Chicken Tikka Masala: Grilled Chicken Tikka Folded into a Tomato Masala Sauce

Chicken tikka masala: charred chicken tikka coated in a deep orange-red tomato masala sauce, scattered with chopped coriander
Serves
4–6 servings
Cuisine
British-Indian curry (origins debated)

How to make chicken tikka masala from a Madhur Jaffrey recipe: chicken marinated in cream and spices, grilled on skewers, then folded into an onion, tomato and yoghurt masala sauce. Covers the uncertain origins, how it differs from related dishes, substitutions, and safe cooking of chicken.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Season the chicken with salt and lemon

Rubbing salt and lemon juice into chicken thighs before leaving them for 20 minutes
The first stage is only salt and lemon; the spices and cream come next

Cut the 1.5 lb (675g) of chicken into pieces of about 1 inch (2.5 cm), keeping them even so they cook at the same rate. Put them in a non-reactive bowl with 1¼ tsp salt and 3 tbsp lemon juice and rub them in. Prick the pieces lightly with the tip of a knife so the seasoning works in, then leave for 20 minutes. This short stage gives the chicken its acidity first; don't extend it into a long soak in lemon.

STEP22 / 6

Add the spiced cream marinade and refrigerate

Chicken mixed with ginger, garlic, cumin, paprika, chilli, cream and garam masala before refrigerating
Covered and chilled for 6–8 hours; the marinade is cream and spices, not yoghurt

Mix 1 tbsp ginger, 2 cloves garlic, 1 tsp cumin, 1 tsp paprika, ½–¾ tsp chilli powder, 6 tbsp whipping cream and ½ tsp garam masala into the chicken. Cover and refrigerate for 6–8 hours. Do not leave it at room temperature. This marinade has touched raw chicken, so it must not go into the finished sauce.

STEP33 / 6

Brown the onion and bloom the aromatics and spices

A masala pan with onion browned and ginger, garlic, coriander, turmeric and paprika added
The ground spices need only about 10 seconds before the yoghurt goes in

Heat 4 tbsp oil in a large lidded frying pan over medium-high heat. When the oil is hot, add the 5 oz (140g) of sliced onions and fry for 6–7 minutes until browned. Aim for a deep brown aroma, not a burnt one; turn the heat down if the pan starts to scorch.

Add 1 tbsp ginger and 5–6 cloves garlic and stir for 1 minute. Add 1 tbsp ground coriander, ½ tsp turmeric, ¾ tsp chilli powder and 2 tsp paprika and stir for about 10 seconds.

STEP44 / 6

Add yoghurt, tomatoes and stock, and simmer

Yoghurt, chopped tomatoes and chicken stock added to the onion and spices and simmered on low heat
No chicken goes in yet; the sauce is finished on its own first

Add the 4 tbsp yoghurt 1 tbsp at a time, stirring each spoonful in before adding the next. Adding it gradually helps the yoghurt stay smooth, as the pan's temperature and moisture adjust step by step.

Add the 2 peeled, chopped tomatoes and fry for 3–4 minutes until pulpy. Pour in 1½ cups (350ml) stock, add ¼ tsp salt and bring to a boil. Cover, turn the heat to low and simmer for 15–20 minutes. Judge by the sauce as well as the clock: it is ready when it coats a spoon thinly and leaves a trail on the pan base that closes only slowly. Then stir in ¼ tsp garam masala and the 4 tbsp chopped coriander leaves, and taste and adjust the salt.

STEP55 / 6

Skewer the chicken and grill under strong top heat

Marinated chicken on skewers grilling under a home grill, browning on the surface
Space between the pieces helps them brown; the core temperature decides when they are done

Preheat your grill (broiler) or oven grill to strong top heat. Thread the chicken onto skewers with space between the pieces, and brush the surfaces with the 3 tbsp oil. Rest the skewers across a tray so the meat does not touch it, and place it close to the heat source. Grill for about 6 minutes per side, then check the chicken rather than relying on the clock.

Check the thickest piece with a thermometer: the centre must reach 167°F (75°C) and stay there for at least 1 minute. Colour alone is not proof that chicken is cooked through. Use clean tongs and plates for the cooked chicken, not the ones that held it raw.

STEP66 / 6

Fold the tikka into the reheated sauce

Chicken cooked through to the centre returned to the reheated tomato masala sauce and folded in without breaking it
Combine at the end rather than simmering the chicken in the sauce, so the grilled edges keep their character

Reheat the sauce. Add the grilled chicken and fold it in gently so the pieces stay whole and their browned surfaces show. Serve straight away. The marinade never goes into the pan.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

For the chicken tikka

Ingredient Amount Role
Boneless, skinless chicken thighs 1.5 lb (675g) The tikka. Cut into pieces of about 1 inch (2.5 cm)
Salt 1¼ tsp First seasoning for the chicken
Lemon juice 3 tbsp Acidity in the first stage of the marinade
Root ginger, peeled and finely grated 1 tbsp Aroma in the marinade
Garlic, grated or crushed 2 cloves Aroma in the marinade
Ground cumin 1 tsp Earthy aroma
Paprika 1 tsp Colour and a sweet aroma
Chilli powder ½–¾ tsp Heat
Whipping cream 6 tbsp Richness in the marinade
Garam masala ½ tsp A layered spice aroma
Olive or sunflower oil 3 tbsp Brushed on before grilling
2 / 2

For the masala sauce

Ingredient Amount Role
Olive or sunflower oil 4 tbsp For browning the onion
Onions, halved and finely sliced 5 oz (140g) Sweetness and body
Root ginger, peeled and finely grated 1 tbsp Aroma in the sauce
Garlic, crushed 5–6 cloves Aroma in the sauce
Ground coriander 1 tbsp A citrusy aroma
Turmeric ½ tsp Colour and an earthy note
Chilli powder ¾ tsp Heat
Paprika 2 tsp Colour
Plain yoghurt 4 tbsp Added a spoonful at a time; acidity and a dairy note
Medium tomatoes, peeled and finely chopped 2 Acidity and moisture
Chicken stock 1½ cups (350ml) Loosens and carries the sauce
Salt ¼ tsp, or to taste Adjust after checking the stock's saltiness
Garam masala ¼ tsp Stirred in at the end
Fresh coriander leaves, chopped 4 tbsp A green finish. Can be left out if you dislike it
0 / 0

The skewers come out from under a hot grill with their edges browned and lightly charred. In another pan, a sauce of browned onion, ginger, garlic, ground spices, yoghurt and tomato has been simmering with stock until it thickens. The chicken slides off the skewers into that sauce and goes to the table straight away. That's chicken tikka masala: grilled chicken tikka folded into a spiced tomato masala sauce that was made on its own. The chicken is marinated in lemon, salt, aromatics, spices and whipping cream, and the yoghurt goes into the sauce.

Chicken Tikka Masala: Origins and How It Differs

The best-known story comes from Glasgow. At the Shish Mahal restaurant in the 1970s, owner Ali Ahmed Aslam is said to have created the dish when a customer asked for something to go with chicken tikka, and he combined tomato soup, cream and spices. A bid to give Glasgow protected status for the dish was turned down after several other restaurants objected.

Some argue for a South Asian origin instead, and chicken tikka itself is eaten across a wide area of South Asia. Both the inventor and the place are still open questions. The structure is not in doubt, though: bite-size grilled chicken and a separately cooked tomato sauce, joined only at the very end. In a home kitchen, keeping those two parts separate until the last moment is what makes the dish work.

The dish has close neighbors. Tandoori chicken is all about the grilled chicken and has no separate sauce. Murgh makhani (butter chicken) is a different dish, built on a tomato sauce that includes butter. Restaurant versions can come close in flavor and even in name, but this version uses no butter, and its chicken marinade is based on cream and spices.

Ingredients: Serves 4–6, Split Between Marinade and Sauce

Chicken thighs, lemon, ginger, garlic, yoghurt, tomatoes, onion and spices such as cumin and paprika laid out as ingredients
Ginger and garlic are needed twice: once for the marinade and once for the sauce

Ginger, garlic, paprika, chilli powder, garam masala, oil and salt each appear in both groups, so measure them out separately for the marinade and the sauce.

Choosing Ingredients and Substitutes for Chicken Tikka Masala

Most of the shopping is ordinary supermarket fare: chicken thighs, plain yoghurt, lemons, onions, tomatoes and cream. The garam masala, paprika and chilli powder may need a special trip. Small packs are enough, and it's worth checking the labels for heat level.

  • Chicken: Thighs are the better choice. Breast works but dries out more easily, so cut it to the same size and don't overcook it, while still reaching the safe core temperature.
  • Salt: Coarse and fine salts taste different by the spoon. Season the sauce at the end by tasting instead of converting to weight.
  • Lemon juice: Bottled juice works, though its aroma is weaker.
  • Ginger and garlic: Tube pastes have a rounder aroma, and ginger paste carries more moisture. Use a like-for-like swap as a starting point and adjust as you go.
  • Cumin: Whole cumin seeds need a different method, so they won't stand in directly for ground cumin.
  • Paprika: Use sweet paprika. Smoked paprika brings a smoky aroma to the front and gives you a different variation.
  • Chilli powder: Heat varies from brand to brand, so start with the smaller amount. Cayenne is not a 1:1 swap; add it gradually.
  • Cream: Creams with different fat contents change the browning and the richness.
  • Garam masala: Choose an unsalted blend. Curry powder has a different mix and aroma and won't make the same dish.
  • Oil: A neutral vegetable oil works. Olive oil adds its own aroma.
  • Onion: Use yellow or brown onions. Red onions change the color and aroma.
  • Turmeric: Leaving it out makes the sauce paler. Curry powder in its place changes the whole spice balance.
  • Yoghurt: Use unsweetened plain yoghurt. Greek yoghurt is thicker, so loosen it bit by bit as you add it.
  • Tomatoes: Ripe tomatoes are best. Canned tomatoes have different moisture and acidity, so watch how the sauce reduces.
  • Stock: Unsalted or low-salt stock is easiest to control. If you use stock granules, cut back on the salt.
Allergens and labels

This recipe contains chicken and milk (cream and yoghurt). Naan served alongside may contain wheat. Check spice blends and stock for allergen labelling and shared-facility statements.

Equipment

  • A non-reactive bowl (glass or similar) for marinating
  • A large frying pan or sauté pan with a lid
  • Long metal skewers
  • A tray or rack that can support the skewers so the meat does not touch the tray; check that it fits your grill before you start
  • A probe or instant-read thermometer for checking the core temperature of the chicken
  • A separate chopping board, bowl and tongs for raw chicken, kept apart from those used for cooked food

Bamboo skewers can scorch near a grill element. Use metal skewers unless you are sure your bamboo will suit your grill.

Method: Marinate the Tikka, Simmer the Sauce, Then Grill

Plan the timing

The chicken needs 20 minutes in salt and lemon, then 6–8 hours in the refrigerator with the rest of the marinade. Make the sauce while the grill heats, or ahead of grilling, and reheat it before the chicken goes in.

Chicken safety

Chicken is not safe just because it is fresh. Avoid raw or undercooked chicken, and cook it until the centre reaches 167°F (75°C) for at least 1 minute. Keep raw chicken and its bowls, boards and tools apart from other foods; wash your hands after handling it, and wash and sanitise the tools. Do not leave the marinating chicken or the finished dish standing at room temperature.

Chicken Tikka Masala Troubleshooting

Problem Likely cause What to do
The chicken doesn't brown Skewers packed too tightly, or marinade pooled thickly on the surface Space the pieces apart and let excess marinade drip off. Home grills differ in power, so check both browning and core temperature
The chicken is dry Uneven pieces, or grilling on for color after it was cooked Cut the pieces evenly. Move the chicken to the sauce once the center has held 167°F (75°C) for 1 minute. Never lower the safety standard to keep it tender
The sauce is watery Tomatoes not cooked to a pulp, or very juicy tomatoes Cook the tomatoes to a pulp before adding the stock, then simmer covered on low. If it's still thin, take the lid off and reduce briefly, checking as you go
The yoghurt looks grainy Added all at once, or boiled hard Add it 1 tbsp at a time and avoid a fierce boil
The heat is too strong Hot chilli powder Use less chilli powder next time, starting with the smaller marinade amount

Serving and Variations

Chicken tikka masala served with plain rice and naan, with a piece of naan used to scoop up the sauce
Serve with Indian-style bread or rice

Bring it to the table as soon as the chicken has gone into the sauce, while the grilled surfaces still have some bite. Serve it with naan or another Indian-style bread for scooping up the sauce, or with rice to soak it up.

There are a few changes worth knowing about:

  • Milder heat: Reduce the chilli powder. The structure stays the same, but the whole dish loses some of its edge along with the heat.
  • Chicken breast: Leaner and quicker to dry out. Cut it evenly and watch the core temperature closely.
  • Oven grill: Your oven's top grill element is the closest home equivalent to a hot grill. Shelf position and timing depend on your oven.
  • Grilling in batches: If your grill compartment is small, grill in smaller batches, as long as the skewers and tray fit safely. Check doneness by temperature for every batch.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should I grill the chicken?

About 6 minutes per side, but grills vary. The real test is the thickest piece reaching 167°F (75°C) at the center and holding it for at least 1 minute.

Can I make it without dairy?

Leaving out the cream and yoghurt changes both the flavor and how the chicken browns. A dairy-free version makes a different dish.

Can I marinate it for less time?

Plan on 6–8 hours in the refrigerator after the salt and lemon stage.

Find more recipes in the India collection.

Sources