Butter Chicken (Murgh Makhani): Delhi-Style, Made Without a Tandoor

Delhi-style butter chicken with browned chicken pieces resting in a glossy tomato and butter sauce
Prep
8 hr 45 min
Cook
45 min
Total
9 hr 30 min
Serves
4 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Indian

Butter chicken, or murgh makhani, made in a home oven without a tandoor. Its Delhi origin at Moti Mahal, why the chicken is roasted first, how thick the tomato sauce should be, kasuri methi substitutes, storage and reheating, and what to buy and what to skip.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 5

Cut the chicken to 4–2 inches (5 cm) and marinate in two stages

Chicken thighs cut to 4–5 cm, coated in a yogurt and red spice marinade

Cut 1.5 lb (700 g) chicken thighs into 4–2 inches (5 cm) bite-size pieces so that they are 2–1 inches (2.5 cm) thick. Opening only the thick parts with the knife to even the thickness keeps the edges from drying while the center stays raw. Press the surface dry with paper towels, rub in 4 g salt, the yogurt, lemon juice, ginger and garlic, and leave in the refrigerator for 30 minutes.

After 30 minutes, add 2 tsp garam masala, the Kashmiri chili, the remaining 3 g salt and the oil and mix everything. The yogurt should cover the surface of the chicken evenly with no powdery spice left. Press plastic wrap onto the surface of the chicken and refrigerate for 6–8 hours, overnight at most. Left for a long time in yogurt alone, the surface tends to go soft, so the spices and oil go in later, in two stages. If you are short of time you can make it with 30 minutes at minimum, but the aroma will go in only shallowly.

STEP22 / 5

Roast only the surface first in a 450°F (230 °C) oven

A baking sheet in a 230 °C oven, with the edges of marinated chicken turning reddish-brown

Preheat the oven to 450°F (230 °C) and set a rack on a baking sheet or line it with parchment. Take the chicken out of the bowl, leave a thin layer of marinade on the surface, and arrange the pieces 4–2 inches (5 cm) apart. If liquid stays thick on the chicken, it steams, so squeeze out the excess once in the bowl.

Roast at 450°F (230 °C) for 18–22 minutes, turning once at the 10-minute mark. Look for a few reddish-brown spots on the surface and edges that look firm. Rather than cutting into the thickest part to check, use a probe thermometer: hold the center of the thickest part at 167°F (75 °C) for at least 1 minute. This loses fewer juices.

If the color is weak, strengthen the top heat for only the last 2 minutes. If the surface is about to blacken, lay aluminum foil loosely over it and cook through. Rest the roasted chicken on the tray for 5 minutes until the sauce is ready. Do not throw away the juices that come out; adding a little to the sauce connects the aromas.

STEP33 / 5

Reduce the tomato and add the butter in two parts

Sauce of tomato passata and cashews simmered until a line remains on the bottom of the pot

While the chicken roasts, put 1 tbsp neutral oil, 1 tsp ginger and 1 tsp garlic in a deep pot and fry over medium heat for 1 minute. When the aroma rises, add 14 oz (400 g) tomato passata, ½ cup (100 ml) water, 1 oz (30 g) cashews, 1 tsp honey and 2 g salt. Bring to a boil over medium heat and when it bubbles, lower to medium-low and simmer for 12–15 minutes.

When you drag a wooden spoon across the bottom of the pot, the line should stay for about 2 seconds and a few red rings of oil should show on the surface; that is the signal for reduction. If a raw tomato smell remains, simmer another 3–5 minutes. If you go on while it is still watery, it turns pale orange when you add the cream and the sauce will not cling to the chicken.

Now add 1 oz (30 g) unsalted butter and melt it over low heat. Do not heat it so much that large bubbles rise; swirl the pot slowly to mix. If you put all the butter in at the start, the fat tends to separate while you reduce, so leave 15 g for the finish.

STEP44 / 5

Cool slightly and make a smooth red sauce

A pot of tomato sauce with cashews being smoothed by a blender

Take the pot off the heat and let it cool for 5 minutes. With a hand blender, sink the blade fully into the sauce and blend on low speed for 1–2 minutes. With a food processor, work in two batches, each less than half the container. Do not blend hot liquid in a sealed container all at once.

If the grains of cashew or tomato skin bother you, strain once through a fine sieve. The guide is a sauce that leaves a trail when you lift it with a spoon and slowly returns. If it is too stiff to blend, add hot water 1 tbsp at a time. If it is watery, return it to the pot after straining and reduce it on low heat for 3–5 minutes. Smoothness is not just for looks; it is needed so the sauce coats the surface of the roasted chicken thinly and evenly.

STEP55 / 5

Return the chicken over low heat and seal in the cream's aroma

Browned chicken warmed over low heat in a red makhani sauce with cream and butter added

Return the smoothed sauce to the pot and set it over low heat. Add ½ cup (100 ml) heavy cream, the remaining 15 g butter, 1 tsp kasuri methi rubbed between your fingers and 1 tsp garam masala. Add the chicken and warm for 6–8 minutes, spooning the sauce over from above. Do not let it boil hard; keep it to small bubbles at the edge of the pot.

It is done when the chicken is reheated to the center and the sauce lightly coats the back of a spoon. Taste: if the acidity stands out, add honey 1/2 tsp at a time; if the sweetness is heavy, turn off the heat and add lemon juice 1 tsp at a time. To soften the heat, add a little cream, but adding water blurs flavor and thickness at once. Adjust the salt last, and when you plate it, scatter a pinch of kasuri methi on top.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 2

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role and substitutes
Skinless chicken thighs 1.5 lb (700 g) Cut into 4–2 inches (5 cm) bite-size pieces. Breast works, but do not overcook
Plain yogurt 5.5 oz (150 g) Unsweetened. Use 4 oz (120 g) if it is strained yogurt
Lemon juice 1 tbsp Acidity and aroma. Up to 2 tsp rice vinegar instead
Grated ginger 2 tsp 2 tsp if from a tube. Use a little less of watery products
Grated garlic 2 tsp The base of the aroma
Garam masala 2 tsp For the marinade. If the blend contains salt, reduce the salt
Kashmiri chili powder 1 tbsp Color and mild heat. Can be replaced by 2 tsp paprika and a little cayenne
Salt 7 g About 1% of the chicken weight. Divided between the marinade and the sauce
Neutral oil 1 tbsp Mixed into the marinade to help browning

Kashmiri chili is a powder with a vivid red color and mild heat. For a substitute, paprika alone makes the aroma flat, and cayenne alone lacks color. Use 2 tsp paprika with a little cayenne to balance color and heat. If you don't like hot food, skip the cayenne and the finishing black pepper.

2 / 2

Makhani sauce

Ingredient Amount Role and substitutes
Unsalted tomato passata 14 oz (400 g) If using whole tomatoes, strain them
Water ½ cup (100 ml) To loosen before reducing
Grated ginger 1 tsp Aroma of the sauce
Grated garlic 1 tsp Supports the tomato's green edge
Unsalted butter 1.5 oz (45 g) Simmer 1 oz (30 g), use 15 g at the end
Heavy cream (35–40% milkfat) ½ cup (100 ml) Milk alone lacks thickness
Cashews 1 oz (30 g) Richness and thickness. Omit for a nut allergy
Honey 1 tsp Rounds out tomato acidity. Sugar also works
Kasuri methi 1 tsp Rub lightly between your fingers. Omit if you have none
Garam masala 1 tsp Finishing aroma
Salt about 3 g Adjust to the salt in the tomato
0 / 0

Straight from the oven, the chicken is reddish-brown and charred at the edges. Break a piece open and the surface is toasty while the inside still holds its juices. In a separate pot, butter melts into the acidity of the tomato and cream rounds off its corners, and the moment the browned chicken touches that sauce, the aroma shifts from grilled chicken to a diner's curry. In India the dish is called murgh makhani: murgh means chicken, and makhani refers to something with a buttery character. It began as a north Indian restaurant dish built on tandoor-roasted chicken, and this home version gets its browning from a hot oven instead.

A pot just before browned chicken returns to a glossy butter chicken sauce

How this recipe works

Cut boneless chicken thighs into 4–2 inches (5 cm) bite-size pieces and marinate them in a yogurt marinade for 6–8 hours. Roast at 450°F (230 °C) for 18–22 minutes and confirm that the center of the thickest part has reached 167°F (75 °C) for at least 1 minute. Reduce the sauce in a separate pot, then combine it with the chicken.

Because the chicken marinates overnight, plan a day ahead. On the day itself, all that's left is making the sauce, roasting the chicken and bringing the two together, and a home oven is all the special equipment you need.

Butter chicken in Delhi

Origins in Daryaganj

Search for the origin of butter chicken and one name always comes up: Moti Mahal, a restaurant in the Daryaganj district of Delhi, where the dish was born in the 1950s. Juices and leftover chicken from the tandoor weren't wasted. They went into a sauce of butter and tomato, and a way of carrying easily dried-out chicken over to the next day turned into a thick red gravy. The richness of butter chicken started as thrift, not luxury.

Who made it first is disputed. The Moti Mahal account centers on Kundan Lal Gujral, while the Daryaganj restaurant, in the same area, claims credit for Kundan Lal Jaggi and his family. Both carry on a lineage of cooks who opened restaurants in Delhi after Partition, each with its own memory of tandoor cooking.

How it is eaten in Delhi

Daryaganj is where Old Delhi's markets and eateries cluster, and butter chicken belongs to that kind of table: roasted meat, bread, sauce and drinks set close together, with everyone reaching in to combine them. Taste the dish by itself with a spoon and it's sweet and rich. Tear off some naan, scoop up sauce with a browned piece of chicken, and the acidity and toastiness come first, with the butter smoothing things out from behind.

That's why a Delhi plate isn't really about the sauce alone. Restaurants often flood the plate so you can dip naan again and again, which is fun at home too, but the dish is built to bring tandoor-roasted chicken, the wheat of the bread and the acidity of tomato together in one mouthful.

A wooden table suggesting an old Delhi eatery, set with roasted chicken and a red sauce

Why the chicken is roasted first

Whichever origin story you believe, they agree on one thing: the roasted chicken and the tomato-and-butter sauce are separate steps. Simmer the chicken in the sauce from the start and it turns tender, but the aroma of browning fades. Roast it first, and the char and juices on the surface stay put, so the flavor gains layers once the sauce coats it at the end.

When a home version tastes "off," the culprit is more often the surface of the chicken than the dairy. Yogurt-marinated chicken cooked in a pan over low heat gives off water and drifts toward plain steamed chicken. A tandoor chars the surface quickly with intense heat; at home, the shortcut is a fully preheated oven, with the pieces spaced apart. If liquid collects on the tray the chicken steams, so don't leave the marinade on too thickly. Turn the pieces once at 10 minutes, and move on when the edges are brown and the surface looks dry. You don't need black char. A few toasty spots are enough to add depth once the chicken meets the red sauce.

Contrast between browned chicken and a red makhani sauce reduced until oil rises

Three things hold the dish together: roast the chicken, cook the tomato until its raw smell is gone, and add the cream at the end without boiling it. Keep those steps separate and you can make butter chicken far from Delhi without losing its structure.

Variations and chicken tikka masala

North Indian restaurants differ in the details. Some use boneless chicken tikka, which is easy to scoop up with the sauce, and some use bone-in chicken for the savoriness of a stew. Some add cashews for body; others finish lightly, centered on tomato and butter.

Butter chicken looks a lot like chicken tikka masala, and that's natural: both are spiced chicken combined with a tomato-based sauce. Murgh makhani is best understood as roasted chicken returned to a smooth tomato sauce containing butter, and keeping that in mind makes substitutes easier to choose.

Ingredients for 4, and substitutions

The list looks long, but divided into three sets (the chicken marinade, the sauce and the finish), it is easy to shop for. You can use chopped ripe fresh tomatoes. But unsalted tomato passata, or strained whole tomatoes, gives consistent water content across seasons and varieties, and makes the thickness easier to judge.

Garam masala, kasuri methi and cashews in small dishes, with the chicken ingredients

Chicken marinade

Milk can replace heavy cream, but the sauce gets lighter. In that case, add 5 g more butter at the end. Coconut milk brings its own aroma forward, so skip it if you want to stay close to murgh makhani. Cashews add thickness, but you can make it without them if you reduce the tomato enough.

Accompaniments

Prepare naan, chapati or basmati rice for 4. Naan if you want to enjoy plenty of sauce; basmati rice with little added aroma if you want something to catch the heat and fat lightly. If you serve a cucumber and yogurt raita, keep the salt low so you do not stack up salt across the whole meal.

The dish uses dairy, chicken and cashews. Even if you omit the nuts, wash the blender and cutting board if you share them. Store-bought garam masala and tomato products can contain salt or allergen labeling, so check the label on the container when you buy.

When to buy kasuri methi

Kasuri methi needs only 1 tsp at a time, so you don't need a large bag for this recipe alone. If you'll keep cooking Indian food, buy a small amount. If not, leave it out and add garam masala at the end.

Choosing ingredients and tools for butter chicken

Spices

Chicken thighs, yogurt, tomato and cream all come from an ordinary supermarket. The only things worth buying specially are garam masala, which sets the finishing aroma, and kasuri methi. Garam masala brands differ in how strongly they show cardamom and cinnamon. A large pack only makes sense if you also cook biryani, tandoori chicken and bean dishes; if you'll make this once a month, use a blend you already have or buy a small pack.

Check the package for whether the garam masala contains salt or coloring. This recipe uses 7 g salt for an unsalted blend, so with a seasoned type, reduce the salt in the marinade.

Kasuri methi is dried fenugreek leaf. Rub it lightly between your fingers and a sweet, grassy aroma rises, and the dish instantly tastes more Indian. If you can't find it, leave it out and add a little garam masala at the end instead. Basil or nori would pull the aroma in a different direction.

Substitutes

Skinless chicken thighs from an ordinary supermarket are fine. A 450°F (230 °C) oven stands in for a tandoor, strained whole tomatoes can replace tomato passata, store-bought naan works, and if you have no basmati rice, another long-grain or short-grain rice will do.

Some swaps change more. Ordinary curry powder in place of garam masala changes the backbone of the aroma, and milk instead of cream makes the sauce lighter. Neither is a failure; it's home cooking where you know what has changed.

Tools for a smooth sauce

If you add cashews, the texture depends on leaving no grains at the end. A hand blender lets you purée the sauce right in the pot. Filling a countertop blender with hot sauce is dangerous, so cool it a little, respect the fill line, hold the lid down and blend in small batches. A strainer removes tomato skin and seeds even without a blender.

A hand blender being used to smooth the red sauce in a pot, a little at a time

If you make soups, hummus and purées about once a week, a dedicated blender or food processor saves labor. Just don't buy a large 3.75 quarts (3.6 L), 700 W model only for butter chicken for 4, especially if storage space is tight.

How to make it

Cooking and storing chicken

Keep the cutting board and tongs used for raw chicken separate from the roasted chicken and the serving plates. Confirm the center of the thickest part has reached 167°F (75 °C) for at least 1 minute, and refrigerate leftovers within about 2 hours.

Fixing butter chicken: thickness first

Butter chicken is easier to repair by restoring thickness than by adding flavor. More garam masala won't fix a thin sauce; it only strengthens the aroma. Check the moisture in the pot first, then the acidity, and the dairy last.

A pot of red tomato sauce and roasted chicken, with the thickness being checked by a wooden spoon

Problem Main cause How to fix it
Sauce is thin and runs off the chicken Watery tomato, not reduced enough Take the chicken out and simmer over medium-low heat for 3–5 minutes, until a wooden spoon leaves a line for 2 seconds
Tomato acidity is sharp Not simmered enough, variety differences Extend 5 minutes over low heat, then add 5 g butter and 1/2 tsp honey
Sweetness is forward Honey or tomato sugar is high Turn off the heat and add 1 tsp lemon juice and a pinch of salt at a time
Chicken is tough Pieces too small, overroasted, or kept cooking while checking the core temperature Return to the sauce, cover and cook 3 minutes over low heat. Next time, even out the thickness and shorten the roasting
Too hot Too much chili powder Add cream 1 tbsp at a time. Do not dilute with water; adjust salt last
Sauce is oily and separated Dairy boiled over high heat Turn off the heat, add 1 tbsp hot water and stir slowly with a whisk

If the aroma seems weak, add garam masala 1/4 tsp at a time at the end rather than all at once. What tastes faint in the pot often feels right with naan or rice.

Once the chicken goes into the sauce, warm it only briefly over low heat. A hard boil thickens the sauce but draws moisture from the surface of the chicken. And before deciding it needs more seasoning, eat a bite with naan: the sauce on its own makes it easy to misjudge how much the bread or rice will absorb.

Serving and storing butter chicken

Sides and plating

Choose the sides by the balance of fat and acidity. On a day you pile buttery naan onto a rich sauce, a cucumber raita or thinly sliced onion settles the plate. With basmati rice, keep the sides light and serve less sauce so the aroma comes through. Make an Indian raita first. For more on tandoor-style roasting, see tandoori chicken, and on a day you want soft rice and lentils without chicken, khichdi, another South Asian home dish, lightens the menu.

A butter chicken table with naan, basmati rice and cucumber raita

Eater / occasion Plating Seasoning adjustment
Family tearing naan More sauce, on a shallow plate Less heat, a little acidity left
Lunch with rice Chicken in the center, not too much sauce Do not add more honey; hold back the garam masala
Next-day lunch box or make-ahead Chicken and sauce in the same container Slightly less cream, so reheating separates less

Storage and reheating

Don't leave the finished pot on the stove to cool slowly. Cool it briefly, portion out what you'll eat now, move the rest to a shallow container and refrigerate it within about 2 hours. Even fully cooked chicken needs careful storage to stay safe.

Refrigerated, butter chicken keeps within 3 days, when its aroma and texture hold best. To freeze, separate the chicken and sauce into single portions, cool them completely and seal. The sauce tends to separate after thawing, so warm it in a pot over low heat, stirring in hot water 1 tsp at a time.

To reheat in a microwave, go 1 minute at a time at 600 W, stirring from the center each time. In a pot, cover it over low heat and add a little hot water so it doesn't scorch. Make sure it is hot all the way through and that the thick part of the chicken has been at 167°F (75 °C) for at least 1 minute; a thick sauce can be hot on the surface and still cold in the center.

Butter chicken portioned into shallow containers, and a pot of sauce being reheated over low heat

Oil rising to the surface after storage is normal. Butter hardens in the cold and can look separated when warmed, but low heat and a few teaspoons of hot water bring it back together. If the aroma has faded, rub in a little kasuri methi just before eating or add a pinch of garam masala.

Frequently asked questions

A closer view of a plate with butter chicken sauce lifted on a spoon and browned chicken

Can I make it taste authentic without a tandoor?

You won't get a tandoor's smoke, but roasting the chicken separately from the sauce keeps the structure of the dish. With a broiler or grill, cook over high heat while watching the surface, and heat the center of the thickest part to 167°F (75 °C) for at least 1 minute. It scorches easily, so check it sooner than you would in the oven.

Can I switch to chicken breast?

You can, but even it out to about 1 inches (2 cm) thick and start checking at 15–18 minutes of roasting. Because breast is lean, leave the marinade on thickly and take it off the tray soon after roasting. If moistness is the priority, thighs are less likely to fail.

Can I make it with curry powder alone?

You can, but it moves away from the aroma of murgh makhani. Curry powders differ in their ratio of turmeric, cumin and other spices, and their color and aroma tend to dominate. If you have no garam masala, cut back the marinade spices and finish with a little black pepper; that holds together better than strong curry powder.

The sauce turns orange instead of red.

The color depends on the thickness of the tomato, the amount of butter and when the cream goes in. Simmer the tomato for 12–15 minutes before adding the butter, and add the cream last. To deepen the color without changing the heat, choose Kashmiri chili or paprika rather than more chili.

Can I make it smooth without a blender?

Yes. Omit the cashews and strain the tomato, and a wooden spoon is all you need. If you use cashews, soak them in lukewarm water for 20 minutes and chop them finely with a knife before adding. Passing the sauce through a strainer at the end smooths the mouthfeel further.

Sources

Roast the chicken first, reduce the tomato, and combine them at the end over low heat. If you keep to that order, even a kitchen without a tandoor can create the moment when the browned surface sinks into the sauce. Buy garam masala only if you will use it in other Indian dishes, and choose tools only if you will use them for more than this one dish. This dish works without large packs of spice or special equipment. Decide what you will cook next before you put anything in your basket.