brief-history-of-pancakes-180981667/
  • Oklahoma Wheat Commission, "Perfect Buttermilk Pancakes" (recipe credited on the page to Wheat Foods Council / Gemma Stafford, Bigger, Bolder Baking). Used only for the handling advice not to overmix and to allow small lumps; its different formula and cooking times are not used in this recipe. https://okwheat.org/recipes/perfect-buttermilk-pancakes/