Nihari: Pakistan's Slow-Cooked Bone-Marrow Curry for Breakfast

Pakistani nihari: a golden marrow curry topped with julienned ginger, green chiles and cilantro, served with naan
Prep
30 min
Cook
5 hr
Total
5 hr 30 min
Serves
6 servings
Level
Intermediate
Cuisine
Pakistani

A full recipe for Pakistan's beloved nihari: beef shank and marrow bones stewed overnight in a rich spice gravy. A homemade nihari masala, how to draw the most from the marrow, and the dish's history from Mughal Delhi to Karachi's back streets.

Cooking flow

Cooking steps

STEP11 / 7

Make the fried onions

20 min

Thinly sliced onions frying to golden brown in a pot
Aim for an even golden brown without scorching the onions. It takes about 15 minutes

Put 5 tbsp neutral oil (or ghee) in a large pot and heat over medium. Add the 3 sliced onions. Stirring now and then, fry slowly for 15–20 minutes. When they are an even deep golden brown, remove to paper towels. Set half aside for topping and return the other half to the pot later. Use the oil left in the pot as it is.

Fried onion tip

The right move is to take the onions out "a little early." They darken further from residual heat, so pull them out one shade before the color you want. If they burn, bitterness comes out and ruins the whole nihari. Store-bought fried onions save a great deal of time.

STEP22 / 7

Sear the meat and bones

5 min

Searing beef shank and marrow bones in a pot, with browned surfaces
Brown every side well. The Maillard reaction is the foundation of the umami

Turn the heat to high under the pot with the onion-frying oil. Add the beef shank and brown it well on every side. About 5 minutes is the guide. Then add the marrow bones and brown them the same way. When the surfaces of the meat and bones are brown, lower the heat for the moment. This searing triggers the Maillard reaction and creates deep umami.

STEP33 / 7

Fry the spices

3 min

Spices mixing with oil in a pot and releasing their fragrance
Frying spices in oil draws out the fat-soluble aroma compounds

Lower the heat to low and add all the nihari masala spices to the pot, including the bay leaves. For 1–2 minutes, coat the oil and spices together without letting them burn. Add the grated 4 cloves of garlic and 1 knob of ginger and fry another minute. Return half of the fried onions to the pot for the simmer and mix lightly. It has worked when the fragrance of the spices rises and fills the kitchen.

STEP44 / 7

Add water and begin simmering

10 min

Plenty of water poured into a large pot as the simmer begins
After adding the water, start on high heat. The key is to lower it to low once it boils

Pour in 2.75 quarts (2.5 L) water and add 2 tsp salt. Raise the heat to high and bring to a boil. When it boils, carefully skim the scum (gray foam) that floats to the surface. When you've finished skimming, cover and drop to the lowest heat. The long simmer begins here.

Simmering time guide

Traditional nihari simmers for 6–8 hours. This article uses a realistic 4–5 hour recipe. In a pressure cooker it can be shortened to 1.5–2 hours. Slow simmering over low heat, however, lets the marrow gelatin dissolve fully. We recommend making it on a day when you have time. Starting the night before a holiday and eating it the next morning is the most authentic.

STEP55 / 7

Simmer over low heat for 3–4 hours

Nihari simmering slowly over low heat, the marrow starting to melt and thicken the gravy
After 3 hours. The marrow gelatin dissolves and the gravy thickens and takes on a sheen

Keep the lid on and simmer for 3–4 hours at the lowest heat. Once every 30 minutes, open the lid, stir lightly and check the water level. If it reduces too much, add hot water. Keep the meat always submerged. After 3 hours, try the meat with a fork. The goal is that the fibers fall apart. The marrow should have melted into the gravy, and a golden layer of oil floating on the surface is ideal.

STEP66 / 7

Adjust the thickness with flour

5 min

Adding flour dissolved in water to the simmering pot and stirring
Add the flour water a little at a time and stir quickly so it doesn't clump

In a small bowl, dissolve 3 tbsp flour in ½ cup (100 ml) water, breaking up any lumps. Pour it a little at a time into the simmering pot while stirring quickly. Simmer about 5 minutes and check the thickness. The gravy should be thick enough to coat the back of a spoon. Taste for salt and adjust if needed.

The secret to thickness

Traditional nihari is thickened by marrow gelatin alone. But the beef bones you can get may not have enough gelatin. Making up the difference with flour is a common method in Pakistani homes too. If you add too much it turns gluey, so add a little at a time. For the authentic way, add one beef trotter (paya) and its natural gelatin gives a perfect thickness.

STEP77 / 7

Finish and serve

5 min

Nihari in a deep dish, topped with plenty of julienned ginger, green chiles and cilantro, with lemon alongside
The finishing garnishes are the essence of nihari. Don't skimp on the ginger

Ladle plenty of hot gravy into a deep bowl. After checking that the meat falls apart and a thin film of oil floats on the surface, arrange the meat and bones in balance. Pile the julienned ginger on generously and scatter the sliced green chiles. Sprinkle plenty of cilantro and top with fried onions. Add the lemon wedges and it is done. Serve with fresh naan or sheermal (a naan baked with ghee).

0 / 0

Karachi, 5 a.m., still dark. A line has already formed outside a street-corner eatery, where a large copper pot (degh) sends up the smell of spices and melting marrow, and laborers jostle to be first to dip their naan in. This is nihari (Nihari / نہاری), Pakistan's pride, a "morning stew curry." In the mouth, the deep richness of marrow rises from under layers of spice, and then the julienned ginger and lemon cut through it. That mix of heavy and bright is what nihari is all about.

What nihari is and where it comes from

Nihari belongs to the family of South Asian spiced cooking. Beef shank and bones are simmered overnight over low heat with plenty of spices, and the gelatin and fat from the marrow thicken the gravy until it turns rich. It is finished with a generous heap of julienned ginger, green chiles, cilantro and lemon juice, and traditionally eaten with fresh naan. It is often called Pakistan's national breakfast dish. Pakistan has other long-simmered dishes, but haleem works wheat and lentils into the meat and comes together like a porridge, so the meat breaks down in a completely different way.

From the Mughal court to street eateries

The name comes from the Arabic nahar (نهار), meaning "morning." Nihari began as a court dish in Delhi in the late Mughal period in the 18th century. Court cooks tended the pot through the night, and it was served after the dawn prayer. When the Mughal Empire fell, nihari moved from the court to street eateries. Around the Jama Masjid in Old Delhi, famous shops that date back to the 19th century still line the streets.

The Partition of 1947 changed nihari's story. Muslims who moved from Delhi to Karachi and Lahore (muhajirs) brought nihari-making with them, and in Karachi their eateries mixed with the food culture of Sindh until a distinct Karachi-style nihari emerged. The city's famous nihari shops have lines from early morning. Dhaka in Bangladesh and Delhi and Lucknow in India have kept their own versions of the dish.

Night scene at a traditional nihari eatery in Karachi, with nihari cooking in a large copper pot
A back-street nihari eatery in Karachi. The nihari stewed overnight in a giant copper degh is ready at 5 a.m.

Three major schools of nihari

Pakistan and India have three major schools of nihari.

School Characteristics Representative city
Delhi style Restrained spices. Brings the umami of the marrow forward Delhi
Karachi style Strong spices and plenty of oil. The heat of chile Karachi
Lahore style Mild with some sweetness. Generous with ghee and refined Lahore

This recipe follows the Karachi style. To move closer to the Delhi style, halve the cayenne pepper and increase the ghee. Moroccan tagine is another long-simmered classic, but the marrow-based body of nihari sets it apart.

Friday nihari

In Pakistan, eating nihari on Fridays is still a strong custom, tied to the Friday prayer (Jumu'ah) in Islam. People start cooking on Thursday night and eat with the family after the early-morning prayer on Friday. For many families, Friday nihari is a special occasion, much like the Sunday curry, and Friday has its own food traditions across the Islamic world, just as Egyptian koshari is a staple. If you already know Nepali dal bhat or Indian khichdi, nihari is the heavier, more powerful cousin, a dish that warms you to the core.


Ingredients (serves 6)

### Main ingredients
Ingredient Amount Substitutes & notes
Beef shank 1.75 lb (800 g) Cut a large block into 4–5 cm cubes
Beef bones with marrow 4 pieces Oxtail also works. Order from a butcher
Onions 3, thinly sliced For fried onions
Neutral oil or ghee 5 tbsp Ghee recommended. The richness is in another class
Water 2.75 quarts (2.5 L) Allowing for what evaporates during the simmer
All-purpose flour 3 tbsp For thickening. Dissolve in ½ cup (100 ml) water
Salt 2 tsp Adjust as you taste
tip Where to find beef bones Beef bones are an ingredient not stocked by many ordinary supermarkets. They may be sold at a butcher or wholesale store as soup bones or marrow bones. You can also order marrow bones online or from a butcher. If you can't find them, substitute oxtail (the kind for soup). Oxtail has the advantage of more gelatin and thickens more easily. :::
Allergen information

This recipe contains wheat (all-purpose flour is used for thickening) and milk (if you use ghee). If you are allergic to wheat, you can substitute rice flour or cornstarch for the thickening flour. Using neutral oil instead of ghee makes it dairy-free. If you have a nut allergy, check that store-bought fried onions contain no nuts.

The main ingredients for nihari: a block of beef shank, marrow bones, onions and ghee on a wooden board
The main ingredients. Marrow bones are the heart of nihari's flavor

The heart of nihari is its spice mix. Ready-made "nihari masala" is available at halal shops. But a homemade blend is far more fragrant.

Nihari masala (spice mix)

Spice Amount Role & notes
Ground coriander 2 tbsp The base aroma
Ground cumin 1 tbsp Earthy depth
Turmeric 1 tsp Color
Cayenne pepper 2 tsp Heat. Adjust to taste
Paprika 1 tbsp Red color and sweet aroma
Fennel seeds (ground) 1 tsp Sweet coolness
Black cardamom 2 pods (seeds crushed) The most important spice. Smoky, deep aroma
Green cardamom 4 pods (seeds crushed) Floral aroma
Cloves 4 (ground) Pungent sweetness
Cinnamon stick 1 (broken up) Warmth
Black pepper 1 tsp Sharp heat
Nutmeg 1/4 tsp Faint sweetness
Mace 1/4 tsp The outer coat of nutmeg. Without it, double the nutmeg
Bay leaves 2 leaves Added during the simmer

Finishing garnishes (the lifeline of nihari)

Garnish Amount Notes
Ginger 1 large knob (julienned) For finishing. Be generous
Green chiles 3–4 (sliced) Heat to taste
Cilantro 1 handful (coarsely chopped) The key aroma
Lemon 1 (cut into wedges) Squeeze over to eat
Fried onions 3 tbsp Store-bought is fine. For topping
About black cardamom

The deciding aroma of nihari is black cardamom. It is an entirely different plant from green cardamom, with a smoky, almost cured aroma. Look for it at import grocers or specialty spice sellers. Leaving it out halves the nihari character. Be sure to get it.

Homemade nihari masala spices: black cardamom, green cardamom, cloves, fennel seeds and cinnamon stick on small plates
The spices of nihari masala. The large black pods in the center are black cardamom

Choosing spices for nihari

Packaged nihari masala is sold at halal shops and online, and it works fine. If you use a store-bought mix, skip the spice-mix step and follow the amounts on the package. A homemade blend is fresher, though, and far more fragrant.



Serving and storing nihari

Pakistanis eat nihari in a particular order. First squeeze the lemon and stir it through the whole gravy. Then push the julienned ginger down into the gravy and let it sit. Now tear off some naan, dunk it deep and eat. Scoop the marrow out with a spoon and eat it on naan; that is the most luxurious bite of all.

Dipping naan generously in nihari gravy, the rich marrow-gelatin body clinging to the naan
Tear the naan and dip it. The marrow-derived gelatin clinging to the naan is the great pleasure of nihari

Nihari is even better the next day, so make extra. Overnight in the refrigerator the spices blend completely and the marrow gelatin sets, giving the gravy more body. To reheat, loosen it with a little hot water and warm it until just before boiling. Eat it within 3 days; it keeps for 1 month frozen.

Side dishes

Nihari is filling on its own, but on the Pakistani table it comes with these sides:

  • Naan / sheermal: nihari's most authentic partner. Sheermal is a rich naan brushed with ghee and baked
  • Whole-wheat roti: a whole-wheat flatbread, plainer in taste than naan
  • Kachumber: a salad of onion, tomato and cucumber, seasoned with lemon juice and chile
  • Raita: yogurt mixed with cucumber and mint. Softens the heat

Eating with roti is common across South Asia, as with Sri Lankan kottu roti. Rice works too, as in Southeast Asian nasi lemak, and many Pakistani households serve basmati rice with nihari.

Variations

Chicken nihari uses bone-in chicken thighs (cut up) instead of beef, and the simmering time drops to 2–3 hours. It is the second most popular nihari in Pakistan after beef, and a good choice if you prefer something lighter. Chicken bones release gelatin as well, so the gravy still thickens nicely.

Mutton nihari is the version many people consider the best. In Japan, lamb shoulder or lamb shank can stand in. It simmers for the same 4–5 hours as beef, and the distinctive flavor of lamb pairs beautifully with the spices. Jordanian mansaf is another lamb stew, a Middle Eastern specialty.

For a pressure cooker version, add the water in step 4 and cook under pressure for 45 minutes to 1 hour. Once the pressure is released, open the lid and do the flour thickening in step 6. The flavor is a little less deep than a slow simmer, but it is still delicious.


More dishes to cook

  • Kabuli Palaw - uses ingredients and aromas from the same region.
  • Chapli Kebab - another Pakistani meat dish, cooked flat on a griddle rather than stewed, with a street-food feel.
  • Ilish Bhuna - uses ingredients and aromas from the same region.
  • Biryani - with nihari, one of South Asia's two great spiced dishes.

Frequently asked questions

Q1. Is nihari spicy?

It uses plenty of spices, but the heat depends on how much chile you add. For a milder version, cut the cayenne to 1 tsp and skip the finishing green chiles. For children, leave out the chiles entirely and use only paprika for color.

Q2. I've never eaten bone marrow. Will I be okay?

Marrow is as smooth as butter and has almost no off-odor. It melts into the gravy as it simmers, so most people eat it without noticing. In Pakistan, scooping out the marrow left in the bones is considered the greatest luxury.

Q3. Can I make it without simmering overnight?

Yes. This recipe takes 4–5 hours, and a pressure cooker can bring that down to 1.5–2 hours. Still, the longer it simmers, the more marrow gelatin dissolves and the better the spices blend, so give it more time if you can.


Sources