Haleem: Pakistan's Slow-Cooked Beef and Wheat Porridge

Pakistani haleem topped with fried onion, ginger, green chili and cilantro
Prep
45 min
Cook
2 hr 40 min
Total
3 hr 25 min
Serves
6 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Pakistani

How to make haleem, the thick Pakistani porridge of cracked wheat, lentils and beef: heat control, stirring so the pot doesn't scorch, substitutions, fried onion and garnishes, storage, reheating, troubleshooting, menu ideas, background and FAQ.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Wash and soak the wheat and lentils

35 min

Soaking cracked wheat, lentils and rice in a metal bowl
Soak the wheat and lentils for 30 minutes so they start cooking at an even firmness

Put 6.5 oz (180 g) cracked wheat, 1.75 oz (50 g) rolled barley, 2.75 oz (80 g) chana dal, 2 oz (60 g) red lentils, 1.5 oz (40 g) moong dal and 1 oz (30 g) basmati rice in a bowl and wash three times, changing the water. When the water is only slightly cloudy, soak in plenty of water for 30 minutes. When the corners of the lentils look slightly rounded under your finger and the surface of the cracked wheat is moist, move on.

STEP22 / 7

Brown the onion to a deep golden color

18 min

Cooking onion with ghee in a pot to a deep golden color
Lower the heat from medium to medium-low and stop at a deep golden color

Put 4 tbsp ghee in a heavy pot and warm it over medium heat for 1 minute. Add 14 oz (400 g) onion sliced 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick, cook the first 8 minutes over medium heat to drive off moisture, then when it begins to color lower to medium-low and stir for another 8 to 10 minutes. When the whole batch is deep golden and the edges are lightly crisp, take out half. Any blackened bits turn bitter, so pick out just the burnt pieces with chopsticks or tongs. Stop when the onion is fully absorbed into the fat and no watery liquid is left on the bottom of the pot.

STEP33 / 7

Sear the meat with the spices

18 min

Searing beef with onion, ginger, garlic and spices
Brown the beef over medium-high heat, and after adding the yogurt, fry until oil seeps out

Add 1.5 lb (700 g) beef cut into 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes to the onion and ghee left in the pot. Sear over medium-high heat for 6 minutes until the surface is browned. Lower to low heat, add 20 g garlic, 15 g grated ginger, the coriander, cumin, garam masala, black cardamom, cloves, cinnamon, bay leaves and salt, and fry for 2 minutes. Add 3.5 oz (100 g) yogurt and stir over medium heat for 5 minutes; when oil seeps out at the edges and the sour smell has rounded out, pour in 1.25 quarts (1.2 L) water. When the spices cling to the meat and the white of the yogurt has gone brown and blended in, move on to simmering.

STEP44 / 7

Break down the wheat and lentils in a separate pot

70 min

A pot of wheat and lentils simmering on low heat, the grains starting to collapse
Simmer the wheat and lentils on low heat until the grains crush easily between your fingers

Put the drained wheat and lentils in another heavy pot with 2 quarts (1.8 L) water, 1 tsp turmeric, 1 tsp red chili powder and 1 tsp salt. Bring to a boil over high heat, skim the scum, and lower to low heat. Set the lid slightly ajar and cook for 60 to 70 minutes, stirring from the bottom every 5 minutes. You want grains that crush easily between your fingers and that spread thinly against the pot wall when pressed with a wooden spoon. If the liquid runs low, add ¾ cup (200 ml) boiling water.

STEP55 / 7

Shred the meat and return the broth

100 min

Shredding tender beef finely with forks
Cook the beef until the fibers separate on their own, then shred it finely and return it with the broth

Bring the meat pot to a boil, lower to low heat, cover and cook for 90 minutes. Stir the bottom only twice along the way, and if the liquid level falls below the meat, add ½ cup (150 ml) boiling water. Take out the meat; if it pulls apart in tender strands when pressed with a fork, remove the whole spices. Using two forks, shred the meat along the grain into pieces about 2 inches (5 cm) long and 0.125 inch (3 mm) wide, and return the broth to the pot without discarding it. If the meat is still firm, cook another 20 minutes on low heat. If the shredded meat soaks up the broth and breaks apart when pinched, it will blend well with the grains in the next step.

STEP66 / 7

Combine the meat and wheat and stir

25 min

Folding shredded beef into the pot of wheat and lentils
Stir over low heat, scraping the bottom, until the meat fibers and the wheat become one

Add the shredded meat (about 2 inches (5 cm) long, 0.125 inch (3 mm) wide) and the broth a little at a time to the pot of wheat and lentils. Over low heat, stir for 20 minutes, scraping the bottom with a wooden spoon or masher. The target is that the line you draw across the bottom stays visible for about a second, the meat fibers are mixed into the grains, and the whole thing is sticky and falls in a smooth, thick drop. If it is too stiff, add ½ cup (100 ml) boiling water; if too loose, uncover and reduce over low heat in 5-minute stretches.

STEP77 / 7

Finish and add the garnishes

10 min

Stirring the finished haleem smooth in the pot
Bring the temperature back up over low heat and adjust to a thick consistency that falls slowly

Just before turning off the heat, add 1/2 tsp garam masala, taste, and adjust with salt 1/4 tsp at a time. Before serving, let it bubble for 1 minute over a slightly stronger low heat so that it is hot throughout. Ladle into bowls and top with the reserved fried onion, julienned ginger, green chili, cilantro and lemon. For scooping with naan make it a little stiffer; for eating with a spoon, loosen it with a small amount of boiling water.

0 / 0
Ingredients

Ingredients

1 / 3

Wheat and lentils

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Cracked wheat or coarse bulgur 6.5 oz (180 g) Choose a coarse grain. Fine couscous makes a different dish
Rolled barley 1.75 oz (50 g) Pearl barley also works. If you have none, use 8 oz (230 g) cracked wheat
Chana dal 2.75 oz (80 g) Split chickpeas. With dried chickpeas, soak overnight and crush coarsely
Red lentils 2 oz (60 g) They fall apart and build the thickness
Moong dal 1.5 oz (40 g) If you have none, increase red lentils to 3.5 oz (100 g)
Basmati rice 1 oz (30 g) A small amount to bind it. 25 g if using Japanese short-grain rice
Water 2 quarts (1.8 L) For cooking the grains and lentils. If short, add ¾ cup (200 ml) hot water at a time
Turmeric 1 tsp For color
Red chili powder 1 tsp Mild. Up to 2 tsp on a spicy day
Salt 1 tsp To season the grains and lentils
2 / 3

Meat korma

Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Beef chuck or a block of beef shank 1.5 lb (700 g) Cut into 1.5 inches (4 cm) cubes. Lamb shoulder also works
Onion 2 (14 oz (400 g)) Sliced 0.125 inch (2 mm) thick
Ghee 4 tbsp (about 2 oz (56 g)) You can use 3 tbsp neutral oil and 10 g unsalted butter
Garlic 20 g Grated
Ginger 25 g 15 g grated, 10 g cut into julienne for finishing
Plain yogurt 3.5 oz (100 g) Unsweetened. Tenderizes the meat and adds a little acidity
Ground coriander 2 tbsp The base aroma for the meat
Ground cumin 2 tsp Earthy aroma
Garam masala 1 1/2 tsp A little more at the end
Black cardamom 2 Without it the smokiness is weaker
Cloves 4 Whole
Cinnamon 2 inches (5 cm) 1 stick
Black pepper 1/2 tsp Coarsely ground
Bay leaves 2 For simmering
Salt 1 1/2 tsp For the meat. Adjust at the end
Water 1.25 quarts (1.2 L) For simmering the meat
3 / 3

Finishing and garnishes

Ingredient Amount Role
Fried onions 1.5 oz (40 g) Half goes into the pot, half on top
Cilantro 25 g Coarsely chopped
Green chili 2 Sliced into 0.125 inch (2 mm) rings
Lemon 1 Cut into 6 wedges
Ginger 10 g Cut into 0.125 inch (2 mm) julienne
Chaat masala 1 tsp Sprinkle at the table if you have it. If not, use a little more lemon
Naan or roti 6 Bread scoops better than rice
0 / 0

Drag a wooden spoon along the bottom of the pot and the wheat and lentils move heavily, while the beef fibers slowly come apart. Haleem (حلیم) is thicker than a curry and too heavy to drink like a soup. In this Pakistani dish, cracked wheat, lentils and meat cook for hours until they merge into something like a porridge. You taste the sweetness of the wheat, the roundness of the lentils, the savor of beef and the fragrance of ghee. At the end, green chili and lemon cut through all of it.

A Pakistani table gathered around a pot of haleem
Haleem is made in a big pot; everyone adds fried onion, ginger, cilantro and lemon at the table

Haleem in Pakistan

Haleem doesn't look like much. It's brown and sticky, and a photo gives little idea of the flavor. Then you squeeze on lemon, top it with fried onion and ginger, scoop up a bite with naan, and your impression changes. It's rich but easy to keep eating, because the garnishes do half the work.

In Pakistan, haleem is eaten at iftar during Ramadan and handed out during Muharram. Karachi restaurants serve it as a thick paste of wheat, lentils, meat and spices, fully blended, with lemon, mint, ginger, green chili and fried onion. At home, it suits a day when you have time to cook for hours, when you're sharing with others, or when you want leftovers for tomorrow.

Haleem is lighter than nihari, which is heavy with bone marrow, and it can sit beside chapli kebab as a main of wheat and meat. Armenian harissa is also wheat and meat cooked and mashed together, but Pakistani haleem goes further with lentils, spices and garnishes.

Haleem versus khichra

In haleem, the meat, wheat and lentils are mashed together into one. Khichra keeps the meat and grains more distinct. This recipe makes a smooth, Pakistani home-style haleem you can scoop up with naan.


Ingredients: think of wheat, lentils and meat separately

A kitchen with cracked wheat, lentils, beef, aromatics and spices for haleem laid out
Shop for haleem in groups: wheat, lentils, meat and garnishes

This makes 6 servings. Haleem scorches easily in small batches, so cook the full batch. Chuck, shank or a block of round all work for the beef, but choose a chunk rather than thin slices, since it is cooked long and shredded.

Allergen information

This recipe contains wheat, beef and dairy. It uses ghee and yogurt; to avoid dairy, cook with neutral oil, leave out the yogurt, and add 2 tsp lemon juice to the meat seasoning for a different flavor. Store-bought fried onions may be made in facilities that handle wheat, milk and tree nuts, so check the label.

What is worth shopping for online is not the meat but the cracked wheat, lentils and strongly scented spices. Buy beef, onions and yogurt locally and gather only the dry goods in one order to cut waste. Many of these ingredients also go into khichdi and biryani, so it is an easy dish to buy for if you plan to keep cooking South Asian food.

How to read the nutrition information

The whole recipe makes 6 servings. Per serving, it has about 650 kcal, around 1.25 oz (35 g) protein and around 1 oz (29 g) fat. Reducing the ghee and fried onion lowers the fat, but the aroma and satisfaction also fade. As a dinner main, serve one naan; as a light soup course, use small bowls with a salad on the side.

Choosing ingredients and substitutes for haleem

The viscosity of haleem, falling slowly from a wooden spoon
Aim for a texture where wheat, lentils and meat fibers have blended and the haleem falls slowly from the spoon

Texture matters more than aroma here. The cracked wheat and lentils should break down well, fine threads of meat should run all through it, and when you tilt the spoon the haleem should fall slowly. Get that right and it eats like haleem even if the spices are a little mild.

Three things should stay the same: a coarse grain, lentils that fall apart, and the finishing garnishes. Coarse bulgur can stand in for cracked wheat, but a fine grain like couscous turns pasty quickly. If you have no chana dal, use more red lentils. Red lentils alone make it too light, though, so keep some chew with pearl barley or rolled barley. For the meat, beef shank, chuck and lamb shoulder all work, so buy whichever is easiest to find.


Method: simmer on low heat, then stir until it becomes one

Don't simmer the meat and grains together from the start. Soften them separately, then combine. Grains sink to the bottom and meat takes time to cook through, so one pot scorches easily and leaves grains behind even after stirring.


Troubleshooting haleem: watery, scorched or grainy

Watery haleem and smooth haleem compared in small bowls
What matters in haleem is less the water than whether wheat and lentils have broken down and merged with the meat

The hard part in a home kitchen is the thickness. If you combine the meat with the wheat and lentils before the grains are soft, the grains stay whole and the texture turns gritty. Too much water keeps the bottom from scorching but makes the porridge taste thin. That's why this recipe softens the meat and the grains separately, combines them, and finishes with a final stir over low heat.

Most failures come down to two causes: the water cooked off before everything got soft, or the pot wasn't stirred enough after combining.

Condition Cause How to fix
Watery Wheat and lentils are soft, but it was not reduced enough at the end Uncover and stir over low heat in 5-minute stretches
Hard grains Not soaked enough, not cooked enough Add ¾ cup (200 ml) boiling water and cook 15 more minutes on low heat
Scorched bottom Heat too high, too little scraping of the bottom Do not scrape the scorched part; move only the top layer to another pot
Chunks of meat left Not cooked enough, shredded too coarsely Take out only the meat and shred it finer
Flavor is heavy Too few garnishes and too little acidity Add lemon, ginger, green chili and cilantro in the bowl

A blender gets it perfectly smooth fast, but haleem should keep some body from the grain and some meat fiber. A short blend of the wheat and lentils alone is fine. If you blend the meat in completely, the texture turns uniform and the fibers that make it haleem disappear. If the grains still bother you, mash the wheat and lentils with a masher and add the meat back afterward. That keeps enough texture that it doesn't get tiresome to eat.


Serving and storing haleem

Haleem divided into storage containers, and being reheated in a pot in the kitchen
Haleem stiffens when cold, so when reheating add a little water and bring it back over low heat

At the table

Put the haleem in the center of a bowl and scatter the garnishes on top. Take the first bite without lemon, squeeze on lemon for the next, and add a little green chili at the end, and you'll notice how the flavor changes. Naan or roti makes it easy to scoop up the sticky parts, and it's closer to how haleem is eaten locally than white rice.

Keep the pot itself mild. In Pakistan, at restaurants and at home, everyone adds lemon, ginger, green chili, chaat masala and fried onion to their own bowl. For a family meal, put only 1 tsp red chili powder in the pot, and let people who like heat add more at the table. That way one pot works for children and older relatives too. It's also a good approach on days when you serve Kabuli palaw or samosas.

For a South Asian table, set raita beside it and add a small portion of chapli kebab for something grilled, so the meal is more than one rich porridge.

Storage and reheating

Plan on 2 days in the refrigerator. Typical cooked leftovers keep 3 to 4 days, but haleem gets handled by hand when it's served, so allow less time. Reheat until it is steaming hot throughout, 74°C (165°F). To freeze, put single portions in shallow containers and eat them within 2 weeks.

A microwave alone tends to leave the center cold. Instead, put one portion of haleem and 2 tbsp water in a pot and stir over low heat for 5 to 7 minutes, until it bubbles. If it's stiff enough that the spoon leaves a line on the bottom, add water 1 tbsp at a time. If it's runny, uncover and reduce for 2 minutes. Add lemon and cilantro after reheating so they keep their aroma.


FAQ

Haleem scooped with a spoon, with garnishes and naan on the table
Haleem that falls slowly from a spoon is also easy to scoop with naan

Q1. I have no cracked wheat. Can I use oats?

You can, but the result is closer to a different dish. Oats dissolve quickly, so replace 6.5 oz (180 g) cracked wheat with 4 oz (120 g) oats and shorten the cooking to about 20 minutes. You lose some of the grain texture and chewy sweetness, so for a first batch, I'd look for coarse bulgur.

Q2. Can I make it with chicken?

Yes, with 1.25 lb (600 g) boneless chicken thighs. Shorten the meat pot to 45 to 60 minutes, and add bone-in pieces if you want more stock flavor. Chicken doesn't have the weight of beef or lamb, so use a little more ghee and fried onion and raise the black pepper to 1 tsp to keep the flavor from going flat.

Q3. How do I adapt it for a pressure cooker?

For the meat, plan on 35 minutes at pressure and a 15-minute natural release. It's easier to judge the thickness of the wheat and lentils in a regular pot. If you cook them in the pressure cooker too, reduce the water to 1.5 quarts (1.5 L) and cook at pressure for 18 minutes. Then open the lid and stir over low heat to adjust the thickness.

Q4. How much can I prepare the day before?

You can soak the wheat and lentils, slice the onions and measure the spices the day before. You can also cook and combine the meat and wheat, refrigerate it, and stir while reheating the next day. Spread it in a shallow container before refrigerating so it cools quickly, because in a deep pot the center stays warm for a long time.

Q5. What should I serve with it to make a meal?

Haleem already contains meat, lentils and wheat, so keep the sides light: naan, a cucumber and onion salad, raita and lemon are enough. If you add one more dish, a vegetable dish such as aloo gobi suits it better than anything fried. For a meat dish, a small portion of grilled chapli kebab works better than nihari, so the spices don't double up.


Sources