Haleem: Bangladeshi Iftar Stew of Wheat, Lentils and Bone-In Beef

Bangladeshi-style haleem topped with fried onion, ginger, green chili and cilantro
Prep
40 min
Cook
2 hr 35 min
Total
3 hr 15 min
Serves
6 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Bangladeshi

Bangladeshi haleem, a staple of iftar made by simmering cracked wheat, lentils and bone-in meat for a long time and finishing with fresh toppings. Covers the street food culture of Old Dhaka, how it differs from the Pakistani version, substitutes, heat control, storage, reheating, why it fails, and what to buy, so you don't get lost in the kitchen.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 6

Wash and soak the wheat and lentils

35 min

Washing and soaking cracked wheat, lentils and rice in a metal bowl
Soak the wheat and lentils for 30 minutes to even out their hardness at the start of cooking

Put 6 oz (170g) cracked wheat, 2 oz (60g) rolled barley, 2.75 oz (80g) chana dal, 2.75 oz (80g) red lentils, 1.5 oz (40g) mung dal and 1 oz (30g) basmati rice in a bowl and wash them 3 times, changing the water. When the water is only slightly cloudy, soak them in plenty of water for 30 minutes. Move on when the corners of the lentils have rounded a little when pressed with a finger and the surface of the cracked wheat is moist.

STEP22 / 6

Brown the onion and bone-in meat

25 min

Searing bone-in beef with onion, ginger, garlic and spices
Brown the meat over medium-high heat, and after adding yogurt, fry until the oil seeps out

Put 4 tbsp ghee in a heavy pot and warm it over medium heat for 1 minute. Add 14 oz (400g) onion sliced 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick and cook over medium heat for the first 8 minutes to drive off the moisture, then when it begins to color, cook over medium-low heat for 8 minutes. When all of it is a deep golden brown, take out half, and put 1.75 lb (800g) bone-in beef in with the remaining onion. Sear over medium-high heat for 6 minutes, and when the surface of the meat has browned, lower the heat to low and add the garlic, grated ginger, spices, salt and yogurt. Stir for 4 minutes until the white of the yogurt disappears, the spices coat the meat evenly, and oil seeps at the edge of the pot.

STEP33 / 6

Cook the wheat and lentils down in a separate pot

70 min

The wheat and lentils simmering over low heat in the pot, grains beginning to collapse
Cook the wheat and lentils down over low heat until the grains crush under a finger

In another heavy pot put the drained wheat and lentils, and add 2 quarts (1.8L) water, 1 tsp turmeric, 1 tsp red chili powder and 1 tsp salt. Bring to a boil over high heat, skim the foam when it boils, and lower to low heat. With the lid slightly ajar, cook for 60 to 70 minutes, stirring from the bottom every 5 minutes. Cook until the grains crush easily under a finger and, pressed with a wooden spoon, spread thinly on the wall of the pot. If the liquid gets low, add ¾ cup (200ml) boiling water, and scrape the bottom before a burnt smell appears.

STEP44 / 6

Simmer the meat tender and take it off the bone

95 min

Tearing tender bone-in beef finely with a fork
Simmer the beef until it comes off the bone, and shred it finely along the fibers

Add 1.25 quarts (1.3L) water, black cardamom, cloves, cinnamon and bay leaves to the meat pot and bring to a boil over high heat. Skim the foam when it boils, lower to low heat, and simmer with the lid slightly ajar for 90 minutes. Stir the bottom twice along the way, and if the water level drops below the meat, add ½ cup (150ml) boiling water. Take out the meat; it is cooked if it slides off the bone, tears softly when pressed with a fork, and loosens with the liquid soaked into the fibers. Remove the whole spices and bones, and tear the meat finely into pieces about 2 inches (5 cm) long and 0.125 inch (3 mm) wide.

STEP55 / 6

Combine the wheat, lentils, meat and liquid and work them together

25 min

Combining the shredded beef and liquid with the wheat and lentils and working it together
Work it over low heat, scraping the bottom, to unite the meat fibers and the wheat

Add the meat torn into pieces about 2 inches (5 cm) long and 0.125 inch (3 mm) wide, and the meat's cooking liquid in 3 portions, to the pot of wheat and lentils. Set over low heat and, scraping the bottom with a wooden spoon or masher, work it for 20 minutes. It is ready when the fibers of the meat have mixed into the wheat, the line traced across the bottom with the wooden spoon stays for about 1 second, and the whole thing drops thickly. If it is too stiff, add ½ cup (100ml) boiling water; if too loose, take off the lid and cook down over low heat 5 minutes at a time. If a burnt smell appears, don't scrape the bottom; move only the top to another pot.

STEP66 / 6

Top with the garnishes and finish at the table

10 min

Topping a bowl of haleem with fried onion, ginger, green chili and cilantro
For the finish, layer the toppings in the center and cut the heaviness with lemon and green chili

Just before turning off the heat, add 1/2 tsp garam masala and 25g fried onion, and adjust the salt 1/4 tsp at a time. Serve the haleem in the center of a bowl and top with the set-aside fried onion, ginger cut 0.125 inch (2 mm) wide, green chili, coarsely chopped cilantro and lemon. Just before bringing it to the table, rewarm it in the pot over low heat until it bubbles, and serving it with steam rising brings up the aroma of the toppings. On days you scoop with naan, leave it a little stiffer; on days you eat with a spoon, loosen it by adding about 3.5 tbsp (50ml) boiling water.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Wheat and lentils

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Cracked wheat or coarse bulgur 6 oz (170g) A coarse grain. Fine couscous tends to turn pasty quickly
Rolled barley 2 oz (60g) Pearl barley also works. Keeps a chewy thickness
Chana dal 2.75 oz (80g) Split chickpeas. If none, add 1.5 oz (40g) more red lentils
Red lentils 2.75 oz (80g) Collapse and create the thickness
Mung dal 1.5 oz (40g) If none, make the red lentils 4 oz (120g)
Basmati rice 1 oz (30g) 25g if using short-grain Japanese rice. Too much leans toward a Japanese-style porridge
Water 2 quarts (1.8L) For cooking the wheat and lentils. If short, add boiling water ¾ cup (200ml) at a time
Turmeric 1 tsp For color
Red chili powder 1 tsp Keep the pot as a whole mild
Salt 1 tsp Base seasoning for the wheat and lentils
2 / 3

Meat cooking liquid

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Bone-in beef shank or beef shoulder 1.75 lb (800g) If you can't get bone-in, 1.5 lb (650g) beef shank and 2 chicken drumettes
Onion 2 (14 oz (400g)) Sliced 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick
Ghee 4 tbsp, about 2 oz (56g) 3 tbsp neutral oil and 10g unsalted butter also works
Garlic 20g Grated
Ginger 1 oz (30g) 20g grated, 10g julienned for finishing
Plain yogurt 3.5 oz (100g) Unsweetened. Rounds the aroma of the meat
Ground coriander 2 tbsp The base aroma of the meat
Ground cumin 2 tsp Adds earthiness to the sweetness of the wheat and lentils
Garam masala 1 1/2 tsp Another 1/2 tsp is used at the end
Black cardamom 2 pods Without it the smoky aroma is weaker
Cloves 4 Whole
Cinnamon 2 inches (5 cm) 1 stick
Bay leaves 2 For the simmer
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Coarsely ground
Salt 1 1/2 tsp For the meat. Adjust at the end
Water 1.25 quarts (1.3L) For simmering the meat
3 / 3

Finishing and toppings

Ingredient Amount Role
Fried onion 1.75 oz (50g) 25g into the pot, 25g as topping
Cilantro 25g Coarsely chopped
Green chilies 2 Sliced thin, 0.125 inch (2 mm)
Lemon 1 Cut into 6 wedges
Ginger 10g Julienned 0.125 inch (2 mm) wide
Chaat masala 1 tsp Sprinkled at the table. If none, use a little more lemon
Naan or roti 6 pieces Easy to scoop from the rim of the bowl
0 / 0

When the sun hangs low and the wooden spoon starts to drag across the bottom of the pot, the haleem (Haleem) is almost ready. In the bowl it looks brown and plain. Add fried onion, ginger, green chili, cilantro and lemon, though, and it looks like a plate from a street stall. Haleem is a thick, porridge-like stew of wheat, lentils and bone-in beef cooked down together, and in Bangladesh it belongs to iftar during Ramadan. One spoonful brings the sweetness of collapsed lentils, the body of the wheat and the savory depth of the meat. Lemon and green chili lighten it at the end.

A Bangladeshi-style haleem table with toppings and naan
Fried onion, ginger, green chili, cilantro and lemon go on separate plates, and each diner decides the flavor in their own bowl

Haleem in Bangladesh

In Bangladesh, haleem is both a dish made at home and one bought from shops and shared. The streets around Chawk Bazaar in Old Dhaka are known for their rows of Ramadan foods, and haleem is one of them. The thick texture keeps you full, but it also holds all those flavors together in a single mouthful. Compared with Pakistani haleem, the Bangladeshi toppings are a little brighter.

What the Bangladeshi style aims for

Aim for a consistency where the meat fibers are still slightly visible, the wheat grains linger on the tongue, and the flavor changes as you mix in the toppings, rather than a perfectly smooth paste. In an ordinary pot, the easy test is: "the trail of the wooden spoon stays for 1 second."


Ingredients: Gather the Cracked Wheat, Lentils and Bone-In Meat Separately

Bone-in beef, cracked wheat, lentils, onion, toppings and spices for haleem
For haleem, buying the grains, lentils, bone-in meat and toppings separately makes substitutions easier

This serves 6. Made in a small amount, haleem scorches easily on the bottom, and the meat's cooking liquid tends to be thin. Make it for 6, and add a little water when you reheat it the next day.

Allergens and ingredient cautions

This recipe contains wheat, beef and dairy. Check the label on store-bought fried onions, since they can be made in factories that handle wheat, milk and nuts. If you avoid dairy, replace the ghee with 4 tbsp neutral oil, leave out the yogurt, and add 2 tsp lemon juice to the meat seasoning.

Buy bone-in beef, onion, yogurt and lemon at a nearby supermarket. Look farther afield for coarse cracked wheat, red lentils and strongly scented spices. If you keep cooking South Asian food, the same dried goods go into khichdi and biryani too.

How to read the nutrition information

The nutrition values are for the whole pot of 6 servings. One serving is about 610 kcal, around 1.25 oz (35g) protein and around 25g fat. Less ghee and fried onion makes it lighter, but the aroma thins out too. For dinner, serve it with one naan. As a small starter, halve the portion and serve cucumber, onion and lemon beside it so it is easier to keep eating.


Method: Combine the Bone-In Meat's Liquid and the Wheat at the End

Cooking everything in one pot looks easy, but with a home burner the wheat sinks to the bottom, and the bottom of the pot tends to scorch before the meat softens. Keeping the meat pot and the wheat pot separate and combining and working them at the end reduces mistakes with heat.


Common Haleem Problems and Fixes

A watery haleem and a smooth haleem compared in small bowls
How haleem feels to eat depends less on the amount of water than on whether the wheat and lentils have collapsed and joined the meat

In a home kitchen, haleem usually goes wrong because of the order of steps rather than the ingredients. Combine the meat before the wheat and lentils are soft and the grains stay gritty. Add a lot of water to avoid scorching and it tastes thin. That's why the liquid from the bone-in meat is made first, the wheat and lentils are cooked down separately, and the two are combined and worked together over low heat at the end.

Nearly every problem shows up in the consistency: runny, scorched on the bottom, or grainy. Behind each one is one of two causes. Either the water boiled off before the grains softened, or the haleem wasn't worked enough after combining.

Condition Cause How to fix it
Watery The wheat and lentils are soft, but it was not cooked down enough at the end Take off the lid and work it over low heat 5 minutes at a time
Grains are hard Not soaked enough, not cooked enough Add ¾ cup (200ml) boiling water and cook 15 more minutes over low heat
The bottom scorches The heat is too high, or the bottom wasn't scraped often enough Don't scrape the scorched bottom; move only the top to another pot
Meat remains in lumps Not cooked enough, or torn too large Take out only the meat and tear it again to about 2 inches (5 cm) long and 0.125 inch (3 mm) wide
The taste is heavy Too few toppings and acidity Add lemon, ginger, green chili and cilantro in the bowl

Blending until completely smooth is quick, but haleem is better when you stop short of that. It isn't a potage, and some wheat texture and meat fiber should remain. If the grains bother you, mash only the wheat and lentils, then stir the meat back in.


How to Eat It, Storage, and Frequently Asked Questions

Spoon the haleem into the center of a bowl and layer the toppings on top. Take the first bite without lemon, then squeeze some in, and finally add a little green chili. You can taste the flavor change with each step. Naan or roti makes it easy to scoop up the sticky stew, and that's closer to how it's eaten locally than white rice.

For a Ramadan-style table, small portions go well with sweet drinks, fruit and light fried foods. As the main dish at dinner, set a plate of sliced cucumber, red onion, tomato and lemon beside it so the meal doesn't feel heavy. With samosa, keep the haleem mild and let it play the thick, soup-like partner to the toasty fried pastry. Serve it on a different day from fish dishes like ilish bhuna. For small, punchy sides, try aloo bhorta, potatoes bound with mustard oil, or begun bhorta, with its charred roasted eggplant. Their heat and sourness give relief between mouthfuls of the heavy stew.

To store, let the haleem cool, divide it into clean containers, and refrigerate for up to 3 days. It stiffens as it cools because the wheat and lentils keep absorbing moisture. To reheat, add 3.5 tbsp (50ml) to ¼ cup (80ml) water per serving to a pot and stir over low heat for 5 to 7 minutes until it bubbles. In a microwave, put it in a deep heatproof container, add 2 tbsp water, heat at 600W for 2 minutes, stir, and then heat 1 minute at a time. It's ready when it's hot to the center and smooth again.

What is the difference from Pakistani haleem?

The Bangladeshi style here finishes with the liquid from the bone-in meat and cuts the richness with toppings and lemon. Pakistani haleem comes from the same South Asian tradition, but some versions are worked smoother and lean harder on chaat masala or aromatic oil. If you make both, use the same dried goods and vary only the toppings and cooking liquid. The difference is easier to taste that way.

What do I do if I can't get bone-in meat?

Use 1.5 lb (650g) beef shank with 2 chicken drumettes to give the liquid body. Thin lean slices alone make the meat fibers too fine and the liquid too light. If thin slices are all you have, treat it as a different home version: brown the meat, combine it with the wheat and lentils early, and shorten the cooking time.

Can I make it not spicy?

Yes. Reduce the red chili powder in the pot to 1/2 tsp, and serve the green chili and chaat masala at the table. Turmeric, cumin, coriander and garam masala add aroma more than heat, so keep them as they are. A mild pot also suits people who like bean dishes such as dal bhat. For children or anyone who avoids heat, extra lemon and cilantro add brightness without spice.

Does the flavor drop if I make it ahead?

No. By the next day, the wheat and lentils have blended together even more. Reheat it gently, because high heat scorches the stiffened haleem on the bottom of the pot, and finish with fresh lemon and ginger. Keep the toppings separate in storage, since mixing them in dulls their aroma. Add the fried onion, green chili and cilantro just before eating.


Sources