Muringayila Thoran: Kerala Drumstick Leaves with Coconut (മുരിങ്ങയില തോരൻ)

A bowl of Muringayila Thoran, drumstick leaves coated in coarse coconut
Serves
2 servings
Cuisine
Indian (Kerala)

How to make Muringayila Thoran, a Kerala-style dish of drumstick leaves seasoned with salt, turmeric and chilli, rested, then cooked with a coarse paste of coconut, shallots and cumin powder. One family's version for 2, with every step, the thoran's place in Kerala food, and how it differs from other home versions.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Strip, wash and season the leaves

Seasoning the washed leaves with salt, turmeric and red chilli powder
Season the washed leaves with salt, turmeric and chilli powder

Pick the drumstick leaves off their stems, leaving the stems behind. Wash the leaves thoroughly, then put them in a bowl. Add salt to taste, a large pinch of turmeric and 1 tsp red chilli powder, and mix them through the leaves. Leave the seasoned leaves to rest for 30 minutes, until they have released some water.

STEP22 / 6

Grind the coconut mixture

Coconut, shallots and cumin powder ground coarsely
A coarse mixture, not a smooth paste

Grind 1 cup grated coconut with 2 shallots and 1/2 tsp cumin powder to a coarse mixture. Keep it coarse rather than smooth, and set it aside until the leaves have had their first cook.

STEP33 / 6

Pop the mustard seeds and add the leaves

Adding mustard seeds and letting them pop
The seeds pop in the hot oil

Add 1 tbsp coconut oil to the pan and warm it over the heat. Add 1/4 tsp mustard seeds to the hot oil and let them pop. Once the seeds have popped, add the rested leaves and stir them through the oil and mustard seeds until they are coated.

STEP44 / 6

Cook the leaves covered

Covering the pan and cooking on low heat for about 5 minutes
The first covered cook is on low heat

Put the lid on and cook on low heat for about 5 minutes. Lift off the lid when the time is up.

STEP55 / 6

Add the coconut and finish cooking

Lid set aside, stirring the leaves partway through the second cook
Stir to keep the bottom from browning

Add the coarsely ground coconut, shallot and cumin mixture to the leaves and mix everything together well. Put the lid back on and cook for another 5–10 minutes. Partway through, take off the lid and stir so the bottom does not brown, then return the lid and finish the rest of the same 5–10 minutes. The thoran is done when the leaves are cooked through and soft.

STEP66 / 6

Serve with rice

Muringayila Thoran served alongside rice
Thoran and rice, kept separate

Serve with rice, with a pulusu or kozhambu of your choice on the side if you like.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 1

Ingredients

Ingredient Amount Role
Drumstick leaves (muringayila) 4 cups The main ingredient; stripped from the stems, washed, seasoned and rested
Salt to taste Seasons the leaves before they rest
Turmeric a large pinch Mixed into the leaves with the salt and chilli
Red chilli powder 1 tsp Mixed into the leaves with the salt and turmeric
Grated coconut 1 cup (adjust to taste) Ground coarsely and added after the leaves have cooked first
Shallots 2 Ground coarsely with the coconut
Cumin powder (jeera) 1/2 tsp Ground coarsely with the coconut and shallots
Coconut oil 1 tbsp Heated in the pan for the mustard seeds
Mustard seeds 1/4 tsp Popped in the oil before the leaves go in
0 / 0

Before anything reaches the pan, the tiny drumstick leaves have to be stripped from their stems. It is slow work, and it is shared: one memory is of a grandmother picking the leaves off one by one, another of cousins helping pluck them for a family thoran. Muringayila Thoran (മുരിങ്ങയില തോരൻ in Malayalam) turns those leaves into a Kerala side dish with coconut. The leaves are rubbed with salt, turmeric and chilli powder and left to rest, then cooked in coconut oil with popped mustard seeds and finished with coarsely ground coconut, shallots and cumin powder.

Muringayila Thoran in a Kerala Home

Thoran belongs to the Kerala table. At sadya, the traditional vegetarian feast served on a plantain leaf with rice, side dishes, savouries, pickles and desserts, it is an important side dish. Common forms are made from minced string beans, cabbage, radish or grams with grated coconut, red chilli and turmeric. Whatever the vegetable, the idea is the same: something green cooked with coconut and a little spice. This one is a home dish, served simply with rice.

The recipe comes from two family cooks, Amma and Aatha. Aatha means maternal grandmother, a term from the family's Reddiar Telugu side, so this Kerala dish carries a second language with it.

The two cooks handle water differently. Amma rubs the spices into the leaves and cooks thoran on low with water sprinkled over. For drumstick leaves, this recipe follows Aatha and adds no water, because the seasoned leaves release their own as they rest.

For more from the same country, browse more dishes from India.

Ingredients (Serves 2)

The nine ingredients for Muringayila Thoran, each set out separately
Leaves, coconut, three spices, shallots, salt, coconut oil and mustard seeds

Serve with rice, and a pulusu or kozhambu of your choice if you like. These are accompaniments, not part of the thoran.

Equipment

  • A bowl for seasoning and resting the leaves
  • A colander or sieve for washing the leaves
  • A tool for grinding the coconut mixture coarsely (any type you have)
  • A pan with a lid
  • A spoon for stirring

Choosing Ingredients for Muringayila Thoran

  • Drumstick leaves: Also sold as moringa leaves. Buy the leaves themselves; the pods, flowers and leaf powder go into other dishes. Spinach or other greens would make a different dish.
  • Cumin powder, not seeds: Ground cumin goes in with the coconut. Whole cumin seeds belong to other versions.
  • Shallots: Stick with shallots rather than red onion or spring onion.
  • Coconut oil: It is the cooking fat for the mustard seeds and the leaves, so keep it instead of switching to a neutral oil.
  • Grated coconut: 1 cup is the base amount, and you can use more or less to taste.

Method: Season, Rest, Cook Under a Lid, Then Add the Coconut

Times and heat

The leaves rest for 30 minutes. The first covered cook is on low heat for about 5 minutes. The second covered cook runs another 5–10 minutes until the leaves are soft. Judge the end by the leaves, not the clock.

Fixing Muringayila Thoran Problems

What you see Likely cause What to do
The bottom is starting to brown Not stirred during the second covered cook Take off the lid and stir partway through, then cover again
The leaves are not soft yet The second cook is not finished Keep the lid on within the 5–10 minute window and check again
The coconut turned into a smooth paste Ground past the coarse stage Next time stop while the mixture is still coarse
The mustard seeds did not pop The oil may not have been hot enough Wait for the seeds to pop before adding the leaves

Muringayila Thoran Variations

Drumstick-leaf thoran has no single formula, because so many households make it. One version uses 3 cups of leaves, 1/4 cup coconut, whole cumin seeds, garlic, curry leaves, 5–6 shallots and a little water, with a 5–7 minute covered cook and ghee drizzled on top to serve. In that version the leaves are plucked the day before, then washed and cooked the next day, which is a handy way to split up the slow part.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I add water while cooking?

No. The seasoned leaves release water as they rest, and that is enough for the covered cook. Some cooks, Amma among them, sprinkle water over thoran on low heat, but this drumstick-leaf version is cooked without it.

What do I serve it with?

Serve it with rice, and with a pulusu or kozhambu of your choice if you like. In the family this recipe comes from, it is usually served with fish curry.

Sources

  • Nags, Edible Garden, "Muringayila Thoran-Kerala Thoran Recipe-Drumstick Leaves cooked with Coconut." The recipe followed here: serves 2, all nine ingredients, the full method, the serving note, the family recollection of plucking leaves, the explanation of Aatha, and Amma's advice on sprinkling water. https://www.cookingandme.com/muringayila-thoran-drumstick-leaves/
  • Divya, Happy's Cook, "Murungai keerai Thoran Recipe | Muringayila Thoran | Drumstick leaves cooked with coconut." A separate family version used for comparison only; none of its amounts or steps are used in the recipe above. https://www.happyscook.com/2015/09/murungai-keerai-thoran-recipe.html
  • Kerala Tourism, Government of Kerala, "Sadya - the traditional vegetarian feast of Keralites." Background on Sadya and on thoran as a side dish with common vegetable and coconut forms; it does not describe a drumstick-leaf thoran. https://www.keralatourism.org/kerala-food/sadya/